Login:  Password:   Remember?  
Show Quick Gamelist
Games:397  Guilds:2,001
Members:1,144,070  Online:0
Guests:0  Posts:3,118,202
Recent forum postsRSS
Active threads
Cloud view
List all forums
General Forums
Developers Corner General Discussion
Popular Game Forums
Click a status to find game forum
Game Forums
Click a letter to find game forum

MMORPG.com Discussion Forums

112 posts found
phoenixxus

Novice Member

Joined: 4/16/04
Posts: 2

 
6/03/09 12:10:42 PM#1

A New V.A.T tax is being batted around in congress. The V.A.T tax is new for the U.S. but not for many of our friends who live in other countries they have lived with it for years and have addapted to it. But in the U.S. how will it effect the gaming industry. What is a V.A.T tax it is a tax of any service or item of value. So an example you play WOW and pay your 14.99 per month.  Now it will be 14.99+ V.A.T. I belive in europe it is 17% but now sure. I am sure someone from europe can chime in with the true amount.  I dislike the V.A.T. i like most others U.S. famliies like on a budget and gaming online falls into the extra category ,but if there is less monty for extra will guess i will be getting out my only off line games. What do you think??

tfwarlord

Novice Member

Joined: 9/08/05
Posts: 213

6/03/09 12:16:34 PM#2

you should count you self lucky you dont like in denmark. Our VAT (called Moms in danish) is at 25%, and that is on top of the 40% A-tax (the lowest tax level. we have 3), and other taxes (like AM which is at 8%).....


Take the Magic: The Gathering 'What Color Are You?' Quiz.


Long live pc gaming, Viva la Steam, and and down with the Usurpers, down with the consoles

Kyleran

Elite Member

Joined: 9/13/06
Posts: 8866

"In EVE, no one gives a damn about a fair fight." - chafin

6/03/09 12:20:00 PM#3
Originally posted by tfwarlord

you should count you self lucky you dont like in denmark. Our VAT (called Moms in danish) is at 25%, and that is on top of the 40% A-tax (the lowest tax level. we have 3), and other taxes.....

 

We own too many guns for our leaders to attempt this. 

But as mentioned, people adapt to new taxes, and I don't see many folks in Europe not playing MMO's because they pay a VAT tax on them.

MIght be a drop at first, but in the end, MMO's are still a super cheap form of entertainment and not likely to cause much pain.

Now, upgrading your PC's to play them, that's where the real expense lies IMO.

 

"This is the most intelligent, well qualified and articulate response to a post I have ever seen on these forums. It's a shame most people here won't have the attention span to read past the second line." - Anon

EVE Cult member since May 2007

Regarding EVE: "To be honest, I think God himself created this game." - Shek

Regarding new players in EVE: "Think of yourself as a child released into a park full of pedophiles..." - Eleazaros
"WoW is a game for tourists, not purists." – Ilvadyr

tfwarlord

Novice Member

Joined: 9/08/05
Posts: 213

6/03/09 12:30:33 PM#4


Originally posted by Kyleran

Originally posted by tfwarlord you should count you self lucky you dont like in denmark. Our VAT (called Moms in danish) is at 25%, and that is on top of the 40% A-tax (the lowest tax level. we have 3), and other taxes.....
  We own too many guns for our leaders to attempt this.  

hehe yea well, because our of our high taxes we dont have to fear poverty and theres free healthcare for everyone,we get PAIED to go to collage / university, etc. I earn enough money to buy the stuff i want + a substansial extra for a nestegg.


Yea OP its like Kyleran says. We have this tax in europe, and we still buy and play alot of mmos. If you can afford to maintain a concurrent computer today (i have a Core-i7 with gb of ddr3 ram, with a nvidia Gforce 285 Zotac Amp! graphics card my self) you can afford subscribing a mmo. Most people in the western world with a computer can scratch up 10-25$ each months, if its something they really want to do.

UPDATE
hehe well theres something we are best at www.libraryspot.com/know/highesttax.htm


Take the Magic: The Gathering 'What Color Are You?' Quiz.


