Trending Games | ArcheAge | WildStar | Landmark | Gigantic

  Network:  FPSguru RTSguru
Login:  Password:   Remember?  
Show Quick Gamelist Jump to Random Game
Members:2,851,772 Users Online:0
Games:732  Posts:6,225,931
MMO Magic | Official Site
MMORPG | Genre:Fantasy | Status:Development  (est.rel N/A)  | Pub:MMO Magic
Distribution: | Retail Price:n/a | Pay Type:Free | Monthly Fee:n/a
System Req: PC | Out of date info? Let us know!

7 Pages « 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Search
136 posts found
  Burntvet

Hard Core Member

Joined: 11/16/07
Posts: 2747

11/14/12 9:38:18 AM#121
Originally posted by Biskop
Seems like there's already some decent drama being stirred up around this game.

If I were a dev here I'd just ignore this forum, instead of letting myself be lured into flame wars and pointless arguments. Better to focus on the actual game (which sounds fucking amazing btw) and provide some hard proof of all these groundbreaking features, than to engage in the mmorpg.com pvp - leave that to the players.

You guys have to accept that people are skeptical and that many won't be convinced by words alone. Many, many gamers (myself included) have been waiting on a game like this, but we have also been burned before by devs promising awesome stuff that never became a reality.

I'm not saying cos is a scam or vaporware, just that most sensible people will want to see more before jumping in with both feet.

I agree.

And especially when the answer to every question/concern is "go to look at the official website".

That's cool and all, but official sites are the most heavily moderated of any sites talking about a game, and are designed for a game to "put the best foot forward", i.e. marketing.

Which is fine, but don't expect people to take everything on there at face value. Most of us have seen plenty of "good demos" before, and that in itself means nothing.

Which does not mean the game is a scam, or bad, but there needs to be more before: 1. Getting remotely excited, and 2. Forking over any cash for a "pre-alpha", which does not seem like a good idea in the present MMO market.

 

 

  Dakirn

Advanced Member

Joined: 2/16/04
Posts: 360

 
OP  11/14/12 3:09:15 PM#122
Originally posted by Burntvet
Originally posted by Biskop
Seems like there's already some decent drama being stirred up around this game.

If I were a dev here I'd just ignore this forum, instead of letting myself be lured into flame wars and pointless arguments. Better to focus on the actual game (which sounds fucking amazing btw) and provide some hard proof of all these groundbreaking features, than to engage in the mmorpg.com pvp - leave that to the players.

You guys have to accept that people are skeptical and that many won't be convinced by words alone. Many, many gamers (myself included) have been waiting on a game like this, but we have also been burned before by devs promising awesome stuff that never became a reality.

I'm not saying cos is a scam or vaporware, just that most sensible people will want to see more before jumping in with both feet.

I agree.

And especially when the answer to every question/concern is "go to look at the official website".

That's cool and all, but official sites are the most heavily moderated of any sites talking about a game, and are designed for a game to "put the best foot forward", i.e. marketing.

Which is fine, but don't expect people to take everything on there at face value. Most of us have seen plenty of "good demos" before, and that in itself means nothing.

Which does not mean the game is a scam, or bad, but there needs to be more before: 1. Getting remotely excited, and 2. Forking over any cash for a "pre-alpha", which does not seem like a good idea in the present MMO market.

 

 

I just wanted to point out that their forums have the least moderation out of any game forum I've seen.  The only person I can remember ever banned was Convo because he was making personal attacks on the CoS Team.

 

i personally put my money in, even if it has .00001% chance of being made.  I want this game and I have no reason not to believe them yet (I'm not jaded enough to believe that everyone is a crook yet).

 

Many others feel the same way.  I also personally would rather spend money helping fund this game than get milked for cash from ArenaNet in their Gem Store, or any other cash shop game that's already out and is complete crap.

 

I still have some hope in the industry, but it's starting to fade.  I do what I can personally... because I believe indies are the future of the industry and not the big money companies.

