Trending Games | ArcheAge | World of Warcraft | Elder Scrolls Online | Final Fantasy XIV: A Realm Reborn

  Network:  FPSguru RTSguru
Login:  Password:   Remember?  
Show Quick Gamelist Jump to Random Game
Members:2,923,640 Users Online:0
Games:760  Posts:6,317,226
Turbine, Inc. | Play Now
MMORPG | Genre:Fantasy | Status:Final  (rel 04/24/07)  | Pub:Midway Games
PVP:Yes | Distribution:Download,Retail | Retail Price:n/a | Pay Type:Hybrid | Monthly Fee:$14.99
System Req: PC Mac | ESRB:TOut of date info? Let us know!

Lord of the Rings Online Forum » General Discussion » Is this quest hub heavy?

18 posts found
  fivetigers

Novice Member

Joined: 6/05/04
Posts: 181

 
OP  4/02/14 1:07:15 PM#1
Is this a super linear quest-hub to quest-hub game?

Me

Her

  Sovrath

Elite Member

Joined: 1/06/05
Posts: 17631

4/02/14 1:10:46 PM#2

Sort of.

There are quest hubs but in certain instances you can level in different places.

Mostly at the start.

Or, if you just want to explore and make your own way you can find orc camps and the like here and there and just kill mobs which is a good part of my game play when I do play.

The game is free so just download and give it a test run. If you like Lord of the Rings and you like reading quest text then it could be a very good game.

  fivetigers

Novice Member

Joined: 6/05/04
Posts: 181

 
OP  4/02/14 1:21:42 PM#3
Yeah, I know it's free.  Been reading up on this and EQ2, trying to figure out which one I want to download tonight when I get home.

Me

Her

  trancejeremy

Novice Member

Joined: 1/30/08
Posts: 1221

4/02/14 6:18:42 PM#4

Not so much for the first 20 levels, but more and more so as the game progresses. In the original design, not so much, in the redesigned areas, yes.

By the time you reach Isengard (65), it's pretty much completely Quest Hub orientated.  To the point where if you miss an object laying on the ground in an obscure part of the game, you'll miss out on an entire quest hub.

And more areas are getting redesigned in the next update (April?) so it's going to be even more linear.

R.I.P. City of Heroes and my 17 characters there

  Torvaldr

Elite Member

Joined: 6/10/09
Posts: 6135

4/02/14 6:37:57 PM#5

Yes it is quest hub based. But like the above two have said you don't have to do all the quests in any one area. You do need to do the story quests. Getting that out of sync will end up being a big pain in the butt. The other quests are optional, but their design is to move from hub to hub. You don't necessarily have to do all the quests in any area or hub though, but since you buy regions by quest pack you're just cheating yourself out of value.

Another good reason to do the quest chain is that the end quest rewards can be very useful.

Curse you AquaScum!

  User Deleted
4/02/14 6:40:01 PM#6
If the choice is between LotRO and EQ2, go with the former.  Despite its many flaws, it still offers a more enjoyable experience than EQ2.
  Torvaldr

Elite Member

Joined: 6/10/09
Posts: 6135

4/02/14 6:42:46 PM#7
Originally posted by asmkm22
If the choice is between LotRO and EQ2, go with the former.  Despite its many flaws, it still offers a more enjoyable experience than EQ2.

See I disagree with this. For me, EQ2 is a much better experience and can be played for a lot less money. I think EQ2 offers a richer experience with quest depth, classes, crafting, solo play, and dungeons/raiding.

You can play both for free though so it's best to check them out and decide.

Curse you AquaScum!

  Jaedor

Elite Member

Joined: 8/17/09
Posts: 1015

4/02/14 6:44:20 PM#8

LOTRO is definitely aging but a solid game with an epic story. And mounted combat. :D

  Xerenix

Tipster

Joined: 5/04/08
Posts: 212

4/02/14 6:58:58 PM#9

As other said, it is quest hub to quest hub but after Lone-lands, you get the choice of picking of several zones(You have to buy zone unlocks for TP to access the quests if you're not subscribing but you gain TP while playing/grinding deeds and such).

