|4 posts found|
Hard Core Member
MMORPGs are no longer about the mass multi-user
OP 5/17/13 12:24:42 PM#1
I'm not sure if it's a psychological effect that the first MMORPG one plays will be the one with the best memories. You know what I mean, the first moment you step into a persistent virtual world and you were awed by everything you saw and how the dynamics of the game made the world actually happen. Of course, along with all the other players around you...
blog-post I made for today...
5/17/13 12:49:29 PM#2
First MMORPG's are the most precious because everything is new and unique. You play without judgement and simply enjoy the game for what it is. The second MMORPG that we play is going to be constantly compared to the first. It could be a good thing if your first MMORPG was pretty terrible, but the second usually ends in disappointment. Fast forward years later and we're constantly judging a game based on our knowledge and previous experiences. The problem is that our memories degrade and people tend to glorify distant memories. I think this happens subconsciously whether we realize it or not.
That's my theory on the subject. I also enjoyed reading your blog post.
10/17/13 11:57:49 AM#3
I don't know if it's necessarily true in all cases that the "new experience" effect can't be repeated beyond your first MMO.
It really has everything to do with how you approach each new game.
My favorite and longest-played MMO of all time is FFXI. However, it wasn't my first. It was actually my 3rd, and so by the time I started it, I was already pretty familiar with MMOs, what they were, etc. It was the first MMO that really grabbed me, though.
After that, I discovered Lineage 2. It gave me that "all new experience" all over again and became my second favorite and longest-played MMO.
After that, I picked up EQ2, and it - again - gave me that "all new feeling".
Same with Matrix Online. Same with Anarchy Online. Same with just about every other MMO I've played that actually kept me interested.
The reason I think that's worked for me is because I basically enter each new MMO with a kind of "self-inflicted amnesia" for the MMOs I played before it. I don't make comparisons between them. When I started playing Lineage 2, I wasn't playing it with expectations of "how it compared to FFXI", or trying to capture that same feeling. How could I? It's a different world, different lore, different races and creatures and such. To try and relate my experience in that new MMO based on how it compared to my previous one would only undermine the experience of being in that new world. This would be completely counter-intuitive.
If I'm going into a new MMO looking for comparisons or similarities to what I've already played, then why even bother playing? I'm playing a different MMO for a new experience. Not for one I've already had.
I approach every new MMO as a brand-new experience. Or at least really try to. With the "me-too" approach so many devs have taken in the last 8 or so years, it's more difficult to do, because even when you try to approach it with a clean slate, there's still that sense of "I've played this before, only it didn't look the same".
So, I can honestly say that - at least for me - my ability to be drawn in and immersed in a new MMO world - whether it's my 1st or my 100th, is almost entirely based on the game itself.
Now, that's how I approach the games for myself.
When it comes to describing those games, or discussing them with others, I'll certainly make references or comparisons. But then it's because the best way to describe something someone may not be familiar with, is often to draw comparisons to other things that they likely are. This is the approach often used and promoted when pitching a new game idea to a Publisher, for example. If it conveys the idea, then it's effective.
But anyway, I guess that's why I always find it odd when people say "you only really enjoyed that MMO because it was your first". My answer to that is always, "No, I really liked that MMO because I really liked it..."
1/20/14 3:01:28 AM#4
I agree with you on most things.
I will say this. Ragnarok online was my first mmorpg back in 2002, and I loved it. I was in the closed alpha beta test. It was my first mmorpg. I played it for a good year in a half. Then lineage 2 came out. I never to this day found another game as good as L2 (2003 - 2006).
In my opinion it was the journey provided to players that made the games so fun to play. Now every game is all about instance soloing sanctions with all nothing to do end game content.
What made L2 memorable to me:
The Grind - trying to find new places or ways to get faster exp on my nuker class. Figured out I could kill any monster solo with slow, nuke, nuke, nuke, sleep, run and gain distance, slow, nuke, nuke, nuke, dead. Eventually I had got the timing down so I didn't need to run so far, and got to the point I ran just enough distance to kill the monster before it hit me. Figuring out these mechanics with timing was fun to me.
Groups - wanted better exp with no rest breaks? Get a support/healer/mprecharger. Make small groups, and level in places that give better exp than solo monsters. Make large groups and level in places that give the best exp. Organize groups, replace people leaving with people on friends list.
PVP - Kill anyone you want with a risk/reward flagging system. Gotta love it. Fight for resources. Participate in clan wars. Anything can happen at anytime, but there was always a price. Game would get real intense.
Now I feel like every game is sanctioned to the baby generation who call themselves hard core, because they can hit level cap in 1 day and press 2 buttons on the keyboard.
It makes me sad. Truly, I miss L2 (the real L2, and not this WoW copycat instanced crap). Here are a few links to help remember what good mmorpg was like:
other players agree - http://forums.anandtech.com/archive/index.php/t-2316034.html
nice siege video - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hh6I0SmA9jE
first valakas killed every 186 player raid - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a9dF1TK-xuw
Played Ragnarok online (3 years), WoW (6 months off and on), Priston Tales (a month), Lineage 2 (6 years),every mmorpg on the game list for 1-3 months, every single player rpg from nintendo up to playstation.