Network Sites: FPSguru.com RTSguru.com UnboundGamer.com
Login:  Password:   Remember?  
Show Quick Gamelist Jump to Random Game
Games:611  Guilds:3,079
Members:1,593,353  Online:0
Guests:0  Posts:4,846,683
Recent forum postsRSS
Active threads
Cloud view
List all forums
General Forums
Developers Corner General Discussion
Popular Game Forums
Click a status to find game forum
Game Forums
Click a letter to find game forum
D-F
D&D Online DC Universe DOTA DOTA 2 DUST 514 Dance Groove Online Dark Age of Camelot Dark Ages Dark Legends Dark Orbit Dark Solstice Dark and Light DarkEden Online DarkSpace Darkblood Online Darkfall Darkwind: War on Wheels Dawn of Fantasy Dawntide Dead Earth Dead Frontier Deco Online Defiance Deicide Online Dekaron Desert Operations Diablo 3 Diamonin Digimon Battle Dino Storm Disciple Divergence Divina Divine Souls Dofus Dominus Online Dragon Ball Online Dragon Born Online Dragon Crusade Dragon Empires Dragon Eternity Dragon Nest Dragon Oath Dragon Raja Dragon's Call Dragon's Prophet DragonSky DragonSoul Dragona Dragonica Dream of Mirror Online Dreamland Online Dreamlords: The Reawakening Drift City Duels Dungeon Blitz Dungeon Fighter Online Dungeon Overlord Dungeon Party Dungeon Runners Dynastica Dynasty Warriors Online EIN (Epicus Incognitus) EVE Online Earth Eternal Earth and Beyond Earthrise Eden Eternal Einherjar - The Viking's Blood Elf Online Embers of Caerus Emil Chronicle Online Empire & State Empire Craft EmpireQuest Empires of Galldon End of Nations Endless Ages Endless Online Entropia Universe EpicDuel Erebus: Travia Reborn Eredan Eternal Blade Eternal Lands Ether Fields Ether Saga Online Eudemons Online EuroGangster EverQuest Online Adventures Evernight Everquest Everquest II Evony Exarch Exorace Face of Mankind Fairyland Online Fall of Rome Fallen Earth Fallen Sword Fallout Online Family Guy Online Fantage Fantasy Earth Zero Fantasy Realm Online Fantasy Tales Online Fantasy Worlds: Rhynn Faunasphere Faxion Online Ferentus Ferion Fiesta Online Final Fantasy XI Final Fantasy XIV Firefall Fists of Fu Florensia Flyff Football Manager Live Football Superstars Force of Arms Forsaken World Freaky Creatures Free Realms Freesky Online Freeworld Fung Wan Online Furcadia Fury Fusion Fall
G-L
GalaXseeds Galactic Command Online Game of Thrones Gate To Heavens Gates of Andaron Gatheryn Gekkeiju Online Ghost Online Ghost Recon Online Gladiatus Glitch Global Agenda Global Soccer GoGoRacer Goal Line Blitz Gods and Heroes GodsWar Online Golemizer Golf Star GoonZu Online Graal Kingdoms Grand Chase Europe Grand Fantasia Grepolis Grimlands Guild Wars Guild Wars 2 Guild Wars Factions Guild Wars Nightfall Habbo Hotel Haven & Hearth Hedone Helbreath Hellgate Hellgate: London Hello Kitty Online Hero 108: Online Hero Online Hero's Journey HeroSmash Heroes in the Sky Heroes of Bestia Heroes of Gaia Heroes of Might and Magic Online Heroes of Thessalonica Heroes of Three Kingdoms Holic Online Hostile Space Huxley Illutia Illyriad Immortals USA Imperator Imperian Infinity Infinity Iris Online Irth Worlds Island Forge Islands of War Istaria: Chronicles of the Gifted Jade Dynasty Jagged Alliance Online Juggernaut Jumpgate Jumpgate Evolution KAL Online Kakele Online Kaos War Karos Online Kicks Online King of Kings 3 Kingdom Heroes Kingdom of Drakkar Kingory Kitsu Saga Kiwarriors Knight Online Knights of Dream City Kothuria Kung Foo! Kunlun Online L.A.W. LEGO Universe La Tale Land of Chaos Online Lands of Hope: Phoenix Edition LastChaos League of Legends - Clash of Fates Legend of Golden Plume Legend of Katha Legend of Mir 3 Legendary Champions Light of Nova Lime Odyssey Line of Defense Lineage Lineage Eternal: Twilight Resistance Lineage II Linkrealms Loong Online Lord of the Rings Online Lords Online Lost Saga Lucent Heart Lunia Lusternia: Age of Ascension Luvinia Online
T-Z
TERA TS Online Tabula Rasa Tactica Online Tales Runner Tales of Fantasy Tales of Pirates Tales of Pirates II Talisman Online Tamer Saga Tank Ace Tantra Online Tatsumaki: Land at War Terra Militaris Terra World Thang Online The 4th Coming The Agency The Chronicle The Chronicles of Spellborn The Elder Scrolls Online The Legend of Ares The Matrix Online The Missing Ink The Mummy Online The Myth of Soma The Pride of Taern The Realm Online The Repopulation The Secret World The Sims Online The Strategems There Thrones of Chaos Tibia Tibia Micro Edition Toontown Online Top Speed Torchlight Transformers Universe Traveller AR Travia Online Travian Trials of Ascension Tribal Hero Tribal Wars Tribes Universe Trickster Online Troy Online True Fantasy Live Online Turf Battles Twelve Sky Twelve Sky 2 Twilight War U.B. Funkeys UFO Online Ultima Online Ultima X: Odyssey Ultimate Soccer Boss Uncharted Waters Online Undercover 2: Merc Wars Underlight Unification Wars Universe Online Valkyrie Sky Vanguard: Saga of Heroes Vanquish Space Vector City Racers Vendetta Online Victory - Age of Racing Vindictus Virtonomics Vis Gladius Visions of Zosimos Voyage Century W.E.L.L. Online WAR (Warhammer Online) WYD Global Wakfu War Rock War of 2012 War of Angels War of Legends War of Thrones War of the Immortals WarFlow Waren Story Wargame1942 Warhammer 40K: Dark Millennium Online Warhammer Online: Wrath of Heroes Warrior Epic WebLords Wild West Online WildStar WindSlayer 2 Wish Wizard 101 Wizards and Champions Wonder King Wonderland Online World Golf Tour World War II Online World of Battles World of Darkness World of Heroes World of Kung Fu World of Pirates World of Tanks World of Warcraft World of Warcraft: Mists of Pandaria World of the Living Dead WorldAlpha Wurm Online Xiah Xsyon YS Online ZU Online Zentia Zero Online Zero Online: The Andromeda Crisis Zodiac Online eRepublik

