| 42 posts found | |||
|---|---|---|---|
|
What do you people think the graphics are absed on? I personally don't see much from Wow, it isn't that comic. Its more like Guild Wars or a bit Lotro.
|
|||
|
The graphics are based on the table top game. Not everything has to be designed after an already existing game . . . It's a Jeep thing. . .
_______ |___  |\_______/ =  |||||| =|X| \*........*/ |X| |X|_________|X| You wouldn't understand |
|||
|
WSIMike
 Elite Member
Joined: 3/09/04
Playing: Lineage 2, Dissidia FF |
Option wasn't there, but I'd have voted "none of the above". Like was said before me, the style of WAR is based on the tabletop game.
|
||
also considering everything WOW was stolen from WAR ages ago WOW looks like WAR |
|||
|
If you strip the O from LOTRO then that option suits rather well I'd think
|
|||
|
HellsMajesty
 Apprentice Member
Joined: 9/30/07
"The only thing that comes to a sleeping man are dreams" |
I voted GW because i think the graphics look reminiscent of the game but i dont think that WARs visuals are "based" on GW i just think they are similar in the general style  |
||
|
It looks like Warhammer, which is rather unsurprising as it's a Warhammer game. |
|||
|
There's a Shit option missing too. Sorry, but I generally hate this new "realistic" look many MMORPG's seem to be doing. AoC, LoTR, VG, WAR and on and on looks entirely unrealistic to me. PoTBS was bad too. The animations look out of place and the movements look like stick men. I much prefer the cartoony look of WoW, TOR and ST Online. I can stand looking at those quite a bit longer than those realistic types. And while I'm not at all tech savvy or know what may or may not be possible to do in an MMO, look at the way characters look and feel in many single and multiplayer shooters. BF Bad Company, Resident Evil 5, Grand Theft Auto 4 and so forth. Why can't I look like THAT if they have to go with a realistic feel. |
|||
|
WAR looks realistic?
I don't get the impression at all from Mythic that they intended any form of realism. WAR's cartoon is just a grittier and darker type of art from WoW's. Both Warhammer and Warhammer 40K are extremely cartoony. The art is extremely exaggerated. Back in EvE. Started with BatMUD. Main MMOs have been EvE and DAoC. |
|||
|
neller2000 has some point. My g/f doesn't feel motivated to even play WAR compared to myself because she doesn't like the realistic look.
The design choice for WAR is not like any other MMO right now, because even GW or LotRO have a more fantasy surreal look compared to WAR. I have to admit that WAR has some awesome texture designers for character models, since it is more realistic than other MMOs right now... AoC lacks model texture detailing, but makes up for it with polygon count.
Considering the grit and brutality of WAR, it requires that sort of realism... not only because the Warhammer Universe is like that... but because I cannot get that sort of grit and brutality feel from the cartooniness of either LotRO or WoW. |
|||
Originally posted by APRAurore
Hmm. Yes, that is true. But even though Warhammer Fantasy and 40k are exaggerated on the model level, the art in the codex/armybooks are fairly realistic despite the exaggerated proportions. |
|||
|
neller is a known WAR hater, so I wouldn't put much stock in anything he says about it. As for the realistic look, that's not the game that I'm playing. It has a definite fantasy feel to it. The weapons bear little resembalance to weapons used in any real war. And when was the last time you saw an infantryman (SM) running around in a dress? Nope, definitely fantasy. Ion |
|||
Originally posted by Ionselon
What ridiculous comments. in EQ2 the characters use magic too, realistic? I guess not, definitely fantasy.
