What do you think Warhammer worth?

A 1,2,3 already after a few  votes. Yes, people who dislike this game for whatever reason are really an unbiased, fair bunch. Goes for the 10's as well, in a way. Though they are closer to my 9; highly entertaining, kick ass game, imo.

Too bad most folks who like the game so much that they forgot about these boards for a while won't be here to vote, they have a damn sweet mmo to play :)

EDIT: Update, for those who can't see the results of this poll: http://i68.photobucket.com/albums/i4/Yngling/WAR_worth_poll_01.jpg

Id rate it with a 6, and that's pretty nice coming from me, Im having fun, can't see it lasting forever, but It's good enough to keep me entertained until my guild's main project.

I would give it a 9.

On top of lots of fun, It's not a time waister like all other MMO's, never expected that 

i gave it an 8.  its good, not the best and the performance issues in towns are insane (thats what you get when you stick 25 NPC's and a tonne of objects all together in one little area) but once i leave those towns its fine.  open world RvR is fun (uncouth but fun) and i have yet to try scenarios.  as for classes, they really capture Warhammar quite well and it actually does feel like your in the warhammar world because you are fighting such iconic tabletop creatures.

the tome of knowledge is epic (tracking kills ftw) even though its "borrowed" from LOTRO, they imporved it significantly. 

so yeah 8/10.   maybe it will go up to 8.5 or 9 in the tier 2 zones, who knows.

Its ok, but it is no MMO, its a single player game played online.

I would have given this game a 6-7. But then I did RvR in Troll Country. I'll say its a 9-10. Several hundred PVPing with little lag is impressive. My warband was using hills and trees to cover our movement from the larger Order force. We were able to flank destruction and force them to retreat. They didn't see us coming until we were right on top of them.

I rated it myself with 9 it has a perfect gameplay and certain if you like pvp :D

a low 7 imo.

its a fun game. but not very deep

 I voted 1, to counteract the fanbois 10, makes the results fairer. 

Originally posted by Professor78

 I voted 1, to counteract the fanbois 10, makes the results fairer. 

.....Thats not the way of voting. Just leave your own vote and not leave a bad vote to compare with the high votes.....

Voted for solid 7.  PvP based WoW clone, but more fun and prettier!

Well I'm a major fangirl, and I voted 8. Nothing is perfect, so it's really hard for me to vote 10 on this or anything- since, *especially* with MMOs, where it's expected- there's always room for improvement. Plus, there are little niggling things that I don't like / don't agree with... but I'm still having crazy fun, and it's definitely at the top of my 'must play' list right now, and likely will be for quite a while yet.

Graphic and design:   5

Newthinking: 4

Fun:    9

Addictive`ness: 9.5

voted 7 

good game has potential

I gave it a 6. It's probably an 8 at release but will go down to a 4 very soon. The game doesn't really promote longevity imo. At release you'll get a chance to do almost all the PQ's , scenarios , and Open world RvR.  After a month or 2 the lower tiers will be sparsely populated and you wont get the full experience anymore. New players will come and think the game is boring. Because you have a wait a few hours for 1 scenario and you spend most of your time doing regular quests, which is not a strong point of this game.

Its an average game. Would of prefered 40k, but instead it is this WoW duplicate. Not a bad game, but also not ground breaking. Upsetting they were unable to release everything at launch, but thats how it is.

Originally posted by DarkPony

A 1,2,3 already after a few  votes. Yes, people who dislike this game for whatever reason are really an unbiased, fair bunch. Goes for the 10's as well, in a way.

I always completely ignore the highest and lowest options possible on such polls to weed out most fanbois and haters. The average of the rest (2-9) is usually pretty accurate. :-)

I voted for a 6 it would be higher if Mystic hadn't removed four classes and four capitol cities.

Originally posted by Senjinn

I gave it a 6. It's probably an 8 at release but will go down to a 4 very soon. The game doesn't really promote longevity imo. At release you'll get a chance to do almost all the PQ's , scenarios , and Open world RvR.  After a month or 2 the lower tiers will be parsely populated and you wont get the full experience anymore. New players will come and think the game is boring. Because you have a wait a few hours for 1 scenario and you spend most of your time doing regular quests, which is not a strong point of this game.

Yup

I am kind of a slow player I dont rush in too fast
I still have only 1 Chosen at level 10 that being I started playing on the 14th of Sept

Already some PQs in tier 1 are deserted and I am talking about EU server and EU peak timings.
Seems people have reached tier 2 and tier 3 already
 

Originally posted by Jefferson81

I voted for a 6 it would be higher if Mystic hadn't removed four classes and four capitol cities.

The classes and cities that were left out were unfinished/broken. So if they had included them at launch would you have given the game a 3-4 for not being polished?

Originally posted by copperclad

Originally posted by Jefferson81

I voted for a 6 it would be higher if Mystic hadn't removed four classes and four capitol cities.

 

The classes and cities that were left out were unfinished/broken. So if they had included them at launch would you have given the game a 3-4 for not being polished?

They should of actually spent time on the and dedicated a team to the completion of the game. As it stands it just goes to show that MMo companys can get away with releasing unfinished games and have people pay money to beta them.

They will introduce the new classes and cities for free in a update later this year (which is in 2-3 month i think) :)

a 10 after I took Profred's tip and installed from the discs. I have AA and AF on as well and boy does it look a whooole lot better than my beta experience. I love the look and feel and we all know the gameplay is addictively fun.

Over 120 votes already