MMORPG.com Discussion Forums

Lord of the Rings Online

Lord of the Rings Online 

General Discussion  » First impression of LOTR: terrible...

4 Pages « 1 2 3 4 » Search
69 posts found
  Vynt

Hard Core Member

Joined: 9/19/04
Posts: 447

11/24/08 11:26:14 AM#41

I didn't like the game in beta either, tried it later and really enjoyed it. I'm not playing atm since I am busy with other things. I found the graphics pretty good, although the char models are a bit bleh. They did look better than the pics posted though.

My only complaint really about the game was the melee. The way the cooldowns and skills were set up mechanically made it feel a little sluggish to me.

  reborngamer

Novice Member

Joined: 11/23/08
Posts: 9

 
11/24/08 11:48:56 AM#42
Originally posted by gestalt11

Come on this is just silly.

 

Yeah sure LOTRO models are a bit stiff and the hair graphics are crappy.  The rest of the game is one of the best looking MMOs around.

 

Trying to say that two minor flaws make the art/graphics complete trash is beyond hyperbole.  It just makes people role their eyes.  Pointing to a face that you probably never even looking at I mean come on. 

 

And the models and animation are NOT worse than VG.  Gimme a break. 

 

It amazes me how many people try to write a review, nitpick a small army of things and then say a whole game sucks without ever commenting or analyzing the important aspects of the game.  These people are usually immediate obvious as they show no blance in their perspective.  They decided not to like something, throw tantrum and like anyone throwing a tantrum they lash out at everything they think seems weak and then explode out to a completely overly dramatic conclusion that is obviously silly in the face of something that has strong features.

 

Of course the flip side of that is that its amazing how many people ignore major problems in design in games and act like its the players such as what goes in with WAR right now.

 

The graphics are not a game breaker for me but boring and none-engaging gameplay is. I never once said Vanguard had better animations and characters. In fact I think they had some of the worst character models of recent mmo's, the whole game was a disaster at launch but was clearly rushed. I can't speak for it now since I haven't gone back since.

I have to wonder how many MMO's some here have played. I'll use EQ2 as an example again because I think it outshines LOTR in almost every aspect unless you have some sort of nostalgic attachment to LOTR lore(which is fine).

I suppose seeing how this is a newer mmorpg I thought perhaps it might be on par or better.

