Network Sites: FPSguru.com RTSguru.com UnboundGamer.com
Login:  Password:   Remember?  
Show Quick Gamelist Jump to Random Game
Games:567  Guilds:2,959
Members:1,440,359  Online:0
Guests:0  Posts:4,569,298
Turbine, Inc. | Play Now
MMORPG | Genre:Fantasy | Status:Final  (rel 04/24/07)  | Pub:Midway Games
PVP:Yes | Distribution:Download,Retail | Retail Price:$09.99 | Pay Type:Free | Monthly Fee:$14.99
Desktop Client | System Req: PC | ESRB:T

LotRO: Developing for the West and the East

Lord of the Rings Online Executive producer Jeffrey Steefel has recently returned from a trip to Korea where Turbine is getting ready to launch Lord of the Rings Online. MMORPG.com Managing Editor Jon Wood recently caught up with Steefel to talk about developing for these two very different markets and what Noth American and European players can expect to see from the move.

Recently, I had the opportunity to sit down and talk with Lord of the Rings Online Executive Producer Jeffrey Steefel where we talked about launching the game in the Korean market and what that might mean for those of us in the west.

As you may or may not know, Steefel had just returned from a business trip to Korea where Lord of the Rings Online is getting ready to make its debut. He told me that right now, they are finishing up the Closed Beta process and are moving toward a limited Open Beta.

It seems as though there is a lot of interest in the game over there and that fans have been enthusiastic as the game gets closer to launch. When I asked him to compare the fans and anticipation in Korea with the fans and anticipation for the same stage of development here in the North American market, he said that it was a bit like comparing apples and oranges as the markets are so different.

While we might not expect that a western story like Lord of the Rings would penetrate into the Korean market in the same way, Steefel gives Peter Jackson's movies a lot of credit for the level of excitement over the game.

One of the challenges that is facing the Turbine team in gearing up for a Korean launch is the speed at which players move through content. For example: while (and remember, we are speaking in broad generalizations here) North American players tend to like quests that are descriptive, but aren't necessarily specific, Korean players would prefer a very specific text description, telling them exactly where they need to go. Fortunately, Turbine has plans to fully localize and culturalize the game, looking to not only bring the game into a different language, but into a different culture as well. As a result (and serving as a pretty good example), a number of the quest texts are being re-constructed to better reflect a more popular Korean play style.

Before we got off the topic of the Korean launch, Steefel pointed out to me another of the differences between developing a game for release in the West and prepping for a release in Korea; customer service. In Korea, game companies have actual physical walk-up windows set up to handle customer service issues. No emails or petitions falling through the cracks here.

So, how does the Korean launch effect western players?

The team at Turbine has their sights set on doing some more work on the Player vs. Monster Player system in the game due to popular demand in Korea where PvP is not only popular, but often taken quite seriously. Turbine has decided to look at both markets to see how they can improve the game for both rather than trying to develop a whole new game for each market.

"Any time that we add anything for any particular region, it's going to be a part of the overall game," he said. "Unless we absolutely have to, we're not going to do anything specific to a particular part of the world."

Often, when North American players think about MMORPG gaming in the east, we tend to think of their dominant business model, the free-to-play / item mall model. As a result, I asked Steefel how the company would handle their business model in the newest version of the game.

"It's something we're talking with them about. The way that you do that for Lord of the Rings is something that you have to be very careful with," he answered. "What we don't want is to ruin the game itself or any of the design or balance of the game... Turbine in general is looking at how we can do that in some of our games coming up. There's no question in my mind that that's going to be a part of the model going forward, period."

As a follow-up, I had to ask whether this means that we should expect to start seeing this sort of model in all Turbine games, or whether we would still be paying our monthly fees.

"It's an and, not an or," he answered. "The market is getting broader, which is great. We're reaching out to more and more people. The way that people want to participate in these games is getting more and more diverse. It's not 100% people who want to take this on as a primary form of entertainment that they are going to spend 30, 40, 50 hours a week on and pay a subscription without thinking about it." Those, he said, are the people who want maximum value and maximum content who would pay a subscription, but they also think that there are other people out there who might play more if they were given a different option.

Turbine is looking for a way to cater to everyone (in terms of their business model). In short, why is Player "A", who plays 30 hours a week paying the same and in the same way as Player "B" who can only play 5-10, tops?

There are lots of ways to look at this issue, and Turbine isn't in a hurry to make any decisions, but they are certainly exploring their options and allowing themselves to be informed by their move into Korea, though I wouldn't expect to see a walk-up window at the Turbine offices any time soon.

