My take on that article: I keep hoping this game will get better and I love Star Wars, I just have to stick it out and hope it gets better.

Give it up, there is nothing coming down the line with enough content to fix it.  They made it for the "I want it now crowd" and they have done what they usually do, left after a few months of gameplay.

Originally posted by Eletheryl

Originally posted by observer

MMORPG.com should just stop featuring this game.  That's how bad it is right now.  It's not even worthy of being called an MMO.

Thats only your point of view, is still the most populated and successful MMO post wow and it keep growing, live with it. But agree MMORPG.com should stop making reviews about swtor, this site is full of haters who know nothing about the game, and just want to see tor  fail. For the last 6 months we have read the hate towards swtor in this site from the community 24/7, gw2 fanboys, sanbox lovers, and people who just dont like the game but they keep trying to convince everyone that the game is just bad. Dear haters, you are a vocal minority, swtor is alive, they have an insane amount of content for the following months and an exp in the 1st year, and even now when most of the servers are light, they keep selling more copies per week than any other p2p MMO in the market, all these ¨swtor is doomed¨, ¨the game is drying¨ etc etc and etc posts and comments will vanish once again  with the free transfers and the 1.3 update, when we will find that actually people is back  to the game, why? because the people who is actually playing the game know what everyone want and is waiting, and all of that is coming pretty soon. At the end haters gonna hate, and even when they know deep in their souls how wrong they are, the hate will be around here. 

  I stopped reading when you said SWTOR was the most populated and successful MMO post WoW and that it was growing... SWTOR it dying fast, really fast, this isn't from a haters perspective, don't you read what EA posts or statistics any site posts?

Rift was more successful, they've made tons of money since releasing because they did not have a ginormous budget like SWTOR and the company has held loyal subscribers.

Also, when Aion released combining it's playerbase in the West and East it had far more players than SWTOR will ever  come close to achieving, so no, SWTOR was not the biggest MMO since WoW and the only reason it sold over 500k copies is because it had the STAR:WARS IP and EA backing it with ridiculously impressive CG trailers.

So SWTOR is neither the most successful or populated MMO post WoW. Seriously, If the game was called something like  "Space War: Total Annihilation", it would have sold nothing.

Good article and I totally agree. Once 1.3 hits and transfers are available this little rut the game is in will be over.

1. Good story

2. Good graphics

3. Good classes

4. Most whiners are gone (back to WoW or Diablo no doubt ;))

5. It's getting better and thank god for server transfers. :)

Hate it if you want but there's plenty who still play and it is just getting better and better.

Originally posted by Pivotelite

Originally posted by Eletheryl

Originally posted by observer

MMORPG.com should just stop featuring this game.  That's how bad it is right now.  It's not even worthy of being called an MMO.

Thats only your point of view, is still the most populated and successful MMO post wow and it keep growing, live with it. But agree MMORPG.com should stop making reviews about swtor, this site is full of haters who know nothing about the game, and just want to see tor  fail. For the last 6 months we have read the hate towards swtor in this site from the community 24/7, gw2 fanboys, sanbox lovers, and people who just dont like the game but they keep trying to convince everyone that the game is just bad. Dear haters, you are a vocal minority, swtor is alive, they have an insane amount of content for the following months and an exp in the 1st year, and even now when most of the servers are light, they keep selling more copies per week than any other p2p MMO in the market, all these ¨swtor is doomed¨, ¨the game is drying¨ etc etc and etc posts and comments will vanish once again  with the free transfers and the 1.3 update, when we will find that actually people is back  to the game, why? because the people who is actually playing the game know what everyone want and is waiting, and all of that is coming pretty soon. At the end haters gonna hate, and even when they know deep in their souls how wrong they are, the hate will be around here. 

 

  I stopped reading when you said SWTOR was the most populated and successful MMO post WoW and that it was growing... SWTOR it dying fast, really fast, this isn't from a haters perspective, don't you read what EA posts or statistics any site posts?

 

Rift was more successful, they've made tons of money since releasing because they did not have a ginormous budget like SWTOR and the company has held loyal subscribers.

 

Also, when Aion released combining it's playerbase in the West and East it had far more players than SWTOR will ever  come close to achieving, so no, SWTOR was not the biggest MMO since WoW and the only reason it sold over 500k copies is because it had the STAR:WARS IP and EA backing it with ridiculously impressive CG trailers.

 

So SWTOR is neither the most successful or populated MMO post WoW. Seriously, If the game was called something like  "Space War: Total Annihilation", it would have sold nothing.

Then how come Ive seen multiple sites say that its been the most successful mmo since wow. I guess ill just have to take your word for it then...

Originally posted by DarnRight

1. Good story

2. Good graphics

3. Good classes

4. Most whiners are gone (back to WoW or Diablo no doubt ;))

5. It's getting better and thank god for server transfers. :)

Hate it if you want but there's plenty who still play and it is just getting better and better.