There are clearly folks(like yourself) who enjoy LOTR and thats fine. I am not trying to say you should hate the game and stop playing. Keep playing and I'll keep looking. Its all just my opinion, don't attack me because you dont agree. Lets keep it chill.

 

 

  sebbonx

Novice Member

Joined: 12/21/05
Posts: 332

11/24/08 12:33:39 PM#43

You actually like that turd EQ1? Obviously LotRO is not for you or those who pine for Vanguard and its ilk. Stupidly sitting there and killing the same mobs over and over is EQ1, you aren't ready for LotRO or WoW obviously. You probably played a Dr00d in EQ or some pet caster, that I easily "AFK" leveled! Heck all these EQ1 nerds claim how "hard" the game is, then played a class that any idiot could get to high level with junk on!  

Now for your next laugh target: BLITZBERG Tunare Warrior-636 days 1 hour 1 minute played!

That is the idiocy of EQ1, lifeless raiders, I so love being away from them!

If you have any questions please ask. I have moved on to WoW from eq and no longer have any desire to play a dead game. Thank you. (posted by another selling his account in EQ1)

  AckbarNL

Novice Member

Joined: 11/20/04
Posts: 460

"its a trap!"

11/24/08 12:35:14 PM#44

EQ2 can be a fine game nowdays afther a few years, but i realy did not like EQ2 when it lanched, and thats a gamebreaker for me sadly, nothing aiganst the people who play it nowdays, it probbly much updated now.

Playing: Lord of the Rings Online.
Played: World of Warcraft, Starwars Galaxies.
Tried: Everquest 2, Guild Wars, Vanguard, Age of Conan, Aion.

  Hugolin

Novice Member

Joined: 9/06/07
Posts: 44

11/24/08 2:54:42 PM#45

this game offer something that other games dont...and that is tolkien world...so...if u wanna play a game of lord of the rings...well...here u go

and if not...go play other game...that simple...this is not a special game...is the same pattern as wow, war, etc etc...but...is tolkien men...that enought for me

  User Deleted
11/24/08 3:13:22 PM#46

 


Originally posted by reborngamer
Maybe this game isn't for me, or maybe I am missing something here...

 

MMO players are a subset of society in general. No everyone likes fine wine or reading a well written book.

Feel free to go back to your Budweiser and comic books (ie. WoW). :D

 

Oh and anyone who thinkgs LOTRO has terrible graphics just doesn't have the rig to run it....which is about a $1000 machine these days.   It's absolutely stunning cranked up.

  reborngamer

Novice Member

Joined: 11/23/08
Posts: 9

 
11/24/08 5:08:11 PM#47
Originally posted by Thradar

 


Originally posted by reborngamer
Maybe this game isn't for me, or maybe I am missing something here...

 

MMO players are a subset of society in general. No everyone likes fine wine or reading a well written book.

Feel free to go back to your Budweiser and comic books (ie. WoW). :D

 

Oh and anyone who thinkgs LOTRO has terrible graphics just doesn't have the rig to run it....which is about a $1000 machine these days.   It's absolutely stunning cranked up.

 

Your bird intelligence is showing. Read the post next time before commenting.

  aleos

Novice Member

Joined: 1/02/07
Posts: 1676

I will rip your world apart.

11/24/08 5:11:04 PM#48
Originally posted by reborngamer

I played LOTR for the first time when it was still in beta. My first impression of beta was "complete trash". Of course the game was in beta, but I was not impressed to purchase it on initial release.


Now here we are with a brand new expansion. I got a little desperate looking for a game to play, I haven't played an mmorpg since the disappointment that we all know of as Vanguard. Thought about WAR, read the forums and saw a lot of negative posts so decided to pass, then I thought about age of conan, same result. I had previously played, UO, EQ, Lineage2, AO, EQ2, Vanguard, SWG(first few months of release, one of the best mmorpg experiences ever...), Guild Wars, DAOC and a tiny bit of WOW(wasn't for me). Out of those I enjoyed EQ2, SWG and the original EQ the most.


Anyway, back to the point. I came to the LOTR forums (i knew the new expo just released) and even though I wasn't impressed initially I decided based on the forum feedback here that the game was decent and worth a try. I went of and bought the complete edition pack, I was impressed with the price of only $39(CND) for both original and expansion. Rushed home to install it and just as soon as the install was complete the disappointment kicked in.


First, the graphics... I have high end system so I maxed everything out and yes the game ran smoothly but the graphics are POOR, even maxed out. The animations are completely terrible. Characters are just not what I expected from a newer MMORPG. Its probably near the bottom of the barrel from every single game I played if you consider the time of release as a factor. The only thing I liked about the graphics where the shadows from the trees... but this was hardly enough and completely offset by the rest of the game.


