Jesus I don't want to be rude, but that OP was stupid as hell.  There have been plenty of MMO's in the past with full looting in PvP that have been extremely successful (And EVE).  End of thread.

Originally posted by WesKhan1

Jesus I don't want to be rude, but that OP was stupid as hell.  There have been plenty of MMO's in the past with full looting in PvP that have been extremely successful (And EVE).  End of thread.

Eve isn't fully open pvp. There are safezones.

Originally posted by ghoul31

Originally posted by WesKhan1

Jesus I don't want to be rude, but that OP was stupid as hell.  There have been plenty of MMO's in the past with full looting in PvP that have been extremely successful (And EVE).  End of thread.

 

Eve isn't fully open pvp. There are safezones.

which makes it successful. Eve has a happy medium. And tbh if earthrise doesnt, and does have "full loot open pvp everywhere", its going to drive alot of players away. You need a balance, which of course im sure the developers will understand. I'll wait for more info before i bash a game because of a small segment in some devlog or QOTW.

Lets not forget about Fury shall we.

Even though full-loot spices up the adrenaline for some reason.

I hope Death penalty's will be 10-15% of total xp

Those games actually do succeed. No carebears no whiners. End good all good :)

Ow btw, OP get your facts straight.

Originally posted by Atomy

Lets not forget about Fury shall we.

Even though full-loot spices up the adrenaline for some reason.

I hope Death penalty's will be 10-15% of total xp

Those games actually do succeed. No carebears no whiners. End good all good :)

Ow btw, OP get your facts straight.

 

LOL fury? the playerbase is so insignificant, that it is barely Massive. And no the death penality's also, especially for a "open pvp" game. They would be stupid to implement something like that. The only XP loss in a game ive ever seen was Lineage 2, and it works for them because there are levels. In a SKILL based MMO, it wont work.

Originally posted by tvalentine

Originally posted by ghoul31

Originally posted by WesKhan1

Jesus I don't want to be rude, but that OP was stupid as hell.  There have been plenty of MMO's in the past with full looting in PvP that have been extremely successful (And EVE).  End of thread.

 

Eve isn't fully open pvp. There are safezones.

 

which makes it successful. Eve has a happy medium. And tbh if earthrise doesnt, and does have "full loot open pvp everywhere", its going to drive alot of players away. You need a balance, which of course im sure the developers will understand. I'll wait for more info before i bash a game because of a small segment in some devlog or QOTW.

Earthrise will, if you check through the forums, there will be high security zones for people who dont like watching their back constantly. Though the areas are safe, the real rewards will be outside in low to no-security zones, mainly rare resources and such.

And there is no sense worrying about Exp in a skill-based MMO :P

Most that happens to you when you die is you lose whatever isnt insured, and even then there is a window of time where you can pay a fee to get the items back if they arent looted, though not everything is insurable, and the one who killed ya gets a cut of what you had to pay for insurance and whatever else there is lol

and they have a nice amount of QotW if you check, some are very interesting reads, specially the current one released, which promises to break the grind that PvE can be.

Originally posted by ghoul31

Originally posted by WesKhan1

Jesus I don't want to be rude, but that OP was stupid as hell.  There have been plenty of MMO's in the past with full looting in PvP that have been extremely successful (And EVE).  End of thread.

 

Eve isn't fully open pvp. There are safezones.

safe zones mean I'm "safe" from all pvp. In EVE this is never true. EVE has 'safer zones' but never 'safe zones'.

Not to mention if you ever ever join a corp any corp can wardec ya. That means they can get you anywhere

There is no safezones in EVE. Safe zones is what players make for themselves in 0.0

Originally posted by Ruckup

Unless they want to fail from the get go ..... Hey mabey they only want 100 subs at launch.

many DEvs have tried Full Loot pvp and the game died or they just forgot about the idea altogethor... I mean Look at AoC right now the WoW fanboy whimps cried and now FFA is going away.

AOC didn't go live with it, they chickened out.  I think there are a lot of features that a new game could make succcessful if they are willing to break with the WoW mold.  Earthrise is looking to do that with a few things, and this hopefully will be one of them.

In EVE large alliance pvp will almost certainly involve your top modules (t2) (faction stuff is left for carriers and motherships). Any alliance doing any serious pvp will refuse to let you in fleet unless you are flying fully t2 fitted ships. Minor exceptions are made but those are rare.

Ive seen 1st hand people ridiculed within fleet for either bringing t1 ships and modules.

That being said i think Earthrise will do just fine with full looting so long as getting back on your feet isnt something that can me recovered in fairly reasonable time. I look forward to this game since it may be the one game that breaks the mold like EVE has. May not see 12349087895634587 subs but thats not really important so long as it has a decent number and a good community.

UO had full loot, and i can imagine that ER will have the same perfect system as UO did.