Long live pc gaming, Viva la Steam, and and down with the Usurpers, down with the consoles

bmdevine

Apprentice Member

Joined: 4/09/09
Posts: 430

6/03/09 12:40:06 PM#5

Here's an article about it from the Washington Post.  One thing about value added taxes is that they are collected at each step in the production-distribution chain (e.g. manufacturing, wholesale, retail) and only assessed against the "value" (read "price increase") added at each step.   This does have the effect of raising the ultimate cost to consumers.  In many cases, participants in the production-distribution chain are eligible for credits, so many people feel as though the consumer is the only one really burdened by the tax.  It's important to note than VATs in many countries are higher than what we are accustomed to seeing in our sales taxes.

VATs are a regressive tax, just like normal sales taxes.  The fact that a tax is regressive in and of itself doesn't make it bad, even though some people may throw the term around in a pejorative sense.  However, it can represent more of a burden for some people than for others, and as a result some governments using the taxes have opted for lower VATs on necessities and higher VATs on luxury items.

I think it will be too controversial here in the US to be passed any time soon.

Brixon

Apprentice Member

Joined: 7/01/04
Posts: 115

6/03/09 1:11:00 PM#6

V.A.T. tax will hit the end consumer hard. Since it's a layered tax applied to all stages of production, a business hit with the tax will pass the cost on to the consumer. Companies don't pay taxes, they simply pass it along with the cost of the product.

It boogles the mind that anyone would support giving the government anymore money considering how poorly they manage the money they do get. Look at the state of Social Security, Medicaid, and Medicare. Someday the government will take it all, and give you the state run MMORPG.

GoldenDog

Advanced Member

Joined: 2/24/06
Posts: 559

6/03/09 1:21:33 PM#7

Just remeber...

Obama swore not to tax the middle/lower class!

Because it's not like the cigarette tax affected any lower/middle class.  Nor will an internet tax...

 

...wait nvm.

LineageII | LoTRO | RFO | 9Dragons | Aion | Perfect World | Ether Saga | Dungeon Runners | GuildWars | Hellgate London | tCoS | Warhammer | AoC | Tabula Rasa

grandpagamer

Elite Member

Joined: 1/08/08
Posts: 1643

6/03/09 1:29:03 PM#8

What i took from our saviors speech the other day was that we are pretty much screwed for the rest of our lives but our grandchildren will live in the land of milk and honey do to our sacrifice. A little tax here a little tax there, pretty soon we will be at the coveted socialist dream of everyone paying 40-50%. 

It has to be true, i have internet links.

Czzarre

Apprentice Member

Joined: 9/10/07
Posts: 3435

MMORPG Character Monuments

...When its time for your character to take a well deserved rest...

6/03/09 1:32:15 PM#9

If it does come down to it, MMOs will likely incorporate the tax into the fee schedule. INstead of $15/month the company will say $16/month ...or perhaps even use it as an excuse to bump their prices "Due to the new V.A T tax, our subscription price has increased to $20/month ...its not our fault)

Shiva_Shadow

Novice Member

Joined: 5/30/09
Posts: 217

The wind carries with it all things forgotten.

6/03/09 1:32:32 PM#10
Originally posted by bmdevine

Here's an article about it from the Washington Post.  One thing about value added taxes is that they are collected at each step in the production-distribution chain (e.g. manufacturing, wholesale, retail) and only assessed against the "value" (read "price increase") added at each step.   This does have the effect of raising the ultimate cost to consumers.  In many cases, participants in the production-distribution chain are eligible for credits, so many people feel as though the consumer is the only one really burdened by the tax.  It's important to note than VATs in many countries are higher than what we are accustomed to seeing in our sales taxes.

VATs are a regressive tax, just like normal sales taxes.  The fact that a tax is regressive in and of itself doesn't make it bad, even though some people may throw the term around in a pejorative sense.  However, it can represent more of a burden for some people than for others, and as a result some governments using the taxes have opted for lower VATs on necessities and higher VATs on luxury items.

I think it will be too controversial here in the US to be passed any time soon.