The battle animations felt awkward at best and the beginning spell/combat effects left A LOT to be desired. The very first few NPCs I interacted with had maybe what felt like 3 polygons for a face with a terribly mapped texture to match.


I did manage to create a character I liked. There was enough customization options for hair, beard and the face that you will likely find a reasonable end result. However, after completing a few quests and getting new armour I found myself wearing orange "leather" armour and green pants, with some brown coloured shoulder pads... It was a complete disaster and broke immersion immediately.
I understand graphics aren't a big indicator of quality and we can easily point to graphically advanced games that failed (vanguard comes to mind) but the rest of my first few hours (and probably last) did little to convince me to continue playing.


The interface is the worst I have seen of any game. It just looks ugly, the mini map is not very friendly and all the menus seemed off putting. The quest log is acceptable but I definitely found it difficult finding locations of my next quest and I don't mind exploring but when the quest is kill "x number of monsters" then the last thing I want to do is spend 15 minutes trying to find the location for a boring generic quest.
Game play wise it just did not seem fun. It’s your typical hit your 1, 2,3 ,4 till enemy dies with absolutely nothing there to spice things up. Usually I would be fine with this if it was at least fast paced but it wasn't. It was slow.


Sounds/Music are mediocre. The music didn't draw me in, didn't add to any form of immersion. The combat sounds are sometimes too echoey... sounds like your in an empty underground tunnel with some of the skills I was using. The NPCs only have partial voice overs, and I suppose it’s better than none at all but if you even played EQ2 for 5 minutes and then played this you would quickly know what difference better voice overs can make.


After a few hours I just felt bored and was forcing myself to play longer to hopefully uncover some hidden qualities that I missed initially. Quickly I realized I can't force myself to play this any longer, at least not in one sitting. Felt inclined to warn new comers that may have played some of the games I have that are just looking for a new game. The whole first impression experience can be summed up into one word "terrible".


Again, this is a FIRST impression. Don't flame me for not playing this longer and giving it more of a chance. I have the whole month left so I will log at least a few more hours in and try a few other starter areas at the very least.


Maybe this game isn't for me, or maybe I am missing something here...

 


 

And what was the first MMO you ever played?

Ten people who speak make more noise than ten thousand who are silent.

  User Deleted
11/24/08 7:05:18 PM#49

For the love of pete let this thread die.  Personally i like the graphics of LOTRO but then again im not trying to bait players of the game.

  Elikal

Spotlight Poster

Joined: 2/09/06
Posts: 6155

11/24/08 7:13:13 PM#50
Originally posted by reborngamer

I played LOTR for the first time when it was still in beta. My first impression of beta was "complete trash". Of course the game was in beta, but I was not impressed to purchase it on initial release.


Now here we are with a brand new expansion. I got a little desperate looking for a game to play, I haven't played an mmorpg since the disappointment that we all know of as Vanguard. Thought about WAR, read the forums and saw a lot of negative posts so decided to pass, then I thought about age of conan, same result. I had previously played, UO, EQ, Lineage2, AO, EQ2, Vanguard, SWG(first few months of release, one of the best mmorpg experiences ever...), Guild Wars, DAOC and a tiny bit of WOW(wasn't for me). Out of those I enjoyed EQ2, SWG and the original EQ the most.


Anyway, back to the point. I came to the LOTR forums (i knew the new expo just released) and even though I wasn't impressed initially I decided based on the forum feedback here that the game was decent and worth a try. I went of and bought the complete edition pack, I was impressed with the price of only $39(CND) for both original and expansion. Rushed home to install it and just as soon as the install was complete the disappointment kicked in.


First, the graphics... I have high end system so I maxed everything out and yes the game ran smoothly but the graphics are POOR, even maxed out. The animations are completely terrible. Characters are just not what I expected from a newer MMORPG. Its probably near the bottom of the barrel from every single game I played if you consider the time of release as a factor. The only thing I liked about the graphics where the shadows from the trees... but this was hardly enough and completely offset by the rest of the game.


The battle animations felt awkward at best and the beginning spell/combat effects left A LOT to be desired. The very first few NPCs I interacted with had maybe what felt like 3 polygons for a face with a terribly mapped texture to match.


