"Massively Multiplayer Online games are built around living, breathing worlds that are always evolving, and Star Wars™: The Old Republic™ is no different. "

This is how the introduction of patch 1.1.5 begins. I have to say I lol'd since the last thing you could say about TOR is that it includes a living breathing world which is always evolving. Is Bioware really so naive that they think their world can be described in this way?

Now I am not a hater, I am subbed to TOR and have been playing it off and on, although I will say I am one of the bitterly disappointed gamers that was expecting so much more than the shallow linear game Bioware served up which is only fun to play for about a month.

You could just say that you don't share in their opinion and shrug it off. Instead you run to the MMORPG.com forums to add one more thread to where no more are needed.

I don't understand how so many people on this forum can be dissapointed by SW:TOR.

It was clear before release what kind of game this was; a simplified singleplayer game with online elements tacked on. Not a reall mmorpg and not an open world.

A MMORPG , is all about, Gain lvl , gathering , evolve, and so on.

its the same as bread

A bread always contain Wheat , Water/milk, a bread is always a bread, you can just flavor it diffrently.

If you are looking for newthinking or something different , you might look for something completley different than a mmo.

You cant take away the basic ingredients for the MMO

Originally posted by djmtott

You could just say that you don't share in their opinion and shrug it off. Instead you run to the MMORPG.com forums to add one more thread to where no more are needed.

AMEN to that....

Originally posted by Ztekan

A MMORPG , is all about, Gain lvl , gathering , evolve, and so on.

its the same as bread

A bread always contain Wheat , Water/milk, a bread is always a bread, you can just flavor it diffrently.

 

If you are looking for newthinking or something different , you might look for something completley different than a mmo.

You cant take away the basic ingredients for the MMO

Isn't that exactly what Bioware did?

Taking away the basic ingredient for a mmo?

A living, evolving WORLD.

I mean WOW get's a lot of flack for being to simple and lineair but SW:TOR takes it to the next level.

Originally posted by djmtott

You could just say that you don't share in their opinion and shrug it off. Instead you run to the MMORPG.com forums to add one more thread to where no more are needed.

Last time I checked the point of a forum was to share views and opinions...   It's hardly the OP's fault that many others agree with him and have said these things before.  On the other hand, I suppose you could fault him for creating a new separate thread when it may have been better to add his disatisfied view to the end of an older negative thread...

Either way what does it matter?  Why are you so upset about people expressing their views?

Originally posted by Tawn47

Either way what does it matter?  Why are you so upset about people expressing their views?

^ only that horse thinks it just won the triple crown

Originally posted by thekid1

Originally posted by Ztekan

A MMORPG , is all about, Gain lvl , gathering , evolve, and so on.

its the same as bread

A bread always contain Wheat , Water/milk, a bread is always a bread, you can just flavor it diffrently.

 

If you are looking for newthinking or something different , you might look for something completley different than a mmo.

You cant take away the basic ingredients for the MMO

Isn't that exactly what Bioware did?

Taking away the basic ingredient for a mmo?

A living, evolving WORLD.

I mean WOW get's a lot of flack for being to simple and lineair but SW:TOR takes it to the next level.

 

A RPG, are all about live your char, that can be done by gain levels from 1 - ***

You gather materials/Gear/Reputation/Comendation/Levels/Freinds/Guild you name it.

Next thing you need are a place to RP in, in this case StarWars Univerese with all its Planets, there you gain levels/gather  and so on.

In wow for the next example,

You gain levels from 1-85/gather/Reputaion/gain Freinds//guilds/Gear and so on.

Now you need somewhere to RP, and there you got Aseroth

others MMORPG are the same,

Gather/so on and so forth/ ****/

And a place to RP.

Thats the concept of a RPG "MMORPG"

RPG comes from Penn and paper game, where the concept was born , and that was in the 80s wich i particepeted in.

If you change these settings of what a RPG are, you dont have a RPG anymore

Than you have Created a new for of style/game/gengre.

MMO just stands for Masivly multiplayer Online, wich emplays you are more than 128 players on the same Shard, more than 128 players counts as MMO, and RPG , is just Role Playing Game.

 

That said all games like Acherons Call, Ultima Online Wow Everquest 1-2 Starwars Galaxies Star Wars the old Republic Guild Wars , i can make the list long, comes from the same Ingredient wich is RPG, if you are looking for something els you arent looking for a RPG.

and by adding a forth pillar in swtor "Voiceover" still makes it a RPG, no different , it just have more flavor to it, you can put 10 or 100 or eaven 1000 new flavors to A game, its still a RPG

What Bioware did is just a flavor its still the basic like all other MMORPGs out there,

Originally posted by djmtott

Originally posted by Tawn47

Either way what does it matter?  Why are you so upset about people expressing their views?

Pretty much this....damn. 

This entire forum has become "SWTOR Blows!" and "GW2 Cures Cancer!"

