I voted Skyrim, but I loved oblivion as well.

Both are great games.

My winner:  Morrowind.  

As others have said, Oblivion felt like I was playing on the playstation or something.  And i didn't care for the leveled mobs.  I missed the feeling of back in Morrowind where you got up to the point where you could enter the areas you had been aware of but not able to survive in.

I played Daggerfall and Skyrim, both are great as well. 

I've never really played any of those games until recently. I've started playing Morrowind really casually when I don't feel like logging into GW2. Really like the game so far. I've got Oblivion and Skyrim too but I won't start them until I've finish Morrowind and I know that will take a lot of time haha.

I was wondering, anyone have some good mods suggestion for Morrowind and Oblivion? I've look into it a little bit already but there is so many differents mods its insane lol. Digging through all this will take a while to find the best ones. So if anyone has some suggestions, I would really appreciate it.

Thanks a lot guys!

Originally posted by SirFubar

I've never really played any of those games until recently. I've started playing Morrowind really casually when I don't feel like logging into GW2. Really like the game so far. I've got Oblivion and Skyrim too but I won't start them until I've finish Morrowind and I know that will take a lot of time haha.

I was wondering, anyone have some good mods suggestion for Morrowind and Oblivion? I've look into it a little bit already but there is so many differents mods its insane lol. Digging through all this will take a while to find the best ones. So if anyone has some suggestions, I would really appreciate it.

Thanks a lot guys!

Start with the Morrowind Graphics Extender (MGE).  It is available in some different places, I just saw it on Sourceforge yesterday.  That is I think the most required mod for Morrowind and many other mods are compatible.  Just google morrowind modding and you should see some tutorials on how to go about it.

Morrowind followed by Skyrim.

I haven't ever played Daggerfall or Arena although if I ever get around to installing virtualbox, I'll play them.

Very good question.

I've been sitting here for the last 15 minutes trying to decide and I really can't.  I enjoyed them all equally.  They're all great games.  They'd been even better with a good combat system.

Imagine Skyrim with a fighting system as titillating as Chivalry Medieval Warfare's.

In order:

Fallout 3

Fallout NV

Skyrim

Oblivion

Fallout felt more comfortable with an interesting story to it.  NV is second only because the story you follow through on seems less engaging.  In version 3 it takes you from birth through it all. 

in NV, it takes you through a more typical "shot in the head, regain memory" gig where you forgot how to survive in a world you've supposedly been traveling through for a long time.

Skyrim had the feel of an MMO "standalone mode".  Everything an MMORPG has only on your own.  Not bad but ...

Oblivion was interesting but rather it just felt more linear than the above 3 as how I felt going through it.  Again, not bad but the above ones seemed more engaging.

The fun part:  I really don't regret playing any of them at all.  No "waste of time" type feel to it.  Some games I've gotten are disappointments - this is more trying to pick a best choice from best choices.

Voted Skyrim. Didn't like how they consolized certain things in it, but it had a much better atmosphere than Oblivion. Also I greatly prefer the leveling system in Skyrim as it actually makes sense and isn't as easy to gimp yourself accidentally.

Fallout 3 doesn't even belong on the list. That game was in an insult to any true fan of the Fallout franchise, IMO. Thank goodness Wasteland 2 looks to be shaping up as a proper post-apoc RPG.

What no Call of Cthulhu fans out there? its not even listed.

Then again there is a small population of people who got it to work without crashing at every save.

For those that like Morrowind. These two mods are rather well known and improve the game a lot

Morrowind Overhaul (makes the graphics look WAY better)

and Tamriel Rebuilt (adds as much land currently, as there is in vanilla Morrowind. Though it is still a work in progress...but there is still a lot of content to do. been in development a while. Right now they have developed 3 maps, and I think there is 5? left...or maybe 2 left? in any case...still lots to do)

There is also Morrowind Rebirth which is pretty popular and it overhauls the game, but I like how Morrowind is and Morrowind Rebirth probably isn't compatible with Tamriel Rebuilt and conflicts with morrowind overhaul.

Morrowind.

I'm playing it now along with skyrim.

It's amazing to see the two side by side, graphics not withstanding, as clearly morrowind is a more deliberately slow game. But one refreshing (if that can be used for an older game) is that in morrowind I needed to kill 4 Telvanni agents that were north/north west of Caldera. In a cave.

And that was what I was given.

I discovered quite a lot while searching for that cave.

In Skyirm there are no such directions so you have to rely upon the little "V" mark.

Still, the atmosphere and visceral combat is really amazing in Skyrim.

I did like oblvion quite a bit but it's not as good as the previous two.

I would love to be able to play daggerfall but every time i start it the age/combat doesn't grab me.