I did manage to create a character I liked. There was enough customization options for hair, beard and the face that you will likely find a reasonable end result. However, after completing a few quests and getting new armour I found myself wearing orange "leather" armour and green pants, with some brown coloured shoulder pads... It was a complete disaster and broke immersion immediately.
I understand graphics aren't a big indicator of quality and we can easily point to graphically advanced games that failed (vanguard comes to mind) but the rest of my first few hours (and probably last) did little to convince me to continue playing.


The interface is the worst I have seen of any game. It just looks ugly, the mini map is not very friendly and all the menus seemed off putting. The quest log is acceptable but I definitely found it difficult finding locations of my next quest and I don't mind exploring but when the quest is kill "x number of monsters" then the last thing I want to do is spend 15 minutes trying to find the location for a boring generic quest.
Game play wise it just did not seem fun. It’s your typical hit your 1, 2,3 ,4 till enemy dies with absolutely nothing there to spice things up. Usually I would be fine with this if it was at least fast paced but it wasn't. It was slow.


Sounds/Music are mediocre. The music didn't draw me in, didn't add to any form of immersion. The combat sounds are sometimes too echoey... sounds like your in an empty underground tunnel with some of the skills I was using. The NPCs only have partial voice overs, and I suppose it’s better than none at all but if you even played EQ2 for 5 minutes and then played this you would quickly know what difference better voice overs can make.


After a few hours I just felt bored and was forcing myself to play longer to hopefully uncover some hidden qualities that I missed initially. Quickly I realized I can't force myself to play this any longer, at least not in one sitting. Felt inclined to warn new comers that may have played some of the games I have that are just looking for a new game. The whole first impression experience can be summed up into one word "terrible".


Again, this is a FIRST impression. Don't flame me for not playing this longer and giving it more of a chance. I have the whole month left so I will log at least a few more hours in and try a few other starter areas at the very least.


Maybe this game isn't for me, or maybe I am missing something here...

 

 

 I certainly wont flame you. ;)  But I disagree. Partially. Yes, the characters dont look very inspiring, but then, in most MMOs these days it doesnt. At least to me. One of the very few decend character generators in terms of look is still SWG, after all those years.
 

As to the gear: you have TWO entire free setups for appearance gear. (Dunno how its called in the English version.) So its easy to make something up to match the colours.

Personally I still find the landscape fantastic. Its second only to the gorgeous landscape of AoC, and the LOTRO world feels much larger and deeper than that of AoC. The flowers in the wind, the rivers, the forests... never seen a game world so rich with atmosphere.

The greatest bonus however is story. Thats what sets apart LOTRO from the other Fedex-Games. Sure it also has the "fetch me 20 of this" part, but if you follow the Books, and many of the small stories, you get such a big, rich carpet of stories and tales, its just epic! I just finished Book 12 today, I dont spoil, but the last two books were really epic tales my character was involved. It wasnt a story merely told by some NPC in a mute chat box, it actually HAPPEND around me! I havent seen anything like that in ANY MMO, and when I put my trust in SWTOR I hope they take this kind of story-events to the next level based on this. Its what gives my character in LOTRO meaning, purpose, as opposed to the borefests most other MMOs are.

LOTRO is far from being perfect, but as I see it from the newer MMOs its by and large the best one.

  Gajari

Elite Member

Joined: 4/18/06
Posts: 918

11/24/08 7:25:14 PM#51

LotRO has beautiful graphics. The landscapes are wonderful, though as others have said, the characters themselves not so much - not that they're terrible or anything, just not as great.

My main problem is that the gameplay is fun for a short while, but then it quickly becomes boring. Also, after the starting area, the amount of quests to be done is overwhelming. I would rather them lower the amount of quests and raise the xp rewarded from each, because it turns me off completely. WoW has a lot of quests, but they're spread out, and there aren't WAY too many in each area - and when you're in the area, for the most part, it doesn't keep running you around everywhere, it'll usually make you complete quests in an area, then move along to another, which I like.

I'd say if the combat was enhanced a bit more, and the quests were fewer, but of higher quality, this game would be better.

The epic storyline quests are too few and far between. My only draw to keep playing is to play through these instances, and that's just not enough.

  jedensuscg

Novice Member

Joined: 1/18/06
Posts: 117

11/24/08 8:57:52 PM#52

 First, im guess that you made a dwarf as your first character? maybe maybe not. If not a dwarf then a human, the only two that can have beards...if you made a dward then ya, the dwarf starting area is kinda lame in terms of graphics..but wait until you get to the northern shire, or any other forested area with crystal clear waters that make you want to jump in and feel the coolness of them...they ARE stunning. the best damn water ever in a game i have personally played.and while that might seem a small thing just talking about water, it so draws your attention that you dont care about anything else.  Then again look up at the sky, its amazing also, and when it rains, clouds actually cover it.  I dont know what your setting are at, but this game is amazing is in quality...maybe not as good as some other high high end games, but its pretty where it counts without adding a crap load of poly-counts just to say they did, and in the end doing nothing but limiting the user base that can play it.