 

Everyone has their own opinion though.. and I don't go around flaming people in other game forums for their choices.  It's sad that most people can't do the same.

  Burntvet

Hard Core Member

Joined: 11/16/07
Posts: 2747

11/14/12 5:46:54 PM#123
Originally posted by Dakirn
Originally posted by Burntvet
Originally posted by Biskop
Seems like there's already some decent drama being stirred up around this game.

If I were a dev here I'd just ignore this forum, instead of letting myself be lured into flame wars and pointless arguments. Better to focus on the actual game (which sounds fucking amazing btw) and provide some hard proof of all these groundbreaking features, than to engage in the mmorpg.com pvp - leave that to the players.

You guys have to accept that people are skeptical and that many won't be convinced by words alone. Many, many gamers (myself included) have been waiting on a game like this, but we have also been burned before by devs promising awesome stuff that never became a reality.

I'm not saying cos is a scam or vaporware, just that most sensible people will want to see more before jumping in with both feet.

I agree.

And especially when the answer to every question/concern is "go to look at the official website".

That's cool and all, but official sites are the most heavily moderated of any sites talking about a game, and are designed for a game to "put the best foot forward", i.e. marketing.

Which is fine, but don't expect people to take everything on there at face value. Most of us have seen plenty of "good demos" before, and that in itself means nothing.

Which does not mean the game is a scam, or bad, but there needs to be more before: 1. Getting remotely excited, and 2. Forking over any cash for a "pre-alpha", which does not seem like a good idea in the present MMO market.

 

 

I just wanted to point out that their forums have the least moderation out of any game forum I've seen.  The only person I can remember ever banned was Convo because he was making personal attacks on the CoS Team.

 

i personally put my money in, even if it has .00001% chance of being made.  I want this game and I have no reason not to believe them yet (I'm not jaded enough to believe that everyone is a crook yet).

 

Many others feel the same way.  I also personally would rather spend money helping fund this game than get milked for cash from ArenaNet in their Gem Store, or any other cash shop game that's already out and is complete crap.

 

I still have some hope in the industry, but it's starting to fade.  I do what I can personally... because I believe indies are the future of the industry and not the big money companies.

 

Everyone has their own opinion though.. and I don't go around flaming people in other game forums for their choices.  It's sad that most people can't do the same.

There is a big difference between "flaming people" and having some healthy scepticism, especially due to: 1. Just about every MMO release in the last 7 years, and, 2. Every indie/small company MMO released since EvE have not lived up to expectations, even reasonable ones.

So, if you want the "party line" I suggest going back to the official site, people actually discuss  MMOs here, both the positive and negative.

I am sure they are more gentile back there.

 

  Convo

Novice Member

Joined: 12/07/05
Posts: 169

11/15/12 6:01:09 AM#124
Yea..I don't get the blind faith here and it annoys me that the same person who reported me to this site continues to throw out subtle shots towards me.. As my concerns are totally legit at this point..be a fan boy for this game.. That's fine but just because the same person who updates the original forums and post here tells you it's all true because its on their "forum". Doesn't make it true...the bottom line is they have 8 years and not even a playable demo.. I deal with facts and the facts are this company has nothing to show you. They also have no investors... They just have a bunch of words on a website. You can't dispute that.  On top of all of that.. If someone is going to ask for your money.. You should demand to see a little something...  Or ask some Devs in the industry their opinion on what this company is promising.   That would be a  very interesting discussion. 
  amusedmonkey

Novice Member

Joined: 9/06/07
Posts: 42

11/15/12 3:54:03 PM#125

This is simply not true. While I get why people are being skeptic - this is afterall something that hasn't been done before - if you take a look at kickstarter you would see that the vast majority of games show little more than concept art and even less details about how things work in-game. I have yet to see any developer offer as much information at this stage of development as CoS does. One of the raffle rewards is logging into the game world THIS MONTH and taking a tour seeing all the current workings of the game.

