Originally posted by Creslin321

Pro:  Extremely good implementation of core concepts that really encourage group play, really feels like an MMOrpg because of this.

Con:  Like BadSpock and Korrigan, I would have loved sandbox features in this game like housing, guild halls, etc.

Fixed ;-)

Pro:

B2P and Features Promised.

Con:

Reserved for launch.

Pro: A proper MMO continuation of GW1 lore in a richly designed world where players end up working together without even trying to and where some, albeit not all, things can change depending on those players actions.

Cons: There is a serious lack of quality tutorials, lots of childish themed quests to start with (only in the starter zones) and an abundence of zerg type gameplay being adopted by players from what we have seen so far.

I'll keep it real simple.

Pro= gameplay.

con=story dialog's .

Pro: Advocating variation in an otherwise very stale genre.

Negative: Gems for gold system and its implication in the ingame economy. 

CON - Too many load screens

PRO - Everything else

Con - i have to wait a month to play it again

Pro - play it as you want: pve(personal story solo mode or the world whihc is fully open), WvW or spvp, just pick what your mood is abo,ut and they are all interesting to play, which is quiet amazing when most mmo can't even do a single of those stuff properly.

Pro: Smart devs that listen to community feedback and implement changes their own way (they seem to have excellent tools), solving the problems without creating more problems.

Con: It is not 4 or 5 years in the future yet, so the game hasn't reached all it can be.

Pro: Extremely well made combat and quest mechanics
Con: Everything else is an afterthought

Pro - Beutifully vibrant game world.

Con- Tutorials don't explain much other than base mechanics

Pro: Most solo encounters feel like an epic battle since many mobs do mucho damage if you don't dodge, and the combat system makes it fun.

Con: Does not, in fact, turn water into wine.

Pro: Structured large scale pvp.

Con: Pure themepark.

From what I know:

Pros: Level scaling, levels being an abstract and dynamic property

Cons: Instances? Not sure but I believe zones are instanced? + no open world pvp

Pro: Strong co-operative element with a deep, position-based combat system

Con: If you wrote down a pro you will be labled a drooling fanboi claiming its the second coming.

Pro: Their presentation on questing (DE's and such)

Con: Their Tutorial needs work, it's not idiot proof.

Originally posted by jazz.be

From what I know:

Pros: Level scaling, levels being an abstract and dynamic property

Cons: Instances? Not sure but I believe zones are instanced? + no open world pvp

Depend on your definition of instance - zones are persistant. You have a loading screen between zones but each zone is massive with hours upon hours of content.

Open world PvP - not in the main PvE world by design. One could argue WvW is open world pvp zone, with several PvE elements, from mobs to resource nodes.

Pro: Deposit all collectibles.

Con: Lacking stats such as server location, ping, etc. to make an informed decision when choosing home server.

Pro: Titty physics

Con: Titties arn't big enough