 

Enough of that, the combat animations do take a but ot get used to, but its not because of any error or faults, but its built that way.  Turbine uses an interesting combat system in terms of timings of attacks, special moves etc that after a while you forget about how it looks as you get used to it.  The only problem is Turbine is pretty hush hush about how their system truly works, making even sites like lotro-wiki (their version of WoW wiki) to guess alot at how numbers are figured and such....but this mean that instead of reading the perfect way to do somthing becuase all the math is right their before you, you have to figure out on your own what works best for you.

 

As for the cloth colors..yes they do suck at low levels..BUT this makes the better lookign gear(or outfits yo get when you have a lvl 20 character) even cooler.   And the community of this game is VERY mature..so no, i have yet so see pink dwarfs myself, and as a general rule of thumb(even though it has gotten worse since the moria release) you wont find many characters with lame names, running around naked or in pink clothes.  On a scale of 1-10 of maturnes, this is a 8 or 9 with WoW being a -232123, and the original EQ being about a 6 or 7.(its all server dependent too, Landrocal is the unofficial RP server and has awseome community ran events all the time...the player music syste m is just TOOO fun.)

 

On the UI. Ya at first is different, but whats not.  But you can download custom UI's that change teh appearance of your UI, but sadly that is it.  No mass customization that adds new functions or anything, but using the ctrl+\ feature you can drag any bar anywhere you want...alas, the resize function does BLOW.  The mini map...well there is a compass, the top is north, always and your character icon moves inside of it, rather then wow where you have the option to make it rotate with you.

 

As for the quests, this is my opinion on of the best games in terms of quests out their.  Ya sure they are kinda generic, but they encompass a story that is more rich then any game out theire..  and if you have ever read the books its surprisingly fun to encounter familiar places and peoples, while solving problems that at times jump right out of the book.  Also the epic quest line is a plus, as you find your self tfilling in between the lines of the book as the Fellowship travels.  You know they got someone and somepeopel followed them, but this game allows you to play a hidden role where you feel you have actually helped them.

I guess this game is not for everyone.  I came from WoW after playing since beta, and at times I do miss WoW for its ease of brainpower to play, easy dynamics, but I can never go back to the immature, rowdy chats, and Blizzard constant destroying of an originally great PvE game in favor of an unbalanced, unimaginitive PvP game.  LOTRO is that great PvE game that takes a bit to get used to, in fact i played in beta and played teh free trial TWICE, but the fourth time I allowed myself to dwelve further into the game and level, and found it completely enjoyable.

  gestalt11

Hard Core Member

Joined: 5/17/06
Posts: 5300

11/24/08 11:46:47 PM#53
Originally posted by reborngamer
Originally posted by gestalt11

Come on this is just silly.

 

Yeah sure LOTRO models are a bit stiff and the hair graphics are crappy.  The rest of the game is one of the best looking MMOs around.

 

Trying to say that two minor flaws make the art/graphics complete trash is beyond hyperbole.  It just makes people role their eyes.  Pointing to a face that you probably never even looking at I mean come on. 

 

And the models and animation are NOT worse than VG.  Gimme a break. 

 

It amazes me how many people try to write a review, nitpick a small army of things and then say a whole game sucks without ever commenting or analyzing the important aspects of the game.  These people are usually immediate obvious as they show no blance in their perspective.  They decided not to like something, throw tantrum and like anyone throwing a tantrum they lash out at everything they think seems weak and then explode out to a completely overly dramatic conclusion that is obviously silly in the face of something that has strong features.

 

Of course the flip side of that is that its amazing how many people ignore major problems in design in games and act like its the players such as what goes in with WAR right now.

 

The graphics are not a game breaker for me but boring and none-engaging gameplay is. I never once said Vanguard had better animations and characters. In fact I think they had some of the worst character models of recent mmo's, the whole game was a disaster at launch but was clearly rushed. I can't speak for it now since I haven't gone back since.

I have to wonder how many MMO's some here have played. I'll use EQ2 as an example again because I think it outshines LOTR in almost every aspect unless you have some sort of nostalgic attachment to LOTR lore(which is fine).

I suppose seeing how this is a newer mmorpg I thought perhaps it might be on par or better.