 

OMFG!!! You people do realize that the Revolution was started in part by just this kind of multi-step taxes imposed by the british government on most goods?

<prepares to exercise her right to bear arms>

Seen_Justice

Novice Member

Joined: 2/29/08
Posts: 101

Want to try the deepest card game ever made? www.5Dthegame.com

6/03/09 1:33:32 PM#11
Originally posted by tfwarlord

you should count you self lucky you dont like in denmark. Our VAT (called Moms in danish) is at 25%, and that is on top of the 40% A-tax (the lowest tax level. we have 3), and other taxes (like AM which is at 8%).....


 

Yeah but having one of the best educational and health system in the world has it's cost.

I would take the quality of life of any middle class Denmark citizen "any day of the week" before an american one. Tax means nothing. You got to take everything into consideration and look at the final result. Survey says quality of like in Denmark is among the best, while US is one of the worst of the civilized world.

So root for Obama to implement this, and hopefully this money will repair your school and give some health care coverage to the most needed in your society.

BTW: I live in canada, and our Tax rate is at 12% and i really don't care so long as i don't have to mortgage my house every time i catch the flu.

Creativity : The ability to transcend traditional ideas, rules, patterns, relationships, or the like, and to create meaningful new ideas, forms, methods or interpretations; using originality, progressiveness, or imagination.

Shiva_Shadow

Novice Member

Joined: 5/30/09
Posts: 217

The wind carries with it all things forgotten.

6/03/09 1:35:44 PM#12
Originally posted by Seen_Justice
Originally posted by tfwarlord

you should count you self lucky you dont like in denmark. Our VAT (called Moms in danish) is at 25%, and that is on top of the 40% A-tax (the lowest tax level. we have 3), and other taxes (like AM which is at 8%).....


 

Yeah but having one of the best educational and health system in the world has it's cost.

I would take the quality of life of any middle class Denmark citizen "any day of the week" before an american one. Tax means nothing. You got to take everything into consideration and look at the final result. Survey says quality of like in Denmark is among the best, while US is one of the worst of the civilized world.

So root for Obama to implement this, and hopefully this money will repair your school and give some health care coverage to the most needed in your society.

BTW: I live in canada, and our Tax rate is at 12% and i really don't care so long as i don't have to mortgage my house every time i catch the flu.

 

I live in Ohio, in terms of the states, we rank like 6th in taxes, and if I took all the taxes I already have than it is easily 12%, and I get damn little for it.

Seen_Justice

Novice Member

Joined: 2/29/08
Posts: 101

Want to try the deepest card game ever made? www.5Dthegame.com

6/03/09 1:39:44 PM#13
Originally posted by Shiva_Shadow
Originally posted by Seen_Justice
Originally posted by tfwarlord

you should count you self lucky you dont like in denmark. Our VAT (called Moms in danish) is at 25%, and that is on top of the 40% A-tax (the lowest tax level. we have 3), and other taxes (like AM which is at 8%).....


 

Yeah but having one of the best educational and health system in the world has it's cost.

I would take the quality of life of any middle class Denmark citizen "any day of the week" before an american one. Tax means nothing. You got to take everything into consideration and look at the final result. Survey says quality of like in Denmark is among the best, while US is one of the worst of the civilized world.

So root for Obama to implement this, and hopefully this money will repair your school and give some health care coverage to the most needed in your society.

BTW: I live in canada, and our Tax rate is at 12% and i really don't care so long as i don't have to mortgage my house every time i catch the flu.

 

I live in Ohio, in terms of the states, we rank like 6th in taxes, and if I took all the taxes I already have than it is easily 12%, and I get damn little for it.

That's my point. The problem is not the tax itself, but who you elect to manage it. The concept in itself works in "many" countries. So ask yourself why it doesn't in yours, and take actions accordingly.
 

Creativity : The ability to transcend traditional ideas, rules, patterns, relationships, or the like, and to create meaningful new ideas, forms, methods or interpretations; using originality, progressiveness, or imagination.

