" EverQuest II "

My favorite would have to be 3 mmo's. They were all my favorites.

1. Ultima Online
2. Asheron's Call
3. Dark Age of Camelot (PRE-TOA)

SWG

the huge storage and decoration option and the trillion collections from easy to super hard to earn

the deepest crafting system, the player vendors....

i can continue for days with it.

its negative was the little content, and that was the only 1

Have to say WoW in its prime it was very engaging and met a bunch of good people. Much like OP TBC to cata primarily.

And regardless of all the failcom out there AoC and TSW (still sub for both). Tortage after 2 or 3 runs sucks btw i couldnt stomach the whole game being that way. These games def come down to having decent people to play with.

But originally and before i had been awakened to a real MMO, Martial Heroes. Click to move, spam combos, spam pots swarmed by enemies .01xp per kill at half level cap..........did that for 12 months (2003-2004) 

What would make me grin..... Dark Souls, mmo format with open world

In order:

1. City of Heroes
2. Vanilla WoW
3. Mines of Moria LotRO

DAoC for me. 

It was the only MMO where I wanted/couldn't wait to log into every single day.

Until ToA hit, which was the ONLY reason I left(to play WoW beta).

RuneScape was my first, and many aspects of it are still my ideals.  

GW1 was the one I had the most fun with.

WoW is good quality, if a bit shallow, and I keep coming back to it.

LotRO is probably the over-all best, though it's starting to feel dated.

Of all the ones I have played, 4 stand out.

4 - City of Heroes - Excellent group play and the character creation was top notch.

3 - World of Warcraft - First MMO I raided in. Was not in a hard core raiding guild, but one that was serious yet fun. Became a main tank for the guild and just had tons of fun. WotLK killed it for me.

2 - Age of Conan - The combat was just plain awesome and the raiding was the best I have ever been a part of. Most of that was due to the fact I was in a very fun guild.

1 - SWG Pre-Cu - My first MMO ever. Was convinced by my friends to try it and finally I downloaded the trial and was playing eery night until the NGE killed it for me. The open world, doing quests that I wanted to do, hunting Jedi, decorating my house with the trophies I aquired. No MMO since has given me the full immersion that SWG did. I stomached CU (Combat Upgrade) but the NGE was a deal-breaker. I do believe I would have stayed a long time. I loved raiding Rebel cities and hunting Jedi.

Anarchy Online.

The only game so far where you could plan for days, read different spreadsheets and sit with a calculator to put on your boots.

Played time: I'd have to go with Warcraft. Kept me subscribing for a lot of years.   

Game play: DCUO

Graphics: I loved Aion.

1. SWG
2. UO
3. Vanilla WoW

1. DAoC

2. EVE

3. WoW

EQ1

I will never forget killing the "unkillable" Sleeper Dragon on Rallos Zek. In fact we had to kill it twice because a GM came online and said we must be cheating to kill him, and had the Sleeper reset so he could watch how we were killing him and make sure we were not hacking in some way.

Of the older MMOs, UO and EQ1 top my list.

Since then, most seem to be overly commercial.

The most fun I've had in the last few years with an MMO would be with Mortal Online.  Kind of a throwback, but it does provide a type of gameplay that's vanished from the MMO space.

For modern themeparks, I think TSW is one of the better ones.  STO is also pretty strong, especially since they've started departing from the instant gratification mentality that most games seem locked into.

Have to go with EQ1, it's one of the very few MMO's I ended up playing for several years, and I still occasionally login today to get a group going if i'm not in the mood to play anything else.

Dark age of camelot had the best PvP i've played pre-Atlantis.