Network Sites: FPSguru.com RTSguru.com UnboundGamer.com
Login:  Password:   Remember?  
Show Quick Gamelist Jump to Random Game
Games:608  Guilds:3,081
Members:1,598,990  Online:0
Guests:0  Posts:4,852,920
Cryptic Studios | Play Now
MMORPG | Genre:Sci-Fi | Status:Final  (rel 02/02/10)  | Pub:Atari
PVP:Yes | Distribution:Retail | Retail Price:n/a | Pay Type:Hybrid | Monthly Fee:n/a
Desktop Client | System Req: PC | Out of date info? Let us know!

Star Trek Online Forum » General Discussion raquo; outdated look in the star trek verse

2 Pages 1 2 » Search
28 posts found
  ricefarmer

Novice Member

Joined: 8/08/05
Posts: 215

 
5/12/09 7:54:36 PM#1

with the movie coming out and all the awesome new special effects, diverse types of aliens, and how bad ass the romulans look...  its just going to make this game look super nerdy and outdated with its old designs..

esp once the second movie comes out and they all look so much better..  and if the klingons and borg look super cool,

what will become of this game?

  neorandom

Hard Core Member

Joined: 1/15/08
Posts: 1555

5/12/09 7:58:38 PM#2

 since i live 90 miles from a movie theatre ill have to take your word for it, but for now i havent watched the new trek movie, probably wont until the dvd is under 10 bucks or its on dish for free.  a new trek movie doesnt have much to do with trek fans and a game theyve been yearning for for decades imo, we want a fun online community game to go around like our old heroes of the past did, the trailers of this new movie youre talking about that ive seen didnt impress me, i mean first off it looked like they were building their ship on the ground, all the good ships in trek are built in orbitdal docks so meh to the new trek its hardly even canon from what ive seen, merely cannon fodder.

  ricefarmer

Novice Member

Joined: 8/08/05
Posts: 215

 
5/12/09 8:39:23 PM#3
Originally posted by neorandom

 since i live 90 miles from a movie theatre ill have to take your word for it, but for now i havent watched the new trek movie, probably wont until the dvd is under 10 bucks or its on dish for free.  a new trek movie doesnt have much to do with trek fans and a game theyve been yearning for for decades imo, we want a fun online community game to go around like our old heroes of the past did, the trailers of this new movie youre talking about that ive seen didnt impress me, i mean first off it looked like they were building their ship on the ground, all the good ships in trek are built in orbitdal docks so meh to the new trek its hardly even canon from what ive seen, merely cannon fodder.


 

honestly? who gives a rats ass what a super nerd thinks? i like the movie and so did everyone else. deal with it, it amazes me the only thing saving trek is this movie yet these god dam nerds dont support it.

go watch that onion story about trekkies

  Brenelael

Elite Member

Joined: 10/19/06
Posts: 3352

Pointing out the Obvious to the Oblivious since 2006

5/12/09 9:45:46 PM#4
Originally posted by ricefarmer
Originally posted by neorandom

 since i live 90 miles from a movie theatre ill have to take your word for it, but for now i havent watched the new trek movie, probably wont until the dvd is under 10 bucks or its on dish for free.  a new trek movie doesnt have much to do with trek fans and a game theyve been yearning for for decades imo, we want a fun online community game to go around like our old heroes of the past did, the trailers of this new movie youre talking about that ive seen didnt impress me, i mean first off it looked like they were building their ship on the ground, all the good ships in trek are built in orbitdal docks so meh to the new trek its hardly even canon from what ive seen, merely cannon fodder.


 

honestly? who gives a rats ass what a super nerd thinks? i like the movie and so did everyone else. deal with it, it amazes me the only thing saving trek is this movie yet these god dam nerds dont support it.

go watch that onion story about trekkies

You mean this Onion story?

 

Bren

while(horse==dead)
{
beat();
}

  DoomsDay01

Advanced Member

Joined: 5/14/08
Posts: 684

5/12/09 10:03:32 PM#5
Originally posted by ricefarmer

with the movie coming out and all the awesome new special effects, diverse types of aliens, and how bad ass the romulans look...  its just going to make this game look super nerdy and outdated with its old designs..

esp once the second movie comes out and they all look so much better..  and if the klingons and borg look super cool,

what will become of this game?

 

I have not seen the movie yet (hope to get to see it this weekend), But I think I can already disagree with this assesment. I mean, look at the style they have chosen. This style can hold up for a long time. See the problem here is to make the game so that most people with modest computers can run it and have it look good. WoW doesn't have 10+ million subs because it has the best graphics in the world. (God I know, shoot me now, I mentioned WoW in a ST thread, WTH was I thinking!)

