<
>

Page 1 of 2

1

2

 Thread (40 posts)
Teala  7/12/08 10:29:52 AM

Rank: 17/100 Rank: 17/100 Rank: 17/100 Rank: 17/100 Rank: 17/100

Novice Member

Joined: 6/16/04
Posts: 1866

God made women because mens brains are broken.

Over at AoC VN boards a poll was set up.  Just after release the game got a B.  See original post here.   Another poll was recently set-up and this is the results.  Click here.   So I'd like to poll the readers of MMORPG.com and see how they vote.  Grade AoC today.  Please be honest and only vote if you ahve played the game.

 

Forum Poll

What grade do you give AoC today?

A
B
C
D
F
(login to vote)

kikinchaz  7/12/08 10:35:52 AM

Rank: 42/100 Rank: 42/100 Rank: 42/100 Rank: 42/100 Rank: 42/100

Advanced Member

Joined: 10/08/06
Posts: 346

D here. Not awful - theres alot worse out there. But its just not good atm. Alot missing, too many broken promises, lack of content, instanced, lack of that "real world" feeling, and alot more. The game has alot of potential, but sadly by the time it reaches it, there could be much much better MMO experiences out there with WAR, LOTRO Mines of Moria and WotLK - only time will tell.

 
Jackdog  7/12/08 11:14:55 AM

Rank: 40/100 Rank: 40/100 Rank: 40/100 Rank: 40/100 Rank: 40/100

Apprentice Member

Joined: 3/19/04
Posts: 3793

I give the game a C, was torn between C and D and there was no C-. Graphics, music and first 20 or 30 levels of quests are awesome. City layout and population is outstanding.  If I was grading Funcom I would give them a D-.  CS, community handling, patches etc suck big time


nemo38  7/12/08 11:22:20 AM

Rank: 26/100 Rank: 26/100 Rank: 26/100 Rank: 26/100 Rank: 26/100

Apprentice Member

Joined: 12/21/06
Posts: 120

I gave it a C also. The more patches I download the more bugs I see. However I'm not ready to start crying like a baby about being ripped off just yet. thnx for asking.

 
heartless  7/12/08 11:29:26 AM

Rank: 40/100 Rank: 40/100 Rank: 40/100 Rank: 40/100 Rank: 40/100

Apprentice Member

Joined: 1/05/04
Posts: 833

pwnt

F for epic Fail!

Seriously though, if they ever manage to fix it, it may become a decent niche game. Will they ever fix it? Judging by the recent letter from their director, I highly doubt it. The man has lost contact with reality.

Thradar  7/12/08 11:33:45 AM

Rank: 50/100 Rank: 50/100 Rank: 50/100 Rank: 50/100 Rank: 50/100

Advanced Member

Joined: 11/11/07
Posts: 371

C for the game itself.  Meh.
D- for readiness at launch.

 
Meridion  7/12/08 11:35:30 AM

Rank: 100/100 Rank: 100/100 Rank: 100/100 Rank: 100/100 Rank: 100/100

Elite Member

Joined: 6/22/06
Posts: 734

DaoC, EQ2, DnL, WoW, GW, SWG, AC, LotRo, Tibia, EvE - atm: WAR

It's exactly what I expected it to be: A  revolutionary multiplayer action tactic loaded gfx demo with sounds. Wheres the MMORPG in this thing?

M

>You hit God with 'Atheism' for 0 points of damage (status immunity).
>Turn ends.
>God casts 'summon plague'
>You suffer from 'Glioblastoma multiforme'
>God's 'Glioblastoma multiforme' hits you for 73281 points of damage.
>You die. Quit? (y/n)

Gamefreek333  7/12/08 11:38:20 AM

Rank: 8/100 Rank: 8/100 Rank: 8/100 Rank: 8/100 Rank: 8/100

Novice Member

Joined: 12/16/07
Posts: 141

I gave it a D. The game's graphics are amazing, and it's combat system is unique from any other game I've played. But so many things get broken with each patch!

I agree with others; If we were grading Funcom, we'd have to make up an entirely new grade. It should be Failcom...

Die_Scream  7/12/08 1:11:36 PM

Rank: 85/100 Rank: 85/100 Rank: 85/100 Rank: 85/100 Rank: 85/100

Elite Member

Joined: 9/11/06
Posts: 1081

"I don''t care! I''m gonna eat somebody."

Graphics - A

Gameplay - C

Patches - F

Dev Communication - F

Community - B (in game) F (official boards)

Overall, I gave it a D.

"nerf rock, paper is working as intended."

- Scissors.

Elsabolts  7/12/08 1:15:52 PM

Rank: 42/100 Rank: 42/100 Rank: 42/100 Rank: 42/100 Rank: 42/100

Advanced Member

Joined: 10/03/06
Posts: 520

F, I believe they intenenionally hyped the game knowing full well game was not what they said it was going to be as to get abit of money up front hoping to keep enough folks around to scam abit more each month.

 
quixadhal  7/12/08 1:18:13 PM