Heres a list of ALL the things that would describe my DREAM MMO.

• No levels. 100% skill based, you buy skills/gear from NPC's OR get them as Drops, or buy them off other players, OR craft them (including skills)
• Skills and gear from drops, NPC's, Players, and crafting are ALL equally good. But all of them are unique in their own ways.
• NO classes. Be whatever you want. Each player can wield all sorts of gear, mail plate cloth leather etc. But each kind of armour has their advantages, and their disadvantages. Same with weapons. You finish deeds (like in LOTRO) and get the ability to equip certain armours and weapons.
• Alot of character customization, kinda like CoH/CoV. A great variety of races.
• Free For All PvP - With FULL player looting. (Yeah, sounds like Darkfall doesnt it?)
• Sieging. Destroyable building's and cities made by players AND npc's. A group of players can destroy other cities, but they're guarded by .. well... GUARDS. And in the end, you get rewarded like saaaaay you get what the city was worth and its divided amongst the players.
• Player owned houses and guild halls. BOTH instances like in the future of LOTRO.
• No button smashing, not FPS either. Like TCoS or AoC or Darkfall (without the 1s person).
• Mount combat.
• Naval combat.
• Other players can board your ships, naval combat mainly like PotBS.
• A major role of player economy, MOST of the items in game to be player crafted.
• A fair bit of grinding aswell as questing.
• Amazing animations.
• Good looking spells, not like Fury though - so much light and explosions you cant even see wtf is happening.
• Ofcourse, top of the line graphics with an AMAZING engine.
• In a fantasy setting, with a mix of mideval.
• Ability to train your own armies (of maximum 10 soldiers), Squad combat ... like Guildwars ? (Plays minor role - you dont NEED them to play)
• Flying mounts aswell.
• Gainable titles like in LOTRO, but they give you buffs.
• Arena's ; like from WoW, but only small and short - kinda like GuildWars.
• NO HEALING! Mentioning arena's from guildwars reminded me of the healfest.
• Massive gear customization, logo's on armour - writings on swords, blood on your axes, cracks on your hammer. You can customize your gear while crafting, customization depends on how much raw material you use, say one bar of iron can only make a small dagger. This also determines the speed and damage. 10 bars would make a 2 handed mace, therefore slower but more damage. Crafting system such that almost no gear looks similar.

Well thats what I want. The closest thing to my list is definately Darkfall, but im slowly losing interest looking at the graphics slowly getting outdated and the First Person view kinda looked gay from the videos. But only time will tell.

What do YOU want in your dream MMO?

(Im bored, thats why I just wrote that! Theres almost no good MMO out there for me atm)

AoC Graphics

AC1 Gameplay

EQ2 Content

WoW Appeal

DAoC PvP

SWG Character Creation

AO community  ( I haven't been playing long but these guys are really helpful )

Similar to the "Too many MMOs" thread...

Sci-Fi world

Skill-based, no classes

Planetside targeting/combat (no aim assist)

DAoC PvP

All player created gear with components dropped by PvE or crafted

Crafting complexity on par with SWG/EQ2

1st person

Realistic lighting (night is DARK not just a blue hue shift with daytime clipping plane)

Established IP perhaps (eg Star Wars, Star Trek, 40K, Starcraft)

My dream MMO?

Easy. That would be a free version of EVE Online

Lineage II without the grind.

I like your list, however i'd change 2 things.

Healing would be in it, but not in the ''press 1 button and get a big chunk of health'' all heals would be dot types.

Wouldn't want another fantasy world filled with elves dorfs humans and a generic small race.

Basically my perfect mmo would be your list set in a Star Wars world (replace naval with a decent and seamless space combat).

Won't happen but gotta love a dream.

Just gotta ask the OP. Why would you not want levels, and then ask for a mix of grind and quests? Other than that a fairly solid list.

Originally posted by xenogias

Just gotta ask the OP. Why would you not want levels, and then ask for a mix of grind and quests? Other than that a fairly solid list.

Direct levels in a skill system isn't needed. I do look on levels as a easy road for developers to add progression and balance.  We get alot more interesting system without it. The drawback without levels is that its more expensive and harder for the developers to make a working system.

I (can have fun with)/(like) almost all styles of MMOs...However I hate almost all of the comunities out there .How about hackers? My dream MMO would be a really kind community with zero hacks , without asian gold farmers and brazilians.(I wouldn't mind about them if they were able to speak english , but most aren't able to , so...)

you basically names what i want in an MMO except graphics arent to big for meas long as they're decent

 Not a bad list, however putting it all in one game would like leave a good half of it unused by most players, it also doesn't mean that the game would be any fun (even though the ideas are good)

So it sounded like you were talking about Ultima Online for a second, mixed with some others.

I don't mind skill based games, but what about the casual player or someone who doesn't play 15 hours a day like myself...

Would I be assed out because some 13 year old can play and I get to play once in a while... 

Skill based games allow casual players a more even playing field than any other type. You just have to specialize more. The hardcore players will have more skills, but not be overpowering like the typical level/gear differential. With a good skill system you can be competitive in a short amount of time as long as the best gear is kept in the hands of the crafters and not put on raid mobs.

