I found out crafting in most games sux because the crafting is always the last to get update or never. And quest or drop items always better than crafted items. It is pointless to spend long time to be able to craft useless armors or weapons.

Any game has better crafting?

EQII came close to a very compelling crafting system. I've never crafted in SWG, however I hear it was even better than EQII (opinions may vary). Depending on who you talk to crafting can be an enjoyable system or a carpal tunnel grind fest (time sink). With the newgen players they don't seem to like the complexity you'd find in say the original EQ or in EQII so I wouldn't expect you'll see anything as involved as those two games anymore.

Bear in mind this is just a opinion but EvE has a pretty good crafting system partly because it was one of the main features when the game was originally made and released 5 years ago.

Originally posted by HYPERI0N

Bear in mind this is just a opinion but EvE has a pretty good crafting system partly because it was one of the main features when the game was originally made and released 5 years ago.

Yah I'm forced to admit that eves crafting rocks. It combines achieved skill with the ability to submit jobs and go afk. SWG had exactly the same idea with factories.

I like PotBS crafting.  You have warehouses and resource on different islands, and to make stuff you have to ship things for one island to another, sometimes going through a pvp area.

Pvp areas can be created just to block good resources for strategic purposes.
Very cool stuff, but It can be a bit slow paced.

Originally posted by grimboj

Originally posted by HYPERI0N

Bear in mind this is just a opinion but EvE has a pretty good crafting system partly because it was one of the main features when the game was originally made and released 5 years ago.

Yah I'm forced to admit that eves crafting rocks. It combines achieved skill with the ability to submit jobs and go afk. SWG had exactly the same idea with factories.

Yea and you can even do stuff like hire miners from outside of your Guild to do your mining for you now which can be a big help if your regular miners cant turn up for some reason.

crafting isn't just the actual making of the items, crafting includes logistics, and maximizing ROI.

No one wants it.

EQ2 when released had by far... by so fukking far the most complexe and community oriented crafting system.
But the crowd, who were not scared away by the group-oriented content said, they don´t like it.

Not EVE, not Horizons, not Vanguard reached it.
It just was not wanted.

Ryzom has the best crafting, IMO.

It depends more on the player's skill and knowledge in experimenting to achieve the best combinations of various materials, ergo the best item stats, than on level.

There are several categories of materials, and within each of those are several types, and for each type there are five grades: Basic, Fine, Choice, Excellent, and Supreme. Supreme materials' stats usually look good, but in practice they aren't always the best choice. Materials react to each other, resulting in unpredicted combination effects, so to bring out the best aspects of one material you may have to use other materials of types and grades you wouldn't have expected.

The ecosystem a material is harvested from, along with its grade, determines its colour; the amount and grades of the materials of a particular colour you use determine whether the resultant item will be that colour, or the colour of other materials you're using.

Materials also have a numeric "quality" from 1 to 250, but this only affects what numeric quality an item using them will be, which determines the maximum values of its stats and its equipping requirements.

For each craftable item there are three or four versions of the crafting plan: basic, "Medium Quality," and "High Quality," and some have an extra with a special visual effect. For example, a basic Matis two-handed sword is called Slathe, and it's brownish. A medium-quality one is called Modi-Slathe and is beige with patterned greenish highlights. A high-quality one is called Kara-Slathe and is silver. The special one is called Living Slathe and drips green poison. Despite the reference to quality in the names of these crafting plans, they don't directly affect the stats of items produced via them - that's still up to the player. They do however require progressively more materials, so with the high-quality and special plans the player has more room to toy with combinations of materials.

Ryzom's crafting is independent of combat in this way: Your combat levels have no effect on your crafting levels, so a crafter never needs to fight. On the other hand, a player can choose to do only combat, but they have to rely on items made by crafters because mobs only drop craftable materials, in general, and those very few that don't either drop specialised equipment of one particular type, keeping 99% of crafting unaffected, or their drops must be assembled by a crafter. NPC-sold items are total junk, and expensive at that. Quests only reward fame with tribes, races, and/or factions. Materials dropped by named creatures and bosses tend to be desirable, and drops from lesser creatures can also be useful, so even if a crafter doesn't fight, they may need to procure such materials from players who do. This creates a reciprocal dependence between crafters and fighters.