Shiva_Shadow

Novice Member

Joined: 5/30/09
Posts: 217

The wind carries with it all things forgotten.

6/03/09 1:43:02 PM#14
Originally posted by Seen_Justice
Originally posted by Shiva_Shadow
Originally posted by Seen_Justice
Originally posted by tfwarlord

you should count you self lucky you dont like in denmark. Our VAT (called Moms in danish) is at 25%, and that is on top of the 40% A-tax (the lowest tax level. we have 3), and other taxes (like AM which is at 8%).....


 

Yeah but having one of the best educational and health system in the world has it's cost.

I would take the quality of life of any middle class Denmark citizen "any day of the week" before an american one. Tax means nothing. You got to take everything into consideration and look at the final result. Survey says quality of like in Denmark is among the best, while US is one of the worst of the civilized world.

So root for Obama to implement this, and hopefully this money will repair your school and give some health care coverage to the most needed in your society.

BTW: I live in canada, and our Tax rate is at 12% and i really don't care so long as i don't have to mortgage my house every time i catch the flu.

 

I live in Ohio, in terms of the states, we rank like 6th in taxes, and if I took all the taxes I already have than it is easily 12%, and I get damn little for it.

That's my point. The problem is not the tax itself, but who you elect to manage it. The concept in itself works in "many" countries. So ask yourself why it doesn't in yours, and take actions accordingly.
 

Fine, I'm moving to Canada, eh. (Sorry about the eh, couldn't stop myself)

'Oh Canada!'

alakram

Hard Core Member

Joined: 11/02/06
Posts: 1176

6/03/09 1:44:50 PM#15
Originally posted by phoenixxus

A New V.A.T tax is being batted around in congress. The V.A.T tax is new for the U.S. but not for many of our friends who live in other countries they have lived with it for years and have addapted to it. But in the U.S. how will it effect the gaming industry. What is a V.A.T tax it is a tax of any service or item of value. So an example you play WOW and pay your 14.99 per month.  Now it will be 14.99+ V.A.T. I belive in europe it is 17% but now sure. I am sure someone from europe can chime in with the true amount.  I dislike the V.A.T. i like most others U.S. famliies like on a budget and gaming online falls into the extra category ,but if there is less monty for extra will guess i will be getting out my only off line games. What do you think??

 

Most mmorpgs will adapt the price and say 14,99 VAT included. At least when I pay for lotro or EQ2 i remember seeing all the proces VAT included. Anyway if you can afford 14.99 you probably can afford 17.

The amount of VAT you pay usually vary depending on country and item, in spain for example we have:

Common items, (mmorpgs for example) 16%

Reduced Items 7% (Higienic stuff)

Basic needs 4% Basic stuff like bread, milk, health stuff and so.

-=AlaKraM=-
Don't fight against poverty, fight against greed.
My Lord of the Rings Gallery

bmdevine

Apprentice Member

Joined: 4/09/09
Posts: 430

6/03/09 1:48:00 PM#16
Originally posted by Shiva_Shadow
Originally posted by bmdevine

Here's an article about it from the Washington Post.  One thing about value added taxes is that they are collected at each step in the production-distribution chain (e.g. manufacturing, wholesale, retail) and only assessed against the "value" (read "price increase") added at each step.   This does have the effect of raising the ultimate cost to consumers.  In many cases, participants in the production-distribution chain are eligible for credits, so many people feel as though the consumer is the only one really burdened by the tax.  It's important to note than VATs in many countries are higher than what we are accustomed to seeing in our sales taxes.

VATs are a regressive tax, just like normal sales taxes.  The fact that a tax is regressive in and of itself doesn't make it bad, even though some people may throw the term around in a pejorative sense.  However, it can represent more of a burden for some people than for others, and as a result some governments using the taxes have opted for lower VATs on necessities and higher VATs on luxury items.

I think it will be too controversial here in the US to be passed any time soon.

 OMFG!!! You people do realize that the Revolution was started in part by just this kind of multi-step taxes imposed by the british government on most goods?

