I really hope Star Wars would out sell Guild Wars on initial sales.....it's STAR WARS.  I think we all know which is the quality game that will have people buying it past the first month, though.

wow oh really?   no mames quey

SWTOR had more hype than any game I can remember, it's not a surprise to me that it outsold GW2.

 

On a side note - SWTOR was a better game too. If GW2 was P2P, you would already be seeing the cancellation of thousands of subs and server merges happening around the first of the year.

The use of the brain is required to play guild wars 2 , because that much freedom cannot be process by some of us, they turn out troll on forum crying out load that guild wars 2 is mean and will die from the MMO death

Most of those troll cast on left hand MMO-Death and the right hand is for badMMO-revive.

They will taunt you with some :"Meh ... you see .... haah "

 

its my 1st post to this site even i read everyday for some time...i am tired of ppl here try to prove their point with nosense...

i play gw2 currently in case everyone thinks i am a swtor fan...but u cant compare their launch ....

someone who played both games will know that first days only in europe swtor had 87 servers if i remember correct..and for  days all server were full and ppl were waiting also for 1-2 hours to log in...so its simple maths...gw2 has not even half servers...and they hype swtor created its unthikable and its logical cause star wars has many fans....the game ofcourse wasnt as most of ppl expekting but thats different think...and u cant prove a game is better than other game by sales in the end of the day..best game is the one u had most fun and spent most time...mine was lotro...others was wow,eve,aion or .....

Originally posted by SuperDonk

SWTOR had more hype than any game I can remember, it's not a surprise to me that it outsold GW2.

 

On a side note - SWTOR was a better game too. If GW2 was P2P, you would already be seeing the cancellation of thousands of subs and server merges happening around the first of the year.

How is SWTOR the better game? It's so...LIFELESS compared to GW2.

Originally posted by Souldrainer
Weighing in at an even 2 million boxes, GW2 is the latest game to be less successful than SWTOR. Others include Tera, TSW, and all other direct competition save for WOW. So, tell me again about this game failing.

says the guy without any proof/sources...

A lot of misinformation here.

 

SWTOR had over 2 mil preorders for box copies only NOT COUNTING digital sales at all.    GW2 will be fine, but if SWTOR was a b2p game do you really think it wouldn't of sold way more ?     People spreading false lies saying 2 mil sales is bullshit it was 2 mil active players NOT SALES.

Originally posted by stratasaurus

Originally posted by Eir_S
Wait.. how is a game that's two weeks old competing with one that's been out for a year and whose sales have basically dried up?  This thread doesn't make sense no matter what game you're talking about.

SWTOR has been out for a year...damn I didn't know it was christmas already, where does the time go.

Sorry, you're right.  It went F2P in 8 months... I was using the standard of one year to F2P, but I forgot SWTOR did worse than most games.

Originally posted by William12

A lot of misinformation here.

 

SWTOR had over 2 mil preorders for box copies only NOT COUNTING digital sales at all.    GW2 will be fine, but if SWTOR was a b2p game do you really think it wouldn't of sold way more ?     People spreading false lies saying 2 mil sales is bullshit it was 2 mil active players NOT SALES.

 

At no point did TOR have 2 million active players.  Take your own advice.

---

Originally posted by Souldrainer
Weighing in at an even 2 million boxes, GW2 is the latest game to be less successful than SWTOR. Others include Tera, TSW, and all other direct competition save for WOW. So, tell me again about this game failing.

---

That SWToR sold more boxes in its first week than GW2 is a fact. You can look it up on VGChartz. The interpretation of the numbers does seem right though.

SWToR did not achieve the goals set for it by EA or Bioware. GW2 was projected to reach 3 million in sales by the end of the year, and it is two thirds of the way there after 2 weeks. It seems much more likely that GW2 will reach the goals set by Anet than SWToR will ever reach any goals set by EA or Bioware.

What's swtor?