Though Ryzom's unlimited skill system allows players the freedom to do anything and everything, including being both master crafter and master fighter, crafting must be levelled through use just like any other skill. Therefore not everyone pursues it. Of those who do, fewer have obtained all the crafting plans and reached the level-250 max that lets them craft the highest numerical quality (to meet the needs of players with high-level skills) in multiple craft skill branches. Of those who've done that, even fewer have the player skill to become truly notable for creating not only great items, but items with whatever particular strengths the buyer requests.

The harvesting system, though on a separate skill tree, goes hand-in-hand with the crafting system and delivers its own complexities. Scattered around the world are "nodes" of material sources; the vast majority of these are hidden and must be brought to light by prospecting...

To explain what I'm about to say, I point out that Ryzom lets you customise your actions and spells with a system of "stanzas." You buy various action components from trainers with Skill Points garnered from gaining levels in corresponding skill trees, as well as action credits. Then you right-click on your hotkey bar and select Create New Action. Now you're faced with a window where you choose a basic template for your action, i.e. healing spell, melee attack, crafting, material extraction, prospecting, etc. After making that choice, you add actions to change the methods and effects, then add credits to pay off the total value of the actions by expending HP, MP (called "Sap" in Ryzom), stamina, or focus (a pool used only by harvesting and crafting). Or, in the case of spells, increasing casting time and/or diminishing spell range.

...Anyway, you can customise your prospecting to fit different situations or achieve different effects. Harvesting in the desert? Add a stanza that provides a bonus to your success rate in the desert. Want to see the names of the materials in a source before you go over to that source and start digging at it? Add the "Knowledge 1" stanza. Want to find Supreme materials but don't know exactly where to look? Add "Supreme Only" and "500m Tracking" to turn your prospecting into tracking that can lead you to the nearest active Supreme node within five hundred metres.

The availability of some materials is affected by season, weather, and time of day. In a given place you may find Choice Motega Wood most of the time, but on a clear night in autumn find Excellent and Supreme Motega Wood. Everywhere but in the underground caverns called the Prime Roots, which constitute one of the five ecosystems in Ryzom (the others are Desert, Forest, Jungle, and Lakelands), Basic, Fine, and Choice materials are always available, with Excellent and Supreme being the only ones subject to season/weather/time conditions. In the PR Choice is also subject.

While you extract/dig materials out of a source, you have some bars to look after:
- One represents the tolerance of the religious-factional nature entities called the Kami, who as self-proclaimed preservers of the planet, will kill harvesters who dig too aggressively for too long in a concentrated area. This used to actually happen sometimes to large groups of harvesters, but at some point the Kami tolerance was raised so it can hardly ever happen anymore.
- The amount of time left before the source disappears. This is about a minute by default, but can be raised if you use certain stanzas in your prospecting.
- The number of materials left in the source.
- Source life. If this bar reaches zero, the source disappears prematurely and there's a chance the node will be depleted prematurely as well. This brings us to the third type of harvesting action: Care Plan. One of the stanzas available to the careplan action template is Resource Preservation, which, when used, increases the source life bar.
- Source stability. If this reaches zero, the source either explodes, causing immediate damage, or releases a toxic cloud that causes damage over time. The careplan stanza Ground Stability increases this bar.

How severe explosions and toxic clouds are, how quickly certain bars decrease, etc. is affected by the source mode, which changes occasionally and is displayed in the system info window. Though you can't change the source mode, you can directly affect the same factors it affects by choosing the stanzas in your harvesting action wisely. To calm a volatile source, you can use a higher ratio of Gentle stanzas. To take advantage of an already-stable source, you can use a higher ratio of Harmful stanzas to get more materials faster for less Focus drainage. Alternatively, you can have another player careplan the sources you dig, so all you have to worry about is digging and you can do so more aggressively because the careplanning is now constant instead of intermittent. With a careplanner or two, you have more room to experiment with prospecting and harvesting stanzas to squeeze the most out of every source.

I've probably neglected some details, but this post is long enough and I'm done typing. xD

EDIT: Ryzom has item durability/wear-out.

FFXI is said to have THE BEST crafting system.

And id agree.