The entire Epic book line (with a very few exceptions) is free and optional but recommended as they give good xp/items and money.

The only epic quest book you are forced to do is to enter moria as digging out the entrance is part of the epic quests.

You can also grind skirmish instances which give very good xp and money instead of going through quest hubs.

  delete5230

Elite Member

Joined: 8/15/07
Posts: 2649

4/03/14 5:47:19 AM#10

Quest hubs make it non- liner.

You can go to a quest hub and pick your quest or disregard, then you can enjoy that zone in any direction you like, adding that you can open world group better than full story line games.

 

How this is becoming a topic for leaner lately is beyond me......If someone can describe how to play an mmo non linear, please fill me in ?

  Po_gg

Elite Member

Joined: 5/12/10
Posts: 2237

4/03/14 6:34:20 AM#11

I tried to point it as well in the other thread (with TOR's replayability)... 

Is LotRO a quest-hub built game? Yes, pretty much like all the games around that era (and even after, the sole exception could be TSW with its deliberately non-questhub based design).

Does it make LotRO a linear game? Nope, you can go questing wherever you want - within the limits of your level range, and in some cases with a previous quest completion requirement, mostly for story chains.

 

"Is this a super linear quest-hub to quest-hub game?"  Quest hub != super linear.

 

edit: while Jeremy's somewhat right in that your options getting more narrow in the expansions range and with closing to the level cap, Turbine is trying to put alternate routes in there as well (Great River, Gap of Rohan, and Wildermore). True, in HD you won't have many options in questing, but I guess by the time you reach lvl85 you'll know already whether you like the game or not :)

  fivetigers

Novice Member

Joined: 6/05/04
Posts: 181

 
OP  4/03/14 12:09:48 PM#12
Originally posted by delete5230

Quest hubs make it non- liner.

You can go to a quest hub and pick your quest or disregard, then you can enjoy that zone in any direction you like, adding that you can open world group better than full story line games.

 

How this is becoming a topic for leaner lately is beyond me......If someone can describe how to play an mmo non linear, please fill me in ?

In Asheron's Call quests of all level were scattered all around the world.  If you went to a new town (which you could do at any time), there were quests for all levels there, not just levels 1-10 or 25-35, etc.  If you skipped quests entirely, you weren't handicapping yourself, because simply killing monsters got you gear from loot and good xp, unlike most of the games now where most of your gear and xp is almost exclusively acquired from quest hub quests.

 

In Asheron's Call (and I'm sure some other games too) you could go anywhere in the world and find something to do.  

 

Most games now force you to play quest-hub to quest-hub.  Yes, once at the hub you have limited choice to do the quests in slightly different order, but my point is that quest hub is specifically designed for your current level, and if you prematurely move on to the next hub, you will be severly underleveld and undergeared, and your only viable option it to return to the previous quest hub and complete it's content.

 

In most newer games, if you even have the option to go anywhere in the world, you won't be able to do anything because you are out of the area designed for your level.

 

So, yes, for the most part quest-hub games are linear.

Me

Her

  Aeonblades

Apprentice Member

Joined: 10/12/12
Posts: 2123

4/03/14 12:12:57 PM#13
Yes it's a quest hub game. That being said, LotRO probably did quest hubs better than any other game out there imo. The story was rich enough to where I actually read quest text. Between EQ2 and LotRO, I'd take the latter, only because EQ2 has gotten progressively worse each expansion and LotRO has had up and down expansions.

Currently Playing: ESO and FFXIV
Have played: You name it
If you mention rose tinted glasses, you better be referring to Mitch Hedberg.

  Torvaldr

Elite Member

Joined: 6/10/09
Posts: 6135

4/03/14 12:22:20 PM#14
Originally posted by Po_gg

I tried to point it as well in the other thread (with TOR's replayability)... 

