| 71 posts found | |
|---|---|
|
10/16/09 11:24:21 AM#26
High ratings aren't just an example of mmorpg.com fanboy write ups. A lot of review sites have been doing this for a while outside of mmos as well. It's been talked about on various forums, internet radio shows for gaming as to whether or not review sites even have any credibility anymore. I certainly do not make decisions to buy games off of reviews from some jobber that makes a little cash to fluff up a game or trash it. I do not respect any review of an mmo unless the write up is from someone that hit level cap. I really don't care if I think it's the greatest game in the world and the reviewer raved about it. That's just how I feel on it and have always felt on it. Especially in a game like Aion where every 10 levels all the way to 50 changes the course and pace of the game. |
|
|
10/16/09 11:25:10 AM#27
You know all this bitching and moaning is starting to look like what happened when WoW came out. Just a coisidence?......hhmmmmm. Currently playing: |
|
|
10/16/09 11:26:29 AM#28
Gameplay videos are 100000x better then reviews imo. www.youtube.com ftw!
|
|
|
10/16/09 11:31:58 AM#29
Originally posted by Cammy
Well, thanks to you for my evening laughs.
I am not 'bitching' about the game, which I think is good, but about the half-assed review. |
|
|
10/16/09 11:32:44 AM#30
Originally posted by dstar.
Agreed completely. |
|
|
10/16/09 11:51:51 AM#31
Originally posted by bastii Wow... Do you really care that much? Kinda sad.
|
|
|
tryklon
 Advanced Member
Joined: 7/17/06
"The flow of time is cruel...its speed seems different for each person, but no one can change it..." |
10/16/09 11:55:25 AM#32
Originally posted by DevilXaphan
Indeed, have been noticing that myself. I think we may have a contender here. The fact is that the servers are blooming with activity, the big fortress capture are already taking place, ppl are evolving and we are all having great fun. This review changes nothing in the way i play and enjoy Aion, and if he has awarded it 4 out of 10 it would be the exact same thing. The wave of hatred around this game just shows how successfull its becoming, and like many people are already noticing, its happening the exact same thing that happened with Warcraft, a wave of haters vs a wave of lovers bitching about it on the forums.
The fact is, like Oscar Wilde once said: “The only thing worse than being talked about is not being talked about.” So, thank you all for making Aion the prime subject of discussion nowadays in the entire MMO market =) we couldnt have done it without you
|
|
10/16/09 12:16:58 PM#33
Pretty sure it's just the prime discussion of the Aion sub forums on the mmorpg.com site. Haha. Because nowhere else do I see Aion being heavily discussed that I visit, except for Aion fan sites and other Aion sub forums. No hate on Aion though it's a good game. |
|
|
10/16/09 12:25:25 PM#34
It cracks me up that people get all worked up because Aion got a good review here....Are your lives that boring that you take video games so seriously? I mean come on folks, its the best pvp MMO out there right now imo . And no I'm not a fanboi, I'm just realistic. When will you all grow up? When you retire? LOL
"Kings of typos" ^^ EDIT: typo... AKA "Hater of haters" |
|
|
Pharoin
 Novice Member
Joined: 11/20/04
Everyone wants to go to Heaven but no one wants to die! |
10/16/09 12:50:08 PM#35
I am directing this to all the negative for no good reason repliers. Ignorance is what makes people have closed minds. Why do u give a freaking fudge about the score he game so bad. Is it because it can lead to other people playing a game that u didnt like? Or is it that it pains u to know that your opinion is not held by others who have an affect on another gamer? If u have such a problem then why u become a writer and spew your hate yourself and stop trying to hurt another persons career as a writer with your allegations of him receiving money or being biased. U have no idea about his or her bank account or what's in his mind. He may truly think it deserves a 8.7. Who are u to tell us his his opinion is wrong? I disagree with the OP saying that the other games have to catch up but thats only because the success over time of some of the titles not because my opinion of the games or fun factor. I could have easily taken the caveman route and said Aion is bad and W.O.W is good or vice versa. Basically what i'm saying is monday morning quarterbacks dont receive sign on bonuses. They just open there mouths and talk about shoulda coulda and woulda's while the real quarterback's play the game and put their careers on the line. So which do u think u are? |
|
10/16/09 1:30:17 PM#36
Originally posted by Pharoin
