Trending Games | World of Warcraft | Overwatch | Destiny 2 | Elder Scrolls Online

    Facebook Twitter YouTube Twitch.tv YouTube.Gaming Discord
Register
Quick Game Jump
Members:3,815,020 Users Online:0
Games:984 

Show Blog

Link to this blogs RSS feed

Strange Sands

Strange Sands is a place for ideas about the game industry, both tabletop and online. I'm interested in understanding how game writers can make better stories while allowing players to create their own interactions within the game world.

Author: Ortwig

Extreme Variety and Imbalance in an MMORPG

Posted by Ortwig Saturday June 15 2013 at 10:37AM
Login or Register to rate this blog post!

Well, I think I’m going to go completely off the rails this week and talk about ways to completely unbalance a game.  A big part of an MMOs development team’s time seems to be taken up with balancing each of the classes in an MMO.  The reasoning behind this is pretty obvious – if one class is “the most powerful,” most players will pick it, and nobody will play those weaker classes.  A good example of this might be the Jedi class in the now closed Star Wars Galaxies.  It was so head and shoulders above the rest of those classes, that Jedi populations skyrocketed. 

Partially due to the effort to balance classes, there typically are limits on the number of races and classes made available in a game.  The more races and classes available, the harder it is to keep on those classes in sync and on par with one another.

But what if both those constraints were removed?  What if there were so many possible varieties of race and class that imbalance was simply less of a factor?  What if variety were the primary concern?  Two tabletop roleplaying games embraced rather than rejected variety – Talislanta and RuneQuest.  In Talislanta, there were a dizzying variety of races, and in RuneQuest the number of religions, or cults, numbered in the hundreds, and each of those cults had unique magics.  Divine magics, spirit magic and sorcery all used different systems, and had effects that varied widely in power.  Of course RuneQuest used a skill-based rather than a class-system and so there was a common template for creating a character, but the ranges of occupation and magic and skills were huge.  As a result, each character felt unique and the world felt large, mysterious and dangerous.

The way the game accomplished this was to create an extensible magic and skill system.  POW (or Power) was used by all three magic systems, but in different ways.  Divine magic used raw POW to call on the gods and bring down earth-shaking events.  Spirit magic was “smaller” but more prevalent and common; everybody used a little spirit magic to sharpen their blade or light a way in a dark cavern.  Sorcery required study and blood but had the potential to rival and even exceed divine magic in power.  But all three systems used the POW stat, just in different ways.  So at its base, the underlying fundamentals of the system were the same – what RuneQuest did was take those fundamentals and view them through different lenses and employ different mechanics.

Couldn’t the same be accomplished in an MMO?  What if players could select from a hundred different religions and races and unique magics all tightly tied to the lore and culture and mythology?  What if the fundamental system were so flexible that it could allow for extreme variety and accommodate new abilities and specialties?

And what are the side effects of such a system?  Do we end up with a bunch of Jedi’s running around and nothing else?  Does the game become so diffuse that it collapses?  You might argue that in the case of Talislanta, though in RuneQuest it held up remarkably well.  Each character had a sense of self, and a belonging to a particular culture and set of beliefs. 

You also end up with a very different set of characters with a lot of unique abilities and spells.  I suppose these would end up being classified into the trinity (tank, dps, healing) and being analyzed and optimized like any other game.  Is it even possible to break out of that mold?  Is it even desirable?   Is there even room for more specialty-style abilities?  It would take an approach to quest and scenario and dungeon building that provided opportunities to use those specialties.  I guess what I am looking for is more talk and cooperation and strategy between different adventuring parties that are a bit more than tank does X, dps does Y, and healer does Z.  Maybe you have a chance with this kind of variety, for someone to call on Jehosovatz the Sartorian Monk to call on his god and receive a vision that would help them in the next room.  Or for the mage to cause a distracting hallucination that would allow the party to attack from behind.  Abilities tend to have a common thread of damage, protection or healing – isn’t there room for some stranger things in the mix?

Okay, now that I have given a headache to all the developers out there, tell me why I am crazy!  Let me know of ways we can have more variety and provide more that is unique?  Is it possible without throwing it out of whack, and is it okay if we do?  Let me know your thoughts!

linpingping writes:

cai123 09.06

brewers jerseys

tory burch outlet store

ralph lauren sale clearance uk

rockies jerseys

fitflop shoes

nmd adidas

mulberry outlet uk

pandora jewelry

ugg boots

canada goose

kobe shoes

rolex replica watches

cheap jordans free shipping

uggs outlet

yeezy boost 350

adidas sneakers

air max

dr martens boots

timberland outlet

canada goose jacket

canada goose outlet

canadian goose jacket

christian louboutin sale

skechers outlet

dr martens

pandora jewelry outlet

pandora outlet

canada goose outlet store

air more money

lebron james shoes

kate spade handbags

air max 1

nike cortez classic

coach outlet online

pandora jewelry

coach canada

canada goose parka

uggs outlet

louis vuitton handbags

coach factorty outlet store

michael kors outlet online

kate spade outlet

birkenstock outlet

marlins jerseys

pandora jewelry outlet

fitflop sandals

coach outlet online

timberland outlet

michael kors handbags

coach factory outlet online

pandora rings

coach outlet canada

ugg outlet

coach outlet online

pandora charms

pandora charms sale

moncler coats

hermens

coach outlet

cheap air max

nike outlet

moncler coats

kate spade handbags

nike shoes

michael kors handbags

adidas store

kate spade handbags

louis vuitton outlet store

canada goose jackets

yeezy shoes

nike air max 90

birkenstock outlet online

new balance outlet store

jordan shoes

adidas nmd runner

blue jays jerseys

cheap ray ban sunglasses

air max 87

kate spade outlet online

timberland shoes

coach outlet online

ugg canada

cheap air jordans

coach factory outlet

michael kors outlet online

reds jerseys

adidas outlet online

canada goose jackets

uggs outlet

moncler outlet store

coach outlet online

louboutin shoes

ysl outlet

nike shoes

kate spade outlet online

kate spade bags

coach factorty outlet store

ugg outlet store

uggs outlet

adidas yeezy boost

adidas originals

oakley sunglasses outlet

nike zoom shoes

white sox jerseys

pandora sale clearance

louis vuitton outlet

coach factory outlet

ugg outlet online

adidas superstar shoes

kate spade outlet online

new balance outlet

adidas ultra boost

coach outlet store online

ralph lauren outlet online

dr martens boots

michael kors outlet store

devil rays jerseys

canada goose outlet online

mulberry handbags

pandora jewelry

kate spade handbags

michael kors outlet canada

nfl jerseys

ralph lauren sale clearance uk

nike shox shoes

ralph lauren outlet online

canada goose outlet

astros jerseys

michael kors outlet store

ralph lauren

fitflops uk

ray bans

fred perry polo shirts

nike huarache shoes

coach factory outlet online

christian louboutin shoes

kate spade handbags

nike outlet

pandora charms sale

nike air max 97

uggs outlet

ugg outlet

moncler outlet store

coach factory outlet online

nike air max 2018

fitflop sandals

ugg canada

kate spade handbags

michael kors outlet store

nike dunks

kate spade outlet store

red bottom heels

coach factory outlet online

moncler outlet online

mont blanc pen

reebok outlet

coach factorty outlet online

ugg shoes

louis vuitton outlet online

coach outlet online

kate spade outlet online

moncler outlet

harden vol 1

red bottom

cheap jordan shoes

basketball shoes

philipp plein outlet

adidas outlet store

christian louboutin shoes

oakley sunglasses wholesale

cheap oakley sunglasses

michael kors

kate spade bags

ugg boots

nike huarache shoes

ralph lauren sale

pandora charms outlet

polo ralph lauren outlet online

supreme uk

adidas yeezy

indians jerseys

timberland shoes

pandora charms

birkenstock shoes

tory burch outlet online

pandora outlet store

adidas superstars

moncler outlet store

cheap jordan shoes

converse shoes

christian louboutin shoes

canada goose coats

pandora jewelry

hermes handbags

canada goose sale

air jordan shoes

kate spade outlet online

nike air max zero

birkenstock shoes outlet

salvatore ferragamo outlet

red bottoms

nike air presto

converse all star

jordan shoes

cheap jordan shoes

burberry outlet store

diamondbacks jerseys

timberland outlet

ray ban glasses

mont blanc pens

coach factory outlet online

cheap jordans

prada shoes

canada goose

coach outlet store online

pandora outlet

michael kors outlet store

hermes bag

birkenstock sandals

fendi handbags

fitflop uk

michael kors outlet clearance

birkenstock outlet store

yeezy boost

ralph lauren uk

pandora charms

coach factory outlet online

nike free 5.0

louboutin outlet

gucci outlet online

cheap oakley sunglasses

michael kors outlet

coach outlet online

pandora charms sale

moncler outlet online

canada goose

prada outlet online

supra for sale

ugg sale

swarovski outlet

ralph lauren

swarovski crystal

coach factory outlet online

nike sneakers

tiffany outlet

salomon outlet

city royals jerseys

michael kors outlet clearance

adidas nmd r1

louis vuitton outlet

moncler outlet

salvatore ferragamo

coach factory outlet online

nike outlet online

ralph lauren sale

nike outlet store

coach outlet

ugg boots

hermes bags

moncler jackets

cheap oakley sunglasses

nike outlet online

kate spade outlet

canada goose outlet store

nike air max 2018

supreme shirts

ugg outlet

coach factory outlet

yeezy shoes

ecco outlet

canadian goose

discount oakley sunglasses

pandora jewelry