More Lord of the Rings Online Features:

Lord of the Rings Online - Bringing Riders of Rohan in 2012 Preview added on Wednesday January 25
Lord of the Rings Online - The Prince of Rohan Preview Preview added on Monday December 05

More Interviews:

DC Universe Online - MMORPG.com Community Interview Interview added on Monday February 06
World of Darkness - CCP’s Plans to Dominate 2012 Interview added on Monday February 06
Entropia Universe - MindArk Interview Interview added on Monday January 30

More Features:

Conquer Online - The Conquer Online iPad Review Review added on Wednesday February 08
Star Wars: The Old Republic - Jedi Guardian Player's Guide Guide added on Wednesday February 08
League of Legends - First Impressions with Ripper X Media added on Wednesday February 08
 
 
Tamalan writes:

Very interesting... should be fun to see how the two versions differ.

Maybe Turbine can spread that attention to detail to the EU, by offering us the same deal as the US, in regards to the recently advertised trial, cheaper client pricing and subscription offer. Not a sniff of anything similar for us Euro-types.

Tam

New Post Quote
6/18/08 11:40:16 AM
 
astrob0y writes:

Good luck in the east Turbine!

And thanks mmorpg for an nice interview.

New Post Quote
6/18/08 5:05:07 PM
 
solareus writes:

It is like Jeff never stops thinking, he is always a step a head of the industry in almost everything he produces. Break a leg in Koreas dudes !

New Post Quote
6/19/08 10:54:09 AM
 
TookyG writes:
Originally posted by solareus

It is like Jeff never stops thinking, he is always a step a head of the industry in almost everything he produces. Break a leg in Koreas dudes !

 

In all seriousness, how is Turbine/Jeff ahead of the industry in what they produce?

New Post Quote
6/19/08 12:07:52 PM
 
ronan32 writes:

i bet he had dollar signs in his eyes when doing that interview..just out for pure financial gain and the game comes second.

New Post Quote
6/20/08 2:23:34 PM
 
Lizante writes:

First of all, I don't see different games for different markets, since it's also clearly said that while some tweaking may be in order, any changes will be incorporated into a game on a worldwide basis.

Second, I hope Turbine studies the Koreans more than they have.  If what Jeff says about what Koreans want and expect from a game regarding content and questing were true, Lineage 2, which is 4 years old, wouldn't have 11 million subscribers worldwide with a large percentage of them, in Korea (NCSoft is a Korean company) and Asia.  While it is true that most Korean MMOs have a rich storyline/backrgound, most quests in their games are nebulous at best.

Lastly, Turbine has to be extremely careful regarding any changes (and actually putting much time and effort in alterations to) Lord of the Rings Online's version of Player versus Player (PvP) -- the Freeps Vs. Creeps, or Player versus Monster Player (PvMP) in the Ettenmoors.  LotRO is not a PvP game.  While PvMP is a cute and interesting diversion for players, the player versus player aspects of LoTRO are, and must remain, a minor diversion.  Careful attention must be taken, when making any changes, to remain completely true to the lore of Tolkein's Middle Earth.  If the Koreans (or anyone for that matter) want true PvP, there are many other games out there for them and drastic changes to LotRO would most definitely alienate more current players then woo new ones.

New Post Quote
6/24/08 11:24:37 AM
 
Leave this field empty
Post Your Comment:
Our Rating
8.5
User Rating: 8.3
Popular Features:
Player Perspectives : Content Locusts Killed My MMO Column added on Friday January 27
It used to be that hitting the level cap in an MMO was something that... Read More
Star Wars: The Old Republic : Good Cop, Bad Cop – SWTOR General Article added on Monday January 30
There is no question that Star Wars: The Old Republic has stirred strong feelings on... Read More
Star Wars: The Old Republic : The Future of the Old Republic Interview added on Thursday January 12
Star Wars: The Old Republic has taken the MMO gaming world by storm over the... Read More
General : The 2011 Player’s Choice Winners Award added on Thursday January 19
A couple of weeks ago, we asked you, our valuable readers, to vote for those... Read More
The WoW Factor : What is a “WoW Killer?” Column added on Monday January 16
Everyone is always looking for that game that will be a "WoW Killer" but what... Read More
Latest News:
Lord of the Rings Online : Screenshot of the Week: LOTRO Edition: Winner's Announcement Reported on Jan 27, 2012
We've pored over your many awesome LOTRO screenshots for this week's "Screenshot of the Week,"... Read More
Lord of the Rings Online : Bringing Riders of Rohan in 2012 Reported on Jan 24, 2012
Turbine is ready to talk about the next Lord of the Rings Online expansion, Riders... Read More
Lord of the Rings Online : Screenshot of the Week: LOTRO Edition! Reported on Jan 23, 2012
Everyone loves to take screenshots of their favorite games, and we want you to share... Read More
Lord of the Rings Online : The Year In Review Reported on Dec 26, 2011
Lord of the Rings Online Senior Producer Aaron "Rowan" Campbell has written a short note... Read More
Lord of the Rings Online : New Screens Feature Update 5 Instances Reported on Dec 20, 2011
Turbine has released new Lord of the Rings Online screens showing off new instances included... Read More

Advertisement