Originally posted by Puremallace

So want to die laughing. So saw the live stream Pokket always does and she talked about how great the vocie overs were and how she felt so immersed. Watching her live stream she was space barring through every single one LULZ

 

lmao

---

Originally posted by Asamof

---

Originally posted by Puremallace So want to die laughing. So saw the live stream Pokket always does and she talked about how great the vocie overs were and how she felt so immersed. Watching her live stream she was space barring through every single one LULZ  

---

lmao

---

Originally posted by itgrowls

people who say these quests are really fun, are brainwashed. LOL they just have dialog that's the only difference is you have to listen to someone talking instead of reading. WoW big breakthru.  So let's see Reasons NOT to play SWTOR. same old end game gear treadmill check, questlines with a single kill ten rats goal check, pvp that's inconsequential to the overall world check. Hmmm. Let's be a little more honest folks, how many innovations are there REALLY and don't give me this crap about it being a storybased mmo, if it has mmo in the name and they want you to pay a fee to play, they had better deliver the innovations.

 

If you feel so strongly about it why don't you make a top 10 reasons NOT to play SWTOR.  You obviously don't like the game so you would be better qualified.  Just don't expect one from somebody who liked the game.  

I've been playing MMORPGs for the better part of 7 years & I've always had one complaint about them all.  No Immersion/connection to the story.  I couldn't keep playing them for very long cause I just can't get into the grinding/raiding/PVP as being the ultimate reward for playing well.  SWTOR changed that IMO,  there is immersion & I do want to find out what happens next in the story, something that up till now was there purview of single player games.

You may be right, it may not do anything different, but in this case it's all about presentation.  If it is no different then at least it does the same ole thing in a different & compelling way

2 reasons not to play: not getting the product key and disc when purchasing the product. LOL. 

If you feel so strongly about it why don't you make a top 10 reasons NOT to play SWTOR.  You obviously don't like the game so you would be better qualified.  Just don't expect one from somebody who liked the game.  

I've been playing MMORPGs for the better part of 7 years & I've always had one complaint about them all.  No Immersion/connection to the story.  I couldn't keep playing them for very long cause I just can't get into the grinding/raiding/PVP as being the ultimate reward for playing well.  SWTOR changed that IMO,  there is immersion & I do want to find out what happens next in the story, something that up till now was there purview of single player games.

You may be right, it may not do anything different, but in this case it's all about presentation.  If it is no different then at least it does the same ole thing in a different & compelling way

 

 

Problem is that "Story" Element You speak of Ends, then what are you going to do, reroll?  Why bother playing an MMO if thats your stance, Skyrim and dozens of other games offer the same experence without the monthly fee's.  IMO the goal of an MMO should be for the players themselves to create the story and in that way you never run out of content.  Of course that would require allowing players to have a real impact on the gameworld which no AAA MMO's have done to this point, so im not just picking on SWTOR here.      

---

Originally posted by tkoreaper
SWTOR is nothing without the SW IP... Also, you should at least sound more enthusiastic about the game. You can clearly tell that you're reading form a script... pretty horrible to be honest. It's almost as if someone's telling you what to say.

---

Awefull video review:(

Originally posted by bloodbone

If you feel so strongly about it why don't you make a top 10 reasons NOT to play SWTOR.  You obviously don't like the game so you would be better qualified.  Just don't expect one from somebody who liked the game.  

I've been playing MMORPGs for the better part of 7 years & I've always had one complaint about them all.  No Immersion/connection to the story.  I couldn't keep playing them for very long cause I just can't get into the grinding/raiding/PVP as being the ultimate reward for playing well.  SWTOR changed that IMO,  there is immersion & I do want to find out what happens next in the story, something that up till now was there purview of single player games.

You may be right, it may not do anything different, but in this case it's all about presentation.  If it is no different then at least it does the same ole thing in a different & compelling way

 

 

Problem is that "Story" Element You speak of Ends, then what are you going to do, reroll?  Why bother playing an MMO if thats your stance, Skyrim and dozens of other games offer the same experence without the monthly fee's.  IMO the goal of an MMO should be for the players themselves to create the story and in that way you never run out of content.  Of course that would require allowing players to have a real impact on the gameworld which no AAA MMO's have done to this point, so im not just picking on SWTOR here.      

