Well I see no reason why the scenario you laid out wouldn't be possible, with all the systems that are in place. We've seen proof that all the major feature (except WvWvW) are working as intended, so all that's pretty much left is the added polish and all the minor features.

As for me... my typical day in GW2 will be to log in, check who in my guild is online. Go to the nearest Asura Gate. Port to the Mist and have some unbalanced, large-scale, PvP fun.

til 80
level up doing whatever you do until 80, learn class/skills etc

at 80
queue for pvp arena
rage for 1-3 hours at random team mates or have fun with friends/guildmates, depending on who is online
log out
so the same thing I did in GW1 for 2 years ^_^

maybe run a dungeon if they actually turn out decent

Look a round, go where I wanna go.  Stumble across a situation and decide if I want to intervene.

Discover a group of players engaged in a battle. Help out and get rewarded.  Maybe we continue on or go our separate ways for the time being.

Gather some mats for crafting. Kill some things, make some new discoveries.  Randomly find some NPC's out in the world that need some things done.  Rally a few guildies to up the stakes and head back to town to shoot the breeze with some folks.

---

Originally posted by Enosh
til 80
level up doing whatever you do until 80, learn class/skills etc

at 80
queue for pvp arena
rage for 1-3 hours at random team mates or have fun with friends/guildmates, depending on who is online
log out
so the same thing I did in GW1 for 2 years ^_^

maybe run a dungeon if they actually turn out decent

---

You don't need to be 80 to do PvP, there is no queue, and your teammates aren't exactly random. No aspect of this game will be like GW1.

Well, i am an avid RP so ill be spending time in the cities of Tyria and meeting up with other RPers,I will also be journeying to far flung places.My guild will have many RP events and we will be doing alot of WvWvW plus plenty of DE/dungeons and city activities and games.

In the cities we will have certain buildings that we meet up in and chat that others don't frequent.

We will also have many secret meetings and talk about what dangers are happening in the world and what we can do to help turn the tide,the list goes on and on to be fare.

Originally posted by Shroom_Mage
You don't need to be 80 to do PvP, there is no queue, and your teammates aren't exactly random. No aspect of this game will be like GW1.

-I know, but getting a class to 80 is a good way to lear the mechanics of the game, how some skills work etc

-how you mean no queue, doesn't it do the matchmaking thingy?

-how you mean "aren't exactly random"? can't I simply say "I want to play arena throw me into a team" if my friends or guild mates aren't online?

Can't help thinking that I'll probably be saying a lot of:

'It's ok, I'm not stealing your kills / xp'

for a few days at least :)

Originally posted by Shroom_Mage

 

---

Originally posted by Enosh
til 80
level up doing whatever you do until 80, learn class/skills etc

 

at 80
queue for pvp arena
rage for 1-3 hours at random team mates or have fun with friends/guildmates, depending on who is online
log out
so the same thing I did in GW1 for 2 years ^_^

maybe run a dungeon if they actually turn out decent

---

 

You don't need to be 80 to do PvP, there is no queue, and your teammates aren't exactly random. No aspect of this game will be like GW1.

Not true. In lore and design philosophy, the games aren't dissimilar. But in mechanics, GW2 is far more comparable to a traditional MMORPG.

Plain old people watching in the open world will be entertaining in this game at times.  Just finding a nice spot with a view and watching what happens.

Originally posted by Serelisk

Not true. In lore and design philosophy, the games aren't dissimilar. But in mechanics, GW2 is far more comparable to a traditional MMORPG.

Yeah, it's worth noting that the design philosophy really hasn't changed much at all from one game to the other.  It's just the budget and programming solutions used have changed. :)

For example, the instancing was a cheap solution to anti-griefing and being able to affect the world.  Now they came up with dynamic events, which is a far more complicated, but simultaneously better solution. :)

GW2 is basically what happens if you're the people who do GW1 and you end up with more money/time and all the experience from GW1 (That's a large part of why the changes to the combat system, like the weapon swaps.  Apparently balancing GW1, biggest pain in the ass ever.  They're valiant for even trying to. :) ).

