Stop! Wait! This is not a WoW-thread.

Some of you may have seen the WAR-video, where a dev (or whatever he was) stated like this:
"WoW is like The Beatles. If WoW is like The Beatles, WAR will be like Led Zeppelin."

If we continue with this analogy, what do you think about the other top hyped not released games? Mmmh, maybe we could make this even with released games, but that is for someone else.

So, if WoW is like The Beatles, then...

WAR = Led Zeppelin (?)
AoC =
Aion =
PotBS =
Tabula =
GodsnH =
Spellborn=

AoC = Creed

Originally posted by 9216544

AoC = Creed

creed?  those guys praise themselves as some holier than thou christ lovers.. and they suck

AoC is a mature game with boobs, decapitation, and dismemberment

AoC= Gwar

WAR = Led Zeppelin (?)
AoC = Michael Jackson... popular during NDA, but flops once the truth comes out =P
Aion = Metallica Reloaded
PotBS = Yanni
Tabula = Dead Eye Dick - Tabula would one of the non- hits from the one hit wonder albulm
GodsnH = not sure about that one
Spellborn= a band nobody ever heard of,  have you seen how dead the Spellborn forum is here on MMORPG.com?

CoX = REO Speedwagon

Not as popular as is should be, but great for those that like it.

By the way Chicago had a huge storm a few weeks ago and I was driving in it, the DJ I was listening to played REO's riding the storm out.  I cranked it and had a great time.

Originally posted by Rayx0r

 

Originally posted by 9216544

AoC = Creed

creed?  those guys praise themselves as some holier than thou christ lovers.. and they suck

 

AoC is a mature game with boobs, decapitation, and dismemberment

AoC= Gwar

 Dont know if u care or remember but Gwar was supposed to get FIGURES in either WH or WH40k a while back.

  which it is pretty much the same over the top sensibility...

 If i recall correctly the Priapus guy queered the deal...?

  but the conan Ip is a bit more serious than GWAR's over-topness dontcha think?

  i remeber going to a gwar show even tho my fever was about 104? THAT was weird...(it was so packed I was actually steady on my feet) and the fake blood stained  -so for about a week you could tell from folks hair who'd been at the show.

Originally posted by Rayx0r

 

Originally posted by 9216544

AoC = Creed

creed?  those guys praise themselves as some holier than thou christ lovers.. and they suck

 

AoC is a mature game with boobs, decapitation, and dismemberment

AoC= Gwar

i dunno.... that Creed description sounds pretty spot on.

PotBS = Yanni?  Yanni is a great musician, but he's not for everyone.  I was thinking PotBS was more like Andrea Bocelli.

Originally posted by badgerbadger

 

Originally posted by Rayx0r

 

Originally posted by 9216544

AoC = Creed

creed?  those guys praise themselves as some holier than thou christ lovers.. and they suck

 

AoC is a mature game with boobs, decapitation, and dismemberment

AoC= Gwar

 Dont know if u care or remember but Gwar was supposed to get FIGURES in either WH or WH40k a while back.

 

  which it is pretty much the same over the top sensibility...

 If i recall correctly the Priapus guy queered the deal...?

  but the conan Ip is a bit more serious than GWAR's over-topness dontcha think?

  i remeber going to a gwar show even tho my fever was about 104? THAT was weird...(it was so packed I was actually steady on my feet) and the fake blood stained  -so for about a week you could tell from folks hair who'd been at the show.

ya maybe a bit over the top. although, seeing the demo on the finishing moves for about 10 minutes at dragon*con.. they were completely over the top.  then the discussion of dual wielding weapons and maul fatalities.. extremely over the top

I cant quote it exactly, but during the demo they said the artists were having way too much fun with the dual wielding fatalaties.  He described one as "cutting off one arm, then the other arm, then cutting off the legs, then the head.. and kicking the torso flat on the ground"

seems pretty gwarish to me :)

I prefer the Beatles to Led Zeppelin.

