Not harsh enough IMO.  

Where did you mention the lack of class balance when it comes to PvP?  That was one of the reasons so many people left in droves (among many other reasons).  

Look, the game wasn't terrible and had some interesting features, but when one side dominates to such an extent in PvP, the opposing side leaves/quits and thus you have a massive decline in PvP activity, and then another server merge.  It's a cycle that just keeps repeating itself.

I suppose recommending the endless free trial is something (since it's free), but that's about it.

the last thing that drove me away from this game was change of my approach from "hey, it has really cool and fast pvp" to "oh hey, theres nothing more to this game than endless repetitive pvp" because lets face it... pve sucks, since its practically impossible to find someone to play with and RP is basically nonexistent

Originally posted by marinrider

Originally posted by bumuscheekus

I can summarise the important points here:

 

Pros: Endless free trial that caps at end of Tier1 (level 15) 

 

Cons: Small player base outside Tier 1

 

In conclusion, as long as you don't mind a slight limitation in content, play it for free and enjoy nearly constant Tier 1 rvr. Win win. To be honest, I never enjoyed the transition into Tier 2 anyway since everyone and his grandmother gets knockbacks which makes combat a fairly frustrating affair being bounced about the place every time you try to cast a heal.

I got capped exp wise at Level 10, but I can finish T1 though.

 

Ah right, haven't played recently, I recall they had extended T1 to level 15 though. 

To a certain extent I respect what they tried to do at launch. In the final analysis, the game has diminishing returns but it is good for a bit of mindless hangover rvr'ing. Since the utterly souless pve element is unplayable for all but the most forgiving (or braindead) and since the BGs that open with the tiers don't exactly blow ones mind with advancing novelty (not to mention the fact that keep captures these days mainly entail watching resource carrier NPCs run between point A and point B) I would argue that you'd pretty much seen everything there was to see in the game in T1 and what remained certainly isn't worth a monthly sub.  

Played it at launch, it was shit.

Played it a year later, cuz I was bored, well it was still even more shit.

Played it again another year later, cuz i was bored, now i learned if i'm ever bored again dont go back to this game, cuz it just shit.

I dont need to tell what part is bad about the game because, mostly all aspects are - best pvp? lol the realm pvp are people sitting afk in zones to get free points, the biggest faction own their oppasite factions town 24/7 .. best PVP u guys call it? hardly .. more or less the worse excuse for a good pvp game. If you wanna waste time, play this.

Originally posted by Maleus666

Warhammer is the best MMORPG ive been played.  This game isn't for those fanboys from WoW. Really, I tried WoW but it so retarded. For those who love PvP, never will forget the adrenaline seeing the timer going down when you get in a pvp lake.

I miss War so much, and I hope to get back to this game next year :)

 

 While you try to look cool, using the common term of "Im cool cuz i hate WoW" - If you, kid, had tried any of the old MMORPG based on PVP you would laugh at this clueless attempt. Mythic Entertainment, made a game long ago, DAOC that was a serious PVP game, why? 3rd faction .. and hundred other thing.

They made a game year before this that was awesome, now they made this EA speedprduction shit while they have the talent to make a good game.

Nah - try some of the old pvp game, UO/DAOC beofer you raise finger at wow-players.

I came back a month or two ago, and found myself in a difficult way. I was RR 53 in T4. Now, even if the RR cap had stayed at 80,  I'd have some work to do. But now, with RR 100 being the limit, T4 is extremely frustrating. The baseline for being even mildly competitive is RR 70, so you can grab your Worn Soveriegn gear (which is why no one does Scens in T2 and T3, to maximize RR and repress XP gain). I struggled through to RR 61, full Warlord, several better iterations of my weapons, and still get hammered on if I am not careful. The best I can do is mill around the back to defend healers, not up in the kill zone where I should be.

It may not be so bad for ranged/casters, but a low RR melee combatant like myself really feels the gulf. I could grind 9 more RR for full Worn Soveriegn, but, honestly, that would only let me live another 2 seconds. Essentially, for me, the game can only really start now at RR 70.

But, I have to admit, when I can find that rare enemy that has comparable gear to me, I enjoy beating them.

I'm surprised Som missed the biggest reason why I don't go back, though he may not have played it long enough to notice.

Once you get to T4 - end game - the grind to get competative gear is absolutely ludicrious and it's only superceded by the disparity between players in R100 gear, and you on your fresh Level 40, R30-50 character. I've seen videos of a low gear Bright Wizard unloading on an AFK R100 gear Chosen, and the Bright Wizard dies first because of his classes Burnout mechanic before he can deal enough damage to kill the Chosen.

It drove me away about a year ago and from what I understand, nothing has been done to fix it.

Patch 1.2  April the 3rd 09 was the beginning of the end for this game.

balancng faction population by nerfing one faction and buffing the other leads to max exodus, then add the Failure of Land of the Dead, and the Raid crowd hammering Mythic  for  20 man dungeons, wasn't this game suppose to be a War and not a raiding extranvaganza?

anyways if SWTOR kills it, i doubt Mythic/EA/BioWare will do the F2P thing with it. they'll kill it and let everyone play the second class F2P game Wraith of Heros and hope some company wants to pay big bucks for the IP some day in the future to recoup their loses

You guys should try Realms Online (also known as Regnum Online). It has faction RvR PvP just like Warhammer but there is ALWAYS combat going on in the war areas. I have never been logged in where there hasn't been people fighting in RvR. Beats the pants of Warhammer.

I'm a current subscriber.  Coming up on my one year anniversary.

I LOVE the game and play at least two hours daily.   But the key things that keep me coming back are:

1) 4 months ago, I found a terrific group of people / guild.  [ Shout-out to "Krit Happens" (Order) and "Hammer Kult" (Destro)! ]

2) The huge number of character classes, plus the fact that each one has three different "paths" of mastery skills you can go with, makes each character quite interesting to play. 

Yes, there are days when I wish there were more people online.  But those days are rare.  I really don't have any problem with a zone only having only 10-20 people in it.  You can still have some pretty intense fights and zone-struggles with those numbers.  And there are MANY when EACH side has roughly 48 people in that zone.

The thing I don't like is how quite often the BALANCE of those numbers is clearly out-of-whack.  There are days when it's the Destro Zerg steamrolling over 4 Order players.   And there are days when Order has that Zerg and it's hard to find a Destro player to throw a stick at.   

Another example of that is the current "Live Event".  There are something like 10 objectives you have to complete in order to finish it.  Well, I think three of the objectives require a particular scenario to pop.  We're playing Tier 2 right now nightly and that scenario just is NOT popping.  Scenarios, again, require a number BALANCE between the sides... or at least something reasonably CLOSE.

That's the part that can be a real drag....low enough numbers to cause a huge imbalance between the Factions.   So perhaps opening up the game to F2P would help that situation. 

That and I DO wish there was more reason to do PVE... because whenever I do go do some PVE, I find the game world to be very, very interesting.   Some of it is truly gorgeous and some of the towns and their "problems" (PVE story line) are interesting.

Even if they go F2P, I would probably continue to pay monthly, because I'm having tons of fun every night and I don't want any limits imposed on my favorite toon:    ShammyDavisjnr (Shammy...errr....Shaman) !!