---

Originally posted by Meowhead
For example, the instancing was a cheap solution to anti-griefing and being able to affect the world.  Now they came up with dynamic events, which is a far more complicated, but simultaneously better solution. :)

---

And yet they make phased resource nodes. I wish they would've made their whole game a dynamic event and not just the questing. Maybe they will add/change that in the future. When I look at this game, sometimes I am more hyped for their first expansion than the vanilla haha.

Originally posted by Granrey

On this game there is no rush to level as there is not much implication for PVP and PVE. You still interact with your friends regardless of their level and so on, you don’t have to compete against other players and you don’t have to worry too much about high level content that you cannot see until you level up.

 

So, a typical day in GW2 might start by you sometime during the day, taking a look at you GW2 smart phone app or webbrowser (either at work, at school, at public transit, at the park, at party, etc) and see what events are going on, see what friends are doing/ interact with them and decide if you want to log in or when to log in.  You might simply decide not to log in but still you had you game experience.

 

Another time, you decide to log in, you probably know what you want to do since you already had a layout of whats happening with your phone app or web browser on computer.

Then, you start participating in those events that you were insterested in, regardless If your friends or guildmates are doing something else.

 

 Some unknown players are there............ Well, no worries about ksing, pking, player levels,  loot issues, player professions, how hard the event is (the events scale up or down). I don’t need to talk to stupid npc to pick up a quest. So, I start playing. Everybody is happy I’m there because the more players, the more epic the event is and more rewards (I might even get somebody saying: “Thx for joining in”).  I might even make some new friends.

 

If I end up not liking the event, I might leave it but still get some rewards and move to something else or finish the event and continue the event chain. I might even go and do some minigames.

 

I could end my PVE day. Doing what I want, when I want, how I want to do it, with who I want, up to when I want, get exps and rewards and think that I had fun and accomplished my day.

 

I could anytime do some PVP without worrying about being low level and not properly geared.

 

Now this is the question:

This sounds too good to be true, this sounds like an MMO Utopia. I like Anet but man even you guys have to admit this is hard to accomplish. I hope they do accomplish it.

 

Don’t get me wrong. I want this game to be as it is described by developers but man, they are setting the standard very high here. It makes me wonder.

 

Actually what you described above, especially in red, seems like a total snorefest.  I sure hope this is not what GW2 is planning on being.  Don't carebears have enough games out there?

---

Originally posted by gainesvilleg
Actually what you described above, especially in red, seems like a total snorefest.  I sure hope this is not what GW2 is planning on being.  Don't carebears have enough games out there?

---

Bro, like, just about every MMO has factions and PvP servers now. What are you talking about?

Originally posted by Shroom_Mage

 

---

Originally posted by gainesvilleg
Actually what you described above, especially in red, seems like a total snorefest.  I sure hope this is not what GW2 is planning on being.  Don't carebears have enough games out there?

---

 

Bro, like, just about every MMO has factions and PvP servers now. What are you talking about?

Don't want to start this debate here, but I strongly disagree with that.  Most MMO's are designed primarily around a PVE ruleset with PVP servers, as well as instanced PVP battlegrounds, very simplistically tossed in.  There are very very few games with a PVP ruleset truly integrated into the core game, such as EVE.

But looks like GW2 is taking the non-competetiveness in MMO's to a new low if what the OP described is accurate.  I haven't been folling GW2 as much as many here, so I'm hoping the OP just has not described accurately what GW2 is about...

Originally posted by gainesvilleg

Originally posted by Shroom_Mage

 

---

Originally posted by gainesvilleg
Actually what you described above, especially in red, seems like a total snorefest.  I sure hope this is not what GW2 is planning on being.  Don't carebears have enough games out there?

