I voted.  Pretty much every questions I was going down the list and thinking NO, NO, NO, NO, NO, what no more options? Wish there was none of the above.

None of the games were innovative, people that still think GW2 was innovative drank way too much Kool-Aid.

Originally posted by wiser22
wtf is that p.o.s. WoW game doing on any of these lists?  Blizzard must have paid this website quite a bit to get their unworthy mmo on any of these lists.

Well that seems quite obvious dont you think? Considering the whole background of the page is currently a WoW add. http://i.imgur.com/DGkDs.jpg

Originally posted by wiser22
wtf is that p.o.s. WoW game doing on any of these lists?  Blizzard must have paid this website quite a bit to get their unworthy mmo on any of these lists.

 

Um, because its a high quality major 2012 release?  There are about 5 or 6 other games that would be booted before MoP gets booted.

Originally posted by Brenelael

Maybe it's just me but the Game of the year for the last 3 years has been a "Pick the least smelliest turd" contest. Oh well maybe next year something at least halfway decent will release.

 

Bren

I could never get this kind of outlook in life. Judging from your harsh words your taste must be on the other end of the spectrum, and if by next year the nominees are actually to your liking they will then be considered "a selection of turds" by the other camp.

Originally posted by KhinRunite

Originally posted by Brenelael

Maybe it's just me but the Game of the year for the last 3 years has been a "Pick the least smelliest turd" contest. Oh well maybe next year something at least halfway decent will release.

 

Bren

I could never get this kind of outlook in life. Judging from your harsh words your taste must be on the other end of the spectrum, and if by next year the nominees are actually to your liking they will then be considered "a selection of turds" by the other camp.

last year was pretty sad

this year has a lot of quality:  TSW, Storm Legion, GW2, MoP, PS2...all easily better than anything launched last year.

I think Guild Wars 2 was reallly innovative.  It has created new features, and revitalized old/good ideas.   (TSW definitely was too, I just think not as much)

-Level Scaling

-Dynamic Event Scaling (Even if you don't like events, the scaling system is still innovative)

-Overflow Servers

-No Trinity

-B2P Model on AAA MMO 

-Reviving WVW (seriously how many of you still play DAoC)

-Combo Fields

-Very Much Horizontal Gear Progression (yes a small lapse with Ascended.)

Monthly content that absolutely no other company can keep up with.

Originally posted by Finit

I think Guild Wars 2 was reallly innovative.  It has created new features, and revitalized old/good ideas.   (TSW definitely was too, I just think not as much)

-Level Scaling

-Dynamic Event Scaling (Even if you don't like events, the scaling system is still innovative)

-Overflow Servers

-No Trinity

-B2P Model on AAA MMO 

-Reviving WVW (seriously how many of you still play DAoC)

-Combo Fields

-Very Much Horizontal Gear Progression (yes a small lapse with Ascended.)

Monthly content that absolutely no other company can keep up with.

 

you can say that again! oops..    nvm.

I voted for Club Penguin. #swagyolo

Gw2. Gw2. and Gw2.

More GW2.

FTW.