| 29 posts found | |
|---|---|
|
To every haters that keep saying WoW copy Warhammer... I wonder where this Myrmidons come from. ;) Hope this help clarifying and end the so old retarded "WoW copy from Warhammer"
cheers |
|
|
5/29/09 8:05:35 AM#2
|
|
|
5/29/09 8:09:04 AM#3
It's a simple world for complicated people- Sonicbrew |
|
|
5/29/09 8:17:08 AM#4
Originally posted by Anthara
Well, as the others have shown, maybe YOU better learn where somethng comes from before using your incomplete and substantially flawed "facts" as proof. And Warcraft has always been a copy of Warhammer. Look up Warhammer, then look up Warcraft. Take note of the race designs, the artwork, ,etc.. Then take note of the dates of release for Warhammer and then Warcraft. Feel free to cry yourself to sleep afterwards. -Letting Derek Smart work on your game is like letting Osama bin Laden work in the White House. Something will burn.- |
|
|
5/29/09 8:18:49 AM#5
Originally posted by eyeswideopen
Well, as the others have shown, maybe YOU better learn where somethng comes from before using your incomplete and substantially flawed "facts" as proof. And Warcraft has always been a copy of Warhammer. Look up Warhammer, then look up Warcraft. Take note of the race designs, the artwork, ,etc.. Then take note of the dates of release for Warhammer and then Warcraft. Feel free to cry yourself to sleep afterwards.
And then start reading books about orcs and the like and don't make the same mistake the OP made ...
|
|
|
5/29/09 8:23:59 AM#6
i laughed so hard my sides hurt well done that chap lol |
|
|
5/29/09 8:26:25 AM#7
Originally posted by Pheace
And then start reading books about orcs and the like and don't make the same mistake the OP made ... Where did I say anything about the orcs themselves? I said the designs and artwork. As in the visual representations and the style used. Which are complete ripoffs of Wizard's of the Coasts' Warhammer by Blizzards' Warcraft. -Letting Derek Smart work on your game is like letting Osama bin Laden work in the White House. Something will burn.- |
|
|
5/29/09 8:30:52 AM#8
ill add my 2 here if were going by art work (and as an artist myself) i have to say that warhammers art far surpasses warcrafts warhammers art is raw gritty bloody dark fantastic i love it warcrafts yes its amazeing but for me its too light lots of soft colours that dont give you the feel of the darkness..there early art work was great almost on par with warhammer but not so much any more as to who copied who...dont care :P |
|
|
5/29/09 8:36:16 AM#9
Originally posted by eyeswideopen
And then start reading books about orcs and the like and don't make the same mistake the OP made ... Where did I say anything about the orcs themselves? I said the designs and artwork. As in the visual representations and the style used. Which are complete ripoffs of Wizard's of the Coasts' Warhammer by Blizzards' Warcraft.
You mean green and bulky with big fangs for teeth? ... I'm not saying they didn't copy Warhammer at some point, i know they had a legal squaffle (if that isn't a word it is now) over it but even then most o fthe graphics direction again comes from books and lore that existed before Warhammer as well. Still in that sense your remark was off the mark since he was talking about naming and you're talking about graphics :)
I do agree WoW copying WAR in that sense is a rather silly remark though ^^
Then again, i don't believe there's much relation at all if any anymore these days to the stuff you find in WoW and the stuff in WAR, both of them have evolved a *lot* since that time when they had that argument. If anything, you can probably say that graphically WoW has a lot of "copy" left over from Warhammer (not WAR naturally, check dates ;)). That said WAR has plenty of "copy" from WoW (Wow in itself being a copy from most other previous MMO's) in terms of MMO mechanics/gamedesign/UI design etc etc. A lot of complaining WAR took too much from WoW (in that sense).
(ow, just noticed you said warhammer and warcraft so disregard that last bit :p)
|
|
|
5/29/09 8:44:45 AM#10
Another stealing ideas thread.... |
|
|
5/29/09 8:50:51 AM#11
Originally posted by Pheace
You mean green and bulky with big fangs for teeth?