---

 

Bro, like, just about every MMO has factions and PvP servers now. What are you talking about?

Don't want to start this debate here, but I strongly disagree with that.  Most MMO's are designed primarily around a PVE ruleset with PVP servers, as well as instanced PVP battlegrounds, very simplistically tossed in.  There are very very few games with a PVP ruleset truly integrated into the core game, such as EVE.

But looks like GW2 is taking the non-competetiveness in MMO's to a new low if what the OP described is accurate.  I haven't been folling GW2 as much as many here, so I'm hoping the OP just has not described accurately what GW2 is about...

I'm all for opinions but stop talking before you [know] lol.

Originally posted by RizelStar

Originally posted by gainesvilleg

Originally posted by Shroom_Mage

 

---

Originally posted by gainesvilleg
Actually what you described above, especially in red, seems like a total snorefest.  I sure hope this is not what GW2 is planning on being.  Don't carebears have enough games out there?

---

 

Bro, like, just about every MMO has factions and PvP servers now. What are you talking about?

Don't want to start this debate here, but I strongly disagree with that.  Most MMO's are designed primarily around a PVE ruleset with PVP servers, as well as instanced PVP battlegrounds, very simplistically tossed in.  There are very very few games with a PVP ruleset truly integrated into the core game, such as EVE.

But looks like GW2 is taking the non-competetiveness in MMO's to a new low if what the OP described is accurate.  I haven't been folling GW2 as much as many here, so I'm hoping the OP just has not described accurately what GW2 is about...

I'm all for opinions but stop talking before you [know] lol.

I was responding to the OP, who was describing how GW2 would be.  And as he described it I would be very very unhappy in that game.  Without competition gaming is meaningless for me.  That is why I play games.  My real life is carebear enough I don't need it in my games!

Originally posted by gainesvilleg

Originally posted by Shroom_Mage

 

---

Originally posted by gainesvilleg
Actually what you described above, especially in red, seems like a total snorefest.  I sure hope this is not what GW2 is planning on being.  Don't carebears have enough games out there?

---

 

Bro, like, just about every MMO has factions and PvP servers now. What are you talking about?

Don't want to start this debate here, but I strongly disagree with that.  Most MMO's are designed primarily around a PVE ruleset with PVP servers, as well as instanced PVP battlegrounds, very simplistically tossed in.  There are very very few games with a PVP ruleset truly integrated into the core game, such as EVE.

But looks like GW2 is taking the non-competetiveness in MMO's to a new low if what the OP described is accurate.  I haven't been folling GW2 as much as many here, so I'm hoping the OP just has not described accurately what GW2 is about...

Sucks to be you then, bub. There's no open PvP in GW2, there's no KSing, there's no stealing, no ninja-ing, none of that. Everyone gets their own loot in dungeons, everyone gets full reward for beating up enemies so there's no KSing, people are rewarded for participating rather than getting the kill, and PvP is separate from PvE. GW2 is designed to be as anti-griefer as possible. By the way, the trend in games these days is exactly what you say it, PvP is generally separated from PvE because that's what the majority of gamers want. If you understand this, why are you suddenly surprised?

The original Guild Wars was no different, it's known for it's PvP and competitive gameplay because it's just that good, but that doesn't mean it's open and anyone can gank each other, or be complete dicks to everyone they come across. If anything, that should prove you don't need to PK in a game to prove you're a competent gamer.

As for your comment about carebears, the game is designed off the original Guild Wars, and adds some new conventions but generally sticks to the mold they established. Whether a subset of gamers already 'have enough games' is irrelevant, Guild Wars was never meant to be 'your' game. It is what it is, has long-since established its target audience. Gankers need not apply.

Originally posted by gaeanprayer

Originally posted by gainesvilleg

Originally posted by Shroom_Mage

 

---

Originally posted by gainesvilleg
Actually what you described above, especially in red, seems like a total snorefest.  I sure hope this is not what GW2 is planning on being.  Don't carebears have enough games out there?