|
|||
Originally posted by Ionselon
I think you missed my point entirely. This isn't about whether or not I hate WAR in particular, it's about the trend in general with new MMORPG's taking the "realistic graphics" approach. War is on the mild side, granted, but still too much in my opinion. When I say realistic, I mean in the general looks of a character in WAR or LoTR for instance compared to a character of say WoW or TOR. The first two I get somewhat the feeling I'm playing a second rate cartoons company's newest addition and in the last two I'm playing Disney's new blockbuster. If you HAVE to go with the realistic look, then jeesh make it actually look more normal in regards to animations and general feel than the cartoony ones out there. |
|||
Originally posted by neller2000
I think you missed my point entirely. This isn't about whether or not I hate WAR in particular, it's about the trend in general with new MMORPG's taking the "realistic graphics" approach. War is on the mild side, granted, but still too much in my opinion. When I say realistic, I mean in the general looks of a character in WAR or LoTR for instance compared to a character of say WoW or TOR. The first two I get somewhat the feeling I'm playing a second rate cartoons company's newest addition and in the last two I'm playing Disney's new blockbuster. If you HAVE to go with the realistic look, then jeesh make it actually look more normal in regards to animations and general feel than the cartoony ones out there. bah neller your wasting your breath. we all know ion is the rabid fanboi. shhh here he comes after licking jacobs behind. Watching Fanbois drop their soap in a prison full of desperate men. |
|||
Originally posted by maxnrosy bah neller your wasting your breath. we all know ion is the rabid fanboi. shhh here he comes after licking jacobs behind. LOL Max, I don't understand why you and neller even bother coming to threads about WAR. You both don't like the game, so why keep posting in threads about WAR? While not a fanboi, I do enjoy playing WAR. As I have said in other posts, the Fun Factor > Frustration Factor. Ion |
|||
Originally posted by Ionselon bah neller your wasting your breath. we all know ion is the rabid fanboi. shhh here he comes after licking jacobs behind. LOL Max, I don't understand why you and neller even bother coming to threads about WAR. You both don't like the game, so why keep posting in threads about WAR? While not a fanboi, I do enjoy playing WAR. As I have said in other posts, the Fun Factor > Frustration Factor. Ion
Maybe you should use some real arguments then, not dumb ones like "ow my character is in a dress -> Fantasy"
|
|||
Originally posted by neller2000
I think you missed my point entirely. This isn't about whether or not I hate WAR in particular, it's about the trend in general with new MMORPG's taking the "realistic graphics" approach. War is on the mild side, granted, but still too much in my opinion. When I say realistic, I mean in the general looks of a character in WAR or LoTR for instance compared to a character of say WoW or TOR. The first two I get somewhat the feeling I'm playing a second rate cartoons company's newest addition and in the last two I'm playing Disney's new blockbuster. If you HAVE to go with the realistic look, then jeesh make it actually look more normal in regards to animations and general feel than the cartoony ones out there. I only said that because all of your previous posts have indicated that you do indeed not like WAR. Maybe I did misunderstand your point. If that is the case, by Sigmar's beard, I find myself having to agree with you. Oh, horrors! Someone else has said that he lives in a photo-realistic world, and he didn't want a photo-realistic game. I feel the same way. I like a fantasy setting, and to some degree a sci-fi setting, that will transport me away from reality for a time (it's called escapism) and distract me from the everyday cares and drama that comes standard with R/L. Now, I don't like WoW's cartoony look and this is just a personal preference. I played WoW for a year, and never could really get "into" it. My friend continued to play WoW for a couple of years after I quit and he liked the graphics. One man's trash is another man's treasure. So, it all boils down to personal preference. Your perfect graphics style may be my least favorite style and vice-versa. I'm just happy there are enough MMOs out with different styles so that at least there is something of a choice. Ion |
|||
Originally posted by Pheace LOL Max, I don't understand why you and neller even bother coming to threads about WAR. You both don't like the game, so why keep posting in threads about WAR? While not a fanboi, I do enjoy playing WAR. As I have said in other posts, the Fun Factor > Frustration Factor. Ion
Maybe you should use some real arguments then, not dumb ones like "ow my character is in a dress -> Fantasy"
I didn't say that SM's wearing a dress made the graphics look like a fantasy setting. What I was saying is that a warrior wearing a dress isn't realistic, and therefore the graphics in WAR can't be considered to be realistic. |
|||
Originally posted by Ionselon LOL Max, I don't understand why you and neller even bother coming to threads about WAR. You both don't like the game, so why keep posting in threads about WAR? While not a fanboi, I do enjoy playing WAR. As I have said in other posts, the Fun Factor > Frustration Factor. Ion
Maybe you should use some real arguments then, not dumb ones like "ow my character is in a dress -> Fantasy"
I didn't say that SM's wearing a dress made the graphics look like a fantasy setting. What I was saying is that a warrior wearing a dress isn't realistic, and therefore the graphics in WAR can't be considered to be realistic.
Which makes it completely besides the point then since what does dress style have to do with graphic realism in the sense that's talked about here?
|
|||
Originally posted by Pheace
Maybe you should use some real arguments then, not dumb ones like "ow my character is in a dress -> Fantasy"
I didn't say that SM's wearing a dress made the graphics look like a fantasy setting. What I was saying is that a warrior wearing a dress isn't realistic, and therefore the graphics in WAR can't be considered to be realistic.
Which makes it completely besides the point then since what does dress style have to do with graphic realism in the sense that's talked about here?
/sigh Never mind
|
|||
|
I think the game graphics are very very good. IMO Graphics is not whats wrong with WAR |
|||
|
I was expecting a clunky low poly option. I am disappointed in this poll. |
|||
|
I think the graphics are deliberately stylized. It's not at all meant to be realistic, it's a slightly watered down take on the art style of games workshop. The colour palette's a little brighter than the GW artists tend to use and the graphics are slightly cartoonier. But realistic - not at all. Played: WoW, Lotro, AoC, Eve, CoX. |
|||
Originally posted by neller2000
You are wrong Warhammer has stylized art style. Lotro has some pseudo realistic enviroments but stylized characters. Age of Conan has realistic art style. From the landscapes to all characters Warhammer is stlized, from colors to proportions... This is not a matter of opinion, there is no realism in Warhammer from an artistic point of view...just remember Im not talking about realism as the artistic movement, but as concept and style. |
|||
