Trending Games | World of Warcraft | Overwatch | The Division 2 | Albion Online

    Facebook Twitter YouTube YouTube.Gaming Discord
Quick Game Jump
Members:3,840,288 Users Online:0

Show Blog

Link to this blogs RSS feed


One man's quest through the world of MMORPGs...

Author: elvenprince9

The Evolution of MMORPG Cash Shops

Posted by elvenprince9 Wednesday March 25 2009 at 10:27PM
Login or Register to rate this blog post!

One thing that is starting to annoy me in the free MMORPG industry is the shift in the type of items sold in cash shops. For those that aren’t familiar with the term ‘Cash shop’ it is the place where players can exchange real life money for in game goodies. Back when I first started playing free MMORPGs, cash shops almost always had strictly aesthetic items like clothes and accessories for sale that had no impact on the game. Back then it was considered taboo for an MMORPG publisher to sell items that would give an unfair advantage to those that paid over those that didn’t. As a player that rarely bought cash shop items, I felt that this was fair, as it rewarded those that paid by making their avatars look really awesome, but it didn’t imbalance the game. Maplestory for example, for a very long time operated in this fashion. Back then It didn’t sell any items that imbalanced the game, but today sells 2x experience scrolls and powerful equipment. GunZ: The Duel at one time also had a cash shop that strictly sold items that had no impact on the balance of the game, but today it sells a lot of over powered equipment that can quickly imbalance a game.

So what happened? Why did free MMOs and MMORPGs suddenly start selling such powerful items in the cash shop? Money of course. Publishers like Nexon and IJJI can generate a lot more revenue if they offer better and more powerful items in their stores, as more players are likely to buy 2x experience scrolls than a shiny robe that only serves one purpose; making your character look cooler. I really don’t mind that much when publishers sell experience scrolls and equipment in their cash shops, as it’s their game, but I do get a bit upset when some publishers overdo it. Every one of IGG’s games, Tales of Pirates, Voyage Century, Godswar and Galaxy Online, for example, have such powerful cash shop items that their games just aren’t worth playing without a cash commitment. Those that purchase cash shop items in IGG’s games have such a huge advantage over those that don’t, which is a huge turn off for players that want to play for free.

I’d personally like to see publishers sell only aesthetic items in their cash shops, but with the current trend it doesn’t look like this is going to happen anytime soon. It’s not that I don’t want to see publishers profit, I do, but I hate seeing non paying players quit a game over imbalanced cash shop items because it destroys the community. Publishers need to find a way to earn a profit without scaring away non paying players. One game that I think did this perfectly is Gunbound, as the game has powerful cash shop items, but has channels in the game that disable the effectiveness of all items, which evens the playing field. This gives the player a choice; he can play on the channel which allows cash shop items or the one that doesn’t. I’m curious to see which direction MMORPG and MMO cash shops will take, but only time will tell.

avalon1000 writes:

Ahh yes let the greed flow...when you start selling weapons and such the game becomes very unbalanced..Also, I might point out that MS has tons of gold farmers and sellers.  When I played well over a year ago it was common to come across all sorts of hacks to gather materials for gold sellers.

Wed Mar 25 2009 11:06PM Report
Compugasm writes:

Ogame is a text based sci-fi game, but it has a nice idea. The features you get from purchase don't offer a huge play advantage. Instead it improves the interface slightly. For example, when you construct a building the paid players get a countdown timer that tells them when the required resources will be gathered. Or, buildings can be placed into a que. Free players can't que buildings. In this way, the game is enhanced with some features, but not gameplay is not imbalanced.

Thu Mar 26 2009 5:11AM Report
wolfmann writes:

Finally the game companies lets the PVE/PVP people foot the bill, instead of putting it all on the fluff gamers.... and then you complain.

Fri Mar 27 2009 4:59AM Report
TTHT writes:


I am familiar with Ogame and as I recall you can also get better exchange rates, which you can make HUGE profit off of, improve your mining production, and increase scrapyard rates. Additionally, when colonizing planets, you may not need to use a terraformer because you can purchase additional fields. While this isn't a game that has been affected extremely by this change, there are people who buy up to 500M deuterium a week for 2:1:1 rates and merch them to make 500M Crystal profit. Ogame is not really all that different.

Tue Nov 12 2013 8:41PM Report writes:
Login or Register to post a comment