There is nothing wrong everyone with having an opinion, its how you voice it and how it comes across to others that matters. The best saying I ever head "When you assume, you make an ass out of you and me." To say this reviewer did an inside job, it not only disrespectful but its flat out wrong with no facts to base your claims on, other then you don't agree with his opinion. I like the game, have a 30 Cleric and I enjoy not rushing to the end and I like the grind I don't need to be max level and eat up all the content in a month cause I have ADD lol.......The gameplay is great, the animation is smooth the art is breath taking at times and most of all its FUN!!! 8.7 is imo too high, I would say around 8.4 to 8.6 if they can fix the rubber banding and some lag issues with large scale raids and add more PvE content(quests and such). |
|
|
10/16/09 2:33:57 PM#37
Originally posted by Ethian
You miss the point. I don't care how good or bad Aion is, what puts me off is the unprofessional review. I expected more from MMORPG.com. |
|
|
10/16/09 2:36:06 PM#38
Originally posted by Pharoin
I think that my main qualm, probably shared by others, is how unprofessional the 'review' is. Being an Aion subscriber myself, I see the review as misleading and a discrediting factor to MMORPG.com, not like this site was review Mecca before, but this is just over the top. |
|
|
10/16/09 2:38:22 PM#39
Originally posted by macmall
I have to respectfully disagree here. The fact that the reviewer chose to ignore all the flaws, especially the lack of endgame content is simply not what I expect of an official review. |
|
|
10/16/09 2:38:31 PM#40
Originally posted by Hrothmund
Really what was so unproffessional about it?. Currently playing: |
|
|
10/16/09 2:39:57 PM#41
Originally posted by DevilXaphan
Really what was so unproffessional about it?. Maybe have a gander at my post history in this thread before retorting with such a pointless post. |
|
|
10/16/09 3:20:41 PM#42
Originally posted by Hrothmund Maybe have a gander at my post history in this thread before retorting with such a pointless post.
In the five minutes of reading this thread you manage to troll the last 2 pages efficiently congrats.
This game to me is a breath of fresh air. I havn't been able to casually play a game like this since WoW. I personally like the atmosphere better then WoW and the pvp is top notch. To me this game strives for something different but on the same platform. Its like comparing one FPS to another. These are all MMORPGS but Aion is a different breed. It cannot be compared to WoW. Ya dig?
Just sayin |
|
|
10/16/09 3:23:14 PM#43
The post above me has nothing to do with anything this thread is about. |
|
|
10/16/09 3:23:53 PM#44
Originally posted by Nasir64
So I am trolling, eh? Please enlighten me as to by what definition. Do you honestly believe the reviewer had ample endgame experience and longevity of play to give the game a 8.7? I play Aion, it is a good game, but definitely NOT worth the 8.7. |
|
|
10/16/09 3:24:24 PM#45
My whole point. Non of these posts have anything to do with this thread. |
|
|
10/16/09 3:25:13 PM#46
Originally posted by Nasir64
You, my friend, are lost. Drop the crack pipe and seek some help. |
|
|
Czzarre
 Novice Member
Joined: 9/10/07
MMORPG Character Monuments ...When its time for your character to take a well deserved rest... |
10/16/09 3:30:11 PM#47
Not sure if I am able, but pulling the thread more on topic. I mentioned this in another thread already. I do not like using numbers in my reviews. Scales are always arbitrary yet give the impression that there is some underlying objective/numerical basis for the scores. The best reviews in my mind (and I try to emulate) are those that dont rate a game's feature but explains the system and then discusses why it works or why it doesnt. |
|
10/16/09 3:32:06 PM#48
Originally posted by Hrothmund
You, my friend, are lost. Drop the crack pipe and seek some help.
Hmm maybe if you wasn't mashing the f5 button crazily waiting for a reply. Hence troll. Personally it doesn't mater what the guy rated the game in his review. I rate it high as well. Higher then a lot of MMO's that have came out recently. Does that make me a liar or biased?
Just sayin. |
|
|
10/16/09 4:01:06 PM#49
Metacritics.com lists 19 Aion reviews. 37% of those reviews give Aion higher score than mmorpg.com review, and 63% give lower score. More than 50% of those reviews are between 80% - 89%. If you don't like the reviews, it's easiest to pretend that they don't exists. Or if you feel like it, you can always argument on how reviewers generally give too high scores. But attacking mmorpg.com reviewer personally and calling him unprofessional because he's given Aion similar score as other reviewers have is just pathetic. If anything, the score is an indication that he has done good and professional job with his review. Link to Aion review list at Metacritic: www.metacritic.com/games/platforms/pc/aionthetowerofeternity |
|
|
10/16/09 4:03:38 PM#50
who cares the majority think the games good and that should be enough for people. If you like it awesome if you don't there are plenty of other games out there. |
|