There are clearly folks(like yourself) who enjoy LOTR and thats fine. I am not trying to say you should hate the game and stop playing. Keep playing and I'll keep looking. Its all just my opinion, don't attack me because you dont agree. Lets keep it chill.

 

 

 

I have played EQ2.  In fact I have said in previous posts on this forum that I thought when it comes down to features EQ2 is a better game than WoW.

 

Other than the guild features I do not see how EQ2 is better than LOTRO and in terms of looks and animations LOTRO is clearly better.

 

Anyone who likes EQ2 alot and says LOTRO is a terrible game needs to do some serious rethinking  IMO.  The games are not that different.  The gameplay is quite similar.

 

Pine for the AA system of EQ2 or whatever other features that are richer.  Doesn't matter because the OP is is not realistic; end of story.  

 

Has nothing to do with valid or invalid criticism taking minor things and minor differences and condemning something as awful is so wildly bi-polar as to be meaningless.

  PSXfile

Novice Member

Joined: 5/18/04
Posts: 30

11/25/08 12:36:02 AM#54

You state you weren't impressed in beta so you obviously went into his with a closed mind.  The graphics and music in this game are gorgeous.  In fact, I often listen to the soundtrack.   I'm not sure what computer you're trying to run this on, but mine look like this.  This is on High without DX10.

  Mentor73

Novice Member

Joined: 5/20/08
Posts: 109

11/25/08 3:21:31 AM#55
Originally posted by Trainedmonky
Originally posted by Mentor73

Trainedmonkey ... nah, you are in wrong topic. This is not Guild Wars ;).

More fun with kinship. But even pugs are not so bad.

 


 

guess i should have pointed out the bad AI, bad mob pathing, and weak endgame raiding in hele and the rift...it's just to easy nothing epic about a boss that gets bugged out because turbine is busy trying to make that boss anti-hardcore (here you go carebear you can do it too!)

 

Dont tell me you beat Rift and Helegrod on your first try. Or CD. And yet whats that got to do with solo grinding you mentioned. Did you even join a kinship?

But as in every mmorpg every instance eventually gets farming status. Even in Moria in few months.

But then again, why did you get lifetime sub for game you don't like, for me thats  .

Enjoy FFXI.

  alakram

Apprentice Member

Joined: 11/02/06
Posts: 1997

11/25/08 3:30:16 AM#56
Originally posted by reborngamer

I played LOTR for the first time when it was still in beta. My first impression of beta was "complete trash". Of course the game was in beta, but I was not impressed to purchase it on initial release.


Now here we are with a brand new expansion. I got a little desperate looking for a game to play, I haven't played an mmorpg since the disappointment that we all know of as Vanguard. Thought about WAR, read the forums and saw a lot of negative posts so decided to pass, then I thought about age of conan, same result. I had previously played, UO, EQ, Lineage2, AO, EQ2, Vanguard, SWG(first few months of release, one of the best mmorpg experiences ever...), Guild Wars, DAOC and a tiny bit of WOW(wasn't for me). Out of those I enjoyed EQ2, SWG and the original EQ the most.


Anyway, back to the point. I came to the LOTR forums (i knew the new expo just released) and even though I wasn't impressed initially I decided based on the forum feedback here that the game was decent and worth a try. I went of and bought the complete edition pack, I was impressed with the price of only $39(CND) for both original and expansion. Rushed home to install it and just as soon as the install was complete the disappointment kicked in.

[...]

 

 

Did you know the game have a free trial, maybe its disabled now but they will reenable it soon. I tried the game in the open beta and didnt like it, when I decided to retry it 2 months ago, I picked up the trial,  this way, in case you dont like it, the dissapointment is a little less.

But amyway, if you dont like the game, it just is not for you, I hope you find soon a new mmorpg to play.

-=AlaKraM=-
Don't fight against poverty, fight against greed.
My Lord of the Rings Gallery

  Majestico

Novice Member

Joined: 1/18/07
Posts: 478

''Hey now!'' - the immortal, cheesy catch-phrase of Hank Kingsly from The Larry Sanders Show.

11/25/08 7:58:07 AM#57

To the OP:

You said that immersion was the most important aspect of an MMO for you, however, your biggest gripe seems to be mainly about character customisation.  Seeing as this, plus the relatively poor character models are probably the game's biggest flaws; I wonder if perhaps you are really just looking for something to complain about.  If it's character customisation you are after, I recommend City of Heroes/Villians.

Like you, I also played in beta, and like you, I also did not like the game all that much.  However, six months ago, I decided to give Lotro another chance, and it has been the best gaming decision I have made in a long time. 