Originally posted by kadepsyson

Originally posted by TheIronLegion

Next let's compare Crysis 3 to Eve Online... :) I'm enjoying the threads that compare two completely different things

After Crysis 3 launches, I will be happy to discuss the comparison with you in a thread you create provided I've played enough Crysis 3 to make informed points.

EVE has more subscribers than Cry3 will ever have.

NBC artcle: Gamers grab 2 million copies of 'Guild Wars 2' despite sales halt

http://www.nbcnews.com/technology/ingame/gamers-grab-2-million-copies-guild-wars-2-despite-sales-999089

 

- GW2 sold 2 million copies in 2 weeks ... despite AreaNet suspending first party sales and retail replenishment for 10 days just 2 days after launch ....

- began selling the game again earlier this week after deploying new servers in NA and Europe

- regularly seeing over 400,000 concurrent

 

I bet EA wished SWTOR had had such a bad start - oh wait, the OP said that SWTOR did better ...... maybe not ....

I don't understand the point of this thread, it's just like saying pacman has more subscribers then gw2 will ever have.

Originally posted by lizardbones

 

---

Originally posted by Souldrainer
Weighing in at an even 2 million boxes, GW2 is the latest game to be less successful than SWTOR. Others include Tera, TSW, and all other direct competition save for WOW. So, tell me again about this game failing.

---

That SWToR sold more boxes in its first week than GW2 is a fact. You can look it up on VGChartz. The interpretation of the numbers does seem right though.

SWToR did not achieve the goals set for it by EA or Bioware. GW2 was projected to reach 3 million in sales by the end of the year, and it is two thirds of the way there after 2 weeks. It seems much more likely that GW2 will reach the goals set by Anet than SWToR will ever reach any goals set by EA or Bioware.

 

Unless you're only counting actual physical boxes, it isn't true.

Based only on information given by both companies (EA and Anet, I'll reuse links postes earlier):

As of december 26 (6 days after release), TOR had sold 1 million copies:

http://www.swtor.com/info/news/press-release/20111226

Anet announced on august 28th (on release day, 3 days after headstart) that they had already sold over 1 million pre-purchases (before release) and that was not counting pre-orders or sales after release

http://massively.joystiq.com/2012/08/28/guild-wars-2-hits-400k-concurrent-users-before-launch/

Post launch, TOR announces 2 million units sold 5 weeks after release:

http://massively.joystiq.com/2012/02/01/ea-reveals-swtor-subscription-and-sales-numbers-beats-financial/10

Anet announced 2 million units sold 3 weeks after release

http://massively.joystiq.com/2012/09/13/guild-wars-2-breaks-the-two-million-sales-mark/

So, based on hard numbers released by the companies themselves, I'd say GW2 indeed sold more than TOR on release. Retention, though, will be harder to judge since TOR is a sub based game while GW2 isn't.

You guys do know that anet had to delay selling more products at one point right? because it was such a high demand they had to slow down and look how the servers are doing, then add in more servers then open up more releases of the product.

Originally posted by lizardbones

 

---

Originally posted by Souldrainer
Weighing in at an even 2 million boxes, GW2 is the latest game to be less successful than SWTOR. Others include Tera, TSW, and all other direct competition save for WOW. So, tell me again about this game failing.

---

That SWToR sold more boxes in its first week than GW2 is a fact. You can look it up on VGChartz. The interpretation of the numbers does seem right though.

SWToR did not achieve the goals set for it by EA or Bioware. GW2 was projected to reach 3 million in sales by the end of the year, and it is two thirds of the way there after 2 weeks. It seems much more likely that GW2 will reach the goals set by Anet than SWToR will ever reach any goals set by EA or Bioware.

TOR sold more in the first week (1.453 million) compared to GW2 (.902 million), but only sold 311k the second week.  VGCharts hasn't submitted second week sales for GW2 yet, but in order to pop over 2 million GW2 would have had to sold around another 1 million copies in the second week.  Really they've already outpaced TORs sales graph at the two week point.

When you look at other platform sales the MMO market is rather "flash in the pan" and paltry.  One thing the B2P model might bring is a broader appeal and larger total sales numbers.  That is one feature all the other platforms tout that MMOs haven't really offered much.