 

Now you're right to feel like it's too risky to throw a dinner's worth of money on a potential indie game seeing the past record of some indies, and you don't have to, but calling something a scam without a solid proof other than "others did it" is at best misleading.

 

It's less of a blind faith and more of a hopeful support for the idea that we are tired of the same old. Hell, I would be getting more than my money's worth just by keeping this hope alive for a few years regardless if the game gets released or not, and from what I've seen I'd say it has pretty good chances of being released and successful.

 

I don't understand that sense of entitlement. Many are happy to donate to help the team (hence the term donate), and anything the devs choose to offer is just a "thank you token" and they're actually offering a lot! I think you're misunderstanding something: supporting the team with money is actually optional, no one is forcing anyone to do so. You are a supporter, not an investor or a share holder to ask for inner mechanics.

 

It's simple. Don't like/trust this game? no problem, go have a nice dinner with your partner. Some of us feel like our money here is well-spent and it's silly of you to try and speak for all of us dectating what should be of value to us.

  Convo

Novice Member

Joined: 12/07/05
Posts: 169

11/15/12 4:12:31 PM#126

I'm not trying to change anyones mind.  I already said in a prior post by all means donate away.   Eventually we will find out who is right and wrong with all this.  I actually havent looked at this thread for over a week until today.. I gotta tread lightly as I already got a warning for "trolling".  I think the naysayers are having a legitmate discussion here.  I would be willing to bet in the near future there will be a post on thier site claiming they are close to Alpha but if they could only get people to donate a little bit more...

 

For the record. MY orignal issue was when I posted my concern that the Raffle was never intended to be honored from Kickstarter.  At first I was told that people had to repledge because they didn't have the emails(that was their initial response) but after I pushed a bit they stated to just PM them.  Only after I called them on it.  That's where I started to have my doubts.  I'm entiled to them and I could be totally wrong.  I didn't like the way things went down, so here I am.. Doubtful you guys who put your money behind this will ever get a playable product.  That's how I feel, and nothing to date they have done has me even close to changing my mind.   You say we have no proof, well.. neither do you.. They are going to let someone in game in a month huh?  I have an idea.. Why don't they let this site or another gaming site inside the game?  

  Isane

Advanced Member

Joined: 5/24/06
Posts: 2696

"Some do , Some don''t , Others just cry"

Jean Sali

11/23/12 8:55:31 PM#127
Originally posted by Convo
Yea..I don't get the blind faith here and it annoys me that the same person who reported me to this site continues to throw out subtle shots towards me.. As my concerns are totally legit at this point..be a fan boy for this game.. That's fine but just because the same person who updates the original forums and post here tells you it's all true because its on their "forum". Doesn't make it true...the bottom line is they have 8 years and not even a playable demo.. I deal with facts and the facts are this company has nothing to show you. They also have no investors... They just have a bunch of words on a website. You can't dispute that.  On top of all of that.. If someone is going to ask for your money.. You should demand to see a little something...  Or ask some Devs in the industry their opinion on what this company is promising.   That would be a  very interesting discussion. 

Your misleading and misguided posts are amusing, but sadly just like yourself a lot of us have probably played as many if not more MMO hours than most. Your opinion just appears very very weak. Your concerns are just that but they are not really that legitimate as if you had taken any time whatsoever to engage properley, which yoiu haven't you would realise exactly what these guys have developed and where they are at..

The facts exist and what they say they have developed is exactly what they have done. Seems to me you are sulking because you were made to look like a complete and utter fool.

That said you are allowed an opinion, even if it is i'll informed. I remember why i stopped posting here too many people trying to look clever when really they are too short sighted to understand the future. What CoS are developing is complex and difficult but not impossible , I am a designer myself and can appreciate what they are doing.

