Guys, he's not even 14 in the first place! :D He's more like 17 now if I remember. I invite you all to go into the fan channel on Freenode and use the /mode #planeshift +b command to see who exactly has been banning people recently (unless you're already listed there).

Age =/ maturity

I can tell you that one of the most respected lead administrators of wikipedia.org was 14 at the time he received his position.  This was, of course, downplayed to avoid just this sort of reaction.

If the OP feels that this individual has abused his powers, I would suggest he make his case.  I would hazard a guess that every moderator on every board has abused his powers in one form or another, either of their own volition or under orders.  Age would have nothing to do with that.

In my experience, however, the abuse of power generally amounts to a moderator not letting someone indulge in their god given right to talk crap.  That too, is not age related, just maturity related.

Originally posted by pstruth

Whether or not he has abused his powers seems contentious at the least.  And neither of your well-informed replies answered my question with regards to his age.

so because he is younger you expect him to abuse his powers?  i think that is a little harsh.  at 14 i would be more worried about how much work load he is undertaking for that position rather than what he is doing with it.

Originally posted by Tuxide

pstruth: I see no factual information here, there is no 14 year old running the fan channel and there is no GM younger than 21.

<modedit>

What do you mean there's no factual information?  I asked a question.  You and Nurahk posted answers.  Are you saying that the answer you gave isn't factual?

Originally posted by UtMoon

He is another op in the channel. Big deal? No. I have never once seem him abuse the commands.

Originally posted by UtMoon

<modedit>

Really now? My points were more than valid, factual, and not flamy in the least. Just the honest truth. Perhaps I'll post them on the PS forum... where the moding is a bit lighter.

I'm sorry, but I haven't seen the mods here edit out stuff that wasn't a flame.  Perhaps that's just my opinion, but your post was probably editted for a reason.  The PS forum is more tolerant of flaming, especially when the person being flamed is disliked by the moderators for giving truthful reviews of the game and its community.

Originally posted by UtMoon

Now, I am going to question why this was posted here, where few actual players visit, instead of simply going into the #planeshift channel and asking the person in question himself.

Perhaps because the #planeshift channel is a big giant flame pit, perhaps because it's run by 14 year olds. ;)

Originally posted by Tyrian

If the OP feels that this individual has abused his powers, I would suggest he make his case. 

That doesn't fly over there.  I don't think I've ever seen someone ever lose their position as GM or moderator after being accused of abusing his position.  Bad GMs and moderators have left the game before on their own, but whenever that happens it's made very clear that they simply decided to leave and no one "fired" them.

Originally posted by Death1942

Originally posted by pstruth

Whether or not he has abused his powers seems contentious at the least.  And neither of your well-informed replies answered my question with regards to his age.

so because he is younger you expect him to abuse his powers? 

No, I'm saying that some people think he has abused his powers on occassion.

hm... a smart kid that know how to do the job... that is fine...

On the other hand i had seen people in the 50s that never had a work before.. they just do a bit of work over here and there.. nothing real ever in their lives... lol.

know what I mean.

Originally posted by pstruth

 

 

Originally posted by UtMoon

He is another op in the channel. Big deal? No. I have never once seem him abuse the commands.

That's just your opinion, and it is contentious.

 

 

 

Originally posted by UtMoon

<modedit>

Really now? My points were more than valid, factual, and not flamy in the least. Just the honest truth. Perhaps I'll post them on the PS forum... where the moding is a bit lighter.

I'm sorry, but I haven't seen the mods here edit out stuff that wasn't a flame.  Perhaps that's just my opinion, but your post was probably editted for a reason.  The PS forum is more tolerant of flaming, especially when the person being flamed is disliked by the moderators for giving truthful reviews of the game and its community.

 

Originally posted by UtMoon

Now, I am going to question why this was posted here, where few actual players visit, instead of simply going into the #planeshift channel and asking the person in question himself.

