| 30 posts found | |
|---|---|
|
10/31/09 6:23:50 AM#21
Originally posted by Dibdabs There are very, very few original plots, with some scholars saying there are only seven original plots throughout literature, so I wouldn't hold that against it. Even District 9 was preceded by Alien Nation, and as with all stories, it is the power of the storyteller that makes or breaks a tale. For those who are curious, one list of Original Plots cites: 1. Overcoming the Monster, 2. Rags to Riches, 3. The Quest, 4. Voyage and Return, 5. Comedy, 6. Tragedy, 7. Rebirth. Another list cites: [Wo]man vs. nature, Wo]man vs. man, Wo]man vs. the environment, Wo]man vs. machines/technology, Wo]man vs. the supernatural, Wo]man vs. self, Wo]man vs. god/religion. You'll find most of those in games and MMOs, too, as these themes seem very symbolic to we poor humans.
Agree with NotNiceDino It's not the same "tragedy" or "man vs the environment" as "guy falls in with non-white people, learns that non-white people are people too, then teams up with non-white people against evil white people". Watching that plot over and over again has become boring. Add to that the "man falls in love with cute savage girl" (ok she is blue this time).
And on another side, the awkward movements of CGI creatures and machines. |
|
|
Thrakk
Apprentice Member
Joined: 2/10/06
If you’re carrying nothing it won’t weigh you down |
10/31/09 11:57:58 AM#22
this looks like District 9 meets Ferngully Aliens/Abyss-style military adventure meets Furries
|
|
10/31/09 4:09:34 PM#23
Im excited...
|
|
|
10/31/09 9:27:41 PM#24
Originally posted by NotNiceDino
Not only does he fall in with them but it looks like he becomes a leader too. |
|
|
Theutus
Apprentice Member
Joined: 5/18/04
Achiever 33.33%, Explorer 73.33%, Killer 80.00%, Socializer 13.33% |
11/01/09 11:28:41 AM#25
|
|
11/01/09 2:42:35 PM#26
I think we are at a point were we can barely come up with anything new and creative anymore, its all been done in one way or another. I look around, read etc. and i always get that feeling that i have read or seen this before. All they can basically do is make things good enough to watch/read, i don't think we will see very many new creative ideas if any at all. That said, i can't wait to watch it, i'm not gonna compare it to anything i have seen before, i'm just gonna enjoy it for what it is and how its delivered. hopefully they don't screw it up lol. "The great thing about human language is that it prevents us from sticking to the matter at hand." |
|
|
11/01/09 7:44:15 PM#27
Originally posted by Dibdabs There are very, very few original plots, with some scholars saying there are only seven original plots throughout literature, so I wouldn't hold that against it. Even District 9 was preceded by Alien Nation, and as with all stories, it is the power of the storyteller that makes or breaks a tale. For those who are curious, one list of Original Plots cites: 1. Overcoming the Monster, 2. Rags to Riches, 3. The Quest, 4. Voyage and Return, 5. Comedy, 6. Tragedy, 7. Rebirth. Another list cites: [Wo]man vs. nature, Wo]man vs. man, Wo]man vs. the environment, Wo]man vs. machines/technology, Wo]man vs. the supernatural, Wo]man vs. self, Wo]man vs. god/religion. You'll find most of those in games and MMOs, too, as these themes seem very symbolic to we poor humans.
Looks like someone payed attention in high school literature. Seems a lot of you folks are basing way too much on a simple trailer. You get the idea of the plot, thats fine.. but you have no idea how the plot unfolds, develops and is finalized. Thats the entire purpose behind reading or watching a film. The creator hopes to leave his/her audience a little more educated then they were before they heard the story. The way in which its told is the trick, if it truely captivates the easier it is for the audience to understand its meaning. IE. I can tell you that the United States was settled by europeans, and in doing so they stole the homes of many native american indians. Until you read more of the details in how they were slaughtered, how new untreatable diseases were brought into their land and how they were forced out of the land that they were born you cannot begin to understand the cruelty of the whole situation. Thats why stories are told, to shed new light through a different perspective so people learn. |
|
|
11/02/09 4:20:40 AM#28
And not only that, isn't him being sued for plagiarism? Seems he can't even think of an overused plot by himself. Or the story is so cliche you can find clones everywhere. |
|
|
tvalentine
Advanced Member
Joined: 4/01/06
“The things you own end up owning you.” -Tyler Durden |
11/02/09 6:07:29 PM#29
it looks like a futuristic pocohantis movie. I'm not that excited about it. |
|
Rikimaru_X
Guru
Joined: 6/06/04
Facts about Riki: I'm a ninja & one of the sexiest guys on this damn site. |
11/04/09 6:28:28 PM#30
I agree with NoteNiceDino and Thrakk. The Dist 9 meets Ferngully nailed it. I'm quite suprised I remembered the big plot and everything of that movie. I forgot all about it. Yeah this is a plot that is over done, but I must say that the movie does look beautiful with a cast of very emotional characters...but yeah this looks like a disney movie in a way. -In memory of Laura "Taera" Genender. Passed away on Aug/13/08- |