Trending Games | ArcheAge | Guild Wars 2 | WildStar | World of Warcraft

  Network:  FPSguru RTSguru
Login:  Password:   Remember?  
Show Quick Gamelist Jump to Random Game
Members:2,785,406 Users Online:0
Games:723  Posts:6,192,818

Show Blog

Link to this blogs RSS feed

the Lonely Alter

I don't play "games", I play MMORPGs! This is where I talk about them!

Author: Tierless

Queer I for the AI

Posted by Daedren Sunday June 10 2007 at 3:58PM
Login or Register to rate this blog post!

Artificial Intelligence. In MMO's, it refers to the behavior of NPC's/MOBS - basically, the stuff you'll be fighting. Current implementations of this behavior, or AI, is almost embarrassing to reference. While gaming AI in general has improved over the past decade, MMO AI has remained stagnant. Compare the mob behavior in a ten year old MMO, like Everquest, with one that's just been released, like Vanguard or LOTRO. It's the same old song, just slightly tweaked.


Developers give all sorts of reasons and excuses of why real or improved AI can't be implemented. Granted, sometimes, there are actual coding and technical restrictions that have to be taken into account. More often than not, though, companies are just unwilling to put the time, effort and money into making real, improved AI.


So where do we look to solve this problem? The community, of course.


Bethesda's Oblivion, or Elder Scrolls IV, released a year or two ago, was a pretty good game. Not multi-player, but for this purpose, it will serve as a great example. Oblivion, when released (the vanilla version, as its referred as), implemented AI that was actually not so great. While not bad, it was nothing to write home about. Encounters were pretty much the same, with goblins and daedra running up to you, smacking you around, then falling to your feet when dead. They'd use their standard combat abilities, and the ones that could heal themselves did, sometimes. Like I said, nothing spectacular here.


Enter the Oblivion modding community. I love these guys. All volunteers, just modding away at a game they love because they want to make it better. Anyway, in the slew of mods that were released, some real gems came out. Staying on subject, they tweaked the AI so well that you really didn't know what to expect when going into a battle. How tough is this guy? Will he run and go get help immediately? Is he a scout? Will he try some crazy weird tactics on me?


It must be a bit shameful to be a developer and have your game improved so drastically by a non-paid member of the community. It's like a priceless thing: Total cost to develop game: $12 Million -- Average salary paid to developer: $70K per year. Having your game made the way it should have been by someone who didn't get paid: Priceless.


Ok, not the best way to say it, but I hope my point is made. As I've preached before, people *want* to be challenged when playing a game. And staying true to my style, I'm going to list a few easy ways to make AI in MMO's to make more dynamic, challenging and fun encounters:


Hail thee, thou are not all the same!


Most MMO's use a simple method of "mob X" has behavior Y. That means every goblin, orc or demon you run up to is going to act pretty much the same. They might be different types of orc or goblin, like an archer, shaman or warrior, but those subclasses will usually act exactly the same way: The warrior will rush you, the archer will shoot you, and the shaman will blast you with a lightning bolt and heal himself or allies when needed. This basic logic is used throughout the entire game, so when you've fought something, you know how the future ones will react. Yay for ingenuity.


  • Make AI randomized for every mob. It's not hard. Simply have a list of AI's to choose from. When the mob is born, he randomly gets an AI. Simple and yet so effective.

And how should it be randomized? Well, using the example above, for instance:


Orc Warrior

Brutal (won't run, fights to death)

Tactician: tries to get help first

Protector: Will shield healer/weaker allies

Coward: retreats easily

Randomly attacks anyone


Orc Archer

Sniper, will always keep ranged

Coward: runs at 50%

Crazy: Loves to shoot random people

Mad: Likes melee, will attack anyone near

Runs to get help at first sign of trouble


Orc Shaman

Suicidal: won't heal anyone

Protector: heals everyone

Delusional: Thinks he is a warrior

Fight another day: If outnumbered, runs

Fights to the death


These are just quick examples I made in 5 minutes. It's simply to show you how even the most basic encounter can be made into a dynamic and fun event. Think of you and your traveling bunch of lunatics running into a group of orcs where the warrior runs to get help, the archer randomly shoots people and the shaman is suicidal. Sure, you'll probably still win, but at least it allows for scenarios that are changing.


Knowing is half the battle... or all of it?


  • Get rid of titles and levels that will instantly tell how the mob will behave and how hard it will be.

Hail, level 5 orc Shaman. I do know that you'll be a moderate challenge to me, although I've never met you. However, I've already killed 20 other mobs with the exact same name, look and behavior of you. Oh, this battle will be fun!


Getting rid of the simple mob name of "orc shaman" is a first step. Losing the level system, or at least the blatant "I am this level" is the next step. That also brings me to my next point:


A detailed enemy: shedding the plague of uncreativeness


  • Bad guys have names, too. Instead of creating rare "named mobs", give every mob an actual name. This will add realism and eliminate the "I know what you are" mentality.

Instead of using something like "orc warrior" or "orc shaman", simply use a name chosen randomly from a list. Even a simple list of 200 names (easily obtainable via orc name generators found online) will be enough to put personality into boring old MMO fights. I think it'd be much more exciting to fight 3 orcs named Garbaz, Dragar and Sarkash than 3 orcs named "orc warrior", "orc shaman", and "orc archer". You might actually have to look at them to see what they're capable of.


That's it for now. 3 easy ways to make AI in MMO's more exciting, dynamic and unknown.

raynerape writes: The MMORPG I am working on is probably going to get good use of the modular AI system you are suggesting, used to a moderate degree as various AI combination can cause balance issues - a mob with Brave and Coward AI traits can make a fight ether too difficult or too easy/annoying (having to chase him around classifies as annoying). I don't agree with the named mobs. While it adds personality, you never actually get to know the 1943509th orc you slaughter through. Giving it a name would be illogical as there's no way you can learn it and little reason to do so. Also, it would make difficult differentiating between common mobs and named uniques/bosses. Sun Jun 10 2007 5:38PM Report
Daedren writes: Thanks for the feedback! Regarding the named mobs, I think a title system would help distinguish between normal and "boss" mobs - like Grinark and things like that. I do understand where you're coming from, though, regarding the names for mobs. While you might not get to know the creature, you at least have to look and see what he's wearing or using as a weapon to see what class he is. It may take some tedium out of the normal battles. And, you are exactly right when you say that these ideas have to be used in moderation to prevent annoyance and over-challenging encounters. Mon Jun 11 2007 2:12AM Report
soulwynd writes:

Instead of random crazyness, I'd rather watch them act as a team. Be mean, have a leader or two, maybe an hierarchy, if the leader decides the mage back there is more of a threat than the meatshield, he could taunt the warrior and order all the arches to shoot the hell out of the mage. Maybe just plain circle the poor healer, since he's the thing keeping the meatshield alive. Oh no, we're losing, issue a retreat, hide in the woods and when the party start resting complaining about their own lack of strategy (which would be dumb if games were anything realistic) they ambush back in and whack the OMGZ out of them.

Fri Aug 31 2007 10:18AM Report

MMORPG.com writes:
Login or Register to post a comment