 

Anyways, I think the style that ST has chosen will do good. Frankly I would have liked a more EvE look to the game (space wise) but I dont think they will suffer with the way they went. However, if they had of chosen to go with what was currently the high end graphics, then yes, I think people would have been disappointed simply because even if they released next year, it would already have been outdated to begin with.

If your only defense for trolling or hatred is a stupid tag line, Then you should quit life.

  ricefarmer

Novice Member

Joined: 8/08/05
Posts: 215

 
5/12/09 11:26:07 PM#6
Originally posted by DoomsDay01
Originally posted by ricefarmer

with the movie coming out and all the awesome new special effects, diverse types of aliens, and how bad ass the romulans look...  its just going to make this game look super nerdy and outdated with its old designs..

esp once the second movie comes out and they all look so much better..  and if the klingons and borg look super cool,

what will become of this game?

 

I have not seen the movie yet (hope to get to see it this weekend), But I think I can already disagree with this assesment. I mean, look at the style they have chosen. This style can hold up for a long time. See the problem here is to make the game so that most people with modest computers can run it and have it look good. WoW doesn't have 10+ million subs because it has the best graphics in the world. (God I know, shoot me now, I mentioned WoW in a ST thread, WTH was I thinking!)

 

Anyways, I think the style that ST has chosen will do good. Frankly I would have liked a more EvE look to the game (space wise) but I dont think they will suffer with the way they went. However, if they had of chosen to go with what was currently the high end graphics, then yes, I think people would have been disappointed simply because even if they released next year, it would already have been outdated to begin with.


 

youve completely missed the point.... its not about high end graphics.. its about  this game being an outdated "style" like how the romulans will look in the game, probably wiht the goofy stash on top of their shiny shirts. as oppose to the badass looking romulans in the movie.. and so on with all the other species

  DoomsDay01

Advanced Member

Joined: 5/14/08
Posts: 684

5/12/09 11:42:36 PM#7
Originally posted by ricefarmer
Originally posted by DoomsDay01
Originally posted by ricefarmer

with the movie coming out and all the awesome new special effects, diverse types of aliens, and how bad ass the romulans look...  its just going to make this game look super nerdy and outdated with its old designs..

esp once the second movie comes out and they all look so much better..  and if the klingons and borg look super cool,

what will become of this game?

 

I have not seen the movie yet (hope to get to see it this weekend), But I think I can already disagree with this assesment. I mean, look at the style they have chosen. This style can hold up for a long time. See the problem here is to make the game so that most people with modest computers can run it and have it look good. WoW doesn't have 10+ million subs because it has the best graphics in the world. (God I know, shoot me now, I mentioned WoW in a ST thread, WTH was I thinking!)

 

Anyways, I think the style that ST has chosen will do good. Frankly I would have liked a more EvE look to the game (space wise) but I dont think they will suffer with the way they went. However, if they had of chosen to go with what was currently the high end graphics, then yes, I think people would have been disappointed simply because even if they released next year, it would already have been outdated to begin with.


 

youve completely missed the point.... its not about high end graphics.. its about  this game being an outdated "style" like how the romulans will look in the game, probably wiht the goofy stash on top of their shiny shirts. as oppose to the badass looking romulans in the movie.. and so on with all the other species

 

Nope, I did not miss the point at all. Who says this particular style wont allow for them to update it more easily? or if people will really care. Look at enterprise. I know many folks that actually quit watching it the first episode simply because the klingons had ridges and this broke cannon. The new movie is set in the past. regardless of how badass it looked, this game is set in the far future (compared to the new movie). I seriously doubt that it will cause a major concern in the game.

If your only defense for trolling or hatred is a stupid tag line, Then you should quit life.

  jusomdude

Spotlight Poster

Joined: 11/21/06
Posts: 1825

5/12/09 11:55:39 PM#8

I honestly doubt it will have any impact on the game, if it does, it will be very slight. Who would judge the game that really wants to play it on such an artificial thing?

  Emeraq

Hard Core Member

Joined: 10/07/06
Posts: 807

5/13/09 12:02:09 AM#9
Originally posted by ricefarmer
Originally posted by DoomsDay01
Originally posted by ricefarmer

with the movie coming out and all the awesome new special effects, diverse types of aliens, and how bad ass the romulans look...  its just going to make this game look super nerdy and outdated with its old designs..

esp once the second movie comes out and they all look so much better..  and if the klingons and borg look super cool,

what will become of this game?