<prepares to exercise her right to bear arms>

You seem to assume that the issue was the nature of the tax, rather than something about the procedure used to impose it.  Your statement appears to imply that you think the sentiment expressed in the phrase "No taxation without representation" was less important to colonial dissatisfaction than the nature of the tax.  That theory isn't really supported by most historical texts.

Go ahead and bare your arms, though.  Get some sun ;)

 

mbd1968

Advanced Member

Joined: 2/21/07
Posts: 1083

6/03/09 1:54:02 PM#17
Originally posted by Seen_Justice
Originally posted by tfwarlord

you should count you self lucky you dont like in denmark. Our VAT (called Moms in danish) is at 25%, and that is on top of the 40% A-tax (the lowest tax level. we have 3), and other taxes (like AM which is at 8%).....


 

Yeah but having one of the best educational and health system in the world has it's cost.

I would take the quality of life of any middle class Denmark citizen "any day of the week" before an american one. Tax means nothing. You got to take everything into consideration and look at the final result. Survey says quality of like in Denmark is among the best, while US is one of the worst of the civilized world.

So root for Obama to implement this, and hopefully this money will repair your school and give some health care coverage to the most needed in your society.

BTW: I live in canada, and our Tax rate is at 12% and i really don't care so long as i don't have to mortgage my house every time i catch the flu.

I lived in Copenhagen for 6 months and have lived in Texas for 8 years... Texas, wins...

Shiva_Shadow

Novice Member

Joined: 5/30/09
Posts: 217

The wind carries with it all things forgotten.

6/03/09 1:55:32 PM#18
Originally posted by bmdevine
Originally posted by Shiva_Shadow
Originally posted by bmdevine

Here's an article about it from the Washington Post.  One thing about value added taxes is that they are collected at each step in the production-distribution chain (e.g. manufacturing, wholesale, retail) and only assessed against the "value" (read "price increase") added at each step.   This does have the effect of raising the ultimate cost to consumers.  In many cases, participants in the production-distribution chain are eligible for credits, so many people feel as though the consumer is the only one really burdened by the tax.  It's important to note than VATs in many countries are higher than what we are accustomed to seeing in our sales taxes.

VATs are a regressive tax, just like normal sales taxes.  The fact that a tax is regressive in and of itself doesn't make it bad, even though some people may throw the term around in a pejorative sense.  However, it can represent more of a burden for some people than for others, and as a result some governments using the taxes have opted for lower VATs on necessities and higher VATs on luxury items.

I think it will be too controversial here in the US to be passed any time soon.

 OMFG!!! You people do realize that the Revolution was started in part by just this kind of multi-step taxes imposed by the british government on most goods?

<prepares to exercise her right to bear arms>

You seem to assume that the issue was the nature of the tax, rather than something about the procedure used to impose it.  Your statement appears to imply that you think the sentiment expressed in the phrase "No taxation without representation" was less important to colonial dissatisfaction than the nature of the tax.  That theory isn't really supported by most historical texts.

Go ahead and bare your arms, though.  Get some sun ;)

 

And you seem to assume that I am an idiot, I didn't spout something about the lack of representation, not that I am getting a good measure of that.  I was referring to the fact that each stage of production through processing to deliver was taxed, it was taxed from step one to step 200, and that made the colonies a poor set of states that were taxed MASSIVELY in comparison to their British Isle counterparts.  And for what the textbooks say, I don't put a whole lot of faith in the propoganda fed to middle schoolers.  The simple fact is the revolution was started about taxes, about money that was being taken out of their pockets without their consent, and that is what in essence this is, an increase in prices for.. what? To fund GM, for bigger government for a war no one wants to fight.  Some might argue that it's just another drop in the bucket of taxes, but the simple fact is the founding fathers didn't like this means of taxation and neither do I.

Valeran

Advanced Member

Joined: 4/17/08
Posts: 904

6/03/09 2:02:21 PM#19
Originally posted by Shiva_Shadow
Originally posted by Seen_Justice
Originally posted by tfwarlord

you should count you self lucky you dont like in denmark. Our VAT (called Moms in danish) is at 25%, and that is on top of the 40% A-tax (the lowest tax level. we have 3), and other taxes (like AM which is at 8%).....