Infinity: The Quest for Earth is the closes thing to my dream sci-fi MMORPG at the moment...

I would really love to see a fantasy MMORPG that follows the same method of thinking as Infinity.

The number one thing that I want as the OP mentioned would have to be no classes. NO CLASSES. Oh, and no levels, only skills and techniques.

SWG as it was in the beginning, with bug fixes and JTL added and NO Jedi (at least not as they did them).

Many of the ideas the OP lists are good ones.  Of course, they are all ideas that have been mentioned before because a lot of gamers would love to see the same things in an MMO.  But I don't think you can describe what your "dream MMO" would be without saying what your ideal setting or world would be.  One of the points listed is lore and that's a very important one.  A game is not going to be much fun if it does not exist in a world that has a history and a story behind it.  It's what makes you want to live in that world.  What are the kingdoms and empires that rule that world?  Who are their chief rivals?  What are the most powerful items and what's the history behind them.  What are the most dangerous creatures and where do they live?  These are the things that are essential to a successful MMO.  You have to start there, then you can talk about the mechanics of the game.  Great gameplay placed in drab lifeless world will get boring pretty fast.  Of course, the reverse is true as well.  Lousy mechanics built into a beautiful world gets old too.

I primarily enjoy skill based games myself, but I disagree slightly with the idea of being able to 'be whatever you want to be'. In other words if you create a character that is going to be focused on magic, you might find yourself having a hard time wearing heavy armor. Not because you are class restricted from doing so, but because you'll find your strength too low after putting all your attribute points into intelligence & wisdom. Etc..

Having many choices is fun. But having choices vs. consequences forces you to think - which is even funner.

My dream MMO would consist of:

-Solo content and quests but with the greatest rewards coming from party quests

-PVE and free PVP (in fields and dungeons, but not in towns)

-Player driven economy

-A tier'd arena where parties of 3 could battle for fame and rare weapons and items.

-An immersive lore. (Not necissarily story, but a backstory on the game world)

-Players can actually make a name for themselves (in-game) and affect the upcoming events.

-More in game events. Nothing too large of a scale, but just something extra and fun thrown in every now and then.

-Fairly decent character customization.

Originally posted by freakomar

Heres a list of ALL the things that would describe my DREAM MMO.

• No levels. 100% skill based, you buy skills/gear from NPC's OR get them as Drops, or buy them off other players, OR craft them (including skills)
• Skills and gear from drops, NPC's, Players, and crafting are ALL equally good. But all of them are unique in their own ways.
• NO classes. Be whatever you want. Each player can wield all sorts of gear, mail plate cloth leather etc. But each kind of armour has their advantages, and their disadvantages. Same with weapons. You finish deeds (like in LOTRO) and get the ability to equip certain armours and weapons.
• Alot of character customization, kinda like CoH/CoV. A great variety of races.
• Free For All PvP - With FULL player looting. (Yeah, sounds like Darkfall doesnt it?)
• Sieging. Destroyable building's and cities made by players AND npc's. A group of players can destroy other cities, but they're guarded by .. well... GUARDS. And in the end, you get rewarded like saaaaay you get what the city was worth and its divided amongst the players.
• Player owned houses and guild halls. BOTH instances like in the future of LOTRO.
• No button smashing, not FPS either. Like TCoS or AoC or Darkfall (without the 1s person).
• Mount combat.
• Naval combat.
• Other players can board your ships, naval combat mainly like PotBS.
• A major role of player economy, MOST of the items in game to be player crafted.
• A fair bit of grinding aswell as questing.
• Amazing animations.
• Good looking spells, not like Fury though - so much light and explosions you cant even see wtf is happening.
• Ofcourse, top of the line graphics with an AMAZING engine.
• In a fantasy setting, with a mix of mideval.
• Ability to train your own armies (of maximum 10 soldiers), Squad combat ... like Guildwars ? (Plays minor role - you dont NEED them to play)
• Flying mounts aswell.
• Gainable titles like in LOTRO, but they give you buffs.
• Arena's ; like from WoW, but only small and short - kinda like GuildWars.
• NO HEALING! Mentioning arena's from guildwars reminded me of the healfest.
• Massive gear customization, logo's on armour - writings on swords, blood on your axes, cracks on your hammer. You can customize your gear while crafting, customization depends on how much raw material you use, say one bar of iron can only make a small dagger. This also determines the speed and damage. 10 bars would make a 2 handed mace, therefore slower but more damage. Crafting system such that almost no gear looks similar.

 

Well thats what I want. The closest thing to my list is definately Darkfall, but im slowly losing interest looking at the graphics slowly getting outdated and the First Person view kinda looked gay from the videos. But only time will tell.

What do YOU want in your dream MMO?

(Im bored, thats why I just wrote that! Theres almost no good MMO out there for me atm)

it is a part of perfect game that a guy was posting

Eve Online with twitch based combat or Eve Online's system in a terrestrial world with at least some twitch based or strategic fighting involved. Or turned based combat. I don't care. Just as long as it's not mind numbing, repetitive combat and a world that is as immersive as Eve.