<
>

Page 1 of 2

1

2

 Thread (49 posts)
Zertyr  9/30/08 7:12:36 AM

Rank: 23/100 Rank: 23/100 Rank: 23/100 Rank: 23/100 Rank: 23/100

Apprentice Member

Joined: 4/01/05
Posts: 250

"The who increases knowledge, increases sorrow." /Bible

I run a small guild. 30-40 active players, most of us are under level 20.

 

 

What is an okay % to have as tax for a normal guild like this in your opinion? I currently have 1% but we did some calculations and was thinking to increase to 5%. Bad part is as i started with such a low tax this change going to seem huge for the members. Have talked to some and none really see 5 as a bad % to tax on, but want to hear what the public says about things like this.
 

Of course this varies on what type of guild you are in and what the goals of the guild are.

Forum Poll

What tax % is max for you?

0% - No taxes!
1-5% - Low and good
6-10% - I can spare a tenth of what I make
11-20% - The guilds need it, so why not
21-30% - Starts to be noticable but guild gains a lot
31-40% - Very noticable but guild needs the money.
41-50% - Half my money to guild, half to me!
51-70% - Guild before individuals!
71-95% - The guild pays all my needs!
96-100% - Guild covers all it's members, gear, pots and so on.
(login to vote)

 
Sovrath  9/30/08 7:15:10 AM

Rank: 100/100 Rank: 100/100 Rank: 100/100 Rank: 100/100 Rank: 100/100

Elite Member

Joined: 1/06/05
Posts: 2599

What does the Guild need taxes for in Warhammer? Other games I can see it but havn't seen where money is really an issue in War.

 
Auxer  9/30/08 7:17:11 AM

Rank: 20/100 Rank: 20/100 Rank: 20/100 Rank: 20/100 Rank: 20/100

Novice Member

Joined: 4/27/08
Posts: 108

Born to Tank!

Originally posted by Sovrath

What does the Guild need taxes for in Warhammer? Other games I can see it but havn't seen where money is really an issue in War.


 

For us in our guild its used for rvr stuff, standards and the like so individuals dont have to pay when the guild goes to war.

The tank that is born to tank!

Kerebo  9/30/08 7:21:47 AM

Rank: 7/100 Rank: 7/100 Rank: 7/100 Rank: 7/100 Rank: 7/100

Novice Member

Joined: 4/08/08
Posts: 126

Semper Fi!

We use 5%, that works perfectly. You hardly notice it and guild gets enough coins also.

 
Shuganubz  9/30/08 7:55:44 AM

Rank: 31/100 Rank: 31/100 Rank: 31/100 Rank: 31/100 Rank: 31/100

Apprentice Member

Joined: 2/16/08
Posts: 20

  Considering how easy it is to make money in this game without having to put forth to much effort, I would probably say 5%-6% is a reasonable level given the size of the guild. The trash loot you receive just randomly killing things nets a decent profit in a short amount of time. In just 2 days of playing made 25g on just random armor to the AH and vendor junk.

Best game ever played (Anarchy-Online - 4yrs of Service)
----------------
Have Played: FFXI, SWG, EQ2, L2, GW, CoH/X, Vanguard, WoW, LOTRO, MxO, AoC
----------------
Currently Playing: WAR (Wurtbad Server) Chaos - Mourtok (Maurader) // Alissua (DoK)

Zodan  9/30/08 7:56:59 AM

Rank: 31/100 Rank: 31/100 Rank: 31/100 Rank: 31/100 Rank: 31/100

Apprentice Member

Joined: 10/07/04
Posts: 183

"It''s good to be evil."

Considering its only from looted corpses which don't give much anyway 50+%

 
Scalebane  9/30/08 8:02:25 AM

Rank: 86/100 Rank: 86/100 Rank: 86/100 Rank: 86/100 Rank: 86/100

Elite Member

Joined: 10/28/06
Posts: 614

Nevermind what haters say, ignore them ''til they fade away.

i have never believed in guild taxes or forcing people to pay them if you do have them but i guess it would be different in WAR, in other games money gets built up for the guild from raiding, not sure how else a guild in WAR would have money unless people pitched in.

 
Cway214  9/30/08 8:05:12 AM

Rank: 40/100 Rank: 40/100 Rank: 40/100 Rank: 40/100 Rank: 40/100

Apprentice Member

Joined: 9/07/07
Posts: 86

Our guild has it set at 2%, and the individual can set there tithe.  I have my tithe set at 15%, I think some other guildies have their tithe at 25 to 30%

 
Goldknyght  9/30/08 8:05:32 AM

Rank: 32/100 Rank: 32/100 Rank: 32/100 Rank: 32/100 Rank: 32/100

Apprentice Member

Joined: 1/12/06
Posts: 1188

It''s one thing to have a opinion, but enforcing one is unconstitutional.


 

NO MORE NEW TAXES!!!

Neiko  9/30/08 8:11:20 AM

Rank: 74/100 Rank: 74/100 Rank: 74/100 Rank: 74/100 Rank: 74/100

Hard Core Member

Joined: 8/07/06
Posts: 133

Our guild is at 5% and you can set the tithe to something high if you really want to contribute that way to your guild. We have at least 2 G just from that 5% and some tithe on a few of our members.

---------------