<
>
 Thread (14 posts)
Galaxo  7/09/08 3:52:19 PM

Rank: 61/100 Rank: 61/100 Rank: 61/100 Rank: 61/100 Rank: 61/100

Hard Core Member

Joined: 3/08/08
Posts: 190

I intend to live forever - So far so good!

---ROMANIA---

I don't play any game right now but i'm thinking to give a try to Istaria: Chronicles of the Gifted untill Ryzom comes back.

Have someone tried the game?

 
Gilgameesh  7/09/08 8:10:57 PM

Rank: 89/100 Rank: 89/100 Rank: 89/100 Rank: 89/100 Rank: 89/100

Elite Member

Joined: 10/27/06
Posts: 194

Pay to play, don''t pay to replay!

Originally posted by Galaxo

I don't play any game right now but i'm thinking to give a try to Istaria: Chronicles of the Gifted untill Ryzom comes back.

Have someone tried the game?

 

If you are speaking of Horizons, i tried it. Graphics and animations are simply horrible. Maybe good as f2p but i would never sub for a game as that. (my info are almost 6 months old, so things can be changed)

Anyway, this is just my opinion, always better to see and judge by yourself.

 

Ryzom (Arispotle) (active) Gilgameesh, Tryker, Follower of Jena, Legion of Atys High Officer
CoH/CoV (Union) (break) @Gilgameesh and others, Immortals founder
Vanguard (Sartok) (break) Gilgameesh Bloodheart, Italian MLS member
Gilgameesh played AoC, AO/NW/SL/AI/LE, LOTRO, GW, EQ2, SWG, EVE, DDO, DAOC, LC, AA, PlanetSide and some other better to forget.
Gilgameesh was in the D'ni Cavern.
The best MMORPG? the one where you are having fun.

Tuyet  7/09/08 10:11:59 PM

Rank: 87/100 Rank: 87/100 Rank: 87/100 Rank: 87/100 Rank: 87/100

Elite Member

Joined: 3/02/08
Posts: 70

I tried it when it was stii Horizons, think I stopped just before the name change.

The graphics are not close to Ryzom's graphics.

It is skil lbased but the skills add up together in a somewhat complicated formula to give a character level. There is a mechanism to forget learned skills so that one can learn other skills. Sounds like it makes it interesting to create different skill sets for one's character.

I mostly just did the crafting. Lots of different crafts with crafts splitting off at different levels.The collection/harvesting of mats is just go out and get em with different game areas for harvesting and hunting. At least at the first levels -- higher levels prob get more interesting for harvesting.

Pretty nice game really, sounds like it is financially sound with some good developers who are dedicated to their game. They've put a lot of work into salvaging their game and making it a solid game. Still needs a lot of work to bring it up to todays standards but they are going in the right direction from what I saw.

 
green13  7/10/08 12:15:52 AM

Rank: 81/100 Rank: 81/100 Rank: 81/100 Rank: 81/100 Rank: 81/100

Elite Member

Joined: 8/02/06
Posts: 597

What game am I playing right now?

mmorpg.com

What?! It's not a game??

%^ck

Oh well...

But I would be playing Horizons right now, if not for a little.... disagreement I had with the devs over their "hands off" approach to dealing with troublemakers.

Like Gilgameesh has pointed out, the graphics are old and a bit shabby - but that only applies to the landscape. Character animations aren't so bad. The dragons, in particular, can pretty awesome. I developed a slightly narcissistic bent, gazing at my pretty, shiny (and enormous) scaly butt...

It is THE mmo to play if you like the idea of building. I had soooooo much fun planning and building my lair. Never seen a building system anywhere near as good as the one in Istaria.

Community is mostly good, but there's also a really nasty element who are allowed pretty much free reign. At least as my guild explained it to me, it's been that way for years. On the Chaos server at least. Order doesn't seem to have that problem. There - I've saved you the trouble Katriell :P

If you like the idea of playing dragons - this is the only mmo that lets you do it.