 

Yeah but having one of the best educational and health system in the world has it's cost.

I would take the quality of life of any middle class Denmark citizen "any day of the week" before an american one. Tax means nothing. You got to take everything into consideration and look at the final result. Survey says quality of like in Denmark is among the best, while US is one of the worst of the civilized world.

So root for Obama to implement this, and hopefully this money will repair your school and give some health care coverage to the most needed in your society.

BTW: I live in canada, and our Tax rate is at 12% and i really don't care so long as i don't have to mortgage my house every time i catch the flu.

 

I live in Ohio, in terms of the states, we rank like 6th in taxes, and if I took all the taxes I already have than it is easily 12%, and I get damn little for it.

You are now a 60% stake holder in Government Motors.  Sell your stock...oh...nevermind.  ;)

--------
Ten Golden Rules Of Videogame Fanboyism

"SOE has probably united more gamers in hatred than Blizzard has subs"...daelnor

grandpagamer

Elite Member

Joined: 1/08/08
Posts: 1643

6/03/09 2:11:16 PM#20
Originally posted by Valeran
Originally posted by Shiva_Shadow
Originally posted by Seen_Justice
Originally posted by tfwarlord

you should count you self lucky you dont like in denmark. Our VAT (called Moms in danish) is at 25%, and that is on top of the 40% A-tax (the lowest tax level. we have 3), and other taxes (like AM which is at 8%).....


 

Yeah but having one of the best educational and health system in the world has it's cost.

I would take the quality of life of any middle class Denmark citizen "any day of the week" before an american one. Tax means nothing. You got to take everything into consideration and look at the final result. Survey says quality of like in Denmark is among the best, while US is one of the worst of the civilized world.

So root for Obama to implement this, and hopefully this money will repair your school and give some health care coverage to the most needed in your society.

BTW: I live in canada, and our Tax rate is at 12% and i really don't care so long as i don't have to mortgage my house every time i catch the flu.

 

I live in Ohio, in terms of the states, we rank like 6th in taxes, and if I took all the taxes I already have than it is easily 12%, and I get damn little for it.

You are now a 60% stake holder in Government Motors.  Sell your stock...oh...nevermind.  ;)

lol yes how true. Now we can go to the Bank of Obama and borrow to purchase a Government Motors green machine. 

It has to be true, i have internet links.

bmdevine

Apprentice Member

Joined: 4/09/09
Posts: 430

6/03/09 2:12:51 PM#21
Originally posted by Shiva_Shadow
Originally posted by bmdevine
Originally posted by Shiva_Shadow
Originally posted by bmdevine

Here's an article about it from the Washington Post.  One thing about value added taxes is that they are collected at each step in the production-distribution chain (e.g. manufacturing, wholesale, retail) and only assessed against the "value" (read "price increase") added at each step.   This does have the effect of raising the ultimate cost to consumers.  In many cases, participants in the production-distribution chain are eligible for credits, so many people feel as though the consumer is the only one really burdened by the tax.  It's important to note than VATs in many countries are higher than what we are accustomed to seeing in our sales taxes.

VATs are a regressive tax, just like normal sales taxes.  The fact that a tax is regressive in and of itself doesn't make it bad, even though some people may throw the term around in a pejorative sense.  However, it can represent more of a burden for some people than for others, and as a result some governments using the taxes have opted for lower VATs on necessities and higher VATs on luxury items.

I think it will be too controversial here in the US to be passed any time soon.

 OMFG!!! You people do realize that the Revolution was started in part by just this kind of multi-step taxes imposed by the british government on most goods?

<prepares to exercise her right to bear arms>

You seem to assume that the issue was the nature of the tax, rather than something about the procedure used to impose it.  Your statement appears to imply that you think the sentiment expressed in the phrase "No taxation without representation" was less important to colonial dissatisfaction than the nature of the tax.  That theory isn't really supported by most historical texts.

