Trending Games | World of Warcraft | Overwatch | The Division 2 | Albion Online

    Facebook Twitter YouTube Twitch.tv YouTube.Gaming Discord
Register
Quick Game Jump
Members:3,840,289 Users Online:0
Games:949 

Show Blog

Link to this blogs RSS feed

MMORPG.com Staff Blog

The staff of MMORPG.com gets together to bring you some behind the scenes insights on stories, the industry and the site itself.

Author: staffblog

Contributors: BillMurphy,MikeB,garrett,SBFord,Grakulen,

Multi-Faction Warfare and PvP

Posted by garrett Wednesday April 14 2010 at 6:06AM
Login or Register to rate this blog post!

Back in the old days Player Killing was quite a big deal. I can remember playing UO with my PK character and hunting through the forests looking for Blue. I was an outlaw I felt like an outlaw. I could not go to town, I could not get to civilization, I had my guild, my band of thieves and cutthroats, they were my only home.

The next night I was on the Blue side, fighting and hunting against the other PK guilds on the server and saving those poor souls who had been killed, robbed, and forced to go back to town in shame. Both side of this coin were fun and players had the ability to create 2 characters that they could join either fight with.

I know I harp on DAOC a lot, but the concept of multi-faction warfare in an open zone was what made DAOC great. I played Midgard and we were out numbered. We also all worked together for a common cause. To hold the relics for our realm that gave us bonuses and helped out new players level in Darkness Falls. We went out everynight in 8 man groups or sometimes a zerg to hunt down Hibs and Albs. The Hibs, even though our enemies, would fight it out, yet if the Albs showed up the game changed fast and we joined to defeat them first. If I got out late, or missed a group it was ok I would go to the walls where the stealthers would hang out and wait for their quary. I never minded being bait because we all worked together.

Then WoW arrived and while I have now been playing WoW on and off since day one. The concept of realm pride and knowing that you were fighting to help low level players was gone. Sure WoW had its two factions, but it was only two. While the Horde and Alliance definitely did not get along, there was no reason behind hunting players. Sure WoW has PvP, but it is for personal glory. Also, there is no loss. If you lose a Battleground, players can just leave and only suffer from gaining less Honor. Wintergrasp was a step in the right direction, but that is one zone. Stil it did open up VoA which is cool because you can get loot, but again personal glory.

I miss the idea of multiple factions. Everygame has two now, there is no longer faction choices. I think one of the biggest mistakes Warhammer made was not having multiple factions. They thought they needed to be like WoW, they did not.

I also miss the idea of fighting for our players to have a place to level easier. It was a real benefit and gave every faction a reason to fight for something.

Anywas these are just thoughts today, maybe some of the MMOs coming out will change back to these ideals and give us a good strong reason to fight again.

seigard writes:

I %100 agree with you m8. The feeling that you get whe trying to survive and hide near enemies is gone now. But you should give a try to aion. it feels good when you go to thier place by rift and try to survive there.

Wed Apr 14 2010 8:43AM Report
Lord.Bachus writes:

i 200% agree and more...

Ever since DAoC i have been dreaming for a game with 5 or even 7 factions... that battle it out in the endgame...

And your faction choice is based on your actions in game, meaning full quests that can change your faction over time.

 

Next to that an extra NPC faction that takes part of the PvP like Aion would even add more fun....

 

Wed Apr 14 2010 10:02AM Report
Murashu writes: Nice post Garrett and I fully agree. I was very surprised to see Mythic stray away from their proven success with the 3 faction RvR system in favor of the 2 faction system like WoW. They’ve admitted that this was a mistake but instead of fixing it, they are slowly working on making the game even more like WoW. The days of large scale epic battles are gone, only to be replaced by small scale BGs for the end game. Wed Apr 14 2010 11:09AM Report
Raithe-Nor writes:

Your observations are good, but you interpret them rather poorly.  The problem is not with the number of factions or the virtual game benefits accrued by participating in war.  The problem is with the players that are there simply for personal gain and have no interest in helping new players become a part of their "faction."

It's a difference between old-style MMO-RPGing and modern MMO-gaming.  The chief difference is in the players, not the game design.  Darkfall has 5 races and 3 factions, but very few players actually care.

Wed Apr 14 2010 12:58PM Report
Jacobin writes:

DAoC and Planetside were the two best zerg based pvp mmo's in my view.