retro 11

coach outlet store

kyrie 4

fred perry outlet

adidas campus shoes

padres jerseys

pandora charms sale clearance

louis vuitton outlet online

kate spade outlet online

coach factory outlet online

north face jackets

coach outlet online

ecco outlet

canada goose

ecco shoes for women

pandora charms outlet

fitflops sale

adidas shoes

coach outlet online

vans outlet store

canada goose outlet

longchamp outlet

christian louboutin shoes

coach factory outlet

ugg outlet

coach outlet online

orioles jerseys

coach factory outlet online

ugg outlet store

pandora charms outlet

nike running shoes

ugg boots

mets jerseys

polo ralph lauren outlet

pandora jewelry store

ugg outlet store

kate spade outlet online

cheap nfl jerseys wholesale

uggs outlet online

coach outlet canada

nike zoom

canada goose sale

christian louboutin sale

rolex replica watches for sale

michael kors bags

michael kors outlet store

ugg outlet

pandora charms outlet

coach outlet online

moncler outlet online

cheap jordans

vans outlet

michael kors outlet online

coach outlet store online

timberland boots

adidas stan smith

timberland shoes

philipp plein

coach factory outlet online

columbia shoes

ecco outlet

rangers jersey

ralph lauren uk

michael kors outlet

air jordan retro

adidas shoes

longchamp outlet

birkenstock outlet store

louis vuitton factory outlet

michael kors

ralph lauren uk

ugg boots sale

mlb jerseys cheap

jimmy choo outlet

kobe shoes

adidas outlet store

birkenstock sale

discount oakley sunglasses

michael kors outlet store

moncler outlet

canada goose outlet store

canada goose outlet

adidas nmd r1

nike air max 2019

braves jerseys

nike outlet store

ugg outlet

cheap ray ban sunglasses

underarmour outlet

dansko shoes

polo outlet online

pandora jewelry outlet

coach outlet store

coach factory outlet

fitflops sale

air more uptempo

ugg boots outlet

kate spade handbag

air max

coach factory outlet online

asics outlet

ugg outlet online

yeezy boost 350

nfl jerseys

michael kors outlet clearance

salvatore ferragamo shoes

north face outlet store

ecco shoes

cheap oakley sunglasses

louboutin outlet

nike air max 97

ronaldo jerseys

coach outlet store online

discount oakley sunglasses

polo ralph lauren outlet online

ugg outlet store

michael kors outlet clearance

cheap oakley sunglasses

ugg outlet online

christian louboutin shoes

nike react shoes

athletics jerseys

air max shoes

canada goose jackets

durant shoes

gucci outlet store

coach factory outlet online

pandora charms sale clearance

michael kors canada

nike cortez classic

polo ralph lauren outlet

angels jerseys

nike sneakers

coach outlet online

birkin handbags

air max 95

cheap jordan shoes

michael kors outlet clearance

canada goose

moncler

coach outlet online

cheap air jordans

supreme clothing

mlb jerseys wholesale

canada goose

coach outlet online

ugg outlet online

coach outlet store online clearance

fitflops sale clearance

canada goose coats

nike free 3.0

hermes outlet

ugg boots outlet

cheap jordan shoes

adidas outlet

michael kors outlet online

cheap jordans

longchamp outlet online

valentino outlet

ugg outlet

michael kors canada

adidas outlet online

tiffany and co outlet

coach outlet online

coach outlet online

mariners jerseys

adidas outlet store

columbia outlet

mulberry uk

jordan shoes for sale

canada goose jackets

canada goose jackets

mulberry

dodgers jerseys

fitflops sale clearance

pandora charms

nike shoes outlet

coach factorty outlet online

nike outlet store

supreme shirts

kate spade purses

birkenstock uk

birkenstock outlet

pandora charms sale clearance

pg 2 shoes

coach outlet online

kate spade outlet online

michael kors outlet online

lacoste polo shirts

coach outlet online

polo ralph lauren

ugg boots

timberland boots outlet

louboutin shoes

ralph lauren uk

coach factory outlet

tory burch handbags

kate spade purses

adidas yeezy boost 350

air max shoes

uggs outlet store

jordans

michael kors outlet online

canada goose jackets

ralph lauren outlet online

nike outlet store online

pandora charms outlet

cheap jordan shoes

tiffany and co jewelry

canada goose coats

jimmy choo shoes

air jordans

burberry outlet

polo ralph lauren outlet online

toms shoes

coach bags

ugg outlet store

twins jerseys

cartier watches

adidas yeezy shoes

air max 90

coach outlet store online

cheap jordans for sale

canada goose outlet store

ralph lauren outlet online

fake rolex

coach outlet store online

yeezy shoes

coach factory outlet online

polo ralph lauren outlet

coach outlet canada

asics outlet store

uggs outlet

kate spade outlet online

oakley sunglasses outlet

tory burch outlet online

cheap air jordans

air max outlet

moncler coats

coach factory outlet

toms outlet online

pandora jewelry

fitflops sale

supra for sale

pandora charms outlet

yeezy boost 350

rolex replica watches

toms outlet store

adidas outlet online

longchamp

pandora canada

cheap ray ban sunglasses

ugg boots

coach factory outlet online

jimmy choo

nike tessen

louis vuitton factory outlet

hermes bags

cheap nike shoes

converse outlet

mbt

adidas nmd r1

ysl handbags

pirates jerseys

cai123 09.06

Wed Sep 05 2018 8:18PM Report

MMORPG.com writes:
Login or Register to post a comment