Some of thoes questions you approved to be asked are so stupid and pointless.   

"Will it have Multiplayer"   i sure hope that was a joke question.

that, my  friend, was no joke....which is probably why the entire channel went nuts LOL.  Best question, and the flood of "name changes" to MULTIPLAYERHAHA, PLAYOFFLINELOL, warhammerOFFLINE.   That was classic.

if i could go backin time i would get that wasted hour back.

I have to agree that was pretty pointless and wish i could get my hour back also.  Seriously if you are going to do something like this shouldnt you have some one who knows a little something about this game, such as the fact is an ONLINE MULTIPLAYER game and weed out some of the stupid inane questions?  At least that would seem like common sense to me, but what do I know.

Maybe it was an inside joke about there Main Competition AoC. Since AoC has some offline aspects....

Could be wrong, but somtimes you gotta read between the lines and AoC is there biggest threat.

Originally posted by Kazered

Maybe it was an inside joke about there Main Competition AoC. Since AoC has some offline aspects....

Could be wrong, but somtimes you gotta read between the lines and AoC is there biggest threat.

Actually, AoC isn't really offline for that first bit. You can still group, it's just that you can turn the other players off for that point.

Ya, I know. I laughed at it when I first read it. But you can only read the same joke so many times in one day before it gets stale.

Except this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5TuK3evLlR0&eurl=

That's funny every time I see it.

It was a joke!  Lighten up.

The dev chat was also fun.

 Yeah, I quite enjoyed it my self. Kind of felt like we were just having a friendly chat with the WAR devs in a way.

Ok first of all thank you for Arranging the Dev chat. Next Please tell me why I and my GF wasted 2hours of our life for it waiting for our question to be answered and to our horror you cut the questions short?

90% of the questions asked had allready been answered in Podcasts or in Warhammer site in General.

Next choosing questions like "is it Multiplayer" is waste of time and effort. That is bad journalism or how you want to MMORPG.com to be known?

So few wishes for future if you do it again let someone who has been reading the "games official site" of the current title to ask the questions and knows bit more than Lady Taera, Make questions that are not self explaining, Ask questions that are relevant, and ask questions bit faster

Yours Respectfully : Lordnagash & Nenwe

Originally posted by Cathalaode

Ya, I know. I laughed at it when I first read it. But you can only read the same joke so many times in one day before it gets stale.

Except this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5TuK3evLlR0&eurl=

That's funny every time I see it.

Thanks for the great laugh.

I'm not sure really what to make of the answers... they all seemed kinda vague.

I would have thought this far into the beta that they could have give us something a bit more specific... It sounds promising but i just don't think they've made their mind up yet about some pretty basic things.

Even if they stated specifics, ran them through the beta and they had to be tweeked is better than playing dumb. If they don't know for sure, no one does :P

I'll be interested to see when it actually get released, but certainly looking forward to it atm

Originally posted by Taera

Have some humor, guys! ;)

if you like the other clip then try this it's genius.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lpZWE8Br1ZA

since i run the IRC server its all hosted on, I can tell you that the mmorpg staff do not "approve" the questions, repeated questions, and inappropreate questions (such as "Why does ur game suck so much") get filtered, but after that, the dev's see all questions, and pick the ones they want to answer... if they want it Taera posts it, if they dont, they just skip it...

as for questions that were submitted, but not 'asked' -- all remaining questions have been logged and forwarded to the dev's, and depending if/when they answer them they will be posted on the forums for all to see... so your question(s) that were left may still get answered...

as i said before, the dev's pick which ones they want to answer, not mmorpg or us (the irc)

Originally posted by Dameonk

 

Originally posted by Cathalaode

Ya, I know. I laughed at it when I first read it. But you can only read the same joke so many times in one day before it gets stale.

Except this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5TuK3evLlR0&eurl=

That's funny every time I see it.

Wow.... I haven't seen that video in months.  How could I have forgotten about that internet gem.

 

Thanks for the great laugh.

it was pretty much as expected.

some good tidbits of information though:

all melee DPS classes will have an "intercept" like ability - including a "tentacle grab" for Marauders

tanks will be able to use 2h weapons for offensive tanking

the eluded to the PVE dungeons - open dungeons with instanced bosses for groups and raids

the eluded that they plan on re-evaluating the importance of open world PVP objectives vs. instanced scenarios, awesome tidbit for those of us not wanting a repeat of the battleground grind from WoW

the mentioned some character customization features like armor dying and different choices upon character creation to keep the distinctive silhouette but still offer originality.

mentioned dwarf women getting bigger "braids" though it seems they may have been referring also to larger (different B word synonymous with pubescent angst)

that's all I can think of now without re-reading it.

I didn't attend the chat because I was playing Halo 3 lol, but i knew they'd post up a chat log.