 

Pushing the story in an MMO is the totally wrong direction to go in imo, especially the way bioware handled it (hamfisting ME'S dialogue wheel into an MMO). don't get me wrong, I love a good story, especially if a game does it well (chris avellone) but the last thing i'm looking for in the MMO genre is a story.

I mean it's a nice bonus, but I'd much rather see newer MMO's push the social interaction aspects of the gameplay, and how you're able to change and affect the world environment

Originally posted by bloodbone

If you feel so strongly about it why don't you make a top 10 reasons NOT to play SWTOR.  You obviously don't like the game so you would be better qualified.  Just don't expect one from somebody who liked the game.  

I've been playing MMORPGs for the better part of 7 years & I've always had one complaint about them all.  No Immersion/connection to the story.  I couldn't keep playing them for very long cause I just can't get into the grinding/raiding/PVP as being the ultimate reward for playing well.  SWTOR changed that IMO,  there is immersion & I do want to find out what happens next in the story, something that up till now was there purview of single player games.

You may be right, it may not do anything different, but in this case it's all about presentation.  If it is no different then at least it does the same ole thing in a different & compelling way

 

Problem is that "Story" Element You speak of Ends, then what are you going to do, reroll?  Why bother playing an MMO if thats your stance, Skyrim and dozens of other games offer the same experence without the monthly fee's. 

Because those games end too quickly.  There isnt a singleplayer game made these days that I can't finish in a week or less (mostly less).  besides, Skyrim sucks. </flameshield>  for the price of the box plus $15, I can play till I'm tired of it instead of till I run out of content.  Once I've finished the Sith Warrior story, I can start on Agent, then Bounty Hunter, etc.  I'm paying an extra $15 so that I can play in a persistent world with my friends for as long as I want.  

IMO the goal of an MMO should be for the players themselves to create the story and in that way you never run out of content.  Of course that would require allowing players to have a real impact on the gameworld which no AAA MMO's have done to this point, so im not just picking on SWTOR here.      

As you said, nobody does that & probably never will, not just the AAA's,  

 How would they?  All content is static no matter how interactive it may appear to be.  

 

A gypsy once told me never to trust anyone with blue hair.

That said, I think the #1 reason to play this game is because its New.

wow!  this text editor is alien,  I had to reformat my entire entry & it still added that weird empty box at the bottom....no wonder Pokket does video reviews, lol

Merry Christmas!

Another great video Pokket. And...Merry Christmas!

Standard Loot=White/Grey

Better then Standard is Green....

Next is Blue...

Guessing Purple is better then Blue?

90% of game = you watching cutscenes(story lines) and running. ...alot of running..

I want to play..not watch/listen to the game.

LOLZ  @ the hate :) Im an mmo veteran and i know this will take off like a rocket after playing the betas. The story driven thing worx and already there are millions of noobs queue-ing in desperation to get their fill of it. I rather enjoyed for once playing an actual story instead of hunting 10 pigs for westfall stew. it refreshing fun and fresh. I have had my fill of grinding and repetative go there kill that bring that quests. really really this is better. If you dont like it stuff off lolz. The warfronts work, the instances do too and im sure the raids will be fun aswell. Now leave me alone and let me plan about how to make time for the thingz that count  :  Tor, rift, skyrim, lol, other...... 

Originally posted by moosecatlol

Wait... tough calls? I thought you could always press escape and pick your answer again, sounds like an immersion breaker to me. Personally the animations are the immersion breaker in my opinion, but that's why I would never play an mmo solely for the questing. No mmo has dedicated a motion capture team to their npc quest givers. Rather they seem to be focusing more on facial animation, while leaving the rest of the body looking like a robot.

I also disagree with someone saying that this game is Star Wars, I personally don't see the "Wars" part of the game. I'm slightly baffled as to why any developer who is creating a game about war would opt for such a passive and non kinetic combat system.  Also when you're participating in the Alderaan warzone, why must they go the round about way to elminate the enemy cruiser? And why do the cruisers insist on taking the punishment from said turrets? Why not temporarily disable the turrets and broadside the enemy flagship?

I don't know, the fact that I have 150 questions about the integrity of the game's IP when you use it in such fashion that reduce Lightsabers to nothing more than big rave sticks, in which you use to beat each other  into submission with... well it' s a little disheartening.

