Trending Games | ArcheAge | Pirate101 | Wasteland 2 | MapleStory

  Network:  FPSguru RTSguru
Login:  Password:   Remember?  
Show Quick Gamelist Jump to Random Game
Members:2,860,143 Users Online:0
Games:742  Posts:6,245,640

Show Blog

MMORPGs Are All the Same

Posted by lordaltay1 Saturday July 12 2008 at 10:41AM
Login or Register to rate this blog post!

I’m tired of getting excited about an MMORPG and after playing it for a couple hours realizing that it’s the same thing as every other free MMORPG out there. It’s as if every single game runs off the same system, but each game has its own character models, classes and setting. Other than those three things, almost every game plays the same way. I’d love to see developers try and innovate rather than using the same rehashed themes and systems. Why not try changing the way uses gain skills or the way players can gain attributes rather than leveling up?

One major complaint I have is that almost every MMORPG has the same slate of character classes. The least developers can do is invent a few classes rather than using the same rehashed variations of Warrior, Mage, Priest, Thief and Archer. I’m sorry, renaming the classes doesn’t count as creating a new class. You can go ahead and call a warrior a fighter, barbarian, berserker, swordsman, knight, or mercenary, but it’s still a warrior. It can’t be that difficult to create different classes. Even combining two or more classes to make a hybrid would be unique. Take a “pirate” class for example. They can be a hybrid swordsman and a marksman with swords/pistols. Most MMORPGs also never utilize the necromancer class or any class that relies on summoning pets, which would be a welcomed addition to the usual slate of classes.

Another feature I’ve seen overused is the standard quest system. How many times have you been presented with a quest that says “Go outside town and kill 10 scorpions “ or a quest that sounds a bit like this, “Take this note and give it to Joe who is standing 15 feet away from me”. I mean come on! I’m not saying the developers should scrap the kill quests, but I’d love to see some variation! MapleStory actually did a remarkable job with its quest system. The game introduced platforming quests to the MMORPG genre. Players actually had to master jumping through a map while avoiding obstacles in their goal to reach the end of the map. Sure this wasn’t exactly a revolutionary concept, but it’s definitely a welcomed change from the usual quests you’ll run into in an MMORPG, and it’s actually fun. No matter how you look at it, killing 10 scorpions for the local butcher shop isn’t fun.

I’m also tired of seeing the leveling system in 99.9% of MMORPGs. Why are developers so afraid of breaking away from the norm? Sure it’s easier to use an already established system, but players definitely want to try new things. I for one would give ANY game a shot if it looked unique to me in some way, even if the game was pay to play, but even pay to play games lack uniqueness. The only game I see in the pay to play market that seems at all unique is Eve online, and I congratulate the people over at CCP [the developers of Eve Online] for taking a chance and avoiding the entire leveling system and focusing rather on a skill system. I’m not at al claiming that games with a leveling system are bad, as if the system is very well polished and balanced it can still be fun, but I’d love to trying something new.

Lastly, I’m tired of seeing the fantasy genre over used. I’ve already written about this, so i’ll keep this short. I’d love to see developers try out new genres. The Sci-fi theme definitely hasn’t been fully utilized yet, as there really aren’t any free MMORPGs that have a large community yet that are sci-fi themed. One game Luckily, there are companies out there that are trying to innovate. Gravity for example, has released Requiem: Bloodymare which labels itself as a “horror game”. Although Requiem feels a bit like fantasy, I’d like to congratulate Gravity for at least trying something new, and would like to encourage all game developers to try something new for a change.

Source:

http://mmohub.org/2008/mmorpgs-are-all-the-same

Psymyn writes:

SPAM... SPAM... SPAM!! YOU SPAMMY SPAMMER GTFO THIS WEBSITE!!!

Sat Jul 12 2008 11:42AM Report
Sepulcher writes:

I alughed at your comments on Necromancers.  You obviously haven't played many MMOs.  EQ, GW, and AoC come to mind immediately.  They all have Necromancers and other games do as well.  As far as pet classes go you are even more blind.  Almost every MMO in existance has some for of pet class.

Sat Jul 12 2008 1:53PM Report
Ascension08 writes:

That's why there's in the same GENRE...

...

...OMG Company of Heroes is just like Age of Empires LOL they're all the same! Stupid RTS.

Sat Jul 12 2008 3:29PM Report
Cursedsei writes:

I gotta say, everything this person lists, is a staple of the Genre, so if this person is so tired of this stuff, go play a single player game.

That's like saying Warcraft is just like Starcraft cause they both handle the same way, and have three different races.

Its like saying Call of Duty and Medal of honor are the same because you shoot nazis in WW2 in both.

I'm not going to bother correcting this person, it just seems like it would be a waste of breathe. I dont know what the hell he's been doing, but it sure as hell doesnt involve playing any MMOs

Sat Jul 12 2008 9:14PM Report
_Seeker writes:

You talk about making "new" classes then you talk about necromaners? Wouldnt they just be another pet summoning class? Like hunters or Warlocks in WoW.

I do believe most MMORPG's are the same. But through that slight variation it will appeal to many different people. I think i am in the same boat as you. I want to play an MMOG, but there just isn't one out there that suits my tastes. Although WAR comes close.

I think you will find one day there will be a different attitude to games. I hope that one day there will be a shadowbane like game with no leveling system.

Sat Jul 12 2008 10:26PM Report
Jimmy_Scythe writes:

Actually Company of Heros is NOTHING like Age of empires. Nor is World in Conflict even remotely similar to Red alert. And if anyone here honestly thinks that Half - Life is like Halo, I'm going to lose all faith in humanity and take up recreational murder as a hobby.

Having said that, Warcraft and Starcraft ARE pretty much the same as is Call of Duty and Medal of Honor. The former two can be forgiven since Warcraft was a pretty good game on it's own and both games come from the same developer, the latter two games just don't have any excuse.

MMORPGs just feel like reskins of one another. Not even true mods, just the exact same shit with a new paint job. Aside from Eve Online and UO, what games really stand apart from the treadmill? What games remain true to the RPG genre while have gameplay unique enough that they could be mistaken for any other game in the genre?

Exactly!

 

Sat Jul 12 2008 11:53PM Report

MMORPG.com writes:
Login or Register to post a comment