Originally posted by xenogias

Originally posted by DJJazzy

Originally posted by FredomSekerZ

Originally posted by DJJazzy

Good lord, first it was SWTOR, then Tera, now it's TSW? If you like your other game so god damn much then post in those forums. FFS, get a life.

Anyway, OP, there are already a few threads on the payment model, look them up.

You do know about GW2 culists in other game forums, right?

Does that make it right? I don't condone their action either.

Other forums I visit have a pretty strict policy against game vs game fights in their particular game forum. Would be nice if this site had a similar policy. I get real tired sifting through all of that bullshit here.

Dont expect that here DJ. They would rather give a warning/ban for someone saying they arent playing any faction in TSW because they dont trust funcom than crack down on posts like the OP's trying to start flame wars. Its how MMORPG works. You can flame, troll, pretty much do whatever you want so long as you pick your words carefully. It doesnt matter how OBVIOUS something is so long as you word it right.

Sadly this is true. And makes this site less appealing every week. The sadest part about it is that, because of the name, this site still has a lot of players who use it for information. What they get instead, are threads like these that bash / flame decent games with misinformation, slander, or just flat out lies. They also get threads that praise the latest FoTM game as being the best thing ever, only to waste their money on it. I mean hell, I've seen this site blow up over games like Aion, TERA; And we see pretty much nothing from either of those games anymore. They are already forgotten. Yet there's no consequences for the people who misrepresented those games with falsehood.

It is nice to have a site that allows for multiple perspectives / criticism on every game, but it would be nice to have a little more moderation in this regard.

Originally posted by Aeolron

Originally posted by MoonBeans

Originally posted by DeserttFoxx

The secret world is better then this game in its current state.

 

Too bad most people wont give the secret world any time of day.

lol even Barbies online is better than TSW. 

TSW= pricey subscription fee.   cash shop,  horrible combat,  horrible animations,  horrible character models.

This proves that TSW is more then what some people can handle,......thinking wise anyways, you didn't play the game did you? Or maybe you did and got stuck on Dr Bannermans mission LOL

don't worry beans, there's a MMO coming up that requires zero thinking and only button mashing, need me to state which one? Or do you want to take a guess?

I think it's hilarious that it's called a "thinking person's game" but to each their own!

Back on topic: Would pay a sub for Gw2 over any upcoming or currently released game!

Originally posted by rdrpappy

If there was a monthly sub for Guild Wars 2, would the game barely make a ripple?. Honestly, the hype is so over the top it's cliche.

If the game changed nothing so far but the addition of a $15 a month fee, would most of you shuffle off or go back to what ever else was F2P?.

Maybe a fair and more realistic hype would be (it's the best looking F2P game coming out) certainly more realistic than the claims right here on these forums that GW2 is a hybid themepark/sandbox.

I have seen no nation, city or home building, only typical and limited crafting and no unstructured open world pvp, things that would point to sandbox are missing by most accounts, but turn on the over hype machine and they magicaly appear.

No endgame? no levels? no character building constraints, just pick a name and heap on the abbilities? the maps have no edges?

I dont have enough time to get into the pvp claims but add a sub fee and this title would crash back to earth faster than Skylab. Does anyone have a calm, logical, honest review of the game? strengths and weaknesses, please feel free to add it here.

I will try and read it before it's crushed under a mountain of hype.

 

It wouldn't crash onto anything... I'd pay a monthy sub for this game without even thinking about it...

Most polished game I've seen lately and it's still has tons of thing they didn't show us... AND not to mention it's still in beta...

REAL beta, not just this PR crap like TSW or SWTOR had.

Originally posted by rdrpappy

If there was a monthly sub for Guild Wars 2, would the game barely make a ripple?. Honestly, the hype is so over the top it's cliche.

If the game changed nothing so far but the addition of a $15 a month fee, would most of you shuffle off or go back to what ever else was F2P?.

Thanks for your input random internet guy 565638983!

I am sure everything you say is true and this game in no way has attracted attention with it's scope, ambition, imagination, and extremely high production values.

One question though... why are people not as excited about those 'F2P' games, which have even less of a barrier to entry, if the price is so important? Are they just not as good?

Originally posted by Aeolron

Originally posted by MoonBeans

Originally posted by DeserttFoxx

The secret world is better then this game in its current state.

 

Too bad most people wont give the secret world any time of day.

lol even Barbies online is better than TSW. 

TSW= pricey subscription fee.   cash shop,  horrible combat,  horrible animations,  horrible character models.

