Originally posted by eycel

I rated it all a 10 except role playing in the rating meter here at mmropg.  I think the lack of voice chat , and the lackluster normalsee of /guild,/group,/yell commands make the roleplaying lackluster.  Only time will tell if roleplaying will get better.  I know my first night i loged in , i was going throug the quests, and i ended up grouping with a group that was full, but no one was chating, no voices, no typing, no nothing, i was like wtf, what is this, single player world in conflict or half life 2, but even so...That was the only part i didnt mark as exceptional.

Yeah they need to work on that :P

I rated it an 8. It's one of the funnest games I've played in a long time. I haven't felt this addicted to a game since DAoC so I guess I am biased towards Mythic's games

I'm not a Mythic fangirl though. I want to see Mythic do better with WAR than it did with DAoC.

Almost 600 votes :D

Yeah the game is fun.

I give War an 8.

Its an amazing game, but could use a few fixes.

First patch arrived....

Did the patch increase the game performance a bit or...

Do you people think they will introduce the removed characters and cities for free or with the next expansion?

Gave it a 6. Fun game, but lots and lots of room for improvement. Especially in oRvR.

Didn't buy the game to play ScenarioHammer: The Age of Knockback.

Gonna keep my sub up and running for 2-3 more months to see what they can do. I have high hopes.

9 from me..

and some comments

+ I like FPS games and WAR is most likely that in a fantasy world..

-/+ WAR has not the depth/ complexity like VG, EQ/EQ2 (suits the time i can invest/  spend atm.)

+ It's about skills and team work --> most FPS are about teamwork (in BF2142 a good team can rip all appart).

So Imo there's a huge potential in a teamwork / FPS - way.. People just need to get used to it.. Like in the very beginning of raiding in EQ, people had to adjust to that type of gameplay.. 

- So many Emo destro players

-The balance conditions atm.. Well they of course have to be fixed.

*** Population .. is good I my self find the activity on Karag Dron very high..

Cant PQ's?? well in old days eq you had to send a tell to many people before you could even assemble a group... I write a message to folks and  invite them on a accept.. PQ's are not a problem.. I Think the problem is that people dont do much about gathering groups ..

I give it a 10, because even though may not be 100% now, it will be pretty soon.

Further to that if every game was released like this then i would not be scared to buy MMO titles!

Game is a 7 currently with the potential of becoming an 8-8,5 when things are ironed out in a year. 

My personal belief is always buy an MMO a year after they are out but I went out of my way and bought this one.

Game is fine right now but I imagine in a year it will be an even better experience.

I voted it a 5. I picked the game up to give it a shot and will probably not renew after my 30 days. I played a Disciple of Khaine and was able to really roll through the PvE content. I talked to some friends who played a Sorceror and Chosen and it appeared as a DoK I had alot less trouble soloing these quests than they did. So for PvE Content, if you like to Solo, DoK appears the way to go. I think I made Rank 18 in a week and a half. When I did jump into RvR, it was apparent that DoK is not the class you want to be if you're into RvR Combat. I repecced and tried the different mastery lines but no matter what I chose, it just didn't cut it in RvR. So, I pulled back and played the healer role and felt that the DoK healing abilities were somewhat lacking for RvR. They do massive amounts of healing over time, but in RvR, time does not appear to be on your side. :) Perhaps the Shaman is a better choice for this support role, I'm not sure. Anyway, during my playtime, the only real issue I had was the queueing for scenario's took FOREVER. But with the last patch they put in where you can queue for all scenarios, that fixed it.

The real reason I won't be renewing is I just didn't like the play style. Nothing against the game at all, but it's essentially a hack n slash game. While fun for a little while, it gets repetitive too soon for my liking.

Originally posted by VultureSkull

I give it a 10, because even though may not be 100% now, it will be pretty soon.

Further to that if every game was released like this then i would not be scared to buy MMO titles!

Its only a 10 for me if they add all cut classes and cities, improve graphics, balances etc etc etc which will never happen I think cause a 10 is PERFECT :D

Ive been a tad critical of mmo's lately, so with a grain of salt , I gave War a 7.

I like the game well enough and really enjoyed orvr in preview/ob. But the turn this game took when it went live to a scenario grind really surprised me. Too bad because the orvr was alot of fun. I think mythic should have understood that players are like water and will flow through the path of least resistance to level.

I'll keep an eye on this title and if it ever goes back to a full on orvr game I'll resub and give it another go. My days of standing in que were long gone, 2 years ago in WoW. As well my days of grinding 100 mobs then another 100 mobs timesinks were full of suck in every mmo i ever played.

I gave it an 8, enjoying it quite alot,  Sieges are simply amazing, holding down Order outnumbered 3 to 1 very thrilling, went for the first time to mount gunbad the other day with my guild was alot of fun, I just keep discovering these litle things that make me enjoy the game even more every day.

The 8 goes for the sound, maybe someone can force Paul Barnett and Mark Jacobs to play Lineage 2 for an hour . 

Abit of a biased place to post, I mean post it on Gamespot or something.

Originally posted by John.A.Zoid

Abit of a biased place to post, I mean post it on Gamespot or something.

You mean instead of posting in the Warhammer Online discussion on a website dedicated to the mmorpg genre where people who are voting have more than likely played the game and/or have read about it can rate it, we should post it on gamespot where people who may have not even heard of the game or not even like the genre will vote? how is that unbiased again?

Originally posted by John.A.Zoid

Abit of a biased place to post, I mean post it on Gamespot or something.

What do you mean?

Almost 700 votes...

Besides high populations, this game is worhtless, and I honestly think that this game is worthless because it's pointless, I tested my addiction level to this game, and it FAILED!~!!!!!!

Originally posted by Xenosaiyan

Besides high populations, this game is worhtless, and I honestly think that this game is worthless because it's pointless, I tested my addiction level to this game, and it FAILED!~!!!!!!

That's okay, because now you have time to learn... literacy!

Getting this tread on top again for more votes!

5 out of 10  - ok for a coupleof weeks but gets boring fast

I'd give it a 6 out 10 very average game which trys to do to many things and masters none of them.