I also played Everquest 2 for a while, and was a big fan of that game.  The one thing that annoyed me about it, (and nearly all other MMO's for that matter), was that it did not have a strong, narrative plot.  Oh, it had some references to back-story, and lore, like all MMO's, but not an actual plot that you could follow.  This is something that I have been looking for in this genre for ages, and it was not until I played Lotro that I was satisfied.  The epic quest chain, complete with cinematic cut-scenes offers an actual story and reason for doing quests.  Sure it has the generic quests as well, but at least with the epic quest line, there is a story behind it all. 

This quest line is also constantly updated every couple of months, with an extra 'book' added.  So you always have the feeling that you are part of some immense story.  Also, the introduction of Moria, (and subsequent expansions) adds an entire new volume of books for you to complete.  And therein lies what seperates Lotro from the rest of the MMO community; its sheer size and ambition.  If you look at the scale of the game so far, and then understand that we are only halfway through Tolkien's first book of the trilogy, it will give you some indication of what the finished game will resemble in size.  What with the advent of the War of the Ring as well, and you get some idea of Turbine's ambition with this project.

Cut-scenes and cinematic sequances have long been associated with strong story-lines and player immersion.  I remember when WoW's Burning Crusade expansion got released, and a lot of players were wetting their pants with excitement, because it had a couple of cut-scenes (not cineamtic ones like Lotro, but merely in-game ones).  Well, Lotro has dozens of these.  Both in-game, and cineamtic.  It also has two narrators, with Gandalf relating the action in Volume One, and Galadriel's soothing voice taking over in Volume Two.

Okay, I've waffled on for long enough.  That is some info about the epic quest line, only one reason why I am so enthusiastic about this game, and I suspect from your post that it is an aspect of these games which you enjoy.

I was not going to bother posting here, but your post is very familiar to what I thought of Lotro way back in Beta, before I had given it a real chance, and so if, as I suspect, you have not gotten very far in the game, then I urge you to give it another go.

Sure, it may not be as graphically spectacular as some of the newer games out there, but bear in mind that it was developed so people like me, with below average pc specs, could still run the game.  Also, if you look at the scenery, and see how dynamic it is (as in the backdrops get more detailed the closer you get), you'll be able to appreciate it better, and thus get more immersed into the world.  Character models are quite poor, I agree, but they do look a lot better once you get some nicer gear.

If you are a hardcore player, who is into pvp and 40 man raids, then Lotro is not for you.  Yes it does have smaller raids, and also has some pvp in the form of monster play, but these are not the game's key features.

However, if you are into pve games, with a very friendly and mature community, with excellent story-lines and quests to match, with different character classes than the norm, with session play whereby you take control of other characters to witness key events in Middle Earth's history, to explore stunning, huge environments full of secrets such as Mines of Moria, to have beautiful orchestral scores flowing from the speakers, and a game that does not require you to forfeit your social life in order to play; then I recommend you give it another chance.

 

falkirkbairn Xfire Miniprofile
  Bama1267

Advanced Member

Joined: 8/24/04
Posts: 1829

11/25/08 8:04:49 AM#58

  I played LOTRO in beta and then tried it out about a year ago as well. I thought it that the game was very polished in beta. Upon trying it last year .... I still think its a great game. The graphics were AWESOME. The only thing that kept me from continuing to play was that it was pretty much just more of the same with some subtle differences. If there were no other games on the market, this would be one of my top 2 choices of games to play , EQ2 being the other.

  User Deleted
11/25/08 10:41:15 AM#59
Originally posted by Majestico

To the OP:


However, if you are into pve games, with a very friendly and mature community, with excellent story-lines and quests to match, with different character classes than the norm, with session play whereby you take control of other characters to witness key events in Middle Earth's history, to explore stunning, huge environments full of secrets such as Mines of Moria, to have beautiful orchestral scores flowing from the speakers, and a game that does not require you to forfeit your social life in order to play; then I recommend you give it another chance.

 

 

Nice post Maj,

  Larry2298

Apprentice Member

Joined: 1/27/05
Posts: 875

11/25/08 11:12:55 AM#60

My first impression about LOTRO was really impressive. Quit LOTRO over a year now, since there is no other game to play so I reinstalled LOTRO 2 days ago with  7 days trial key but the feeling is all gone. If I could retrieve my old account, then I will play the expansion again, otherwise, I will not started from lv 1 all over again.

LOTRO is above average quality game. I like it but few things I dont like was not enough contents, monster play is unforgivable, and I don't like too many quests.

 

 

4 Pages « 1 2 3 4 » Search