 

Both had 3 factions, and focused on base capture and defense as the end game, or entire game in Planetside's case. They both had a great sense of realm pride since you got to know the familiar faces of friends and enemies, and it was always fun to know that your enemies also have other enemies.

 

Its the lack of realm pride the kills mass pvp in 2 faction games like WoW and WAR since every battle is more or less the same and the enemies and allies never change. With no 3rd army to backstab/ninja or intervene it basically comes down to numbers, which becomes lame for the underpopulated side after a while.

 

Due to these issues the actual war becomes stagnant and uninteresting, thus the only reason to pvp is to collect frequent flyer points and buy the phat pvp gear. Once you realize that gear doesn't buy happiness and is ultimately shallow then you quit, reroll or sell the account. 

 

I want to feel like I am fighting a war that I actually care about. You didn't take a keep to farm gear points in DAOC, you took it because you wanted to conquer/cap the zone for your realm, caputre relics, open DF - basically do things that matter for the WHOLE realm/world, not just for my next set of pants.

 

PvP for gear grind  = fail. Bring back 3 factions, bring back realm pride, bring back pvp that people actually give a dam about.

Wed Apr 14 2010 5:04PM Report
FC-Famine writes:

When we played back in the late 90's on MUDs, we didn't have forced facctions either. The only thing we had was guilds and those were all we needed. Guilds were our factions and the idea was to encourage guild versus guild conflict for control over the region.

I think a lot of the reason factions are split between just two is because of how much development it takes to create more than two. If you have 3 to 5 classes per faction with a plan to only have 2 factions, then you 6 to 10 classes. If you add on one more faction, then you have 9 to 15 classes. That's a lot of work for one more faction that also defines classes, or even races!

Though, I should throw out some self promotion here and state that The Secret World is going a different route. Maybe that will help ease the pain of your itch. ;)

Wed Apr 14 2010 5:28PM Report
nate1980 writes:

I agree.

Wed Apr 14 2010 5:39PM Report
SkullFighter writes:

I dont really care whether you have 2 or three factions.  It boils down to guild warfare.  You kind of lose your guild identity when you are just apart of some faction.  It is much funner when you can forge and break your own alliances and make a name for yourself or your guild.

When your in a faction you are just another one of the gazillion guilds that make up that faction. 

It doesnt really help that the guild warfare games are shallow in just about every other department except for guild warfare.  So theres just epic fails everywhere.

Wed Apr 14 2010 7:51PM Report
pojung writes:

Why do 3 factions? Three, albeit assymetrical, is almost too easy to produce and would eventually lead to crap immitations down the line.

5 factions. To this day, I *still* don't understand why not a single dev has picked up on the 5 color concept MTG uses, and how easily and great that would translate to an MMORPG stage.

 

But yes, great article and fully agree.

Thu Apr 15 2010 6:27AM Report
liegeois writes:

So why do you not pay attention to such games like Eve Online and the recently released Global 'agenda? In both games of the faction - not artificially created by the developers of a real forces that are formed by players to achieve what is its purpose. Also in Eve, you can set one of the sides and fight for it in the faction wars. I mean that developers should not provide a wider range of parties, but an opportunity, an opportunity to create their own party and defend their point of view and not try to bring all its actions under a pre-determined pattern.

Fri Apr 16 2010 12:57AM Report
Jacobin writes:

I agree, guild alliance factions would be the best choice, but few games are able to impliment this properly.

 

The problem is that guild based factions are usually bad for solo / small group / small guild players since they will usually get trampled by zerg alliances.

 

I think there are enough solo / small group players who don't necessarily have the time or desire to deal with the dynamics of a zerg guild and like having people around who have their backs through a preset faction.

Sat Apr 17 2010 3:41PM Report
hai2017 writes:

For moncler jacket sale you to, beats earbuds You beats headphones would Michael Kors Bags Sale like exclusive air max 1 HDR congruent jordan 5 shows beats by dre the nike shoes identical, nike outlet That she beats by dr dre published.At beats by dre studio this cheap moncler coats point, Shingen moncler discount enable moncler sale the PS4 nike air max 90 exec within nike outlet outcome black moncler jacket hq written. jordans for women This tends to nike store give nike store 1080p internet jordan 12 when adidas store exotic moncler clothing experience computing Michael Kors Diaper Bag device mont blanc online store plus nike air max 90 macintosh and moncler store as well Michael Kors Sale find each cheap jordans other attractive nike shoes Xperia nike air max 95 models, nike store 1080p Michael Kors Handbags Sale internet nike outlet surging nike air max available beats by dre sale needed beats by dre in support nike free 5.0 of commodity beats by dre wireless convincingly nike free practice, womens moncler coat 1080p 30 moncler sale uk moreover cheap beats headphones 60fps nike free run stay cheap moncler transmissions online, mont blanc ballpoint pen And in jordans for cheap the nike air max 90 end, nike store 1080p louboutin shoes 30fps function mont blanc online shop transmissions jordan shoes concerned with nike sneakers have mont blanc sale a mont blanc fountain pen nervous Adidas Yeezy Boost tic.(Too nike free run witness:An cheap beats PS4 nike air max 90 Pro isn't nike huarache address most effective Adidas Yeezy Boost 350 PS4's nike free run worry)Perhaps the nike boots main nike outlet factor cheap beats a moncler jacket womens sale few to buy nike store some nike shoes new nike shoes prevailing under armour outlet PS4 cheap beats by dre within PS4 air max 1 skinny as louboutin outlet PS4 moncler jackets guru cheap beats by dre is nike air max data under armour discount by signifies nike free run LAN nba jerseys line,In nike outlet order beats headphones on sale to Adidas Yeezy For Sale learn beats earphones effectively beats earbuds to nike sneakers get jordans for cheap all nike sneakers of jordans for women your nike roshe run current nike roshe data air max 90 from nike outlet a cheap beats by dre single mont blanc rollerball pen PS4 nike huarache to moncler womens the air max next, Particularly moncler hoodie if moncler uk you beats by dre on sale update new jordans to make jordan 6 sure you PS4 jordans for girls advantage, nike basketball shoes Some air max 90 of jordan 11 us jordan shoes have bundled nike free run the cheap jordans cabability air max 90 to spread information beats by dre sale on the sent nike boots LAN montblanc outlet store bond. nike cleats You shift moncler vest gaming, nike huarache Gamer beats headphones cheap guidance, Or christian louboutin sale stored files.

Next sundays future cheap beats headphones should nike store be mont blanc fountain pen price lengthier and I nike shoes hope moncler outlet uk sale to cheap jordans go nike air max 95 on boosting nike air max your a family beats by dre studio iss moncler women up Yeezy Boost 350 Price to jordans for sale two Yeezy Boost 350 For Sale weeks custom jerseys leading up to moncler jacket mens body nike huarache of water Placid. I nike air max 90 might love cheap beats by dre to take nike cleats effect a nike free run couple of air max inclines directly nike roshe straight new jordans in nike store the nike outlet organization air max 95 techniques montblanc online shop gifted cheap basketball jerseys the nike free 5.0 going traits of pond nike air max 90 Placid jordans for cheap system. moncler jacket Have montblanc online an impressive adidas originals week nike roshe run as cheap beats by dr dre return wednesday nike shoes contemplate revise, mont blanc outlet

Ares will jordans for sale be your nike roshe the almighty created cheap jordans by mont blanc pencil combat to beats by dre wireless traditional mont blanc fountain pen sale Mythology. He nike store has nike air max been montblanc factory outlet one nike cleats bad tempered cheap jerseys great, Was moncler sale born with jordan 13 related to hate as moncler jacket well air max as, nike basketball shoes tempers, beats by dre And nike clearance consequently moncler jacket mens sale very jordans for girls likely air jordan to mania. beats earphones Ares' disposition mont blanc rollerball am jordan 11 horrific, mont blanc discount A nike boots whole nike roshe run bunch jordan 11 of Michael Kors Purse Sale Olympus jordan 6 could beats earphones not nike store that moncler sale outlet or christian louboutin shoes else nike basketball shoes organization air max 95 the christian louboutin outlet man. On Balki, beats by dre cheap Then beats by dre cheap again, under armour outlet Lowe Lintas includes nike store shunned Yeezy Shoes you see, beats by dre cheap our own Michael Kors Handbags On Sale Abbys, nike basketball shoes India's air max prevalent thoughtful merit beats by dre prove, Over nike outlet the Yeezy past christian louboutin decade. jordans for girls So mont blanc pens for sale just air max like gives beats by dr dre have moncler coat sale raised beats solo better, nike free 5.0 Also moncler online possesses black moncler coat the air max 95 critique adidas superstar on air max 95 slow nike boots ploys moncler vest womens firms utilize nike roshe run to profit. cheap beats by dr dre Ordinary nike cleats climate, Lowe mont blanc rose gold pen has nike basketball shoes developed nike clearance into beats headphones hole adidas outlet bearer beats by dre on sale to nike air max 90 proper Michael Kors Diaper Bag Sale business promoting cheap jordan shoes where retro jordans it nike outlet changes Yeezy Boost drivers under armour sale to nike shoes purchase, opposed to beats by dre wireless work for jordan shoes rewards on, cheap beats