 

________________________________________________________
SWTOR and COS games that could deliver !!

  Loktofeit

Elite Member

Joined: 1/13/10
Posts: 12138

Currently playing EVE, SMITE, Wildstar, and Combat Arms

11/23/12 9:13:43 PM#128
Originally posted by Convo
Yea..I don't get the blind faith here and it annoys me that the same person who reported me to this site continues to throw out subtle shots towards me.. As my concerns are totally legit at this point..be a fan boy for this game.. That's fine but just because the same person who updates the original forums and post here tells you it's all true because its on their "forum". Doesn't make it true...the bottom line is they have 8 years and not even a playable demo.. I deal with facts and the facts are this company has nothing to show you. They also have no investors... They just have a bunch of words on a website. You can't dispute that.  On top of all of that.. If someone is going to ask for your money.. You should demand to see a little something...  Or ask some Devs in the industry their opinion on what this company is promising.   That would be a  very interesting discussion. 

I don't think they're confident in their project and I know they don't have a handle on marketing. Both were very clear in the Kickstarter campaign, which is a shame because it's entirely possible they've got a diamond in the rough they're working on.

Anyone with at least a half a brain approaches an indie MMO with skepticism, and when the answer to every question is danced around it just makes people that much more skeptical.

"And wikipedia is as accurate as Britannica. Wikipedia is very reliable. You would be hard pressed to find a more reliable source for these kinds of things." -fovoroth

  Convo

Novice Member

Joined: 12/07/05
Posts: 169

11/25/12 1:07:23 PM#129
Originally posted by Isane
Originally posted by Convo
Yea..I don't get the blind faith here and it annoys me that the same person who reported me to this site continues to throw out subtle shots towards me.. As my concerns are totally legit at this point..be a fan boy for this game.. That's fine but just because the same person who updates the original forums and post here tells you it's all true because its on their "forum". Doesn't make it true...the bottom line is they have 8 years and not even a playable demo.. I deal with facts and the facts are this company has nothing to show you. They also have no investors... They just have a bunch of words on a website. You can't dispute that.  On top of all of that.. If someone is going to ask for your money.. You should demand to see a little something...  Or ask some Devs in the industry their opinion on what this company is promising.   That would be a  very interesting discussion. 

Your misleading and misguided posts are amusing, but sadly just like yourself a lot of us have probably played as many if not more MMO hours than most. Your opinion just appears very very weak. Your concerns are just that but they are not really that legitimate as if you had taken any time whatsoever to engage properley, which yoiu haven't you would realise exactly what these guys have developed and where they are at..

The facts exist and what they say they have developed is exactly what they have done. Seems to me you are sulking because you were made to look like a complete and utter fool.

That said you are allowed an opinion, even if it is i'll informed. I remember why i stopped posting here too many people trying to look clever when really they are too short sighted to understand the future. What CoS are developing is complex and difficult but not impossible , I am a designer myself and can appreciate what they are doing.

 

 

There is nothing misguided about what I'm saying.  What we have is a disagreement on what this company is actually capable of and in my opinion how honest they are really being about what they promise..  I would call you misguided for drinking that kool aid..  Tell me..Where are they?  What proof have they shown you to actually back up what you are saying?  All we see is bad graphics...That's not misinformation.. What they created the most amazing engine and tools but they are not going to sell it like the Hero Engine, they are just going to hold onto it and ask for donations to fund the game since the investors they showed it to must not of been too impressed...I mean if the engine was really that amazing don't you think that would get their attention?  They are making some pretty incredible claims here for a MMO.   I'm just not buying that they are selling and the reasons why have already been debated on this forum.  But like I said, time will tell.  You can always PM me again like you did when I predicted what would happen with the raffles and tell me I was right.. You might want to rethink that comment about me looking like an utter fool.. Not even sure where that came from considering what I posted and when I posted about it.  If anything, I was correct and I was just holding them accountable..  

