Originally posted by nick4545

I honestly don't know weather or not I should pick up Warhammer or not. I have seen so many more negative posts about Warhammer than positive posts.(maybe its just mmorpg.com trolls) I have been waiting a while to see if the game would get better but, from reading the negative posts about Warhammer that people post pretty much everyday; I honestly don't want to have my hopes high for nothing and only end up being disappointed like everyone else. So I ask the fans of Warhammer and the ones who enjoy it and the ones who might have enjoyed and just got bored quickly---should I just play something else like LOTRO (which was a second option I had in mind) or go ahead and get Warhammer?

What a silly post. Clearly you want to buy the game so just go and buy it. You will find out what its like for yourself.

I quit in the first month by the way but you can form your own opinion 

I've made this point before, but I'll make it again.

I applaud the choices WAR gives players. I'm all for choices and I think a game should try to appeal to different playstyles. I enjoy scenarios, as well as PvE and RvR.

However, because scenarios are so accessible and so rewarding as far as XP, it's very easy to fall into a trap where you never get immersed in the world or experience the PvE content in a positive way.

The PvE in this game is good to excellent. Some zones are better than others, but there is a lot of content.

I'm a jaded MMORPG vet, but I'm still really enjoying this game. Everyone is different, but IMO this is the most appealing MMORPG in the last two years. It's definitely worth a shot by fans of the genre who are still on the fence.

Honestly, Its a good game, and they are doing lots to make it better; the latest scenario is really very good. That not say if for everyone, or that there're aren't a few things that could be a bit better.

Don't be put off by the trolls in this forum, if they put off one person from trying this game, then they have "won" their twisted little game :) Give it a go and make your own mind up, after all it only the cost of two weeks coffee at workl; ok maybe the coffee is expensive here:)

I'm a player who enjoys competitive PVP, guild vs guild wars, and difficult and rewarding PVE. I play mainly for endgame and challenge. I want to be known as one of the best and be in one of the best guilds.

Warhammer suits me perfectly, it's got the best PVP there is, hands down, every night on my server there are huge battles with multiple warbands fighting multiple warbands in the tier 4 zones (often 2 at a time) and skills like "Hold the Line" - formation battles in essence - make the game much richer tactically than any other PVP mmo

And the PVE is much better than I thought it would be - in terms of polish not quite as good as LOTRO, but certainly harder and more rewarding than WOTLK (EQ2 wins the difficulty scale though)

Warhammer just rocks, WoW is already dead and people don't realise it :) Quite a few of them are still playing it like zombies or addicts but that will soon wear off as WoW has become very easy, boring and pointless

Warhammer is awesome, plenty to do and a lot of fun to do it :)

If you're a PvP person play this game.

If you're a PvE person play LotRO

If you like grinding for gear play WoW

If you like a fun game play EvE.

I say try the trial for LotRO and if you like it...play it. If you are afraid of buying WAR, buy it in 6 months or try it out when a trial comes.

Originally posted by Magter

If you're a PvP person play EVE or stick to FPS games.

If you're a PvE person play LotRO.....or AoC.....or EQ2.....or Vanguard.....or WoW.....or pretty much any bog standard mmo

If you like grinding for gear play WoW

If you like fun game play then stick with single player games.

I say try the trial for any game (cos its free....duh) and if you like it...play it. If you are afraid of buying WAR, buy it in 6 months or try it out when a trial comes.

Originally posted by Greyhooff 

Warhammer just rocks, WoW is already dead and people don't realise it :) Quite a few of them are still playing it like zombies or addicts but that will soon wear off as WoW has become very easy, boring and pointless

Warhammer is awesome, plenty to do and a lot of fun to do it :)

After 4 years you'd think people would stop beating that drum :p

Hmmm, lots of mixed opinion here and this probably means the OP needs to try it for themselves.

