What do you think the rating of GW2 be a month after it is released?

I personally think it is gonna stay at a solid 9 at least.

Originally posted by Vaultar

What do you think the rating of GW2 be a month after it is released?

I personally think it is gonna stay at a solid 9 at least.

no way to tell in advance buddy..

Besides the usual trolls that will continously bash this game no matter how well or poor it does, I think the ratings will be pretty fair..I can see them dropping but not too far.

---

Originally posted by Vaultar
What do you think the rating of GW2 be a month after it is released?
I personally think it is gonna stay at a solid 9 at least.

---

well at least people wont be inclined to unsubscribe eh? so they have their player retention there :P

people say x game is not worth 15$/month so they unsub after the free month...

with GW2, if they think its not worth the 15$/month well they wont have to and still keep playing, 

(looks left and right, with a secret voice as if trying to hide something, in a sarcastic voice...) i think they are on to something

I'm sure it will have a lower rating than it has now. If it turns out to be bad, people will trash it. If it's good, it will be voted bad out of spite and fandom rivalry.

It's going to be high - the most recent release once GW2 drops will have been SWTOR - and with the non stop talk of it being the same ole same ole - just having a bunch of new / different things is going to be enough for many people to praise GW2 to the moon.  Looks like everything is really high quality - I will be surprised if it isn't consistently in the 90's.

I can easily see reviewers giving it 5/5 and 9-10/10.

Player reviews will probably be somewhat lower (you can´t please everyone and I fear some people are expecting stuff that just ain´t there), 8.5/10 maybe.

Still, I think it will be pretty high, ANET have some really good devs and for once we will get a MMO made by competent programmers, that is not a everyday thing. :)

Originally posted by Loke666

I can easily see reviewers giving it 5/5 and 9-10/10.

Player reviews will probably be somewhat lower (you can´t please everyone and I fear some people are expecting stuff that just ain´t there), 8.5/10 maybe.

Still, I think it will be pretty high, ANET have some really good devs and for once we will get a MMO made by competent programmers, that is not a everyday thing. :)

Yeah... we'll definitely see a lot of people racing to endgame and wondering "WHERE'S THE RAIDZ!?", insighting rage on the forums, scoring it a 0/10 on Metacritic, followed by rage quiting the game and then coming back to repeat the process in the next expansion.

Originally posted by Squal'Zell

well at least people wont be inclined to unsubscribe eh? so they have their player retention there :P

people say x game is not worth 15$/month so they unsub after the free month...

with GW2, if they think its not worth the 15$/month well they wont have to and still keep playing, 

 

(looks left and right, with a secret voice as if trying to hide something, in a sarcastic voice...) i think they are on to something

No lol,The trolls will have to say 'I uninstalled this game!'

It will drop. Maybe not much, maybe alot. But it will drop. They always do. Also dont forget you still have thoes people that think GW2 will be like nothing we have seen before. They think there will be NO themepark mechanics in the game and everything is the greatest innovation in MMO history. These people are going to be severly disapointed and will drop the rating. The bigger question to me is, how many of these delusional people are there?

Originally posted by Master10K

Originally posted by Loke666

I can easily see reviewers giving it 5/5 and 9-10/10.

Player reviews will probably be somewhat lower (you can´t please everyone and I fear some people are expecting stuff that just ain´t there), 8.5/10 maybe.

Still, I think it will be pretty high, ANET have some really good devs and for once we will get a MMO made by competent programmers, that is not a everyday thing. :)

Yeah... we'll definitely see a lot of people racing to endgame and wondering "WHERE'S THE RAIDZ!?", insighting rage on the forums, scoring it a 0/10 on Metacritic, followed by rage quiting the game and then coming back to repeat the process in the next expansion.

Lol, my thoughts exactly. :D

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TBtpyeLxVkI

It really depends on the magazine or webpage. My favourite print magazine will probably rate it like GW:EN, which was given a 9.3. PCGamer will probably give it a 9 or 9.8. Sometimes they are just hilarious.

On my personal record and based on what I've experienced myself, seen or read, I'll give it a 9.3 either. The major downsides would be no seamless world, which is not that important but relevant, and flaws in cutscenes. The biggest flaw there would be the fixed camera. I prefer close-ups and swapping cameras in dialogues. They add so much to them.

Originally posted by Vaultar
Hmm fair points guys :). But in terms of average user rating right here in this site, what would u predict the score to be for gw2 a month after its release ?

no matter how low it falls on this website, i think it could easily be higher than every game released and ranked on this website. Thats just my thought.

Will fall down as every game there will be % of people that will not like this game for certain reasons.

Some will not like that there are no macros / add-ons, some will not like lack of raids, some will not like lack of big gear progress.

Some will not like not-so-important crafting or lack of real player-made economy, etc

So rating will fall down, it still will be over 8.00 though.

Originally posted by Vaultar
Hmm fair points guys :). But in terms of average user rating right here in this site, what would u predict the score to be for gw2 a month after its release ?

It depends on if the game is good or not. Honestly, you can't prepredict this...