 

I have not seen the movie yet (hope to get to see it this weekend), But I think I can already disagree with this assesment. I mean, look at the style they have chosen. This style can hold up for a long time. See the problem here is to make the game so that most people with modest computers can run it and have it look good. WoW doesn't have 10+ million subs because it has the best graphics in the world. (God I know, shoot me now, I mentioned WoW in a ST thread, WTH was I thinking!)

 

Anyways, I think the style that ST has chosen will do good. Frankly I would have liked a more EvE look to the game (space wise) but I dont think they will suffer with the way they went. However, if they had of chosen to go with what was currently the high end graphics, then yes, I think people would have been disappointed simply because even if they released next year, it would already have been outdated to begin with.


 

youve completely missed the point.... its not about high end graphics.. its about  this game being an outdated "style" like how the romulans will look in the game, probably wiht the goofy stash on top of their shiny shirts. as oppose to the badass looking romulans in the movie.. and so on with all the other species


 

No big deal in my opinion I don't think one character model can ruin gamers opinion of a game.... Look at most MMORPG's, most male avatars look, well, you know where I'm going with this..,

You also have to take into consideration that they've stated that you can create your own alien race.. So, create your own version of those 'bad ass romulans', and think of whatever version that's in game as inferior cross breeds.

 

  neorandom

Hard Core Member

Joined: 1/15/08
Posts: 1555

5/13/09 1:42:05 PM#10

 brace yourselves super nerd moment inc.  klingons without ridges were a result of the klingons using the gene manipulation experiments of dr soung (datas creator dabbled in genetic mods before androids) that created khan and his ill fated kind.  the genetic virus delivery system that manipulated the genes didnt quite work with klingons (seen on enterprise series where dr flox cured them dieing of it) but resulted in a loss of ridges more aggression and stonger faster reflexes ect.  now i dont know if it was intended back when kirks klingons were flat heads or if they threw this in at the point of enterprise as a convenient explanation (khan and soungs saga was already long established so having the klingons steal the research and fubar it made perfect sense) but they definitely made it canon if it wasnt back then.  and as far as romulans looking badass, sorry theyre just vulcans that left instead of going along with emotion supression, they arent a seperate species theyre just emotional vulcans (and that is hard canon).

  Yamota

Elite Member

Joined: 10/05/03
Posts: 4846

Money in politics is the root of all political evil. It is corruption at it's worst.

5/13/09 1:45:51 PM#11
Originally posted by neorandom

 since i live 90 miles from a movie theatre ill have to take your word for it, but for now i havent watched the new trek movie, probably wont until the dvd is under 10 bucks or its on dish for free.  a new trek movie doesnt have much to do with trek fans and a game theyve been yearning for for decades imo, we want a fun online community game to go around like our old heroes of the past did, the trailers of this new movie youre talking about that ive seen didnt impress me, i mean first off it looked like they were building their ship on the ground, all the good ships in trek are built in orbitdal docks so meh to the new trek its hardly even canon from what ive seen, merely cannon fodder.

 

I would wager that the amount of trekkie fans among the potential subscriber base for this game is quite small. So if this MMORPG only caters to old time trekkie fans then it will be a failure as it should cater to MMORPG fans, not just trekkie fans.

 

  ktanner3

Master

Joined: 3/19/06
Posts: 3085

5/13/09 9:12:08 PM#12
Originally posted by ricefarmer

with the movie coming out and all the awesome new special effects, diverse types of aliens, and how bad ass the romulans look...  its just going to make this game look super nerdy and outdated with its old designs..

esp once the second movie comes out and they all look so much better..  and if the klingons and borg look super cool,

what will become of this game?

I don't see how that is possible. The game takes place 30 years after Nemesis, which is a timeframe we haven't seen. The Federation is different(and not just in uniform,see pics) and so is the rest of the galaxy. With the ability to customize your ship in so many different ways, I don't see how any part of this game will look outdated. 

MMOs played:SWG,NGE,Warhammer, World of Warcraft, Star Trek Online,Eve, Star Wars the Old Republic.
Favorite MMO: Star Wars the Old Republic
Least Favorite MMO: NGE

  Sovrath

Elite Member

Joined: 1/06/05
Posts: 12550

5/13/09 9:14:47 PM#13
Originally posted by ricefarmer

with the movie coming out and all the awesome new special effects, diverse types of aliens, and how bad ass the romulans look...  its just going to make this game look super nerdy and outdated with its old designs..

esp once the second movie comes out and they all look so much better..  and if the klingons and borg look super cool,

what will become of this game?