---

 

Bro, like, just about every MMO has factions and PvP servers now. What are you talking about?

Don't want to start this debate here, but I strongly disagree with that.  Most MMO's are designed primarily around a PVE ruleset with PVP servers, as well as instanced PVP battlegrounds, very simplistically tossed in.  There are very very few games with a PVP ruleset truly integrated into the core game, such as EVE.

But looks like GW2 is taking the non-competetiveness in MMO's to a new low if what the OP described is accurate.  I haven't been folling GW2 as much as many here, so I'm hoping the OP just has not described accurately what GW2 is about...

Sucks to be you then, bub. There's no open PvP in GW2, there's no KSing, there's no stealing, no ninja-ing, none of that. Everyone gets their own loot in dungeons, everyone gets full reward for beating up enemies so there's no KSing, people are rewarded for participating rather than getting the kill, and PvP is separate from PvE. GW2 is designed to be as anti-griefer as possible. By the way, the trend in games these days is exactly what you say it, PvP is generally separated from PvE because that's what the majority of gamers want. If you understand this, why are you suddenly surprised?

The original Guild Wars was no different, it's known for it's PvP and competitive gameplay because it's just that good, but that doesn't mean it's open and anyone can gank each other, or be complete dicks to everyone they come across. If anything, that should prove you don't need to PK in a game to prove you're a competent gamer.

As for your comment about carebears, the game is designed off the original Guild Wars, and adds some new conventions but generally sticks to the mold they established. Whether a subset of gamers already 'have enough games' is irrelevant, Guild Wars was never meant to be 'your' game. It is what it is, has long-since established its target audience. Gankers need not apply.

So what you're saying is it almost an exact opposite of the PVP model of a game like, say EVE?

if so, probably not a good thing for me as I really enjoyed the conflict, the competion, the big risks for the big rewards.

Between you and the OP you're pretty much confirming that they'll be none of that, and if so, you are correct, its not my style of game and strangely enough, I'm a carebear at heart.

Originally posted by Kyleran

Originally posted by gaeanprayer

Originally posted by gainesvilleg

Originally posted by Shroom_Mage

 

---

Originally posted by gainesvilleg
Actually what you described above, especially in red, seems like a total snorefest.  I sure hope this is not what GW2 is planning on being.  Don't carebears have enough games out there?

---

 

Bro, like, just about every MMO has factions and PvP servers now. What are you talking about?

Don't want to start this debate here, but I strongly disagree with that.  Most MMO's are designed primarily around a PVE ruleset with PVP servers, as well as instanced PVP battlegrounds, very simplistically tossed in.  There are very very few games with a PVP ruleset truly integrated into the core game, such as EVE.

But looks like GW2 is taking the non-competetiveness in MMO's to a new low if what the OP described is accurate.  I haven't been folling GW2 as much as many here, so I'm hoping the OP just has not described accurately what GW2 is about...

Sucks to be you then, bub. There's no open PvP in GW2, there's no KSing, there's no stealing, no ninja-ing, none of that. Everyone gets their own loot in dungeons, everyone gets full reward for beating up enemies so there's no KSing, people are rewarded for participating rather than getting the kill, and PvP is separate from PvE. GW2 is designed to be as anti-griefer as possible. By the way, the trend in games these days is exactly what you say it, PvP is generally separated from PvE because that's what the majority of gamers want. If you understand this, why are you suddenly surprised?

The original Guild Wars was no different, it's known for it's PvP and competitive gameplay because it's just that good, but that doesn't mean it's open and anyone can gank each other, or be complete dicks to everyone they come across. If anything, that should prove you don't need to PK in a game to prove you're a competent gamer.

As for your comment about carebears, the game is designed off the original Guild Wars, and adds some new conventions but generally sticks to the mold they established. Whether a subset of gamers already 'have enough games' is irrelevant, Guild Wars was never meant to be 'your' game. It is what it is, has long-since established its target audience. Gankers need not apply.

