I have sunk many hours into all of them

My most played so far is Oblivion , quickly catching up with skyrim time played tho. Fallout 3 was a great game but did not grab me as much as oblivion or skyrim.

Overall great games, have gotten more than my moneys worth on every title.

Skyrim > Morrowind > Fallout 3 > Daggerfall

for me :)

Oblivion and then Fallout 3. The few that I know that did not like those games the most never discovered the modding community that made them 2 of the best games ever made.

Heck, there is a mod that brought almost ALL of Morrowind to Oblivion, the land, NPCs, quests...Oblivion is a beast with the right mods...same with fallout 3. Hell, someone created a mod for fallout 3 that added a gathering system that also allowed you to build your own towns/forts with NPCs, defenders and allowed you to set up monster attacks on it.

Originally posted by Rayshe

What no Call of Cthulhu fans out there? its not even listed.

 

 

Then again there is a small population of people who got it to work without crashing at every save.

Mm, loved what little I got to play of it. But it kept crashing every 10 mins, so I gave up.

And for the record people NV was made by obsidian not Bethesda afaik.

  I just lost my entire post.  It was wordy and I'm not retyping it.  So I'll just say Morrowind wins.  Better casting, finding items was more intersting because they weren't leveled to you and you might find something awesome behind a rock.  Stealing mattered, and there were awesome enchanted items to be found, (like the boots that made you run fast, but blinded you.  The boots of blinding speed, lol)

  My favorite thing, however, was this.

  I could kill someone, and basically steal their house.  I could decorate that house.  Items didn't have physics, and that was great because it meant that you could point and a spot, and drop something there, and it would stay there.  I had candles lining my stairs, skulls mounted on shelves.  My buddy made an entire fort of pillows.  Items that won't sit still are a headache, and the fact that you cannot simply PLACE one makes me mad in skyrim.  I have to drop it at my feet, slowly pick it up, tiptoe around wobbling it like a child, and pray to god that when I finally set it it won't roll three rooms down the hall.

  You didn't need "secure chests".  That inn you just wiped out was yours.  You didn't have to worry about the game resetting your loot you hid in the inns barrels.  You could sleep in the beds, "ownership" wasn't a thing.

I like all of them. Dagerfall was a great game also.  I still have my copy of it. 

My favorites were Wayne Gretzky Hockey and Hockey League Simulator 2.

Morrowind and Oblivion are pretty sweet, not played enough Fallout 3 yet and still have not played Skyrim.

Originally posted by m0lly
one of these threads where you need to say the oldest game that compnay have made just to be cool.

  Nah thats just silly.  I couldn't get into Daggerfall.  I mean, its was too large and most the space wasn't anything at all.  Most people are going to say Morrowind because of how perfect the design of that game was.  The reason we've lost many of those elements was because Bethesda was trying out new tech for AI and the stuff was getting process heavy and making development time longer.  So we have more "alive" NPCS in a smaller world.  Skyrim really refined that element by adding repeat quests to keep the game moving even after you've done the fluff.

  If you did a side by side list of what each game had going for it, Morrowind probably sits at the top of the pile for a variety of things.  Technology just cannot be awesome enough yet to do all the things Bethesda wants to.  Plus they wanna keep changing things up so we don't start feeling like we are playing the same game over and over.  Which is wise.  I just lament what we've lost is all.

1.Morrowind

2.Skyrim second also becouse of its much improved dungeon design and not one is the same.

I like the MODS more in morrowind becouse when i installed one it felt like it realy gave me something more and realy add to game experience.

In skyrim i just click and i have the mod and so many its not realy special at all anymore.

Originally posted by Gishgeron

Originally posted by m0lly
one of these threads where you need to say the oldest game that compnay have made just to be cool.

 

  Nah thats just silly.  I couldn't get into Daggerfall.  I mean, its was too large and most the space wasn't anything at all.  Most people are going to say Morrowind because of how perfect the design of that game was.  The reason we've lost many of those elements was because Bethesda was trying out new tech for AI and the stuff was getting process heavy and making development time longer.  So we have more "alive" NPCS in a smaller world.  Skyrim really refined that element by adding repeat quests to keep the game moving even after you've done the fluff.

  If you did a side by side list of what each game had going for it, Morrowind probably sits at the top of the pile for a variety of things.  Technology just cannot be awesome enough yet to do all the things Bethesda wants to.  Plus they wanna keep changing things up so we don't start feeling like we are playing the same game over and over.  Which is wise.  I just lament what we've lost is all.

I actually truly like Morrowind a lot more than Oblivion. I never had the GOTY and there were never the big mods for Morrowind when I played. But Morrowind with the graphics overhaul mod looks epic, and think it looks better than Oblivion and art wise...better than Skyrim. And I've sunk more hours into Morrowind than any other game I bought or was gifted in 2012...and I only got (someone/anon on MMORPG.com gifted it to me) Morrowind GOTY a few days ago lol.

If I was to redo my vote, it would go to Morrowind. I've been having a blast.

And one thing I really like, that sold me. Was that quests aren't a "HERE IS AN ARROW! HERE LOOK I'M BLINKING! GO HERE! ARE YOU BLIND?? I"M A BIG ARROW"...and if you turn off the dumb arrow...there is no way to do the quest because the quest journal was 99% removed from the previous games...

you actually have to talk to NPCs for information on quests in Morrowind, and actually explore and investigate to complete the quests. Even Oblivion had a proper quest log, not as good as Morrowind, but it was still good and you could turn off quest markers and still do the quests.