 

I sort of think of it as retro.

  DragonShark

Novice Member

Joined: 2/16/04
Posts: 227

5/14/09 5:49:48 AM#14

 Since the new movie looked like Star Wars to me, I'd think that these special effects are dated too. 

  Death1942

Advanced Member

Joined: 2/24/07
Posts: 2595

5/14/09 6:04:29 AM#15
Originally posted by ricefarmer


 

youve completely missed the point.... its not about high end graphics.. its about  this game being an outdated "style" like how the romulans will look in the game, probably wiht the goofy stash on top of their shiny shirts. as oppose to the badass looking romulans in the movie.. and so on with all the other species

 

correct me if i am wrong but the Romulan in that movie was a mining ship captain?  again correct me if i am wrong but does Star Trek the MMO only support players as Captains of fighting/exploring ships?  Now to me a mining captain is going to look a whole lot different to a fighter or explorer shio captain.  I would highly doubt the mining captain would wear a proper uniform (choosing comfort over looks) or even act like a proper captain.

 

I can see why you think the Romulan in that movie was awesome but seriously...aside from his face, would you really want those bland clothes?  Most people i know like to show off their character with awesome armour sets (or in this case, outfits) and i trust the devs to provide for those players.

MMO wish list:

-Changeable worlds
-Solid non level based game
-Sharks with lasers attached to their heads

  catmaykate

Novice Member

Joined: 1/03/08
Posts: 48

5/14/09 6:17:46 AM#16
Originally posted by Death1942
Originally posted by ricefarmer


 

youve completely missed the point.... its not about high end graphics.. its about  this game being an outdated "style" like how the romulans will look in the game, probably wiht the goofy stash on top of their shiny shirts. as oppose to the badass looking romulans in the movie.. and so on with all the other species

 

correct me if i am wrong but the Romulan in that movie was a mining ship captain?  again correct me if i am wrong but does Star Trek the MMO only support players as Captains of fighting/exploring ships?  Now to me a mining captain is going to look a whole lot different to a fighter or explorer shio captain.  I would highly doubt the mining captain would wear a proper uniform (choosing comfort over looks) or even act like a proper captain.

 

I can see why you think the Romulan in that movie was awesome but seriously...aside from his face, would you really want those bland clothes?  Most people i know like to show off their character with awesome armour sets (or in this case, outfits) and i trust the devs to provide for those players.

You are right, it was a mining ship and they had face tattoos, if the poster watched the movie he would of seen spocks flash back on Romulus and seen that the romulans there look the same as vulcans

 

I guess he missed all that and was more into the explosions then the story line.

 

  Wyluli

Apprentice Member

Joined: 6/06/04
Posts: 80

5/14/09 8:45:36 PM#17
Originally posted by ricefarmer
Originally posted by neorandom

 since i live 90 miles from a movie theatre ill have to take your word for it, but for now i havent watched the new trek movie, probably wont until the dvd is under 10 bucks or its on dish for free.  a new trek movie doesnt have much to do with trek fans and a game theyve been yearning for for decades imo, we want a fun online community game to go around like our old heroes of the past did, the trailers of this new movie youre talking about that ive seen didnt impress me, i mean first off it looked like they were building their ship on the ground, all the good ships in trek are built in orbitdal docks so meh to the new trek its hardly even canon from what ive seen, merely cannon fodder.


 

honestly? who gives a rats ass what a super nerd thinks? i like the movie and so did everyone else. deal with it, it amazes me the only thing saving trek is this movie yet these god dam nerds dont support it.

go watch that onion story about trekkies

 

What, it's not insulting enough anymore to call someone a geek? I suppose you're not a nerd, sitting around on a forum talking about video games? Bad form sir, Your attitude is what's wrong with the world. I bet you voted for Bush too. :P

  Darth_Osor

Advanced Member

Joined: 2/17/09
Posts: 1080

Just because you are unique does not mean you are special

5/18/09 1:30:06 PM#18
Originally posted by neorandom

 brace yourselves super nerd moment inc.  klingons without ridges were a result of the klingons using the gene manipulation experiments of dr soung (datas creator dabbled in genetic mods before androids) that created khan and his ill fated kind.  the genetic virus delivery system that manipulated the genes didnt quite work with klingons (seen on enterprise series where dr flox cured them dieing of it) but resulted in a loss of ridges more aggression and stonger faster reflexes ect.  now i dont know if it was intended back when kirks klingons were flat heads or if they threw this in at the point of enterprise as a convenient explanation (khan and soungs saga was already long established so having the klingons steal the research and fubar it made perfect sense) but they definitely made it canon if it wasnt back then.  and as far as romulans looking badass, sorry theyre just vulcans that left instead of going along with emotion supression, they arent a seperate species theyre just emotional vulcans (and that is hard canon).