 

  Isane

Advanced Member

Joined: 5/24/06
Posts: 2696

"Some do , Some don''t , Others just cry"

Jean Sali

1/04/13 8:39:31 PM#130
Originally posted by Convo

 

There is nothing misguided about what I'm saying.  What we have is a disagreement on what this company is actually capable of and in my opinion how honest they are really being about what they promise..  I would call you misguided for drinking that kool aid..  Tell me..Where are they?  What proof have they shown you to actually back up what you are saying?  All we see is bad graphics...That's not misinformation.. What they created the most amazing engine and tools but they are not going to sell it like the Hero Engine, they are just going to hold onto it and ask for donations to fund the game since the investors they showed it to must not of been too impressed...I mean if the engine was really that amazing don't you think that would get their attention?  They are making some pretty incredible claims here for a MMO.   I'm just not buying that they are selling and the reasons why have already been debated on this forum.  But like I said, time will tell.  You can always PM me again like you did when I predicted what would happen with the raffles and tell me I was right.. You might want to rethink that comment about me looking like an utter fool.. Not even sure where that came from considering what I posted and when I posted about it.  If anything, I was correct and I was just holding them accountable..  

 

You are misguided; And I am laughing my socks off because you are plain wrong. The game is exactly where the developers say it is at . Some of the Kickstarter Videos show a lot more than vaporware, you are just too bitter and blinkered to see it (Remember Pre-Alpha).

The raffles delivered exactly what they said they would , you dug yourself a hole made a fool of yourself  had a good rant and your ignorance here just shows that ever since you are trying to I don't know create some form of "Cult of Convo".

If you look at current MMOs and the ammount of design effort they put in against an extended design period , then you may realise that a lot more can be acheived if the correct focus and effort is applied. Some of us understand this and we are not all fools far from it.

Your petty nature must come from some where other than this game , remember the core here is the design and toolsets to deliver something truly different. I can only applaud this development team for putting so much effort into their design.

But why am I explaining something you already know? Be Bitter and be twisted but remember it won't do you any good.

 

 

________________________________________________________
SWTOR and COS games that could deliver !!

  User Deleted
1/04/13 11:34:27 PM#131
Originally posted by Isane
Originally posted by Convo

 

There is nothing misguided about what I'm saying.  What we have is a disagreement on what this company is actually capable of and in my opinion how honest they are really being about what they promise..  I would call you misguided for drinking that kool aid..  Tell me..Where are they?  What proof have they shown you to actually back up what you are saying?  All we see is bad graphics...That's not misinformation.. What they created the most amazing engine and tools but they are not going to sell it like the Hero Engine, they are just going to hold onto it and ask for donations to fund the game since the investors they showed it to must not of been too impressed...I mean if the engine was really that amazing don't you think that would get their attention?  They are making some pretty incredible claims here for a MMO.   I'm just not buying that they are selling and the reasons why have already been debated on this forum.  But like I said, time will tell.  You can always PM me again like you did when I predicted what would happen with the raffles and tell me I was right.. You might want to rethink that comment about me looking like an utter fool.. Not even sure where that came from considering what I posted and when I posted about it.  If anything, I was correct and I was just holding them accountable..  

 

You are misguided; And I am laughing my socks off because you are plain wrong. The game is exactly where the developers say it is at . Some of the Kickstarter Videos show a lot more than vaporware, you are just too bitter and blinkered to see it (Remember Pre-Alpha).

The raffles delivered exactly what they said they would , you dug yourself a hole made a fool of yourself  had a good rant and your ignorance here just shows that ever since you are trying to I don't know create some form of "Cult of Convo".

If you look at current MMOs and the ammount of design effort they put in against an extended design period , then you may realise that a lot more can be acheived if the correct focus and effort is applied. Some of us understand this and we are not all fools far from it.

Your petty nature must come from some where other than this game , remember the core here is the design and toolsets to deliver something truly different. I can only applaud this development team for putting so much effort into their design.

