<
>

Hype-level

8.32

8.323353616518.323353616518.323353616518.323353616518.323353616518.323353616518.323353616518.323353616518.323353616518.32335361651

PlaneShift

Show Game Details

  • Developer: Atomic Blue Corp
  • Genre: Fantasy
  • Status: Beta Testing (est. release N/A)
  • Platforms: PC Mac Linux 
  • Website: http://www.planeshift.it

Planeshift » General Discussion » Okay, where's the negative about this game?

Page 2 of 4

1

2

3

4

 Thread (81 posts)
pstruth  3/13/08 6:59:33 PM

Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100

Novice Member

Joined: 9/22/07
Posts: 253

His suggestion is that Planeshift is attractive to the furry community.  I'm not saying he's right.

In terms of skins, culture, body movements, etc, enkidukai have recieved the most code and artwork, and they seem to recieve new things before the other races.  They are the only race to have their own city and their own language, and they are further subdivided into seperate tribes.

You can say that new features will come with time and development, but Planeshift has always been a game in development and will be a game in development for quite some time.

 
Tuxide  3/13/08 7:59:09 PM

Rank: 42/100 Rank: 42/100 Rank: 42/100 Rank: 42/100 Rank: 42/100

Advanced Member

Joined: 8/14/07
Posts: 188


Originally posted by pstruth
They are the only race to have their own city...

Not true anymore, Kran has its own city now as per 0.4 Steel Blue. Then again, Enkidukai is still only one of twelve possible races, so I don't think I would label it as a furry game since none of the others are animal-like.

 
pstruth  3/14/08 5:19:23 AM

Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100

Novice Member

Joined: 9/22/07
Posts: 253

Shame on me for spreading false information!

 
Dalmont  3/25/08 7:45:27 PM

Rank: 8/100 Rank: 8/100 Rank: 8/100 Rank: 8/100 Rank: 8/100

Novice Member

Joined: 2/07/04
Posts: 85

Its free game so going to try it.

Its not going to waste much of my time!

 
charlizd  3/25/08 7:59:11 PM

Rank: 80/100 Rank: 80/100 Rank: 80/100 Rank: 80/100 Rank: 80/100

Hard Core Member

Joined: 2/07/07
Posts: 760

Live Life today, Because tomorrow is but a dream and yesterday only a
memory!

The only Negative i find with this game (not my personal opinion either) is that the Graphics are just 2 old and thus not many people even trying it because visually it just does not appeal.


pstruth  3/26/08 2:29:49 PM

Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100

Novice Member

Joined: 9/22/07
Posts: 253

There are a number of games out there that have outdated (or even 2d!) graphics and yet are immensely popular.  Maple Story is probably the best example, even though it's such a horrible game IMO.

 
Tuxide  7/23/08 2:27:28 AM

Rank: 42/100 Rank: 42/100 Rank: 42/100 Rank: 42/100 Rank: 42/100

Advanced Member

Joined: 8/14/07
Posts: 188


Originally posted by Tuxide
Well I'm being told Crystal Space 1.3 is done now so we should be seeing paging landscape soon.

* me really hopes there's paging landscape now



Thought I would mention that as of yesterday, PlaneShift is using Crystal Space 1.4's terrain2 engine now, which is the part that supports this feature (although PlaneShift doesn't use paging landscape as of yet). Also, terrain2 supports the more advanced lighter2 engine for more natural lighting effects of landscapes.

That doesn't mean terrain2 itself is without bugs; usually PlaneShift is the first to try out new features in Crystal Space, and due to the size of the user base this is good for the engine that a decent number of players are consistently finding the flaws in it and pushing the engine to its limits. Another notable game that uses Crystal Space is Yo Frankie! aka "Project Apricot" from the Blender Institute.