 

There was that DS9 episode were they went back in time to the "Trouble with Tribbles" episode to prevent a Klingon spy from assassinating Kirk, and the DS9 crew looked at Worf and looked at the Klingons on K-7 and said (maybe not exact quotes but you get the idea) "Those are Klingons?!?", and Worf said "It's a long story".  I liked the STE episodes where they explained why Klingons of that era looked like humans with spray on tans and bushy eyebrows.  They made it canon instead of ignoring TOS cheesy FX.

I agree the only thing about the latest movie Romulans that made them look badass are the facial tattoos.  Not sure why they did that since I can't ever remember a Romulan in any version of Trek that had tattoos.

  ktanner3

Master

Joined: 3/19/06
Posts: 3085

5/31/09 9:30:43 AM#19
Originally posted by Darth_Osor
Originally posted by neorandom

 brace yourselves super nerd moment inc.  klingons without ridges were a result of the klingons using the gene manipulation experiments of dr soung (datas creator dabbled in genetic mods before androids) that created khan and his ill fated kind.  the genetic virus delivery system that manipulated the genes didnt quite work with klingons (seen on enterprise series where dr flox cured them dieing of it) but resulted in a loss of ridges more aggression and stonger faster reflexes ect.  now i dont know if it was intended back when kirks klingons were flat heads or if they threw this in at the point of enterprise as a convenient explanation (khan and soungs saga was already long established so having the klingons steal the research and fubar it made perfect sense) but they definitely made it canon if it wasnt back then.  and as far as romulans looking badass, sorry theyre just vulcans that left instead of going along with emotion supression, they arent a seperate species theyre just emotional vulcans (and that is hard canon).


 

There was that DS9 episode were they went back in time to the "Trouble with Tribbles" episode to prevent a Klingon spy from assassinating Kirk, and the DS9 crew looked at Worf and looked at the Klingons on K-7 and said (maybe not exact quotes but you get the idea) "Those are Klingons?!?", and Worf said "It's a long story".  I liked the STE episodes where they explained why Klingons of that era looked like humans with spray on tans and bushy eyebrows.  They made it canon instead of ignoring TOS cheesy FX.

I agree the only thing about the latest movie Romulans that made them look badass are the facial tattoos.  Not sure why they did that since I can't ever remember a Romulan in any version of Trek that had tattoos.

The Enterprise Episode still doesn't explain Kang,Kor and Koloth's transformation from TOS to DS9. THe look isn't the only thing different about the Klingons. Their culture and customs were completely different as well and there was no explaining that. People just need to accept the fact that it was a design change and leave it alone. Star Trek broke it's own rules numerous times and this is just one example.
 

MMOs played:SWG,NGE,Warhammer, World of Warcraft, Star Trek Online,Eve, Star Wars the Old Republic.
Favorite MMO: Star Wars the Old Republic
Least Favorite MMO: NGE

  carnagespice

Novice Member

Joined: 11/30/05
Posts: 1

6/06/09 8:40:40 AM#20

I agree the only thing about the latest movie Romulans that made them look badass are the facial tattoos.  Not sure why they did that since I can't ever remember a Romulan in any version of Trek that had tattoos.

 

The problem with the new movie is there is a bunch of back story only told in the comic which explains so much more and gives Nero a reason for being the way he is. It would have given this new movie more substance. The comic is basically and Next Gen ep. You can get it here : www.amazon.com/Star-Trek-Countdown-J-Abrams/dp/1600104207/ref=sr_1_1

During the super nova that took out Romulas, Nero lost his family, apparently when a Romulan looses a family member they paint tatoos on them and when they wash off they stop mourning however Nero felt so bad about loosing his family and his home planet he shaved and had ink tatoo's put on him to symbolise his lost and he will never get over it and convinced his crew to do it also.

So this game will be set in the "prime" universe in which Spock and Nero dissapeared from it and all designs and etc will be for the natural development of this time line. Romulans are still the same unless there are others that decide to ink tatoo themselves due to grief.

So because the new movie is set in an Alternate universe where events and stuff have occurred differently to the prime universe its going to look different, who knows, maybe in 200 years times from this new time line Star Fleet will have a new fleet of Star Destroyers working for them (with warp drives instead of hyperdrives ofcourse) :)

2 Pages 1 2 » Search