Is LotRO a quest-hub built game? Yes, pretty much like all the games around that era (and even after, the sole exception could be TSW with its deliberately non-questhub based design).

Does it make LotRO a linear game? Nope, you can go questing wherever you want - within the limits of your level range, and in some cases with a previous quest completion requirement, mostly for story chains.

 

"Is this a super linear quest-hub to quest-hub game?"  Quest hub != super linear.

 

edit: while Jeremy's somewhat right in that your options getting more narrow in the expansions range and with closing to the level cap, Turbine is trying to put alternate routes in there as well (Great River, Gap of Rohan, and Wildermore). True, in HD you won't have many options in questing, but I guess by the time you reach lvl85 you'll know already whether you like the game or not :)

They're giving you a choice of lines to take, but 5 lines is still linear. The zones and progression only moves one way. The freedom they give with zone choice (say Angmar or Forochel) makes it feel slightly less on rails. It's still a straight line though. You also move in a directed pattern through the zone hubs. You can't start at Lothlorien and move back through Moria and some quest lines later in the zone aren't available unless you unlock key events or do quests early in the zone.

Not only that but each zone is a spot frozen in time in the story. Some even tell you the date and where you are with regards to the Fellowship or story. It is the very definition of linear.

Curse you AquaScum!

  Po_gg

Elite Member

Joined: 5/12/10
Posts: 2237

4/03/14 12:45:16 PM#15
Originally posted by Torvaldr
Originally posted by Po_gg

Does it make LotRO a linear game? Nope, you can go questing wherever you want - within the limits of your level range, and in some cases with a previous quest completion requirement, mostly for story chains.

They're giving you a choice of lines to take, but 5 lines is still linear.

...

Not only that but each zone is a spot frozen in time in the story. Some even tell you the date and where you are with regards to the Fellowship or story. It is the very definition of linear.

You need some sort of linearity, few chokepoints and intersections, it's still a story in the end :) and I like the design idea of the dates set according to the Fellowship's location and status.

 

I wasn't talk about parallel zones (ok, at the expansions I did, but you have some options in those as well), I ment something similar like the example above with AC. There are a few ties among the "hubs" indeed, but for a big part you can play anywhere you like - if the levels are fit. So you can jump on your steed after finishing some quests in Agamaur, riding to Thorenhad, after a few quests jumping back to Dwaling in Evendim, then a few quests later riding up north to Tinnudir and then heading east to Othrikar in the North Downs, then back to Thorenhad for some leftover quests.

There are a few dependencies, there will be quests you can't take at the moment, and it would be a huge ride in itself just for the sake of freedom, but still: beyond your level range you can quest wherever you please. (Again, above 65 your options are narrower, but even there you can add some variety to your personal questing story.)

edit: for OP, those locations are not connected by any quests, that's why I cited them for the example :) so no linearity among those specific areas, nor are they the "starting" hub in their zones.

  fivetigers

Novice Member

Joined: 6/05/04
Posts: 181

 
OP  4/03/14 3:09:56 PM#16

One more gameplay question, where do you aquire most of your gear?

Is most of your gear from quests, dropped from monsters, or crafted?

Me

Her

  Torvaldr

Elite Member

Joined: 6/10/09
Posts: 6135

4/03/14 4:52:59 PM#17
Originally posted by Po_gg

You need some sort of linearity, few chokepoints and intersections, it's still a story in the end :) and I like the design idea of the dates set according to the Fellowship's location and status.

I wasn't talk about parallel zones (ok, at the expansions I did, but you have some options in those as well), I ment something similar like the example above with AC. There are a few ties among the "hubs" indeed, but for a big part you can play anywhere you like - if the levels are fit. So you can jump on your steed after finishing some quests in Agamaur, riding to Thorenhad, after a few quests jumping back to Dwaling in Evendim, then a few quests later riding up north to Tinnudir and then heading east to Othrikar in the North Downs, then back to Thorenhad for some leftover quests.

