It's the rebirth of this nearly 3 year old thread i never participated in: http://www.mmorpg.com/discussion2.cfm/thread/246625/page/1

So, to give more spice to the topic, because i have a feeling most of you will refernce EVE or LOTRO (and WOW), what are the 3 best and worst communities you're seen in mmos?

WARNING: Because i also know many of you will say the older mmorpgs like UO, EQ, DAOC, SWG, etc, i'm talking about the mmorpgs of today's time, being it AAA, indie, whatever, like Rift, SWTOR, FE, etc (probably the post-WOW mmos). I understand the older times might have been beter, but this is nowadays. Sorry

GW2 is already showing the best community I have seen in years.

Best: Fallen Earth, Wurm and FFXIV

Worst: EVE, Mortal Online and APB

*notice a trend with the worst and their PvP nature*

I would say GW2 and TSW have a good community, but only because the people playing them, respectively, are dead-set fans of the game, so they tend to get along with their own kind - but if how the two camps bicker with each other is any sign of the real underlying stigmas within - then they could also go in the worst catagory.

Best.

EQ. It's still running and being updated, therefore it is 'of today's time'.

SWG. Still around (hush). In it's original form, you couldn't survive completely by yourself (unless you had multiple accounts).

Vanguard. Very friendly bunch of people and easy to find assistance when required (though my experience is maybe 2 years old)

Worst.

WoW. This game heralded the end of the gaming community as we once knew it. 

TERA. The rudeness, trolling, and immature behaviour caused me to drop my sub.

SWtOR. Same reasons as WoW and TERA.

(not sure why only the first line got posted before the edit)

i'll make this very short.......imho communities in TODAY's games are dead.....the only one that will have a bit (at least i hope) of a communitie will be GW2 me thinks....but the rest is all single player games on servers with a fiew 100 or 1000 players occupying it but communities are far gone over the years.

people party to get to better loot, not because they want to do their part in a community.

my 2 copperz

Best: UO, AC1, LOTRO (all are still running, so all are today's MMORPGs).

Worse: anything with FFA PvP with full loot. Darkfail, MO, etc... are breeding grounds for asshats.

I had some great guilds in some of the worst MMO communities, now this doesn't reflect what I think about the gameplay and this is outside of my guild friends.

- WoW, Lineage 2 and APB

The best communities I have come acrossed in my mmo history.

- Anarchy Online, SWG, LotRO and EQ in their PRIME!

MMO gaming communities aren't like they used to be, however Fallen Earth and The Secret World currently got a nice community going so far.

Best: I have to agree on the community in GW2 beta. Will it change at release? probably.

Worst: while technicly not an mmo. Its listed in the game forums. League of legends.... Communities do not come worse then this.

Originally posted by The_Korrigan

Best: UO, AC1, LOTRO (all are still running, so all are today's MMORPGs).

Worse: anything with FFA PvP with full loot. Darkfail, MO, etc... are breeding grounds for asshats.

UO had ffa and looting.

To be honest if the players of LOTRO had the ability to clobber each other you would soon see their true colours. Only when someone has the chance to pummel you into the ground or otherwise "do you over" and they don't, do you know something of their character.

Originally posted by darwa

 

Worst.

TERA. The rudeness, trolling, and immature behaviour caused me to drop my sub.

 

Agreed. The zone chat was some of the most racist, homophobic, xenophobic, idiotic dribble I've ever seen in a game. As in any game, there were some nice, helpful people roaming about, but the chat made it feel like a 6th grade school yard. A decent guild would be a must but I lost interest before trying. 

Originally posted by FredomSekerZ

It's the rebirth of this nearly 3 year old thread i never participated in: http://www.mmorpg.com/discussion2.cfm/thread/246625/page/1

So, to give more spice to the topic, because i have a feeling most of you will refernce EVE or LOTRO (and WOW), what are the 3 best and worst communities you're seen in mmos?

WARNING: Because i also know many of you will say the older mmorpgs like UO, EQ, DAOC, SWG, etc, i'm talking about the mmorpgs of today's time, being it AAA, indie, whatever, like Rift, SWTOR, FE, etc (probably the post-WOW mmos). I understand the older times might have been beter, but this is nowadays. Sorry

Bummer for you if you never played the older ones. My argument would be there isn't a single good game out there... /shrug, not one. Show me an online game made with passion and innovation and I'll retract that statement.

Originally posted by Morv

Show me an online game made with passion and innovation and I'll retract that statement.

The Secret World.

As for the OP...

Best: TSW, FFXIV, CO

Worst: WoW, FFXI (although I still played it for 4 years), and of course LoL (even though its not MMO)

Every MMO that comes out is going to have a crappy community, just a simple fact of large amounts of people and the anonymous nature of the internet.  Older games will in general have better communities, since the population is smaller, everyone on a particular server is more likely to know everyone else, and the average age of the players in games that are a decade or more old is likely to be 30s-40s, which generally will lead to more mature players.

DDO.

I pretty much only do pugs, and people tend to be very reasonable and even accepting of failure.

The Secret World seems to have the best community atm in my opinion, this has to do with how Funcom gets the community involved in activities. Guild Wars 2 started off with a really good community, but now it seems to be going the way of Wow's, I recall a thread was posted here awhile ago and the OP was asking a question about races and some GW2 people called him stupid.

Best:

GW1

GW2

LOTRO

Worst

World of Tanks

WoW

World of Tanks