But why am I explaining something you already know? Be Bitter and be twisted but remember it won't do you any good.

 

 

 

Right but some of us have been around long enough to remember countless mmorpgs with videos from some early alpha.  Many of those never launched, that was vaporware.  In fact, ill have to do some digging, but i know more than one was using this site and the hype generated by claims of an awesome mmorpg in the works, as a lunchpad to get investors and or sell their game engine.

 

Im not interested in the personal back and forth you two seem to have here, just that ive been down this road before, this isnt my first rodeo, ive heard it all before.  Its not this specific game companies fault i tend to giggle at outrageous claims of some indy developer with some screenshots and a video, its the countless companies that came before them with the same pitch, the same promises (not specifics but the general promise of *instert hype buzzword*)  

Hell even the mega companies with 500+ developers working round the clock and mega million budgets seem to have issues getting just the fundamental basics down right...

 

I wish these guys the best of luck, but no formal support, no money, until theres a playable beta, player feedback, and more than hopes and dreams with screenshots and a few free camera videos of a couple of places.

 

Also, there was a big point being made by the guy your arguing with.  If this game engine was absolutely stunning and revolutionary...they wouldnt need financial support from customers.  If the game was setting the stage to break the mold, again, this all wouldnt be needed.  That isnt to say that its all a scam, just that with what they have now, they are unable to gather serious 3rd party support and invetment, and need to turn to players for help....which is ok...but should be an indication as to where they are with the game and its revolutionary game engine...and to me that seems like the issue...

 

From what i can gather this game is going to be like marrowind on a private invite realm, where you can kill an npc and have it change the course of the game, and then port back to a persistant world where you cant do that but can participate in normal mmorpg repeatable stuff.  Again its sad i need to make assumptions like this but the info isnt out there, and what is avalible is very vauge and open ended.  That shouldnt be the case if they are asking players for help finacially.

 

Ill be the right all the supporters of this once they get an open beta or launch ready client, despite im more proned to froth at the mouth over full loot sandboxes, which this wont be, but ill always support quality work that isnt setting the bar at a wow with nicer graphics and a gew extra gimmicks...and this doesnt seem to be the case for this game...

ill support this when theres an actual game to support however.

 

And i dont think im being out of line with this frame of mind, i think its more than deserved considering how a LOT of these games end up...

 

  PieRad

Apprentice Member

Joined: 11/14/08
Posts: 1169

1/05/13 6:45:08 PM#132

Ehhh, the kickstarter ended on 8th of nov. short of $656.101

 

  Cursedsei

Advanced Member

Joined: 12/17/07
Posts: 1020

1/05/13 7:32:18 PM#133
Originally posted by PieRad

Ehhh, the kickstarter ended on 8th of nov. short of $656.101

 

You forgot a few zeros in there mate.

http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/mmomagic/citadel-of-sorcery-mmorpg/posts

Required 700,000.00

Had 43,899.00

 

Just barely above 5%. Which doesn't surprise me too much considering the lack of any explanation on the kickstarter proper for much of the rewards/tiers/items and their significance. Most posts choose to just say "Go here and read" instead of providing the information within the kickstarter itself. And well, a severe lack of public/online presence (least from what I've seen) didn't help much either.

  Convo

Novice Member

Joined: 12/07/05
Posts: 169

1/22/13 8:36:46 AM#134
Is this game in beta yet?!
  Jalitan

Novice Member

Joined: 7/08/06
Posts: 79

1/22/13 8:42:07 AM#135

It isn't alpha yet. Here is the latest news.

http://www.mmomagic.com/NewsDetail.php?newsID=131

  Vorthanion

Elite Member

Joined: 7/02/11
Posts: 1912

2/13/13 9:59:05 PM#136
They have a crowd funding effort going on at their website.  I dontated 50 bucks just for the off-chance for a different kind of MMORPG that isn't being turned into an arcade game.

7 Pages « 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Search