---

Originally posted by Torvaldr

---

Originally posted by lizardbones  

---

Originally posted by Souldrainer Weighing in at an even 2 million boxes, GW2 is the latest game to be less successful than SWTOR. Others include Tera, TSW, and all other direct competition save for WOW. So, tell me again about this game failing.

---

That SWToR sold more boxes in its first week than GW2 is a fact. You can look it up on VGChartz. The interpretation of the numbers does seem right though. SWToR did not achieve the goals set for it by EA or Bioware. GW2 was projected to reach 3 million in sales by the end of the year, and it is two thirds of the way there after 2 weeks. It seems much more likely that GW2 will reach the goals set by Anet than SWToR will ever reach any goals set by EA or Bioware.

---

TOR sold more in the first week (1.453 million) compared to GW2 (.902 million), but only sold 311k the second week.  VGCharts hasn't submitted second week sales for GW2 yet, but in order to pop over 2 million GW2 would have had to sold around another 1 million copies in the second week.  Really they've already outpaced TORs sales graph at the two week point.

When you look at other platform sales the MMO market is rather "flash in the pan" and paltry.  One thing the B2P model might bring is a broader appeal and larger total sales numbers.  That is one feature all the other platforms tout that MMOs haven't really offered much.

---

You're doing it wrong.

* Limit your data set to only the information that supports your hypothesis. In this case, only the first week's sales are "relevant".
* Guess values for a dataset that cannot be confirmed. It's best if you guess a starting number, like a ratio, and then calculate a final set of numbers from the assumed values. This gives your final numbers legitimacy.
* Only use logic that supports your hypothesis when connecting the dots between numbers.

Also, there's a type in my post. The bit, "the numbers does seem right though" should read, "the numbers doesn't seem right".

** edit **
LOCOman is doing it wrong too.

Originally posted by Torvaldr

Originally posted by lizardbones

 

---

Originally posted by Souldrainer
Weighing in at an even 2 million boxes, GW2 is the latest game to be less successful than SWTOR. Others include Tera, TSW, and all other direct competition save for WOW. So, tell me again about this game failing.

---

That SWToR sold more boxes in its first week than GW2 is a fact. You can look it up on VGChartz. The interpretation of the numbers does seem right though.

SWToR did not achieve the goals set for it by EA or Bioware. GW2 was projected to reach 3 million in sales by the end of the year, and it is two thirds of the way there after 2 weeks. It seems much more likely that GW2 will reach the goals set by Anet than SWToR will ever reach any goals set by EA or Bioware.

TOR sold more in the first week (1.453 million) compared to GW2 (.902 million), but only sold 311k the second week.  VGCharts hasn't submitted second week sales for GW2 yet, but in order to pop over 2 million GW2 would have had to sold around another 1 million copies in the second week.  Really they've already outpaced TORs sales graph at the two week point.

When you look at other platform sales the MMO market is rather "flash in the pan" and paltry.  One thing the B2P model might bring is a broader appeal and larger total sales numbers.  That is one feature all the other platforms tout that MMOs haven't really offered much.

Problem with vgchartz is that they usually don't track digital copies sold by the company itself (which Anet did):

"

Data-Collection Methodology

All sales estimates on VGChartz are arrived at via a number of proprietrary and ever-developing methods:

• Passively polling end users to find out what games they are currently purchasing and playing
• Polling retail partners to find out what games and hardware they are selling
• Using statistical trend fitting and historical data for similar games
• Studying resell prices to determine consumer demand and inventory levels
• Consulting with publishers and manufacturers to find out how many units they are introducing into the channel

All data is regularly checked against manufacturer shipments and data released publicly from other tracking firms to ensure accuracy. VGChartz holds no responsibility for the use of our data – any business decisions made are made at your own risk.

"

Source: http://www.vgchartz.com/methodology.php

which is why in my prevous post I'm using only data announced by the companies and not VGchartz.