So what you're saying is it almost an exact opposite of the PVP model of a game like, say EVE?

if so, probably not a good thing for me as I really enjoyed the conflict, the competion, the big risks for the big rewards.

Between you and the OP you're pretty much confirming that they'll be none of that, and if so, you are correct, its not my style of game and strangely enough, I'm a carebear at heart.

 

Are you guys somehow put off by the lack of ability to gank and grief other players?

If it's competition you want there are PVP modes, and the WvWvW that occurs in a separate huge map. 

Here's something I got from Sylvarii taken from http://www.mmorpg.com/discussion2.cfm/thread/337040/page/2:

Structured PvP:

"Hot join" games are the casual side of structured PvP. Hot join PvP can be played from 1v1 all the way up to 10v10.

Players can browse through a list of available games, each displaying the current map, the number of players, etc. Players can search by server population or friends list.

Tournaments are the more organized side of structured PvP. Tournament play is 5v5, but matches take place on the same maps that are used for hot join play. 


Pickup Tournaments: These single-elimination tournaments wait for 8 teams to join before starting. Once they start, they go through 3 rounds of eliminations, with winners receiving qualifier points. 

Monthly Tournaments: For monthly tournaments, you'll need a certain amount of qualifier points to join. 

Yearly Tournaments: These grand tournaments feature the winners from the monthly tournaments slugging it out for the right to call themselves the best PvP players of the year. 

Player-Run Tournaments: These tournaments will be customized by players, allowing for great flexibility and unique bragging rights. 

Guild Wars 2 PvP features different maps that all dramatically alter a single game type called Conquest. In the Conquest format, teams compete over a certain number of capture points. Holding a capture point and killing enemies improves your team's score. The first team to reach the score limit—or the team with the highest score when time runs out—wins the match. 

WvWvW PvP:

This is a game mode where 3 servers are pit against each other in a FFA across 4 persistent maps in a place off the world map called The Mists. This is joinable by anyone at any time, 24/7. Each battle lasts 2 weeks and the winner of the 3 servers then gets matched up with 2 other equally matched servers. A world's rank increases as it wins more often. During combat there is no direct way for these worlds to communicate with each other.

At launch there will be 1 map that is split into 4 maps, 1 map that is the home map for each server and in the center is a neutral center map. Each map has resources and objectives to capture, things like castles, fortresses, mercenary camps, mines, lumber mills and villages. These sites, with the management of their capture and defense, allow teams of all different sizes to find a way to participate.

For example, larger groups or guilds may take or hold keeps, while smaller group sizes or even individual participants might assist by disrupting supply caravans, weakening defenses, or capturing other objectives that will stop reinforcements. Maps will also be populated with defensively-oriented NPCs to set the pace of gameplay, but their presence is to allow defending players a chance to join in the defense as opposed to being a credible or reliable threat.

Resources gained from mines and lumber mills are used to rebuild walls, create siege engines, and generally defend the world's fortress. Once they move to the central map, players joining will start at their world's portal keep. From there they may continue to capture objectives while dealing with players from other worlds seeking to invade opposing home maps via the central map zone. Thus, play will travel between the central map and home maps as worlds gain and lose footholds such as keeps and strategic points that influence bonuses for their home world.

So all of the objectives in WvW use the Dynamic Event system. Say like your server takes over a mine, a new event will kick off to escort the minecart back to a nearby keep. Both of the other servers will have an event to destroy your minecart. If you get it back to a keep, your server then gains access to siege weaponry to use against your enemies.

World benefits

Territories and control points within the map will confer benefits to the world that controls them, such as faster energy/health regeneration, increased drop rate or increased experience gain for a time.

Individual rewards

Players can gain experience and level their character entirely in World PvP. Killing people in World vs World gives the player loot which means a player doesn't need to leave World PvP to get better gear.