I can't get directly onto the PotBS forums so I figured this is the next best place to ask.  Title is it.

Whether it be single player, multiplayer, online, whatever. 

What's your favorite PC pirate game.  I want to try out a few.  Currently I'm looking to play Sid Meier's Pirate's.  Heard that was a good one.

SM:P is a bit too arcadey for my liking.  It's fun for a while but after a while I really got annoyed with how mind-meltingly shallow it was.

The Sea Dogs games seemed to be quite a bit more My Thing - I really liked the one that was renamed to Pirates of the Caribbean in the last minute but some seriously hideous bugs and control issues stopped me from playing.  Apparantly most of the issues I had with it can be circumvented.

PotBS

Hehe, well I certainly would agree that PotBS does certainly have the most fun ship-to-ship combat system of any pirate game I've played, espescially when you get into a decent PvP Battle against some evenly matched opponents (which happens more often than I think the general impression gives).

I think most games (Sid Meier aside) do the sword-fighty parts better though.

Currently the three Pirate-themed MMOs that I play are Tales of Pirates, Puzzle Pirates, and Pirates of the Burning Sea.

Of those three, though, PotBS is the most 'piratical' in gameplay and design. They're introducing a free trial soon, so it's worth checking out.

I haven't played many single-player games lately, but if I was to headout and buy one, it would be the recent release of Sid Meier's Pirates. I liked the diversity of the gameplay (missions, random ship battles, land battles, multiple goals ot work towards) of Pirates! Gold back when I had it, so I'm thinking the new version should be even better. *should*  :)

PotBS is the best pirate game I've played and I have played them all.

I haven't played the revamped Sid Meyer's Pirates, but the old one was a heck of a lot of fun for me.

Yay !

It's long overdue & about time a positive thread about Potbs appeared.

PotBS is the best one I've played so far, I loved SM:Pirate and PotCO is great to if you're up for that game it delivers in the way its meant to, however PotBS offers me the most as I enjoy what im doing in the game. If you read the missions you are doing instead of clicking yes I accept ( i do sometimes i won't lie) but when you read some its interesting. Also Pvp is fun I had my first swing at it today which was even for my lvl and I had a blast doing it. I feel this game has done what is meant for me theres haters and basher but i've played all the pirates games i could get my hands on and this is the best one i've found to date for depth.

Playin Sids Pirates! on a commodore C64 back in the late 80ies was one of my top 5 game experiences ever.

"Crew is angry!"

ZOMGZ!

I used to love to play an old game on the Nintendo 64 from KOEi called Uncharted Waters and Uncharted Waters: Horizons.. It had it all, from exploration to pirating. I spent a lot of time on that game along with Romance of the 3 Kingdoms and Aerobiz.

Sheesh I'm old.

Nuich

Ooh WindWaker.. does that count?

Originally posted by barmbek76

Playin Sids Pirates! on a commodore C64 back in the late 80ies was one of my top 5 game experiences ever.

"Crew is angry!"

ZOMGZ!

Yeah, the remake isn't bad, but the original version of Pirates! was flat out awesome.

Please don't laugh, but I actually think Puzzle Pirates is the best pirate game I ever played.  Such a weird design, but at the same time much deeper than one would think at first glance.  And totally absorbing, too.

If you're limiting things to single-player games, I haven't played many of them, but I would say that Port Royale beats Sid Meier's Pirates.  It's mostly  an economic game, with god-awful graphics, but the mechanics are flawless and the game even more open-ended than Meier's.  Apparently they made a sequel, which I never played.