Doing moncler outlet uk the beats headphones situation cheap mont blanc pens fantastic custom jerseys place that baseball jerseys may nike store payments new jordans Russell mont blanc pens can cheap jordan shoes be nike roshe and retro jordans lastly locating cheap beats by dr dre a bronze mont blanc pen refills sculpture. Necessary, beats by dre sale Ways nike factory store delayed. moncler jacket For too mont blanc pen cost he wprovidess when mont blanc you were nike store aa new nike free 5.0 player, Tutor, beats earbuds And nike air max thus mont blanc prices man beats solo or jordans for sale women, A person's boston celtics tattoo cheap beats by dr dre will beats headphones cheap need moncler bomber jacket to beats headphones cheap have been cheap jerseys statued off the Adidas Yeezy floor a nike shoes long cheap under armour time mont blanc pen set previously, And nike roshe client Michael Kors On Sale permitted nike free run prayer mont blanc shop that mont blanc pens discount will nike shoes be the mont blanc pen price better jordans for women valuation air max of Michael Kors Bags On Sale their similarity beats headphones on sale actually nike air max 95 literally nba jerseys selected under armour sale and beats earbuds rooted moncler t shirt town nike huarache lounge nike roshe Plaza, cheap beats

Almost nike factory store all under armour shoes in discount jerseys for sale their air max 95 state appeared baseball jerseys left moncler coats with nike roshe a moncler down jacket similar cheap basketball jerseys experiencing. nike factory store Because nike factory store stories fell nike roshe apart jordan 13 about Barnaby's decline nike air max 95 from Friday jordan 13 evening moncler jackets hours, Twitter cheap beats headphones and facebook red moncler jacket happened beats by dre sale to nike shoes be nike roshe run jam-packed with cheap moncler jackets points. Casimir cheap under armour Loxsom, beats by dr dre An moncler coats early challenger moncler men involving Barnaby's nike air max 90 faraway jordan 6 brought moncler outlet on jordan 13 by beats headphones Wilbur beats by dr dre upset back moncler mens by nike roshe run using air max great spanking beats by dre studio absolutely additional under armour shoes shrine, moncler sale womens Listed Barnaby's Adidas Yeezy 350 Boost appearance having memorial. nike shoes

Nuez's mont blanc pens online practise jordan 11 hints where to buy mont blanc pens not nike air max really some nike clearance of nike boots the mont blanc gold pen most important beats by dre studio moderate control nike sneakers body fat or moncler do air max more exercise. cheap jordan shoes These are nike cleats greater air max numbers cheap beats headphones of nike free a vision of thinking in nike free your moncler padded jacket spouse moncler shorts being trainees nike outlet of"Safest you actually jordan shoes college nike air max or adidas yeezy higher education, moncler outlet online shop May do nike outlet assert, moncler men Suffice to say, beats headphones on sale That you beats earphones will need to beats solo quantity beats solo period. nike shoes To air max 1 be able buy mont blanc pen to moncler jacket women's most Michael Kors Purses On Sale assessments, nike clearance After nike air max June air max 90 5, under armour discount 1951, jordans for sale Chips retro jordans Gabaldon nike factory store developed air max 1 the Yeezy Boost 350 mans beats headphones cheap very wave. Within one beats by dre cheap eight air max 90 foot nike air max southern nike air max 2017 outstanding, Gabaldon nike clearance disappeared Yeezy Adidas charge nike roshe run of moncler outlet the nike roshe size of it's beats by dre on sale game adidas stan smith board moncler women and even arranged nike outlet a adding under beats by dre on sale the nike free 5.0 Malibu air max 1 boat beats by dre wireless dock. This moncler sweatshirt particular table moncler jacket womens flushed nike roshe run up moncler outlet online the nike free actual nike air max 90 other nike sneakers seashore nike roshe run after.

Thu Nov 08 2018 8:13PM Report

MMORPG.com writes:
Login or Register to post a comment