Its very very simple, yet very very very complex at the same time, and without crafters, there wouldnt be a lot of good gear in the game.

Originally posted by CDCosta

without crafters, there wouldnt be a lot of good gear in the game.

 

Bren

I totally agree with the OP. In most games crafting is an afterthought. And It's a shame because crafting can keep people from getting bored. EnB had a really cool crafting system where all races pretty much depended on each other and only the best items in the game were crafted (or modified). That's an aspect of MMO's that I haven't seen since.

And thats why FFXI's crafting was so good.

Some people deticated a lot of time into crafting and it took lots of time and money to max out the craft.

swg was great in that it was useful.   Problem most games have is the whole paradigm.  The community has this mind frame that has cause the narrow minded devs to keep within the walls.  They need to break free and take it to the next level.  The next level may not feel good at first or look good on paper but it needs to make that step.

Originally posted by Brenelael

 

Originally posted by CDCosta

without crafters, there wouldnt be a lot of good gear in the game.

 

This is the basic principal that most games of the WoW era of MMOs just don't get. Crafting has to have a real purpose or its pointless for people to invest time in it. In my opinion all gear except the very basic noob gear should be player crafted only. The game that does this will be a crafter's paradise as they will be in high demand. This would also promote a very healthy player run economy as the prices for everything would be set by the players and competition would keep the prices reasonable.

 

 

Bren

Adventures need some immediate reward for killing some mob, waiting and being dependent on a crafter (and yes I was both) just sucks.

Venge Sunsoar

To the poster above me:

I agree that ALL armour should NOT be crafted, nor should it all be the BEST. But it should definately have its big part in the game, and tahts why i have to keep mentioning FFXIs crafting system. Allthough i dont play it anymore, id love to see more MMOs follow its crafting.

Originally posted by VengeSunsoar

 

Originally posted by Brenelael

 

Originally posted by CDCosta

without crafters, there wouldnt be a lot of good gear in the game.

 

This is the basic principal that most games of the WoW era of MMOs just don't get. Crafting has to have a real purpose or its pointless for people to invest time in it. In my opinion all gear except the very basic noob gear should be player crafted only. The game that does this will be a crafter's paradise as they will be in high demand. This would also promote a very healthy player run economy as the prices for everything would be set by the players and competition would keep the prices reasonable.

 

 

Bren

I don't really agree with this.  Horizons had all gear crafted, and while the crafters loved it, the adventurers hated it.  There was no reward for fighting that mob.  Oh they would get a crafting component but then they would either have to wait and craft it themselves or find a crafter willing to make it if, you could, then wait for the crafter to make it, which sometimes took days depending on when he was on, when your on, and how hard it was to make. 

 

Adventures need some immediate reward for killing some mob, waiting and being dependent on a crafter (and yes I was both) just sucks.

Venge Sunsoar

You hit the nail on the head.  I despise games that make me either dependent on a crafter to get my gear or make me feel like I must craft to be competitive.  If it was up to me, all gear would be drops or bought from merchants.   OK if other players sell the gear they make/own to me as well, as long as its on a marketplace, and not done by bargining/shouting.

Originally posted by CDCosta

FFXI is said to have THE BEST crafting system.

I heard from someone who crafted in FFXI and he said it was utterly pointless.

To sell his items, he would have to sell them at 1/5 of material price or something.

Originally posted by Adamantine

 

Originally posted by CDCosta

FFXI is said to have THE BEST crafting system.

.. really ??

 

I heard from someone who crafted in FFXI and he said it was utterly pointless.

To sell his items, he would have to sell them at 1/5 of material price or something.

 

But it was, and if not for the RMT (real money traders) "goldfarmers" it would still be the best.

FFXI has the most involved crafting there is, one of the most rewarding I'd say, makes a whole lot more sence than WoW's which is more like a side quest than crafting

Example?

Since when does making bandages make you better and USING bandages?   Thats stupid

WoW's   Crafting was way too easy, FFXI's may be a little too involved for most people to understand.

Two opposite ends of the spectrum

The Reason FFXI's Economy is broken is because they have no durability on their items, so when you make the BEST ARMOR IN THE GAME type stuff it gets passed around until everyone has one and the price drops a lot on it because of market saturation.

The fix?  add durability, or make things Bind when equip.