I love pvp, pve, crafting etc. I left WOW 2 years ago as I was bored of same-old-same-old (I had been playing WOW for several years). I have played over 10 titles trying to find a new home. I had high hopes for both AOC and WAR; unfortunately, for me, they both failed to hook me and I have returned to WOW and EVE.

The best alternative to WOW I played was LOTRO, although the crafting in VGSOH was inspired.

WAR failed for me because:

1. I'm sorry, but the world did feel empty of players because of scenario grinding. I changed servers 3 times on Euro because the die-hards convinced me my problem was bad server choice rather than game design.

2. I played the same old scenarios again and again. Total blind zerg fests, although this was quite fun for the first few days. I realized that WOW battlegrounds were more innovative, varied and that classes in wow had more options and tricks than in WAR. This was a disappointing realisation for me, WAR was supposed to be the pvp king.

3. The open-world pvp - which I got a taste of during the Halloween event - was a boring stand-off in which range-dps were king. It was extremely dull. No tactics, no sneakiness, no lure and bait, no traps...just stand-off, zerg, die, rez, stand-off. The stand-offs lasted 10 minutes at a time btw, with some foolhardy types testing the water and dying in no-man's-land.

4. PQs are empty. The end-game playas will tell you that at end-game they are full and wholesome. That's great, but not much consolation for those who are expected to drift through endless ghost-towns.

I am still perplexed about how bad - for me - this game was. First AOC, then this.

When I went back to WOW two-weeks ago I was struck by how much Blizzard have gotten it right. For sure I am in nostalgia mode, for sure I will tire of it (again), but until a solid mmorpg fantasy pvp game is released I would recommend LOTRO (pve) or WOW (pvp server). If you can live without fantasy, then EVE is maybe yer best pvp bet.

Just my opinion!

Regards

Melmoth

I have been playing MMO's since EQ and I can honestly say that this is the most overhyped piece of garbage I have ever played. I have never been more disapointed in a game than I have been with WAR. The game is one big scenario grind, it lacks a meaningful world to explore, theres no sense of WAR or battlefield which you feel you must hold your ground in. Keeps dont mean a single thing, I had imagined they would be forward spawns and every keep capture would bring you that much closer to the enemies city.

On top of the horrible RVR design, the game's combat feels god awful. Never have I played a game where the only way I know my "Sword Attack X" ability went off is by looking at my hotbar to see if it had actually went on cooldown. The combat animations are horrible, the game runs as if it is displaying AoC quality graphics... its basically one big unfixable mess.

Anyone who is on the fence about buying the game... watchout for all the people who post how great it is... I bet there still level 1-20 which imo is the "prime" of the game. After that is all goes downhill from there.

Originally posted by Brone87

I have been playing MMO's since EQ and I can honestly say that this is the most overhyped piece of garbage I have ever played. I have never been more disapointed in a game than I have been with WAR. The game is one big scenario grind, it lacks a meaningful world to explore, theres no sense of WAR or battlefield which you feel you must hold your ground in. Keeps dont mean a single thing, I had imagined they would be forward spawns and every keep capture would bring you that much closer to the enemies city.

On top of the horrible RVR design, the game's combat feels god awful. Never have I played a game where the only way I know my "Sword Attack X" ability went off is by looking at my hotbar to see if it had actually went on cooldown. The combat animations are horrible, the game runs as if it is displaying AoC quality graphics... its basically one big unfixable mess.

Anyone who is on the fence about buying the game... watchout for all the people who post how great it is... I bet there still level 1-20 which imo is the "prime" of the game. After that is all goes downhill from there.

This sums the game up pretty well actually. The fact that taking or losing a keep doesnt mean anything was a massive turn off for me as well. Its all just a level grinding treadmill exactly like WoW and the RvR is just a gimic.

To the OP - If you want a game with meaningless RvR that you can actually ignore with no consequence then this might be the game for you.

well, I bought it, patching now-anyone have any idea which server has the largest pop?

Enjoy levels 1-11 and 18-21, after that your gonna be wishing you never wasted your time.