And gear will be easy to replace. I cant wait to someone release sandbox MMORPG. Games without freedom and complexity maybe for you, but for me, its sandbox style!

Originally posted by Timacek

UO had full loot, and i can imagine that ER will have the same perfect system as UO did.

And gear will be easy to replace. I cant wait to someone release sandbox MMORPG. Games without freedom and complexity maybe for you, but for me, its sandbox style!

Yes UO had full loot. And it was such a disaster that they got rid of it. And no game has done it since.

Originally posted by ghoul31

Originally posted by Timacek

UO had full loot, and i can imagine that ER will have the same perfect system as UO did.

And gear will be easy to replace. I cant wait to someone release sandbox MMORPG. Games without freedom and complexity maybe for you, but for me, its sandbox style!

 

Yes UO had full loot. And it was such a disaster that they got rid of it. And no game has done it since.

 

Yes, and look at how many full loot Fel servers there are now through RunUO.  A lot of people were outraged when they put insurance into UO, myself included. 

A related note, the game's community was several times better before they added insurance.  Between Tram and insurance, the game and it's community went straight to Hell.

Once a true sandbox mmorpg will be released, it will have huuge community.

People from sanbox uo shards come in, angry people from the Darkfall will join too. Not mentioning the very huge base of people from SWG, who left after the NGE hit.

All in all, there is a very massive huge amount of people waiting for freedom and complexity. Iam one of them.

I remember making my first nail

which was used in making the chair

I miss the taming my very  first horse

Let Earthrise show everyone sandbox course.

Originally posted by gorgondo

Originally posted by ghoul31

Originally posted by Timacek

UO had full loot, and i can imagine that ER will have the same perfect system as UO did.

And gear will be easy to replace. I cant wait to someone release sandbox MMORPG. Games without freedom and complexity maybe for you, but for me, its sandbox style!

 

Yes UO had full loot. And it was such a disaster that they got rid of it. And no game has done it since.

 

 

Yes, and look at how many full loot Fel servers there are now through RunUO.  A lot of people were outraged when they put insurance into UO, myself included. 

A related note, the game's community was several times better before they added insurance.  Between Tram and insurance, the game and it's community went straight to Hell.

funny, i remember the population spiking AFTER trammal ....

Originally posted by tvalentine

Originally posted by gorgondo

Originally posted by ghoul31

Originally posted by Timacek

UO had full loot, and i can imagine that ER will have the same perfect system as UO did.

And gear will be easy to replace. I cant wait to someone release sandbox MMORPG. Games without freedom and complexity maybe for you, but for me, its sandbox style!

Yes UO had full loot. And it was such a disaster that they got rid of it. And no game has done it since. 

Yes, and look at how many full loot Fel servers there are now through RunUO.  A lot of people were outraged when they put insurance into UO, myself included. 

A related note, the game's community was several times better before they added insurance.  Between Tram and insurance, the game and it's community went straight to Hell.

funny, i remember the population spiking AFTER trammal ....

Well yes and no. After Trammel was introduced a large part of the community started to leave, but to offset that there started an even larger influx of new and returning players. I was part of the returning players contingent, but not because I didn't like UO pre-Ren, I just had other things going on that interfered with MMOG playing. It's all academic now since Ultima Online is a shell of it's former self... What this demonstrates is simply that there are a lot more casual gamers in the world than anything else. 

As for the full looting in Earthrise, it will be fine. Not every game system or MMOG is for everyone. There is a large gamer demographic that loves games with more open "sandbox" type features and harsher gameplay. It will do fine...

Originally posted by ghoul31

Originally posted by Timacek

UO had full loot, and i can imagine that ER will have the same perfect system as UO did.

And gear will be easy to replace. I cant wait to someone release sandbox MMORPG. Games without freedom and complexity maybe for you, but for me, its sandbox style!

 

Yes UO had full loot. And it was such a disaster that they got rid of it. And no game has done it since.

  

 

  Really no one...hmmmm EVE does !!! minus what gets blown up :)

full loot is very discouraging for players, it promotes a very nasty way of behaving towards people who have lost, a game like EVE is not as "avatar" driven. It's one thing to lose your bag of gold, losing all loot is a bit like being demoted several ranks and nobody likes that.

Originally posted by havel

full loot is very discouraging for players, it promotes a very nasty way of behaving towards people who have lost, a game like EVE is not as "avatar" driven. It's one thing to lose your bag of gold, losing all loot is a bit like being demoted several ranks and nobody likes that.

But consequence (rewards and penalties) makes my heart beat faster when I PvP.

Originally posted by havel

full loot is very discouraging for players

speak for yourself :P

It's the same for everyone.

Can't handle it? You lose.

Games such as EvE Online and Tibia is all about social skills. 

So get friends before they're someone elses!