Perhaps because the #planeshift channel is a big giant flame pit, perhaps because it's run by 14 year olds. ;)

 

This is all just your opinion.  In fact, everything you post here has just been your opinion.  You say Jose has abused power but, you have no proof.  You say the PlaneShift mods have favorites but, again, you have no proof.

And he is no longer 14, pstruth, he has aged.

Now... Is there any point to this thread?

"Perhaps because the #planeshift channel is a big giant flame pit, perhaps because it's run by 14 year olds. ;)" -pstruth

'Perhaps' is a good way of saying nothing and implying much. The channel is not a 'big giant flame pit' as defined by en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flaming (Internet).  Interestingly enough, the deleted section of my post is not defined as flaming either, by this section of the article: "Similarly, a normal, non-flame message may have elements of a flame -- it may be hostile, for example -- but it is not a flame if its author seriously intends to advance the discussion." What I wrote was nothing more than a breakdown of the phasing of the original post, and why people took offence to it. There was no name calling, goading, or insulting aside from giving my opinion at the end that I am sad that you feel the need to be so petty, which was valid by your above statement and the following.

As said many times, it is not run by a 14 year old -now-. Three years ago, it was modded by a 14 year old, along with others who were not. Even by saying this is 'perhaps' the cause is showing that you are bias, judgemental, and yes, petty.

Try to answer the question without using slippery words. I think the honest motivation of the original poster is a more than valid discusion topic for any thread.

I concur, this thread has no point to it because it is clearly a personal attack thread.

VPellen: With all due respect, I have no idea why the hell you claim this is not an attack thread because this obviously is one. This is not a discussion about 14 year old GMs in general, this thread is clearly about a particular person. I would be happier if we could hold this discussion WITHOUT disparaging individuals.

Originally posted by Tuxide

I concur, this thread has no point to it because it is clearly a personal attack thread.

You already tried that one.

VPellen: With all due respect, I have no idea why the hell you claim this is not an attack thread because this obviously is one. This is not a discussion about 14 year old GMs in general, this thread is clearly about a particular person. I would be happier if we could hold this discussion WITHOUT disparaging individuals.

Then I guess you need to stop posting, eh? Or do you quickly forget things you write?

VPellen: I'd suggest locking the thread, my self. pstruth has made his point, { Mod Edit }, case closed.

I'd consider that a flame.  The only real reason he posted it was to attack us "fanbois" isn't exactly a compliment.

Either way, no, pstruth has yet to make any point, Zorvan.  This thread has been

"14 year old GM?"

"No, not GM and no longer 14"

"14 year old GM?"

"No... not GM and no longer 14"

"But... but... 14 year old GM?"

And so on and so forth.  I've yet to see a point.

Originally posted by Nurahk

I'd consider that a flame.  The only real reason he posted it was to attack us "fanbois" isn't exactly a compliment.

 

Either way, no, pstruth has yet to make any point, Zorvan.  This thread has been

 

"14 year old GM?"

"No, not GM and no longer 14"

"14 year old GM?"

"No... not GM and no longer 14"

"But... but... 14 year old GM?"

 

And so on and so forth.  I've yet to see a point.

You guys ( especially Tuxide ) consider anything you don't agree with ( which means anything said against anything to do with Planeshift ) a flame. Kinda funny, in a sad way.

Originally posted by pstruth

 

Perhaps because the #planeshift channel is a big giant flame pit, perhaps because it's run by 14 year olds. ;)

 

Since this seems to be a blatant attack on Jose, i would like to call myself as a witness ;) Personally, it took me several months before i realized he was even younger then me. He is an incredibly mature, intelligent individual, fully capable of handling the position of op on the planeshift irc channel. I would also like to point out that there are several others with op status, including Talad himself much of the time. So any claims of mod abuse, are completely unwarranted in my opinion.

As for the claims that the channel is one big flamefest, thats also quite untrue. I am pretty much there most of the time, and there are RARELY any instances of flaming. 99.9% of the time it is a pleasant discussion..Of course there are a few individuals who take pride in causing trouble, { Mod Edit }

Sincerely yours,

Anumesa