Aion, 7.5 or 8 out of 10

LOTRO 8 or 9 out of 10

 LotRO: 8/10: Graphics are great, community is excellent. Gameplay and story are fun. But i just can't seem to get into it, i resubbed like 6 days ago and at first i couldn't wait to log in and now i'm like meh, i'm gonna go play some Counter Strike. 

EVE: 9.5/10: Not playing right now thinking of resubbing. Played a year ago the only problem i had was how hard it is to get a start, but once you get past that it's a great, well rounded game. 

Fallen Earth - 9/10

i like the graphics, the crafting, the world etc etc etc - so much to do and see - and just so darn fun to play

might have been a 10 but there are bugs of course and my current decent computer does struggle to run it - got a new one on the way though (ATI Radeon HD 5870  with a 3.4GHz Phenom II, whoohoo)

DDO - 8/10

good looking game and the dungeons all seem unique - nice going

Everquest 2     9/10 for content.        Visuals getting dated though brings it down to 7.5

Was playing EQ2 free trial till yesterday.  Would give it a 6/10.  It felt like the "same old" as I've felt in every other game.  I tried making different characters but in the end the animations didn't feel really fluid, and the game overall felt a bit rigid.  That and I've also come to a conclusion that I could never give SOE my money.

EvE (not playing for a while but...) - 9/10

Fallen Earth - 7/10 ( crafting, crafting, crafting, I like it )

Lord of The Rings 8/10 ( great PvE, I like Ettens too )

D&D - 7/10 ( its good, balanced, fun(+1)  )

The Chronicles of Spellborn - 7/10 ( unique combat system(+1), lore(+1) so its 8ish ) 

EQ 7/10  - outdated graphics/controls

WoW 8/10   - game goes by to fast

Vanguard 7.5/10  - weak pvp and  not  enough people play

Currently playing :

WoW 8

AoC 7

D&D 7

Lotro - 8  I like the look and feel of the game, also the quests.

Everquest 2- 8 Sadly im a sucker for housing and I feel Everquest 2 did it better. I do not like that is not in a neighborhood but I like everything else. Aslo being in a good guild helps.

My active subs ( so many mostly couse I tend to go for annual subs or such with bonuses at releases ) :

Star Trek Online - 6/10 It has outstanding potential and with the regular updates and new content I think it will be one of the more complete game experiences offered anywhere....once day.  In the mean time I got to lvl cap in first month, started doing dailies and got bored.

Age of Conan - 9/10 Now, after the two years or so that have passed, after all the crap got fixed, after the content gaps got filled.  WOW, just wow, what a beautiful game. http://www.youtube.com/MrGunbad

Lord of the Rings - 5/10 Nothing but more of thesame all the time since launch.  If you like lotr you might really liek this though.

Fallen Earth -  8/10 Solid game core, outstanding idea, fallout online ftw ;)  They need to start adding PvE content, and FAST.

Champions Online - 4/10 I don't even wan tot comment.  TOTAL LACK OF SUPPORT.  I mean, any, at all, ever, it is a joke.  The game has enough content to keep you busy for about of 2 weeks of casual play.

I played everything out there as far as pay to play mmorpgs.  Out of the ones I am playing right now I would easily highly recommend Age of Conan.

wow 9/10 great game great pve imbalanced pvp and not much to do during down time

darkfall 9/10 great game has some ironing out to do and is too time consuming.

meanwhile I wait for APB,Catclysm, and GW2 

 Fallen Earth 8/10 , cause of a few bugs and a bit weird animation at times , other than that it is a breath of fresh air , nice game and a great developers team , those guys are doing a great job .

EVE Online 9/10 , need to take a break though been playing for a few years .

 Fallen Earth: 9/10. It is addictive and the openess is wonderful along with what might be the best indie company out there since I no longer consider CCP indie.

EVE 9.5/10. If the pve was better would be the perfect 10. CCP continues to impress with how they treat their first born and the community is one I am proud to be part of.

Star Trek 5.5/10 great graphics and gameplay is good but lacks all the fun stuff

Fallen Earth 6.5/10 but definate potential. Keeping my account active and will play occasionally

Darkfall 8/10 Active account love the tension the open pvp gives ya. The game has its flaws but over all game play experience is damn fun. Like playing with serial killers but fun.

Champions online exact same as star trek ... It's a butter gameplay .. everything is nice butter gameplay.:)

I really prefer mmorpgs compared to all other style of games. I've tried them all. Had Altitess on all of them Darkfall prevents that for me game only allows one toon per account which is a great thing because of the amount of time it takes to make one toon great make you really wanna make it just right.

If you get Darkfall join a clan it's a must.

Let's see. Sadly each of these game will never go above 8 because of one flaw or another, the main one being a lack of an alternate progression model. That being said here is my list of games I've been playing and my rating.

LOTRO: 8/10 - Awesome lore, graphics, combat, community. I play less and less though as my character is capped and I really wish they would make a new alternate progression system to keep my entertained.

WAR: 5/10 - Game is far too shallow, but with the play forever first tier the game gives a small dose of casual quick combat play every now and then.

AoC: 6/10 - I keep popping back into this one hoping enough has changed, most times it hasn't, but I do see the sweet expack coming down the road which will hopefully bring this rating to an 8 or more.

Eve: 8/10 - Love the concept, lore, setting, graphics but having to wait for skills over time sucks, and lack of any true ACTION to combat keeps this game below 9. That and I hate forced PVP.

Vanguard 7/10 - Much better game these days than at launch, suffers from lack of players making all that group content at low to mid game obsolete. I can't even solo quest to level cap which would have made this game awesome. Stuck at level 22 and getting annoyed because I can't go any further. Still, best class design in an MMORPG I've seen in a long time. Each one is truly unique.

EQ2 - 6/10 - So much content, yet far to much instancing, character models move far to fast, and for the sheer amount of classes I really don't feel unique in each and every one. They feel far too similar. They need to take a page out of Vanguard's playbook for awesome class design.

Allods Online. Ranking it against p2p models its a solid 8/10. Ranking it against other f2p games its a 10/10. My opinion of course.

WAR 9/10. They have done alot of small things that have really made this much better than it was at launch; and fighting other players has never been more fun, balanced, and easy to get into. Tier 1 just rocks.

Eve 6/10. Great graphic update, shame I have to have so much clutter on the screen to play. Still feels like a solo game to me though. Be nice if fights were slightly more fun than target and fire - but maybe I just haven't got far enough into the game in fairness.

LOTR 7/10. Great story, needs groups to do a lot of quests and traits grinding appeared to be the worse thing ever :(