Hey everyone.

Yeah it was an interesting dev chat, of course we didn't get to hear all the answers we wanted to hear, But thanks to mmorpg.com for hosting this, it was fun to be able to sit in and listen to the real Mythic devs.

Hrm not sure why everyone feels they wasted an hour or two, not like we were chained to our desks :P I was actually doing some reading and looking over the chat from time to time, knowing there would be a chat log. It was quite amusing to hear that question regarding multiplayer though, silly but amusing all the same.

-Manaia

dev chats are a load of rubbish in my opinion, what they need to do instead of forcing players out of the conversation is stick the devs in one room with the players and have them talk to each other, not talk through them, I barely look at these things because of the way they're ran.

Originally posted by Ghozer

since i run the IRC server its all hosted on, I can tell you that the mmorpg staff do not "approve" the questions, repeated questions, and inappropreate questions (such as "Why does ur game suck so much") get filtered, but after that, the dev's see all questions, and pick the ones they want to answer... if they want it Taera posts it, if they dont, they just skip it...

as for questions that were submitted, but not 'asked' -- all remaining questions have been logged and forwarded to the dev's, and depending if/when they answer them they will be posted on the forums for all to see... so your question(s) that were left may still get answered...

 

as i said before, the dev's pick which ones they want to answer, not mmorpg or us (the irc)

May you please give us the link in this thread when and if they answer those questions not answered in dev chat

Thank you

Bad news , no bonus for grouping. I hate this it is so dumb, there should be + xp / reknow for grouping just like there is in DAOC. Not becuase there is in DAOC , but becuase it makes grouping worthwhile . It could be 3% + xp /RK per player in group, IE 2 players = +3%, 6 = +18%.

Other bad news Universal Cooldowns, WOW anyone. There can be many cool downs on abilities thats fine in fact its good. But unviversal cool downs are dumb. There should be moves/spells abilities that do not have any cooldown.

These Dev Chats are mostly for entertainment and to get a chance to see the personalilites of the developers.    Some people seemed to think that they were going to announce the last elf classes or something.

By now we should ALL know that major news is saved for major conferences and shows.  It baffles me why people ALWAYS ask questions that they know would be big revealtions (How does Crafting work?  How do Living Guilds work?).    Everyone KNOWS they wont' be answered in an informal IRC discussion, but we get the questions anyway.    We'll get the answers to those types of questions the way we always have - major press releases, major articles or major events.

There were some useful tidbits of course - no XP bonus for grouping and such.  And the Devs also give people a general feel of the game with their chat and those tidbits.  Obviously some people aren't happy with what they're hearing and that's to be expected.  Mythic has been clear that they're not trying to make a game that will appeal to everyone, they want a a focused game and if that means less subscribers they're willing to accept that.   Which, frankly, has been one of WAR strengths IMO.    And I think that focus might actually bring in more subscribers rather than push them away.

Originally posted by Taera

Over 300 questions were submitted during the chat; while the devs stayed a half hour late to answer more of those questions, we still had 98 questions in the queue (after deleting duplicate questions).  Today I will be going through these questions and sending 20 on to the WAR team.

We apologize if your question did not get answered; there was no favoritism, no rating "X" question over "Y" question; questious were selected purely on a first come, first serve basis.

Very cool Taera.  My question was only included for humor purposes and submitted before I found out how large the queue was. 

Well, I didn't get to attend live...but read the chatlog...interesting stuff.... of course, never enough info...but thanks for hosting it none the less.....

I just want to play this game.... I hope they actually get it released in early 2008.

I thought the information given was alright and informative. Of course I'm coming from the view of not having been to all the fansites or the gamesites.  I am eagerly anticipating the release though

Originally posted by Taera

Over 300 questions were submitted during the chat; while the devs stayed a half hour late to answer more of those questions, we still had 98 questions in the queue (after deleting duplicate questions).  Today I will be going through these questions and sending 20 on to the WAR team.

We apologize if your question did not get answered; there was no favoritism, no rating "X" question over "Y" question; questions were selected purely on a first come, first serve basis.

Hmmm seems to be two different stories then, someone posted earlier the the developers decided on what questions were answered and now your saying that it was first come first serve?

Get your stories straight at least... and if your going to show favoritism at least be straight and admit it.

Originally posted by Tyfreaky

Originally posted by Taera

Over 300 questions were submitted during the chat; while the devs stayed a half hour late to answer more of those questions, we still had 98 questions in the queue (after deleting duplicate questions).  Today I will be going through these questions and sending 20 on to the WAR team.

We apologize if your question did not get answered; there was no favoritism, no rating "X" question over "Y" question; questions were selected purely on a first come, first serve basis.