 
Hiraghm  8/26/08 2:20:11 AM

Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100

Novice Member

Joined: 8/26/08
Posts: 39

I got a look at the deathrealm area the other night... the lighting in there is awesome! That is one of the spookiest places I have been in a long long time. The music helps a lot. I dunno who's doing the music for PS, but it's top shelf. On a par with WoW, better than EQ1

 

 

 
QueenofFools  8/26/08 2:55:49 AM

Rank: 100/100 Rank: 100/100 Rank: 100/100 Rank: 100/100 Rank: 100/100

PlaneShift Developer

Joined: 12/18/07
Posts: 53

Every book is the bible, and every written word is blasphemy against the human spirit.

"Pstruth" just admit that you are an enemy of the game. You are not some crusader looking for a bastian to express yourself freely your recent comments make it clear you have not been in game for a long time due to a ban. Mmorpg.com continuing to tolerate this transparent poison is a great source of sadness for me. 

We did our best to make a sincere effort to post straightforward views of issues.

When one individual is permitted the chance to "run the table" and say whatever they want unfounded or not there is a problem. I have called upon mods and been answered well.

At this point I will have no more to do with this forum. I thank the kind mods who did their best to make sure a fair dialogue occurred here. 

This "pstruth" character clearly has a destructive agenda aimed at tearing down the game and the fact that he is in any way tolerated or believed to be a neutral poster is so far beyond what I can reasonably accept that I will have no more to do with this forum.

I hope to the gods that he will not come back to ps after his ban is lifted. (despite protestations to the contrary this is a person banned for trolling).

 

 

 

 

pstruth  8/26/08 4:16:48 AM

Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100

Novice Member

Joined: 9/22/07
Posts: 253

Originally posted by QueenofFools

"Pstruth" just admit that you are an enemy of the game.

 

I have no interest in admitting to something that isn't true.  I'm no more an enemy to the game than you are.

 

Originally posted by QueenofFools

You are not some crusader looking for a bastian to express yourself freely your recent comments make it clear you have not been in game for a long time due to a ban. Mmorpg.com continuing to tolerate this transparent poison is a great source of sadness for me.

An open discussion where players share their opinions and experiences is not poison.  It's discussion.  I'm sorry that you're frustrated because you can't lock and delete threads like you can on hydlaa.com.

Originally posted by QueenofFools

We did our best to make a sincere effort to post straightforward views of issues.

When one individual is permitted the chance to "run the table" and say whatever they want unfounded or not there is a problem. I have called upon mods and been answered well.

There's three sides to every story.  Your side, my side, and the truth.  That's why we try to give evidence when we post, when we remember to.

No one is running the table here.  Everyone can post freely, so long as they don't violate basic internet rules of decency.

Originally posted by QueenofFools

At this point I will have no more to do with this forum. I thank the kind mods who did their best to make sure a fair dialogue occurred here.

And what counts as fair dialog in your book?  When only positive things are said, and anyone who says something negative is bullied into submission?  I don't understand what you're trying to imply.

Originally posted by QueenofFools

This "pstruth" character clearly has a destructive agenda aimed at tearing down the game and the fact that he is in any way tolerated or believed to be a neutral poster is so far beyond what I can reasonably accept that I will have no more to do with this forum.

What is a neutral poster?  I have my opinions.  I have my experiences.  And I don't want to tear down the game.  All I've done is point out ways the game could be improved, and ways the game's social culture should be improved.  You might not like it, but that doesn't mean I'm an enemy of the game who has a secret mission to destroy ps.

Balanced reviews are tolerated here.  Even negative reviews are tolerated here.  And they should be.  If that changes, then I'll be leaving mmorpg.com as well, but it won't.  The real world doesn't work like the ps community.  I'm sorry you think I'm out to ruin you, because it simply isn't true, but you don't get to play Big Brother here.

 
Hiraghm  8/27/08 12:29:08 AM

Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100

Novice Member

Joined: 8/26/08
Posts: 39

Originally posted by pstruth
Originally posted by QueenofFools

"Pstruth" just admit that you are an enemy of the game.