 

After watching this videohttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RDMxQcg5bTA (Alderaan WZ PVP), I can safely say that this does not feel like war in the least.

 

Something else that Pokket touched point on, is that when you choose your "alignment" through out the numerous quest "multiple choice questions" that they offer you through out the game, you're working towards certain rewards from vendors that unlock the more progressed you are in your alignment. Now to me that seems like they're forcing you to choose either Light or Dark, and that you will be inferior for being indifferent. Which will directly effect a players decision through out his or her personal quest experience. Doesn't that completely diminish the purpose of the whole unique quest experience, when every other Joe and Curly are going to be selecting the choices that reward the most alignment points of their desire? That is hardly what I would call immersive. So if the game doesn't offer immersion (at least for me it never will), then what does it offer?(Yes I understand there is a Neutral path, but there hasn't been any neutral requirement gear vendor implemented yet, or so I've gathered from the forums, considering the stats on the aligment gear, your easily set at a disadvantage if you're unable to use them.)

Who am I kidding, there's probably 500 users on MMORPG that love a good gear treadmill. But if you break the game down to its core, is that all it is? A book to read as you run on your treadmill?

Maybe one day I'll understand what all the hype is about, but for now I'm going to turn up the "Feed Me" as loud as I can, and  go make breakfast.

 

lol I bet that you also don't see the war part of the movies too untill the sudden bam there your in the middle of it I'm sorry to tell you but the movies also have the non war elements why should the game  focus on it solely but then your probly someone who want nothing but a PVP life in a starwarish enviroment. as for chooseing to stick with an alignment hell any game you point out also does the same thing when there is a choice will force you to pick a side and stick with it if you want the goodies the only benefit for being indesicive and indifferent is you might get some neutral quest. and that is true with any game. I personally liked the way biowar did lots of things in the game to make you feel like you were acomplishing something instead of spending hundreds of hours grully grinding to get that next lvl so you can hit max lvl and say hey I'm here now what do I do and end up farming so you can buy that tier 12 armor and weapon set and show how much you  suck for haveing no life. by the way pokket I liked your review and many of your reasons you will play  I have too shared even though my time playing swtor was only a couple days dureing the stress test phase before the release. and then I was extreamly skeptical about it until I got in the game.now my only thing I'll have to worrie about is getting my subscribtion fees together in time lol.

Listing what is predominantly single player quests as the main reason to play an MMORPG shows a clear lack of understanding of the genre.

Originally posted by forest-nl

 

---

Originally posted by tkoreaper

SWTOR is nothing without the SW IP... Also, you should at least sound more enthusiastic about the game. You can clearly tell that you're reading form a script... pretty horrible to be honest. It's almost as if someone's telling you what to say.

---

Indeed horrible and i think she is just payed to say this thats also obvious.

 

Awefull video review:(

 

agree

Originally posted by Yamota

Listing what is predominantly single player quests as the main reason to play an MMORPG shows a clear lack of understanding of the genre.

 

I think that they understand the genre perfectly,  that's why they went a different direction.  In case you didn't notice, the genre is in danger of failing.   You are pervectly entitled to your opinion, but I for one am grateful that that something has finally come out that can succeed, even you don't like it.  It makes it a vaiable investment for others to make new MMOs instead of the genre dying with WoW,  which was what was happening, IMO.  

Is it perfect?  No, there are things I would have done differently (if I were a brilliant game designer instead of some shlub who plays them all day, lol) like the space combat (why?? Bioware, WHY???) .  I also hear that there is something wrong with the PVP but since I'm a PVE player I'm not aware or qualified.   

I know that some people are determined not to like this game,  were hating on it even before is went into beta.  I blame the agressive marketing (hype from hell).  I admit, I was put off by this too,  nobody likes having a product crammed down their throat no matter how good it is.  for a while there it completely took over the forums too,  People just got tired of hearing about it.  I have a friend that would be a perfect match for SWTOR but refuses to play simply because he doesn't like EA (plus he's a bitter SWG Vet).  there are all sorts of reasons for the hate that have absolutely nothing to do with the game itself.

My message to that guy that is combing these posts trying to decide whether or not to buy the game,  well you know what I think, so I'll just say this: don't listen to the hate & don't listen to the hype,  watch Pokket's channel & decide for yourself if that is something that you want to play