Go ahead and bare your arms, though.  Get some sun ;)

 

And you seem to assume that I am an idiot, I didn't spout something about the lack of representation, not that I am getting a good measure of that.  I was referring to the fact that each stage of production through processing to deliver was taxed, it was taxed from step one to step 200, and that made the colonies a poor set of states that were taxed MASSIVELY in comparison to their British Isle counterparts.  And for what the textbooks say, I don't put a whole lot of faith in the propoganda fed to middle schoolers.  The simple fact is the revolution was started about taxes, about money that was being taken out of their pockets without their consent, and that is what in essence this is, an increase in prices for.. what? To fund GM, for bigger government for a war no one wants to fight.  Some might argue that it's just another drop in the bucket of taxes, but the simple fact is the founding fathers didn't like this means of taxation and neither do I.

Your last statement essentially proves my point that you're either conflating or confusing issues.  You're assuming that the nature of the tax was at issue, but there's really not a lot of evidence to support the proposition that the nature of the tax was more important than other issues, including the lack of representation that the colonies had in the decision to impose the tax, as well as the issue that the tax was levied to support (raising revenue from the colonies to pay for British troops stationed in the colonies after the 7 Years' War.)   There may have been a portion of the population that was ideologically opposed to the concept of a VAT tax, but I haven't seen any evidence to support the proposition that the nature of the tax as value added, rather than some other form of tax, was a motivating factor in the revolution.  You yourself state other issues in your argument, e.g. "taxed MASSIVELY" and "without their consent" that don't really have much to do with the tax being a value added one.

If you just don't like value added taxes, that's ok.  A lot of people don't.  That's part of why I don't think it will pass here in the US any time soon.  I just think it's disingenuous to argue that dissatisfaction with the nature of a value added tax was the cause of the American Revolution.  Here's a brief item from history.org and a small article from publicbookshelf.com that might help.  You may notice that neither reference the terms "VAT" or "value added."  They do however point to other sources of dissatisfaction with the tax.

It may be pointless for me to point out that the Stamp Tax was a direct tax (as pointed out by John Dickinson in his writings in opposition to Britain's policies) rather than an indirect tax like a VAT, since you seem hell bent on making the analogy regardless of its validity.

Brixon

Apprentice Member

Joined: 7/01/04
Posts: 115

6/03/09 2:14:13 PM#22
Originally posted by Seen_Justice
Originally posted by tfwarlord

you should count you self lucky you dont like in denmark. Our VAT (called Moms in danish) is at 25%, and that is on top of the 40% A-tax (the lowest tax level. we have 3), and other taxes (like AM which is at 8%).....


 

Yeah but having one of the best educational and health system in the world has it's cost.

I would take the quality of life of any middle class Denmark citizen "any day of the week" before an american one. Tax means nothing. You got to take everything into consideration and look at the final result. Survey says quality of like in Denmark is among the best, while US is one of the worst of the civilized world.

So root for Obama to implement this, and hopefully this money will repair your school and give some health care coverage to the most needed in your society.

BTW: I live in canada, and our Tax rate is at 12% and i really don't care so long as i don't have to mortgage my house every time i catch the flu.

Do you realize the amount of control the government has over you when the control your ACCESS to health care?

As far as education goes, we have been pooring money down the drain at all levels for our education system for years, and it still isn't up to par. More money isn't going to fix it. Heck they don't want to fix it, they want you to be a good little serf.
 

Europeans don't mind because they have been serfs for hundreds of years.

 

Shiva_Shadow

Novice Member

Joined: 5/30/09
Posts: 217

The wind carries with it all things forgotten.

6/03/09 2:20:27 PM#23
Originally posted by


Your last statement essentially proves my point that you're either conflating or confusing issues.  You're assuming that the nature of the tax was at issue, but there's really not a lot of evidence to support the proposition that the nature of the tax was more important than other issues, including the lack of representation that the colonies had in the decision to impose the tax, as well as the issue that the tax was levied to support (raising revenue from the colonies to pay for British troops stationed in the colonies after the 7 Years' War.)   There may have been a portion of the population that was ideologically opposed to the concept of a VAT tax, but I haven't seen any evidence to support the proposition that the nature of the tax as value added, rather than some other form of tax, was a motivating factor in the revolution.  You yourself state other issues in your argument, e.g. "taxed MASSIVELY" and "without their consent" that don't really have much to do with the tax being a value added one.

