| Thread (221 posts) | ||
|---|---|---|
|
Raston 5/23/08 4:14:09 PM
|
||
|
Hard Core Member
Joined: 9/19/06 |
Originally posted by scarothers08 I disagree with your classification about who would like the game. I'm personally loving it and I've played nigh on every MMO that is out there. Have I hit them all? No, but I've played alot of them and betaed even more than that. Been playing MMOs since may of 1999 (Asheron's call), and I've not been as excited or as pleased with a game since AC as I am with AoC. Opinions differ, just because mine does doesn't mean I'm a MMO newb (so to speak) |
|
|
scarothers08 5/23/08 4:34:57 PM
|
||
|
Novice Member
Joined: 5/20/08 |
Originally posted by Raston Please reread deeper. I stated most people that had a problem. I also said it comes down to personal tastes too. I am really glad you enjoy your AoC gaming. I only try to offer the other side of it. Every thing has two sides. Pro and con. I mayself am on the con side. I am sure there are alot of people that want and need to hear both side before making up their minds on buying game. Not everyone can afford to dish out $50 or more on a game on a wim. I too waiting with excitement for this game for any months. I read and watched everything. In the end, I was disappointed. My tastes differ from your, and thats okay. |
|
| |
||
|
Brannigan 5/23/08 5:30:53 PM
|
||
|
Novice Member
Joined: 6/18/07 |
I was only trying to say: I want an open-world with lesser marvellous graphic and more PC's action-talking around me, more people to meet.Not so instanced,not so zoned,not so game-immersion breaker.Too many pvp/pve campers?Raise respawn rate and put some guard patroIs,I'm/I will get used to them.IMHO.BIG QUOTE to scarothers8(can't remember full nick). |
|
|
Reyzoul 5/23/08 6:11:54 PM
|
||
|
Novice Member
Joined: 4/23/05 |
I'm probably going out to purchase the game today to check it out but.. thought I'd try to comment here as I think I understand what the original poster was getting at.
Imagine realizing that your player keep is under attack (or will be soon). Obviously you defend it but perhaps you also
And you couldn't camp the choke points either.. since again.. once they realize you are camping the choke point in instance3, they all swap to instance4 instead and bypass you. |
|
| |
||
|
Majestico 5/23/08 6:27:45 PM
|
||
|
Hard Core Member
Joined: 1/18/07
''Hey now!'' - the immortal, cheesy catch-phrase of Hank Kingsly from The Larry Sanders Show. |
Having read the bulk of the posts here, I am somewhat disappointed to hear about this 'instancing' of the game. Also, a lot of people seem to have confused the issue with 'zoning', which is a completely different question altogther, and not relevant to what the OP was saying. I was about to upgrade my pc, so that I could try this game, but now I am having second thoughts. I knew about the 'zoning' and as I liked EQ2, it was not a major issue for me. However, if the outside world is instanced, as in a game like 'guild wars' that changes everything for me. So, before I spend money on this, how much instancing happens in the game? Is the gameplay akin to Guild Wars? If so, then I shall just wait for the x-box launch next year. Also, in an unrelated topic. Shadenis: I noticed in your sig that you have played most of the major MMO's out there, but not EQ1 or 2, and was just curious as to why? No other reason, other than I am a nosey bugger! :) |
|
|
terrant 5/23/08 6:34:37 PM
|
||
|
Novice Member
Joined: 3/16/07 |
Originally posted by MajesticoThe outside world IS instanced....all zones are.
This does not mean you can't ever play with your friends or anything like that. Now, it DOES mean you can't gank to your heart's content. If someone feels griefed they can change instances. And it does mena you won't have overcrowding and spawn competition as badly as some other games. Now on the flip, there are some downsides. but the game's pretty, I like the class system, the world, the combat engine, etc...so to me it's worth any negative impact instancing might have. It's not like GW though. When you leave a city, you and/or your party are NOT the only ones in that copy of the outside zone. The only time instancing comes to play is when there's too many people in a copy of a zone, or if a player manually chooses to leave that copy for some reason. Otherwise, you're all together. |
|
| |
||
|
odysseas70 5/23/08 6:40:32 PM
|
||
|
Apprentice Member
Joined: 7/30/05 |
I'm so dissapointed and even pissed.....lol I've read 16 freaking pages only to see that the majority of people confuse "instances" to "zones". They think instances are zones and they "defend" the instaned AoC talking about zones. Let me explain it very simple. Say the game's map is Europe. The different zones are the different countries. So once you walk to the borders of Germany you're going to enter a different zone that is -lets say- France. Now, if there are enough people in France already, the game creates a copy (instance) of France. France Nr. 2. So say the limit of people who can be in one copy of France is 100, then the 101st person that enters France (#1), he will actually enter France #2. This is the difference of a zone (France, as an area) and instances (copies of France like France #1, France #2 etc because each copy of France (istances) can only have (lets say) only 100 people playing inside). Now, let me put it again very simple. A game having many zones is not a real problem. There's no big deal if you have a load screen every once in a while if you travel from Germany to France to Spain etc. In some games those zones are bigger than others, not a big problem. However, the different copies (instances) ARE a big (huge) problem. Why? Let me put it very simple. PvE-ers have no problem with instances. less people camping their good spots, less people going after the same mobs for their quests, less people (etc etc), as well as less lag etc. PvP-ers (like me) however, absolutely loath (hate) instances. Why? Because if some freakin ass**** attacked me as I was XPing earlier with 2 mobs on me and low health and killed me, and I want to hunt him down and get revenge, and he runs out of Germany to France and he ends up in France #2 while I end up in France #3 because France #2 maxed out in population, I don't want to spend the rest of my time guessing where the freakin dude went, or all the more so, not being able to go (enter) where he went. And hey, that was a simple example. If any of you played Lineage II he'd understand me. Say a group of my guild of like 16 people are XPing in some place and a party of an enemy guild of 25 people comes, takes us by surprise and kills (most of) us. So now we want to take revenge. We gather a group of 25-30 people and go after them. But hey, we can NOT go after them, because even if we KNOW they are in England, they are in England #1 and we can NOT enter England #1 because it has max population. We tried and we entered England #2. So that's it. End of the fight, end of the day, end of story. A game that has instanced zones is not an open world game, PERIOD. When you can not find your enemies to hunt them, when you can not raid the area they are XPing to cause them trouble or take revenge for whatever reason, when you just stay in different copies of the same world and have them laugh at you because they ganged you earlier and there's nothing you can do now to revenge them then............ .. to heck with it. Eve online had many zones but there was no problem. Because if you entered a zone (a system called XYZ lets say), that was it. One system, one zone for all inside. If your enemies were there you WOULD gonna find them and fight with them. Who gave a shit if there was thousands of zones? Nobody. Because it was ONE world (one instance for all). The good, the neutral and the bad, the friends and the enemies all there for whoever to do anything he liked. Lineage II was the same. Some dude killed you? You had a spy or a friend who tipped you where he was? You could go and FIND him and take your revenge. Simple as that. Now he's gonna say "hey, that guy who killed you was sighted in France #2 but he was seen zoning out to Germany, so he might be anywhere between Germany #1 and Germany #123 - good luck) lol Fuck it. As I said, instances are for PvE-ers. PvPers want to have their friends close and their enemies even closer. Enjoy.
|
|
| |
||
|
masterjedi 5/23/08 6:41:20 PM
|
||