WoW = MCR imo

Cool!   I guess that makes EQ like Elvis

I think UO is like Buddy Holly.  Everyone that was a fan says he was good, but the rest of us really don't know or get it from what we've seen.

EVE = The Stooges ( Iggy Pop ) who were ahead of their time musically.

Muds = All the black rock and roll and rhythm and blues artist who never got credit for the genre they started and songs that were stolen/borrowed by white main stream artists.

Although I love Led Zeppelin, fav band of all time....

WAR is not the Zeppelin of MMO's. Maybe if you're going by the "JIMMY PAGE STOLE BLACK MUSIC AND WAS LARGELY SUCCESSFUL BECAUSE OF IT", referring to "WAR STOLE WOW'S GAME TEMPLATE AND FIXED IT" then I guess you are correct.

But as far as I'm concerned, if you want to have a fun thread like this at least get real. WoW and WAR (in my opinion) are one of the same. Led Zeppelin and The Beatles are two completely different bands. So shouldn't the next step up from WoW be something more innovative? Call me biased but shouldn't it be more like Age of Conan...? ;)

Originally posted by M0BiUs

Although I love Led Zeppelin, fav band of all time....

 

WAR is not the Zeppelin of MMO's. Maybe if you're going by the "JIMMY PAGE STOLE BLACK MUSIC AND WAS LARGELY SUCCESSFUL BECAUSE OF IT", referring to "WAR STOLE WOW'S GAME TEMPLATE AND FIXED IT" then I guess you are correct.

 

 

But as far as I'm concerned, if you want to have a fun thread like this at least get real. WoW and WAR (in my opinion) are one of the same. Led Zeppelin and The Beatles are two completely different bands. So shouldn't the next step up from WoW be something more innovative? Call me biased but shouldn't it be more like Age of Conan...? ;)

 

lol. teh warhamr gam3 is ripin off teh wurld uv warkraft gam!!!

 On that second bit, no. I'd say The Chronicles of Spellborn wins that prize.

You're off to the wrong start, re-title this "If WoW is like (insert any bubble gum pop band here) ....." and try again.

The Beatles comparrison can be tied to UO or EQ or ANYTHING other than WoW.

WoW

WAR

AOC

So, if WoW is like The Beatles, then... (you mean Nsync)

AoC = Take your pick!

WAR = Disney theme tune maybe something sung by Elton John (sells lots but ultimately forgotten fast) or something hardcore like this: Teletubbies hardcore! because this is war you know!

Aion = Brokeback Mountain to look of love (80's) song

LotRO = Leonard Nimoy's Ballad of Bilbo Baggins

PotBS = The Worst Pirate Song

Tabula = Any Christmas Carol - (fashionable for 1 month only)

GodsnH = The G** Barbie Song

Spellborn= The Happy Birthday song (once a year peaks interest)

Darkfall = Darkfall Hardcore PvP - annoying wait

Just my opinions dont take them to heart! friendly banter!

It all depends on how you look at it.

WAR I would say would be more like Weezer, not because of the lyrics but the general sense of the songs. They go with the gameplay eerily in my opinion.  (Listen to them if you want to know why)

AoC would be more like Ramstein, dark, hardcore

AION. Pretty much any game theme song. Repetitive, doesn't really go anywhere but the next track, just something to fill space. (My Opinion)

PotBS I guess would be Sam Roberts. Good story, kind of mellow, fun parts, the pirates and the band both have beards, songs are usually kind of intricate but not too deep.

Tabula Rasa would be... well any 80's hair band. Get's hyped up then turns out to be incredibly dissapointing (I hate the 80's)

Gods and Heroes. I don't know but from what I've seen I'd go with something generic, just a rehash with different lyrics and one minor gimic (I haven't seen to much).

SpellBorn, I couldn't care less. (Cruel but, again, it's my opinion)

And WoW would have to be one of those bands, that everyone is copying and making all their songs generic trying to imitate. Even when the band wasn't that great to start, just famous.

Originally posted by Cathalaode

like Ramstein, dark, hardcore

Far from it.