Don't get me wrong, I love SWTOR and and excited for GW2...but damn, folks know there *are* other MMOs out there, right?

Originally posted by Naral

Originally posted by djmtott

Originally posted by Tawn47

Either way what does it matter?  Why are you so upset about people expressing their views?

Pretty much this....damn. 

This entire forum has become "SWTOR Blows!" and "GW2 Cures Cancer!"

Don't get me wrong, I love SWTOR and and excited for GW2...but damn, folks know there *are* other MMOs out there, right?

But have you played SWTOR?  It really does deserve it...

Originally posted by killion81

Originally posted by Naral

Originally posted by djmtott

Originally posted by Tawn47

Either way what does it matter?  Why are you so upset about people expressing their views?

Pretty much this....damn. 

This entire forum has become "SWTOR Blows!" and "GW2 Cures Cancer!"

Don't get me wrong, I love SWTOR and and excited for GW2...but damn, folks know there *are* other MMOs out there, right?

 

But have you played SWTOR?  It really does deserve it...

Yeah, and believe it or not, I actually have fun doing so. I don't really care that it gets a beat down, and folks don't like it, as long as I am having fun I will play it. But let me say this....I am a very casual player. As in, I play a lot of alts, and play a handful of hours a week. I have 4 characters in their 20s, and one 44. I know this game has little life at the end, so I am just treating it like a coop game I play with my wife, and its been a good time, so, meh.

That said, I am not going to defend it, I see the brown shining through the finish on this gilded turd, I am just getting tired of these forums being pretty much focused on it.

From my PoV, SWTOR is an unmitigated disaster area.  It feels empty and soulless and the PvP is a standing joke.

If this had been any other IP than Star Wars, it would have folded after the first month.

Endless debate and bashing, Endless debate and bashing, Endless debate and bashing, Endless debate and bashing, Endless debate and bashing, Endless debate and bashing, Endless debate and bashing, Endless debate and bashing, Endless debate and bashing, Endless debate and bashing, Endless debate and bashing, Endless debate and bashing,

This is how MMORPG feels these days, it gone beyond people reviewing its now a new game comes out and everyone likes it for a week then starts bashing the hell out of it, will be the same for GW2, and the only reason behind this is that the game isnt 100% what the person wanted.

*dead horse has been beaten get over it*

Originally posted by Naral

 

Yeah, and believe it or not, I actually have fun doing so. I don't really care that it gets a beat down, and folks don't like it, as long as I am having fun I will play it. But let me say this....I am a very casual player. As in, I play a lot of alts, and play a handful of hours a week. I have 4 characters in their 20s, and one 44. I know this game has little life at the end, so I am just treating it like a coop game I play with my wife, and its been a good time, so, meh.

That said, I am not going to defend it, I see the brown shining through the finish on this gilded turd, I am just getting tired of these forums being pretty much focused on it.

I understand your view point. 

But cause it IS basically "coop game" - is one of reason it get so much bad treatment on this (and some other ) forums.

I think you'll have to get used to it or find other forum. 

Originally posted by Ztekan

A MMORPG , is all about, Gain lvl , gathering , evolve, and so on.

its the same as bread

A bread always contain Wheat , Water/milk, a bread is always a bread, you can just flavor it diffrently.

 

If you are looking for newthinking or something different , you might look for something completley different than a mmo.

You cant take away the basic ingredients for the MMO

Exactly,

Just as videogames are about wandering the labyrints eating dots and escaping from ghosts.

You know, like Pac Man.

If you want something different , perhaps video games are not for you.

...i bet there were people thinking like this in 80s

Thanks god that , we had game companies willing to try and innovate.

Not like Bioware today....

Originally posted by Ztekan

A MMORPG , is all about, Gain lvl , gathering , evolve, and so on.

its the same as bread

A bread always contain Wheat , Water/milk, a bread is always a bread, you can just flavor it diffrently.

 

And just like some people think that all MMORPGs are like themeparks, some people think wheat is the only grain you can make bread of...

Originally posted by tom_gore

Originally posted by Ztekan

A MMORPG , is all about, Gain lvl , gathering , evolve, and so on.

its the same as bread

A bread always contain Wheat , Water/milk, a bread is always a bread, you can just flavor it diffrently.

 

And just like some people think that all MMORPGs are like themeparks, some people think wheat is the only grain you can make bread of...

 

+1 

Newsflash - bread does not have to have wheat and mmorpg does not have to have levels ,etc

Originally posted by tom_gore

Originally posted by Ztekan

A MMORPG , is all about, Gain lvl , gathering , evolve, and so on.

its the same as bread

A bread always contain Wheat , Water/milk, a bread is always a bread, you can just flavor it diffrently.

 

And just like some people think that all MMORPGs are like themeparks, some people think wheat is the only grain you can make bread of...

 

Well put sir, way to take a "half baked" analogy and add some relevance to it.