Hmmm seems to be two different stories then, someone posted earlier the the developers decided on what questions were answered and now your saying that it was first come first serve?

Get your stories straight at least... and if your going to show favoritism at least be straight and admit it.

Well i was there , and it looked very first come first serve. that being said when the mythic peeps said we are not answer anymore about guid stuff after the first question was asked, the MMORPG people cleared out all of the guild questions  from the bot (this happened to em and it told me about it ).

How it worked was , you joined the irc channel then you sent a message like this: /msg devbot <your question here>. It spit them out 1 after another in the order they were recived.

That being said the MMORPG staff did look at the questions before sending them into the channel, thus avoiding flames and trolls (like soem oen sayign why does mythic suck, the mmorpg staff would have removed that question from the bot). Addtionally , the mmorpg staff removed repeditive questions and questiosn that the mythic people said ina  reply to a question they would not answer (guild and crafting stuff)

MMORPFG's "stories" were fine,  you just need some logic. Anyone could submit any question at the start all questions (other than 100% trolls) were open game, however, the dev.s (mythic people) decied which one they would answer. 

Ok what this means is if i asked you: why do you suck at all games, are you sweet, what color is your hair, and how many time have you smoked weed?  And you answered you hair is brown, you are sweet and said i am not answering the other two. You just chose what questions you would answer, the same way the mythic peoples did.

Originally posted by Jetrpg

 

Originally posted by Tyfreaky

Originally posted by Taera

Over 300 questions were submitted during the chat; while the devs stayed a half hour late to answer more of those questions, we still had 98 questions in the queue (after deleting duplicate questions).  Today I will be going through these questions and sending 20 on to the WAR team.

We apologize if your question did not get answered; there was no favoritism, no rating "X" question over "Y" question; questions were selected purely on a first come, first serve basis.

Hmmm seems to be two different stories then, someone posted earlier the the developers decided on what questions were answered and now your saying that it was first come first serve?

Get your stories straight at least... and if your going to show favoritism at least be straight and admit it.

You and i meet agian.

 

Well i was there , and it looked very first come first serve. that being said when the mythic peeps said we are not answer anymore about guid stuff after the first question was asked, the MMORPG people cleared out all of the guild questions  from the bot (this happened to em and it told me about it ).

How it worked was , you joined the irc channel then you sent a message like this: /msg devbot <your question here>. It spit them out 1 after another in the order they were recived.

 

That being said the MMORPG staff did look at the questions before sending them into the channel, thus avoiding flames and trolls (like soem oen sayign why does mythic suck, the mmorpg staff would have removed that question from the bot). Addtionally , the mmorpg staff removed repeditive questions and questiosn that the mythic people said ina  reply to a question they would not answer (guild and crafting stuff)

MMORPFG's "stories" were fine,  you just need some logic. Anyone could submit any question at the start all questions (other than 100% trolls) were open game, however, the dev.s (mythic people) decied which one they would answer. 

Ok what this means is if i asked you: why do you suck at all games, are you sweet, what color is your hair, and how many time have you smoked weed?  And you answered you hair is brown, you are sweet and said i am not answering the other two. You just chose what questions you would answer, the same way the mythic peoples did.

 

So there was filtering of questions, by the Devs, but again Taera states there was no filtering of this sort and that the questions were first come first serve.

Secondly:

Taera just stated they CHOSE 20 questions to be sent on to Mythic to be answered. If it was truly first come first serve the first 20 questions of the 98 unasked ones would have been sent and there would be no choosing process.

It seems MMOrpg.com does have a favoritism policy, I just want them to admit it.

Originally posted by Tyfreaky

 

I have to disagree with your logic. MMORPG apologised for not everyones question being answered, and stated it was on a first come first serve basis. If this was true there would be NO selection process other than the obvious filtering of "mythic sucks" and repetitive questions.

 

 

So there was filtering of questions, by the Devs, but again Taera states there was no filtering of this sort and that the questions were first come first serve.

Secondly:

Taera just stated they CHOSE 20 questions to be sent on to Mythic to be answered. If it was truly first come first serve the first 20 questions of the 98 unasked ones would have been sent and there would be no choosing process.

 

It seems MMOrpg.com does have a favoritism policy, I just want them to admit it.

Wow, you're really stretching here.

Taera said that the questions were selected on a first come first serve basis, not that they were answered as such.

Mythic still had final say over what questions were displayed in the channel (or so was stated).  So no one lied.

As far as the 20 questions that were selected out of the 98 that remained.  Did you consider the fact that there were probably duplicate, innapropriate, already answered, or not valid questions out of those 98?

Seems to me like you are looking for something to be upset about when nothing is there.

Tyfreak just think about it a bit.  Find a copy of the full irc log and its really obvious that nothing shady went down.