They yellow does not agree with the red.  That is all. 

I don't see any reason to insult the intelligence of the OP, however....

I went through the entire game's content and you will never get me to go back.

They blew it when they made PVP a total waste instead of something to look forward to.

Then they blew it when they made it so easy to get to 50 that you had to AVOID PVP and heroic quests... and all of the rewards from them.

Then they blew it by making post 50 game play a conglomeration of the worst parts of the rest of the game.

3 major patches since i left and none of those major game breaking items have even been addressed.

Originally posted by Kabaal

It’s Star Wars!

That was enough to try the game, not to keep playing.

Free Transfers & Permanent Free Trials are Coming!

They're a reason to resub once they appear, not to keep playing.

PvP is Fun*

PvP is fun, but it so limited in TOR that it's more repetitive than anything else.

Playing With Others

I can do that in any other game. In TOR it cant be done unless re-rolling to one of the most populated servers, which are also now rapidly losing numbers of people online. *see Free Transfers

Expanding Your Legacy

Legacy is one of those tacked on features that mean nothing other than some stuff we don't need. My Legacy level is already 50 and i gain nothing more than someone who has a Legacy of 25 and even it gave nothing of worth other than the multiple group buffs.

What you said.

Originally posted by mcburly

Then how come Ive seen multiple sites say that its been the most successful mmo since wow. I guess ill just have to take your word for it then...

 Money talks.

Aion had 3.5million subscribers just in the East.

Originally posted by Pivotelite

Originally posted by mcburly

Then how come Ive seen multiple sites say that its been the most successful mmo since wow. I guess ill just have to take your word for it then...

 Money talks.

lol I love this site. The conspiracy theorists and utter hatred towards SWTOR is hilarious.

This is tiresome. Why are some people incapable of discussing SWTOR in any respect without devolving to bickering over whether or not the game is successful?

5 reasons to keep playing, 50 reasons not to...and im being nice because its missing and lacking in far more than 50 things.

[mod edit]

Amusingly enough, it's about as much of an MMO as every other themepark that's come out in the last 10 years.  It just had better stories than most.

The 5 reasons given in this article are about as forced as I've seen, and stretch the limits of credibility, especially with questionable reasons like "It's Star Wars", "Play with Others", and "For the PvP".  But, seriously, almost no themepark game offers much of a legitimate reason to play it long-term.  Almost all of them are contrived, repetitive junk.

SWTOR is average/lackluster, but it's not the worst themepark offender in recent memory.  And it does have good single-player storylines.  Unfortunately, the stories end, and end abruptly, leaving nothing more than the vapid themepark staples many players have long since grown tired of.

Originally posted by Rohn

SWTOR is average/lackluster, but it's not the worst themepark offender in recent memory.  And it does have good single-player storylines.  Unfortunately, the stories end, and end abruptly, leaving nothing more than the vapid themepark staples many players have long since grown tired of.

I think that people are more critical of it because of the widely popular IP and the fact that the game was developed by BioWare and financed by EA. What we got was mediocre at best, when SWTOR should have been one of the best MMOs on the market.

Originally posted by heartless

Originally posted by Rohn

SWTOR is average/lackluster, but it's not the worst themepark offender in recent memory.  And it does have good single-player storylines.  Unfortunately, the stories end, and end abruptly, leaving nothing more than the vapid themepark staples many players have long since grown tired of.

I think that people are more critical of it because of the widely popular IP and the fact that the game was developed by BioWare and financed by EA. What we got was mediocre at best, when SWTOR should have been one of the best MMOs on the market.

I think you're right - huge IP, enormous amount of money spent by major developers - it had high expectations to meet.  Probably unrealistically high.  Farther to fall and all that.

It'll also have SWG's ghost haunting it forever, which isn't exactly fair.  Different games, different game companies.

It's an average game, and will probably get better over time.  Most do.

Please remain on topic in the discussion. The topic is the SWTOR list and not our editorial policy or EA in general. If you want to make suggestions or post feedback about our editorial policy or structure, please do so in the Site Suggestions forum, where there's a thread for that purpose.

Sorry its time to crash and burn SWTOR. There is no way this will drive up the population atleast not in any permanent way. Gamers, MMO Gamers specifically are the most Unforgiving type of consumer. SWTOR was doomed before it launched, and it NEEDS to die to revitalize the Genre and prove we dont want the same old crap, and developers cant spend nearly 300 million to create a copy of a game that only cost ~50 million.

I actually liked the game while I played it, but the article did not highlight reasons that would be good enough for me to start playing again. I'm not sure what would get me to play again. It seems like I could get the stuff they're adding to the game from any number of games, just without the Star Wars IP. Games that are free to play.

Originally posted by mcburly

Good article and I totally agree. Once 1.3 hits and transfers are available this little rut the game is in will be over.