There are a few dependencies, there will be quests you can't take at the moment, and it would be a huge ride in itself just for the sake of freedom, but still: beyond your level range you can quest wherever you please. (Again, above 65 your options are narrower, but even there you can add some variety to your personal questing story.)

edit: for OP, those locations are not connected by any quests, that's why I cited them for the example :) so no linearity among those specific areas, nor are they the "starting" hub in their zones.

It works for this game. I don't think it's bad. The "must have a sandbox" crowd has turned it into a dirty word, plus there is a stigma with poorly implemented linear design. I just didn't think saying it wasn't linear was accurate. It's just not bad linearity. What I do think is bad are those portions where the game gets totally on rails and you have to do exactly what Turbine wants in order get where you want to be.

OP: Your gear can come from 3 main places: crafting, quests, and token vendors (from dungeons, raids, skirmishes, and factions). Crafted gear is more than sufficient for overworld and solo play. Some crafted gear is nearly as good as dungeon gear and some crafted gear is made from dungeon components. Quests often have mediocre gear, but some key quest rewards have top quality gear for that level. The vendor gear is obtained from tokens by running the appropriate content. Sometimes the reputation/faction vendors sell crafting recipes for good gear rather than the gear itself. It really depends on which part of the game you're in.

The bottom line is you don't have to run dungeons or raids to get decent gear or weapons. It's been quite a while since I've played, but I think you can still buy legendary weapons on the auction hall.

Curse you AquaScum!

  Po_gg

Elite Member

Joined: 5/12/10
Posts: 2237

4/04/14 4:39:37 AM#18
Originally posted by Torvaldr
 

It works for this game. I don't think it's bad. The "must have a sandbox" crowd has turned it into a dirty word, plus there is a stigma with poorly implemented linear design. I just didn't think saying it wasn't linear was accurate. It's just not bad linearity.

I agree, and I like the "It's just not bad linearity. " I also ment something like that with my post.

Maybe it was just my wording, for me "linear" means the on-the-rails, "there's only one way (to rule them all)" questing, and LotRO is not like that in most times. I admit it has some linear parts indeed, mostly the book quest lines (though those can be played parallel to each other too, or even skipping one you don't like, so there's some freedom in them). Yep, this "good / bad linearity" sounds like a great approach :)

 

As for the gear question, nice summary, I can only +1 it.  Crafting can give gear which is close to the best available ones, but not on every level, just at around every 6-8 levels (at the end of each crafting tier). Quest gear can be nice as well, and since the game is not that hard nowadays, quest gear can be more than enough for leveling. In the expansion part above lvl50, crafting (within the crafting guild) becomes more important with the crafted LI's. OP was also curious about monster drops, well, those are average at best :) except the end bosses (questchain end, or instance end), they drop nice pieces. But world drops can give some really cool-looking stuff, it's nice enough to wear them cosmetically.

"Is most of your gear from quests, dropped from monsters, or crafted?" Depends on the mood. I like crafting a lot, so I'm usually running around in a mix of quest and crafted (and the ratio is based on the afforementioned mood, if it'd take too much of a chore to gather the mats, I just go with quest ones... /me lazy :) ). I also mixing into them the barter ones from reputation, and occasionally I used to do some instances, so there's a few pieces from those as well. But that's just me, I don't really care about gear and gear grind :)

 

edit: for shortly back to the linear part, OP if you're fast enough you can play North Downs before they revamp it (and with it probably streamlining it). That's the last area close to its "original" state, so it's like your AC example, chaotic and fun :)

Quests in the range of lvl20 - lvl 42, with a loose path (and even that is going back and forth among the many questgivers / mini hubs all over the map), lots of satellite quests (which you can take without any mandatory previous one), mixed mob population (like chasing white mobs and suddenly you bump into oranges/purples, or walking into an area full of signatures 5 levels above you, who'll wipe the floor with you) - and of course lots of group quests. Dunno what will stay in there after U13, but I hope the most, ND is a great area. If you start a character now, you can reach into ND with 1-2 days of playing and check it while it lasts.