Originally posted by Laserwolf
I heard Eragon is weak and very very cliche. I thumbed through it in a bookstore and it was very obvious a kid wrote it.

I picked up the first book for exactly that reason.  I had heard over and over again how amazing it was that a kid wrote the books.  Once i started reading I just assumed that I had misunderstood people.  I guess they were just amazed that the kid had gotten his work published so early, I thought they meant that it was amazing that a kid wrote something that good.

Which it isn't.

Good that is.

Eragorn takes just too much ideas from the "Dragon Riders of Pern" Chronicles, which are so much better, Harry Potter isn't half bad, and the third I didnt read so wouldnt know.

Originally posted by slish

---

Originally posted by Vertex1980

Harry Potter has good books.  A lot of people bash em because it's Harry Potter, but if you actually read the first few books, they are great.  Once the movies started to come out, the books started to change (knowning it will be turned into a movie) and got worse.

WTG Hollywood.

---

i know what you mean i mean the 4th book rock but when the 6th book came out dumbldore died

Cute.. thanks for that.

It's like when I watched a pirated Die Hard 4 a while back. Whoever it was that pirated the movie, decided to edit the video and placed a book spoiler on TVs during certain scenes. So instead of seeing the background "news video" on the televisions, it would show the spoiler in white text on black background.

It was like... hmm.. okay, thanks.

3 year old thread resurrection. Good job.

 I don't read these books. I'll say nothing else.

Edit: Also, I think we've got ourselves a troll, or an over-enthusiastic kid on our hands.

I didn't resurrect the thread, it was up top just now from some reply. Decided to read through and found that little spoiler mine.. made a decision to comment, etc.

God vote for Eragon ok why is harry potter better then eragon?

Why harry poter is better then eragon?
 

VOTE FOR ERAGON I WANT AN 


ERAGON MMORPG WHY IS

HARRY POTER BETTER THEN ERAGON!!!!! DREAM OF THE FUN 

AND THE AVENTURE

Where is the option for "none of the above, I prefer novels not written for children"?

Seriously, all three of those series are fun to read, but if they remotely represent the scope of the literary material you have acquired, you have barely scratched the surface of what is available. It is roughly equivalent to watching a few Dragon Ball Z episodes and declaring it to be the best of all animes without ever seeing anything else in the category.

EDIT: way to go proving my point the unknown

DREAM OF IT CHANGE YOUR MINDS AND DO YOUR AVENTURE COME ON GUYS

I WANT AN ERAGON MMORPG

   MAKE ERAGON MMORPG
 

Originally posted by Aelfinn

Where is the option for "none of the above, I prefer novels not written for children"?

Seriously, all three of those series are fun to read, but if they remotely represent the scope of the literary material you have acquired, you have barely scratched the surface of what is available.

EDIT: way to go proving my point the unknown

Well ty i think xD i read the book and i watch eragon every night i dreamed of an eragon mmorpg this is my final change to have it

ye i want an eragon mmorpg just dream how fun it will be and the aventure of traveling though alagesia with your dragon or horse it will be the best fantasty mmorpg i think

Non, all over rated childrens books. harry potter...iv read them all and its so over rated/.

Originally posted by aeroplane22

I didn't resurrect the thread, it was up top just now from some reply. Decided to read through and found that little spoiler mine.. made a decision to comment, etc.

  Didn't say that you did. I'm afraid that honor belongs to our beloved Eragon fanatic over here.

Originally posted by TheUnknownM

ye i want an eragon mmorpg just dream how fun it will be and the aventure of traveling though alagesia with your dragon or horse it will be the best fantasty mmorpg i think

why did you necro this thread?

and stop spamming.

im srry for spamming i just wanted everyone to vote for eragon

SHIT Harry poter is                                    winning                                          :( vote for eragon why harry poter is better ffs

 You're doing it again.

umm doing what? spamming? i just want an eragon mmorpg

I have to say eragon is very cliche story wise. And i cant understand why it got the accolades like it did especially for what was largly a dragonrider clone. Harry potter was what i voted for it has a lot more depth than eragon and is not as predictable as Eragon. The Artimas Fowl one i havent read so cant comment.

Originally posted by TheUnknownM

umm doing what? spamming? i just want an eragon mmorpg

Yea, just because it wins a poll on mmorpg.com doesn't mean that it will get made into a game man.

well

harry poter won o.0

after they make harry  poter can they make

eragon?

Originally posted by TheUnknownM

after they make harry  poter can they make

eragon?

Short answer No.

Long answer, Eragon does not lend itself to a MMO due to the lack of content to it. Harry Potter has a similar problem but not as bad as Eragon has the problem of lack of content.

ok harry potter won

 PS:are there dragons?

i saw 1 movie not the series o.o