Trending Games | World of Warcraft | Elder Scrolls Online | WildStar | Final Fantasy XIV: A Realm Reborn

  Network:  FPSguru RTSguru
Login:  Password:   Remember?  
Show Quick Gamelist Jump to Random Game
Members:2,738,120 Users Online:0
Games:714  Posts:6,176,967

Show Blog

Link to this blogs RSS feed

MMORPG.com Staff Blog

The staff of MMORPG.com gets together to bring you some behind the scenes insights on stories, the industry and the site itself.

Author: staffblog

Contributors: BillMurphy,MikeB,garrett,SBFord,Grakulen,

Community Spotlight: Voice Acting

Posted by MikeB Sunday December 16 2012 at 9:58PM
Login or Register to rate this blog post!

In this week's Community Spotlight, we focus on the thread, "Poll: Does voice acting make the game better?" by Axehandle.

We all have either played or at least heard of the debacle of the massive amount of voice acting in swtor and how that went down with the community but is it such a terrible idea to have that kind of voice acting and cut scenes in Mmorpg's?

Id like to hear the opinions of the community on this specifically what went right and wrong.

Ambros123 doesn't feel it is black and white:

It isn't such a black and white answer.  Voice acting can improve upon the story as one doesn't have to read every text in order to understand whats going on and thus makes the games story a bit more immersive.  However it does not mean it can make up for shallow or piss poor stories.  SWTOR went way overkill for every single damn thing being a cutscene.  They should have kept it to the class story lines or like in GW2 it was strictly with dungeons and personal stories.

EAWare did a great thing with the whole dialogue options in groups and really all MMOs should try to emulate.  Vocie actiong needs to be done in moderation.

mmoDAD feels VA is a total waste:

Voice acting, IMO, is a waste of delopment time and money. Moreiver, it locks the quest into place. For instance, if a dev wanted to add to it or change it later, he would have to start a whole new acting scenerio.

Also, it makes the game disk req so much more.

Questing in general needs to be revamped. Atm, it's boring. People just speed right through it, hit "M" for map, follow the arrow, pick up the item or kill goblin, return the item, and omve on to next quest. All of it is boring

Torgen wants voice acting, but not necessarily in every quest:

YES! But not every quest has to be fully voiced. The most important quests (story quests, epic quests or whatever) should be fully voiced and for side quests it is enough if every quest npc only says one or two phrases but not the whole questtext.

It just makes the world so much more lively and vibrant!

I'm at a point where I've been spoiled by great voice acting in so many games that I find voice acting to be critical to the experience, whether it's a singleplayer game or an MMO. However, bad voice acting can actually make things worse, but this is true for any sort of acting, whether it's poor acting on film, in an anime, or any other genre of videogame.

How about you? Share your thoughts with us below!

bcbully writes:

You know I was just thinking about SWTOR (fondly) maybe an hour ago.

 

I was thinking about my Imperial Agent. MY imperial agent. Out of now where I felt a certain attachment, that I didn't feel while I was playing. 

 

Through the story and the voice acting, My Cipher 9 became unique. My Cipher 9 was a sexy lil cyborg. 

Mon Dec 17 2012 12:57AM Report
Roxtarr writes:

I have mixed feelings about voice acting in an MMORPG.  For example, there are times that it does add 'drama' to a particular quest.  However, I am not a fan of hearing my own character's voice.

The biggest trouble with voice acting of quests is that it increases the cost of developing/changing the game.  It also slows down the expansion of new content.

All in all, I guess I can say I'm in favor of a careful use of VA or not at all.

Mon Dec 17 2012 5:10AM Report
bcbully writes:

I think the directionWoW is moving with MoP is the right way to go with voice acting. No cut scenes, but with "live" npcs telling the story w/o taking you out the game world. 

 

If it more like that, put voice acting on everything!

Mon Dec 17 2012 7:03AM Report
Freezzo writes: I think SWTOR voice acting was great, but a little too much, as a lot of the quests were quite bland. Also I think what was a bad idea was for them to have VA in English, German and French... Which costs way way way more Mon Dec 17 2012 7:11AM Report
paulytheb writes: Vioce acting adds nothing to the longevity of a MMO. Mon Dec 17 2012 3:25PM Report
Hluill writes: I really enjoy some of the cutscenes in STW.  Some of the voice actors do a really awesome job.  Many times I have clicked thir dialogue boxes to listen to their different lines.  Is it the main reason I play the game?  No, though it might be in the top ten.  If they didn't have it and had spent that money on a bigger, deeper game would I still play it?  Yes. Sun Dec 23 2012 12:05PM Report

MMORPG.com writes:
Login or Register to post a comment