If you just don't like value added taxes, that's ok.  A lot of people don't.  That's part of why I don't think it will pass here in the US any time soon.  I just think it's disingenuous to argue that dissatisfaction with the nature of a value added tax was the cause of the American Revolution.  Here's a brief item from history.org and a small article from publicbookshelf.com that might help.  You may notice that neither reference the terms "VAT" or "value added."  They do however point to other sources of dissatisfaction with the tax.

 

Whatever, you obviously aren't going to admit I have a point without a but, and, if in front of it, I stated an opinion and you are going to lunge after me no matter what I say, so whatever, I am not going to get into a flaming match with you over something.  My statement is essence is true and you are trying to quibble over the symantics and no one will ever win such an arguement so I will neither continue this fight or force others using this thread to contend with a massive quotation blocks in front of the posts..

tfwarlord

Novice Member

Joined: 9/08/05
Posts: 213

6/03/09 2:26:40 PM#24


Originally posted by Seen_Justice

Originally posted by tfwarlord

you should count you self lucky you dont like in denmark. Our VAT (called Moms in danish) is at 25%, and that is on top of the 40% A-tax (the lowest tax level. we have 3), and other taxes (like AM which is at 8%).....


 
Yeah but having one of the best educational and health system in the world has it's cost.
I would take the quality of life of any middle class Denmark citizen "any day of the week" before an american one. Tax means nothing. You got to take everything into consideration and look at the final result. Survey says quality of like in Denmark is among the best, while US is one of the worst of the civilized world.
So root for Obama to implement this, and hopefully this money will repair your school and give some health care coverage to the most needed in your society.
BTW: I live in canada, and our Tax rate is at 12% and i really don't care so long as i don't have to mortgage my house every time i catch the flu.


i know. I wouldent like anywere ells (why i wrote in #4 hehe yea well, because our of our high taxes we dont have to fear poverty and theres free healthcare for everyone, we get PAIED to go to collage / university etc. I earn enough money to buy the stuff i want + a substansial extra for a nestegg.)
It was also what i was trying to illustrate, though i can see from your comment that i failed :-/


Take the Magic: The Gathering 'What Color Are You?' Quiz.


Long live pc gaming, Viva la Steam, and and down with the Usurpers, down with the consoles

eyeswideopen

Apprentice Member

Joined: 5/24/09
Posts: 281

6/03/09 2:27:14 PM#25
Originally posted by Brixon
Originally posted by Seen_Justice
Originally posted by tfwarlord

you should count you self lucky you dont like in denmark. Our VAT (called Moms in danish) is at 25%, and that is on top of the 40% A-tax (the lowest tax level. we have 3), and other taxes (like AM which is at 8%).....


 

Yeah but having one of the best educational and health system in the world has it's cost.

I would take the quality of life of any middle class Denmark citizen "any day of the week" before an american one. Tax means nothing. You got to take everything into consideration and look at the final result. Survey says quality of like in Denmark is among the best, while US is one of the worst of the civilized world.

So root for Obama to implement this, and hopefully this money will repair your school and give some health care coverage to the most needed in your society.

BTW: I live in canada, and our Tax rate is at 12% and i really don't care so long as i don't have to mortgage my house every time i catch the flu.

Do you realize the amount of control the government has over you when the control your ACCESS to health care?

As far as education goes, we have been pooring money down the drain at all levels for our education system for years, and it still isn't up to par. More money isn't going to fix it. Heck they don't want to fix it, they want you to be a good little serf.
 

Europeans don't mind because they have been serfs for hundreds of years.

 


 

Heheh, so very true.

V.A.T. will not be passed in this country.

*cocks shotgun*

Get the boys ready, Shiva!

5 Pages 1 2 3 4 5 » Search