Again, I said art work and style. Green bulky and with big fangs is a general orc description, not the artistic style used to represent that description. Let's say someone said to you and me that they wanted an orc with the description of green, bulky, and with big fangs? Now what are the odds that your orc and my orc are going to be 99% identical in artistic style? -Letting Derek Smart work on your game is like letting Osama bin Laden work in the White House. Something will burn.- |
|
|
5/29/09 9:05:46 AM#12
warhammer and warcraft 1 where very similart but i think after the years Warcraft has evolved allot so they are not really rip of warhammer anymore.
|
|
|
5/29/09 9:08:28 AM#13
Originally posted by SgtFrog
Once a rip, always a rip. -Letting Derek Smart work on your game is like letting Osama bin Laden work in the White House. Something will burn.- |
|
|
Euphoryk
Apprentice Member
Joined: 4/30/09
"A man must live by his principles. Who he is, not what he is." |
5/29/09 11:58:03 AM#14
Originally posted by Anthara
/facepalm |
|
5/29/09 12:29:40 PM#15
Originally posted by Anthara
Maybe Im not following all the replys well but when i first seen this post this comes to mind: http://www.camelotherald.com/section.php?id=23 I am sure everyone here posting knows this info and that Dark Age is a product of Mythic. Perhaps Mythic/EA is having some simple fun with npc names. When I played WAR, i did notice a few little hints and easter eggs from DAoC. Not enough for my liking mind you , hence why i quit it. Anyway, scoll down the realm ranks and follow the red (Albion). Realm Rank 3 of Albion is called a "Myrmidon". Realm Rank 4 of Albion is called a "Gryphon Knight." Does anyone see a connection? Hope this helps. WoW vs WAR is old and silly. It has been posted and reposted over and over. Nuff already. |
|
|
5/31/09 10:24:29 AM#16
The "OMG teh warhammer copaeied WoW!1111" nonsense got old about 2 years prior to WAR's release. |
|
Originally posted by Euphoryk
/facepalm
I am sorry but dudes.... I didnt said anywhere that Myrmidons were Warcraft invention.... cause i never saw one myrmidon in WoW in 4 years. What I mean is that NEITHER one of them invented anything here. I JUST SAID WARHAMMER AINT ORIGINAL IN ANYTHING.... ZERO. Nada! /facepalm
resuming: Warhammer copy from an existing fantasy world but all other games copy from Warhammer and not the "source" like Warhammer did. THis sound retarded. note: probably the way i wrote made this confusion... but no.. I didnt want to say Myrmidons were WoW material. Maybe my shit english explained it wrong. |
|
|
Laughing-man
Elite Member
Joined: 4/23/09
I thought what I'd do is I'd pretend I was one of those Deaf-mutes. |
5/31/09 11:16:56 AM#18
Can't believe someone would make a thread without even bothering to google first. You saying there are no new ideas is also an old idea. http://ask.yahoo.com/20050407.html
"The story that's most often told is that in 1899 the head of the U.S. Patent Office sent his resignation to President McKinley urging the closing of the office because "everything that could be invented has been invented." It's been told and retold so often that even President Reagan used it in a speech. "
I'm sure many of you remember this story from your youth, people have been complaining that there are no new ideas for a long long time. Thinking of trying TERA? Check out my guild on Basilisk Crag! We're actively recruiting! www.proxytera.enjin.com/ |
Originally posted by Laughing-man
Dude... I've said it. Was probably bad english used.. YES I DID KNEW about Myrmidons, call me stupid or not, but i've checked google about it sicne I saw the Achiles Brad Pit crap. Whatever... In no place of my post i said WoW invented Myrmidons... stop throwing rocks at first sight when you read something
and to repeat myself again... War copy from the existing fantasys, legends, myths, history.. whatever... but all other games copy from War and not the same source. Is that clear now? THANKS |
|
|
Laughing-man
Elite Member
Joined: 4/23/09
I thought what I'd do is I'd pretend I was one of those Deaf-mutes. |
5/31/09 11:22:53 AM#20
Read the whole post please. Sorry had to edit it because of how you edited your previous post. Also, I wasn't trying to throw stones, or insult you, I was merely trying to point out that if you wanted to make a statement you should make the entire statement rather than only half of it. The way you phrased your origional post makes it seem like your saying Warcraft copied off Warhammer, which is just stupid. They both copied off a multitude of other things. Thinking of trying TERA? Check out my guild on Basilisk Crag! We're actively recruiting! www.proxytera.enjin.com/ |