This proves that TSW is more then what some people can handle,......thinking wise anyways, you didn't play the game did you? Or maybe you did and got stuck on Dr Bannermans mission LOL

don't worry beans, there's a MMO coming up that requires zero thinking and only button mashing, need me to state which one? Or do you want to take a guess?

Just WOAH... I played the beta weekends and if you call this "a thinking game" ... -.-'

This game has nothing that could get you stuck, it requires a little googling and a little common sence. It's easy and boring at best... So please, stop bragging how you "can handle" TSW... You're just emberassing yourself. 

Originally posted by korent1991

Originally posted by Aeolron

Originally posted by MoonBeans

Originally posted by DeserttFoxx

The secret world is better then this game in its current state.

 

Too bad most people wont give the secret world any time of day.

lol even Barbies online is better than TSW. 

TSW= pricey subscription fee.   cash shop,  horrible combat,  horrible animations,  horrible character models.

This proves that TSW is more then what some people can handle,......thinking wise anyways, you didn't play the game did you? Or maybe you did and got stuck on Dr Bannermans mission LOL

don't worry beans, there's a MMO coming up that requires zero thinking and only button mashing, need me to state which one? Or do you want to take a guess?

Just WOAH... I played the beta weekends and if you call this "a thinking game" ... -.-'

This game has nothing that could get you stuck, it requires a little googling and a little common sence. It's easy and boring at best... So please, stop bragging how you "can handle" TSW... You're just emberassing yourself. 

I absolutely agree, most boring game ever played.

Lol at the button smashing, and you claim you played both the games?

TSW is bad, Tera bombed, SWTOR bombed, D3 bombed and still people are hating on GW2. Bizzare!

I would actually pay a sub for GW2, it has already proven its gameplay thru BWEs, and the world is huge!! Content for months and months.

The PvP is like DAOC with some additions, and many players agree that DAOC was one of the best PvP games around, its hard to take anyone seriously when they say GW2s PvP is lacking.

GW2 is the only other mmo that I would pay a sub for at the moment, luckily enough I don't have to.

First sign of useless post.. OP havent replied inside first 5 pages... Why you post it and dont even care to answer? 

Anyway test it, dont like it - forget it.

I feel with all MMOs it's difficult to decide if the game is worth it. I've enjoyed leveling in a lot of MMOs but once you hit that cap, then what? We'll see how things end up once the game is released.

Nope. Never paid a sub, never will.  Subs are for people that believe to drive a car, they need to pay monthly for the keys.

Originally posted by DeserttFoxx

The secret world is better then this game in its current state.

 

Too bad most people wont give the secret world any time of day.

I could not find a single thing in TSW that I liked.

IMO no mmorpg is worth the sub fee any more. All recent mmorpgs have failed to keep people interested for more than a few months.

Originally posted by DeserttFoxx

The secret world is better then this game in its current state.

 

Too bad most people wont give the secret world any time of day.

? i would say GW2 on BW2 was in  better state than the last TSW beta i test (an TSW will be release very soon)

TSW have many great things, animations/combat are clear not one of them

Originally posted by Roybe

Nope. Never paid a sub, never will.  Subs are for people that believe to drive a car, they need to pay monthly for the keys.

Gotta put gas in it, insurance, tune-ups, new tires,  etc. :)  F2P, P2P, B2P all cost something somewhere down the line.

Originally posted by p_c_sousa

Originally posted by DeserttFoxx

The secret world is better then this game in its current state.

 

Too bad most people wont give the secret world any time of day.

? i would say GW2 on BW2 was in  better state than the last TSW beta i test (an TSW will be release very soon)

So would I.

Originally posted by Cromica

Originally posted by DeserttFoxx

The secret world is better then this game in its current state.

 

Too bad most people wont give the secret world any time of day.

I could not find a single thing in TSW that I liked.

Nor could I.. and I really tried.  Gave it a lot more than just the time of day.

Originally posted by Thorbrand

I wouldn't even look at this game if it had a sub. It isn't even close to a good MMO

This is the only valid part of his post since it is his opinion. However GW2 is a mmorpg and it's a lot more than just GW1 with a new skin like he would have you believe.

Not sure why these posts keep creeping up...it's not like it was a surprise GW2 isn't going to have a subscription nor is it a surprise they make a sequel that is as hyped up or as popular as their previous release.

Asking if people would pay if there was a sub is fairly pointless since: there isn't one, there won't be one, and everyone knew (before it was even announced to be in development) that there wouldn't be one. Seems like just trying to stir crap up.

It has hype because it's a sequel to a well built and popular game from a company that is respected.