Trending Games | The Crew | Elder Scrolls Online | Lichdom: Battlemage | Neverwinter

  Network:  FPSguru RTSguru
Login:  Password:   Remember?  
Show Quick Gamelist Jump to Random Game
Members:2,843,168 Users Online:0
Games:732  Posts:6,221,428

Show Blog

Link to this blogs RSS feed

Vicarious Existence

To blog about what is going on in the MMO genre from a casual MMO player's viewpoint.

Author: UnSub

Grand Theft Auto Hot Coffee: Lawyers (Likely) To Drink The Milkshake

Posted by UnSub Wednesday June 25 2008 at 12:10AM
Login or Register to rate this blog post!

According to the NY Times the class action lawsuit inspired by GTA:SA's Hot Coffee mod (you can do your own googling for that!) is close to being settled. The end result - the people in the suit will get a few dollars, the lawyers behind it get a good payday:

"Far bigger than the payout to plaintiffs will be the fees sought by the lawyers who brought the class action. Mr. Lesser and his colleagues at 10 other law firms have asked for more than $1.3 million — compared with less than $30,000 that Take-Two Interactive’s lawyers say it will spend to resolve the claims for $5 to $35 each (and, sometimes, a sanitized copy of the game).

“It doesn’t typically go that way,” said Mary J. Davis, a law professor at the University of Kentucky who has studied this type of litigation. To have legal fees dwarf a settlement payout, she continued, “is sort of backwards.”

The company and the plaintiffs lawyers both point out that the company has also agreed to make an $860,000 charitable contribution."


The full article is interesting, especially the back half that talks about parents being more interested in protecting their children from a mini-game they can't unlock during normal play but not caring so much about the violence in GTA.

Personally I don't care that the lawyers ended up with the cash here half as much as I care that Rockstar didn't fight against it harder and try to seek a legal ruling. Any game that can be impacted by mods - this includes MMOs - runs the risk of someone unlocking something they shouldn't and this kind of decision opens the door to the next time someone sees something that offends thine eyes (obviously not the copious blood and gore, but perhaps a stray nipple or undressed female character model) they'll run after the company, wallet open to collect the cash. It's a risk to Rockstar, sure, but if they - who make a lot of money off their adult-orientated games that they keep trying to pretend don't have the content they have - won't stand up and fight, no-one will.

Or someone will who doesn't have the money / resources they have and are more likely to lose, thus locking the rest of the industry into a legal finding they don't want.

And yes, I'm aware I'm abusing both beverage analogies and internet memes in the title. :-)

Rob_dc84 writes:

people are still fighting over that crap?? wow ... rule number 1 as a parent check the game before u buy it... 2 u as the parent buy it therefore u cant bitch when your kids goes out and does something stupid he saw in the game. parents should be held accountable for it not the game.

Wed Jun 25 2008 8:12AM Report
Locklain writes:

Christ, people this day in age. . .

Give it 20 years and we will all have genetically installed censorship bars.  Heavens forbid we see a nipple or ass here and there.

Wed Jun 25 2008 10:13AM Report
Hexxeity writes:

When GTA:SA came out, I saw a young mother in GameStop buying it for her son (who looked about nine years old).  The clerk was rattling off the disclaimer: Mature rating, graphic violence, strong sexual content, GameStop not responsible, you cannot return the game because of the content, blah blah blah.  The mom didn't even bat an eye.  She just said, "Yes, I want the game," and handed over her credit card.

I wanted to call child protective services, but of course it was none of my business.

Wed Jun 25 2008 1:56PM Report
sdozer writes:

"I wanted to call child protective services, but of course it was none of my business." Good thinking. Mind your own dmn business and go fasco your children.

Wed Jun 25 2008 3:43PM Report
Death1942 writes:

sounds like that lawyer got the good deal in that horrible mess.

 

good on him/her for finding a way to scam a million off the idiots who are fighting over this dumb issue

Fri Jul 11 2008 2:31AM Report

MMORPG.com writes:
Login or Register to post a comment