 

I have no interest in admitting to something that isn't true.  I'm no more an enemy to the game than you are.

 

Originally posted by QueenofFools

You are not some crusader looking for a bastian to express yourself freely your recent comments make it clear you have not been in game for a long time due to a ban. Mmorpg.com continuing to tolerate this transparent poison is a great source of sadness for me.

An open discussion where players share their opinions and experiences is not poison.  It's discussion.  I'm sorry that you're frustrated because you can't lock and delete threads like you can on hydlaa.com.

Originally posted by QueenofFools

We did our best to make a sincere effort to post straightforward views of issues.

When one individual is permitted the chance to "run the table" and say whatever they want unfounded or not there is a problem. I have called upon mods and been answered well.

There's three sides to every story.  Your side, my side, and the truth.  That's why we try to give evidence when we post, when we remember to.

No one is running the table here.  Everyone can post freely, so long as they don't violate basic internet rules of decency.

Originally posted by QueenofFools

At this point I will have no more to do with this forum. I thank the kind mods who did their best to make sure a fair dialogue occurred here.

And what counts as fair dialog in your book?  When only positive things are said, and anyone who says something negative is bullied into submission?  I don't understand what you're trying to imply.

Originally posted by QueenofFools

This "pstruth" character clearly has a destructive agenda aimed at tearing down the game and the fact that he is in any way tolerated or believed to be a neutral poster is so far beyond what I can reasonably accept that I will have no more to do with this forum.

What is a neutral poster?  I have my opinions.  I have my experiences.  And I don't want to tear down the game.  All I've done is point out ways the game could be improved, and ways the game's social culture should be improved.  You might not like it, but that doesn't mean I'm an enemy of the game who has a secret mission to destroy ps.

Balanced reviews are tolerated here.  Even negative reviews are tolerated here.  And they should be.  If that changes, then I'll be leaving mmorpg.com as well, but it won't.  The real world doesn't work like the ps community.  I'm sorry you think I'm out to ruin you, because it simply isn't true, but you don't get to play Big Brother here.

Oh, yes the "both sides are equally wrong" argument. But, sometimes, the truth is on the side of one person's opinion. In fact, when there's a rational person in the argument (Hi, there, Queen), that side is usually the true side, as well.

 

"And I don't want to tear down the game"... are you sure your name isn't Obama, or Clinton? Because they speak as you do... and then follow it up with denegration. "I love America..." "Evil is right here in our streets".. the literal truth of that is supposed to override the fact that the focus is on associating "our streets" with evil.

You do the same thing with Planeshift. You claim to like it and want to support it... and then you go on to denigrate it.

I am, regrettably brought to the same place as the developers; yes, they could use more help with development. You have endless opinions about what could and should be done with the game. You obviously can write fictoin, based on your body of work here... have you ONCE volunteered your expert services at writing? Maybe to free someone else up to deal with customer service, bug repair, content creation?

 

Have you, alternatively, said, "You know guys, I've pointed this out to you, I've pointed that out to you, and I would love to play the game, how bout giving me a ring when you've got it finished?" and then *dropped it*?

No, this crusade against a game you claim to like is what ives you your entertainment, and I suspect other people are beginning to see that, as well.

 

 
pstruth  8/27/08 12:46:16 AM

Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100

Novice Member

Joined: 9/22/07
Posts: 253

Supporting something doesn't mean ignoring its flaws.  Supporting a person doesn't mean supporting everything they do.

I'm finding your posts very confusing.  You've said you've read through all the threads here so I'll take you at your word.  It seems like you're looking for some sort of Kumbaya moment between PS's developers and people who have negative things to say about the game or the behavior of the ps team.

I'll pose the question to you then:  How do you see such disagreements being resolved?  You've said that people should just join the dev team if they want to see things change.  Do you think that's the solution?  People like myself should apply to the dev team, and then everything will be solved?

I'm just trying to "understand" you here.

 
Hiraghm  8/27/08 3:12:43 PM