The 3 serious gameplay downsides in my opinion:

  1. Dragons are a bit limited - theoretically you can play a dragon melee'er or a dragon spellcaster, but dragon melee is about 10 times as powerful as spellcasting, so spellcasting is just for masochists. This is obviously no problem at all if you actually want to melee.
  2. Unlike Ryzom, Istaria's multiclassing (for non-dragons, i.e. bipeds) is a complete disaster. It essentially kills group-play. The only times people team up are to eg. kill mega-bosses for quests (and that's not needed often). I've never played any other mmo where the game mechanics actually discourage teaming up for combat.
  3. Unbelievably long load times. I have a P4 with 2 gig of RAM. I don't have any problems with load times for any on- or off-line games, except for Istaria. It wasn't uncommon to have to wait 5 minutes (and sometimes longer) for the game to load when you portal between areas. I also couldn't play for more than 4 hours without needing to reboot my machine.
 
Arcken  7/10/08 12:17:00 AM

Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100 Rank: 1/100

Novice Member

Joined: 8/14/04
Posts: 1032

Im playing the waiting game. Cmon WAR!

 
green13  7/10/08 12:24:16 AM

Rank: 81/100 Rank: 81/100 Rank: 81/100 Rank: 81/100 Rank: 81/100

Elite Member

Joined: 8/02/06
Posts: 597

Originally posted by Tuyet

I mostly just did the crafting. Lots of different crafts with crafts splitting off at different levels.The collection/harvesting of mats is just go out and get em with different game areas for harvesting and hunting. At least at the first levels -- higher levels prob get more interesting for harvesting.

They don't. It's basically the same all the way to the top. There might be just be a few materials you need to kill stuff for - that's as interesting as that gets.

It has been argued (somewhat fairly) that harvesting just becomes tedious at higher levels, as you'll need to spend more time dragging harvested materials around very, very, very slowly on your cargo disc. Though I  believe they've revamped cargo discs recently to make this less time-consuming.

There also comes a point where you either need to have your own land (with silos and crafting machines) or join a guild that has them - and joining a guild is generally a good idea anyway.

I think Istaria has a good crafting/harvesting system, but it pales in comparion to Ryzom's.

 
jackoba  7/10/08 2:15:28 AM

Rank: 56/100 Rank: 56/100 Rank: 56/100 Rank: 56/100 Rank: 56/100

Advanced Member

Joined: 12/12/05
Posts: 108

Klients online

Tho I re-subbed to eve, then un-subbed 2 hrs later and have no loaded it since

I'm also on my last 30 days of vanguard but not logged in to play for ages

 
Galaxo  7/10/08 5:57:00 AM

Rank: 61/100 Rank: 61/100 Rank: 61/100 Rank: 61/100 Rank: 61/100

Hard Core Member

Joined: 3/08/08
Posts: 190

I intend to live forever - So far so good!

---ROMANIA---

Originally posted by jackoba

Klients online

Tho I re-subbed to eve, then un-subbed 2 hrs later and have no loaded it since

I'm also on my last 30 days of vanguard but not logged in to play for ages

 

Do you have a buddy key for Vanguard?I want to try it too..

Edit: I got one ..

 
thorwood  7/10/08 6:09:16 AM

Rank: 50/100 Rank: 50/100 Rank: 50/100 Rank: 50/100 Rank: 50/100

Advanced Member

Joined: 10/04/07
Posts: 170

I liked Istaria (Horizons) when I played it.

The bipeds (non-dragon classes) can train in more than one class (multi-class).   You can switch between classes by talking to a trainer.  Some skills carry over between classes, so if you have trained several classes you are much more powerful.  I liked this aspect and its is different from most other games.

The crafting system was the best I have seen in any of the 10 MMO's I have tried.  Leveling training skills was a grind, but profitable.

You can build structures in the world that are "permanent" as long as you continue to play the game.

Its several years since I played, so the graphics may well be dated now. 

It is all one big world, so loading is slow in some areas.  There were no instances.  Even the main cities are part of the one big world.

There were lots of innovative ideas that could have made this game great if the technical challenges could have been solved.

 
Sasi  7/11/08 10:17:29 AM

Rank: 76/100 Rank: 76/100 Rank: 76/100 Rank: 76/100 Rank: 76/100

Hard Core Member

Joined: 8/31/07
Posts: 68

I enjoyed a free trial period in Istaria. I liked harvesting and crafting, the combat wasn't too great. I liked playing a dryad, too.

But I decided to focus on playing with my guildies in Eve, so I never subbed.

===============================
Acting Guild Leader of Pegasus Foundation
in Ryzom

Cynthe  7/11/08 10:33:11 AM