The World just don't feel like a Warhammer World but a simple background.Mythic's vision of Warhammer is  a travesty of World of Warcraft...and Paul Barnett is very annoying as he looks like always overdoing things to sound interesting.

Making it. (@OP)

Mythic had a huge PvP/RvR rep from Daoc and practically destroyed that with WAR.

I picked Other because I feel the biggest misstake they made was to make the game too casual. No death penalty, no big penalty for losing a keep or even your city. All made this way to cater to the casuals who doesnt want to put effort in gaming and basically want everything handed to them.

If they just made some more hardcore servers with somewhat higher penalties and bigger penalties for losing a zone or your city I think more people would play the game. Right now the game is fun but after a while you just feel like you are at a themepark and there is no real incentive to fight for anything.

Originally posted by Yamota

All made this way to cater to the casuals who doesnt want to put effort in gaming and basically want everything handed to them.

While this game can be played casual I will have to step in an defend the casual player here. The casual player simply does not have time to play a lot. This however does not mean they do not WANT to put an effort into the game or want everything handed to them. Infact pretty sure many casual player prefer to spend more time in the game and less on there work.

i am still suprised that it took them a month after to release to even implement region chat (before each region sub zone that their own chat so there would 10+ chat channel you can switch while traversing a single map/region). It killed player comm, i remember saying to myself i never played MMO in OB that was this quiet.

They completly forgot player interaction even cities felt like dead zones primarily cause there is no real reason to hang around in there till 30s since you could only queue scenarios from you own tier GG.

---

Originally posted by Lobotomist
scenarios
 

---

Originally posted by Raztor

 It's a long list of mistakes. Also include Paul Barnet in it, hype hype and more hype and no substance.

 / Agreed

 Took another month and... stopped 5 days after. Played War from 19.02 to 24.02, can't play anymore. Pve is boring, RvRE is not RVR, RVRE is repetitive. Most boring game played, worst than Wow. War is a cheap paste copy of Wow. Full of bugs... 

 - Mythic's biggest mistake with WAR??:

> war is a wow clone

Reason why i quit this game is because they released too many servers at launch.   They basicly spread the population all over the place leaving a FEW over populated realms and the rest of them UNDER populated.

Since i was coming from WOW, i was not interested in having to queue up to play on a descent population server, so i just quit cause all the servers i tried days after launch were ALL already ghost towns.

Originally posted by Aguitha

Reason why i quit this game is because they released too many servers at launch.   They basicly spread the population all over the place leaving a FEW over populated realms and the rest of them UNDER populated.

Since i was coming from WOW, i was not interested in having to queue up to play on a descent population server, so i just quit cause all the servers i tried days after launch were ALL already ghost towns.

i have not seen any queues when i was there a month ago, i think queue are actually good since it makes player base more appreciate their playing time. It beats me why they paniced listening to the player base and cloned more servers during launch week.

Don't want to sound too much like DAOC 2....but I think a third side would have vastly improved the RvR

I was looking forward to this game since they announced it so you can only imagine what lead me to actually post this response

1. It still feels like beta with all the bugs

2. Clunky/Non responsive game play STILL happening

3. The world doesn't feel like a world

4. Screwed up Mob pathing STILL happening

5. Over hype/leading us on(I fell for this, but never again)

6. Too many servers/Not merging servers before it got out of hand.

7. Making terrible decisions and adding things to the game rather then fix what was wrong.

I've had to transfer servers and now I'm stuck a low pop one because they won't let me transfer anymore.

Originally posted by BruceYee

I was looking forward to this game since they announced it so you can only imagine what lead me to actually post this response

1. It still feels like beta with all the bugs

2. Clunky/Non responsive game play STILL happening

3. The world doesn't feel like a world

4. Screwed up Mob pathing STILL happening

5. Over hype/leading us on(I fell for this, but never again)

6. Too many servers/Not merging servers before it got out of hand.

7. Making terrible decisions and adding things to the game rather then fix what was wrong.

I've had to transfer servers and now I'm stuck a low pop one because they won't let me transfer anymore.

 

I agree! EA should fire MJ and or Mythic period.......

He is an idiot.

 The world feels disjointed and not like a world at all, just a series of small "levels". However, their biggest problem was itemizing things that had no business being itemized, and playing the "gear set" game ala WoW. Keeps should NEVER have been directly itemized. Realm rewards, sure. Wargear? Fine. Awarding loot for "raiding" a keep directly was the stupidest decision ever and trivialized the whole war.  There is also no reason why you should have to have a specific "tier" of armor to do dungeons. 

Oh, and scenarios. Let us never ever forget scenarios.

Originally posted by Kordesh

 The world feels disjointed and not like a world at all, just a series of small "levels". However, their biggest problem was itemizing things that had no business being itemized, and playing the "gear set" game ala WoW. Keeps should NEVER have been directly itemized. Realm rewards, sure. Wargear? Fine. Awarding loot for "raiding" a keep directly was the stupidest decision ever and trivialized the whole war.  There is also no reason why you should have to have a specific "tier" of armor to do dungeons. 

Oh, and scenarios. Let us never ever forget scenarios.

What about MJ's crafting system he is so proud of.

Crafting(trades) in this game is a F'N joke.

That should be a top priority in a large big budget MMO.

What a disgrace to the MMO world this crap has been.

I bet 1 year from now only 38k at best will still be playing .

I voted "Balance Issues", that said I played apart of the CB and loved my WH from day one.

That said it got dumbed down so much that the friggin priest had more zeal to them

The came the Retail launch, another culling of WH features, buffing other destructo classes, and then at patch v1.03 my character got corrupted. The stats (Strength, Weapon Skill, etc.) wouldn't apply to the character no matter what I did. After waiting 3 months for them to patch it or give me an excuse why, I've left.

I tried EA support as well, seven emails later the only piece of decent attempt at seeing what the problem was, the claimant said, "Check your minimum system requirements". WTF

I didn't give up there, I went back and leveled a WP to 32, and when they released them the KoBS with him reaching 25 while I waited, yearning to return to my WH. Eventually I ticked over that last rank to 40 and well, STILL BROKEN.

So after spending a year and a half of my life expecting a reasonable MMO, I leave the game with my guildmates (82 at our peak and an alliance of 300'ish) already jumping ship.

In the end I sold all my Mythic gear and stood in the middle of Altdorf and gave away our guild to the first person who wanted it. I shook my head as I tried to change the Guild Leader to the person, it wouldn't let me.

For a community based PvP game there is alot to be said for the Designer of War, well I can sum it up in one word but cannot resist using a term first, "YOUR FIRED" and that word, BANG.....you're dead

I think all of the above mentioned points made Warhammer fail. This game is going down the drain.

Most of you sound like sore losers...

I won't bother with respond or correcting alot of the dum stuff that has been said... too much trouble.